Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this Why We Eat Too Much is a fad?

137 replies

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 14:47

OK - probably provocative title, and I’m not trying to be goady or anything like that.

However, I’m losing weight. Every time I click on a weight loss thread this book is being pushed at people.

I remember this happening with Paul McKenna and more recently some Facebook weight group, then it was all about fasting. AIBU to think it’s another faddy thing?

Will have a look at the threads but does anyone want to convince me otherwise? Smile

OP posts:
Rainingonsaturday · 22/08/2021 15:42

@BIWI - it’s not about not being bothered. But if I had read every diet book that I have seen pushed on here in the time I’ve been a member I would live in a very overcrowded house, have very little time and be very poor.

Admittedly the latter two might contribute in a roundabout way to weight loss but that’s not the idea!

OP posts:
BIWI · 22/08/2021 15:34

It’s not a groundbreaking point and I’d be surprised if anyone on this thread would disagree with it

... if only they could be bothered to read it instead of dismissing it!

Jujujuly · 22/08/2021 15:30

I’ve read the book and found it interesting. The poster who said the key message is not eating nuts and seeds is massively misrepresenting it. In fact one of the key points he makes is about the disrupted ratio of omega 6: omega 3 in our diets. It should be something like 3:1 but it’s actually more like 15:1 (not actual numbers but similar) in western diets because there is so much omega 3 in vegetable oils (and yes nuts and seeds but these are good for other reasons) and processed foods generally.

It’s not a diet as such but an explanation of why we should avoid processed foods and refined sugar, and how that affects your metabolism as well as other aspects of general health. It’s not a groundbreaking point and I’d be surprised if anyone on this thread would disagree with it.

Anubias · 22/08/2021 15:24

@jewel1968 So according to his theory, starvation wouldn’t occur because the body would lay down fat reserves.

When I’ve reached my goal weight if I don’t eat over my tdee to maintain I shouldn’t gain weight. If I do gain I’ll simply alter my calorie limit to suit.

I think a lot of people who fail at weight loss are looking for reasons why. What they really need to look at is how much they are eating and drinking.
Like I said in my previous post, different things work for different people.

RubyGoat · 22/08/2021 15:21

I've been following this WOE for a while now. I'm 40 & been trying to lose weight for nearly a decade, since I had DD. Unfortunately I've not felt well this week, had an absolutely rotten sore throat (negative LFT), had my period, & 3 migraines in the last 8 days. Finally been out of the house today. Eaten much worse than usual this week, less healthily, had GF fish & chips twice (I really didn't fancy anything else & wouldn't usually have it), lots of rice, some pancakes yesterday, potatoes, porridge, & a bar of chocolate. Loads of sugary throat sweets. Been stuck in bed at least 5 days with the migraines. I've lost 4lb. I usually eat mostly salad...

gwenneh · 22/08/2021 15:04

you will mess with your metabolism and when you start eating normally (to maintain) your brain will think it needs to lay down more fat in case of future calorie deficit

This is the key piece of theory he's vastly overstating. The science around adaptive thermogenesis shows that while it certainly occurs, it's just not got the impact he implies.

It's estimated that the real impact of adaptive thermogenesis is an average of ~100-150 kcal. Even in the most extreme diet scenarios the biggest loser study, or starvation studies the impact is around 10-15% of the TDEE.

It's just not what is causing the cycle of loss & gain.

jewel1968 · 22/08/2021 14:49

@Anubias his theory using your approach as an example is that:

  • you will lose weight with calorie deficit
  • you will mess with your metabolism and when you start eating normally (to maintain) your brain will think it needs to lay down more fat in case of future calorie deficit
  • so he argues you should start by eating as if you were maintaing
  • calorie reduction if not done carefully will lead to a cycle of weight reduction followed by weight gain and each time you gain a little more weight

Others might explain it better than me. He heard this story time and time again from his patients hence his research.

CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 14:41

Ok, I should have been clearer... for weight loss, you need to eat fewer calories. Ideally, in the form of 'healthy' foods. Good luck if that's not your approach to shifting the pounds. :)

Anubias · 22/08/2021 14:28

Different approaches suit different people.

For me, calorie counting works and I’ve lost 35lbs in four months. When I reach my goal weight I’ll eat to maintain.

jewel1968 · 22/08/2021 14:10

I agree it's not a diet book and I agree with the poster that said some people are treating it like a diet book. It's full of science and history and things that have confounded scientists for years.

The sense I get from it is that science is quite far behind in understanding weight, obesity and health. He tries to build our knowledge using relevant research so that we can make informed choices. He specifically says don't weigh yourself as I think he has some understanding of the mindset behind dieting and yet loads of people are weighing themselves.

As others have said have a read and make your own mind up.

gwenneh · 22/08/2021 13:52

Calories are still calories. Different macronutrients have different amounts of calories, but they're still the same things -- calories.

badpuma · 22/08/2021 13:49

A calorie isn't really a calorie though.

Calories are based on experiments by Wilbur Atwater in the 1880s and according to New Scientist on 16th June this year:
'In Atwater’s experiment, he fed various foods to human volunteers and measured the heat of combustion of the resulting faeces (reflect on this the next time you want to complain about your job). By calculating the difference in the heat of combustion between the food and the faeces, he approximated the calories that were absorbed by his volunteers.
In 1900, after a whole lot of burnt poop, Atwater presented his calculations to the world: we absorb 9 kcal per gram of fat, 4 kcal per gram of carbohydrates and 4 kcal per gram of protein. More than 120 years on, these “Atwater factors” are still the basis for how calorie counts on all food packaging are derived.'

54321nought · 22/08/2021 13:46

@CirqueDeMorgue

Meh, 'burn' more calories than you consume, it's the only way you'll lose weight. Anyone who says otherwise is kidding themselves.
but, as the book explains, this has been disproved.

If you use up more calories, your body simply compensates by using fewer elsewhere for a while

Peridot1 · 22/08/2021 13:43

I’ve read the book. It really resonated with me. I have been dieting for 30 years. And gotten progressively bigger. I’ve done WW, SW, Atkins, BIWI’s bootcamps etc etc etc etc. I have been feeling more and more like a failure and have gotten to the stage even thinking about starting yet another diet utterly depresses me. I’ve sworn off diets now.

The book explained to me why it’s not my fault. It’s not a diet book. It’s a scientific explanation as to why dieting doesn’t work in the long term. For most people. Yes some people go on one diet in their lives and lose the weight they need and successfully maintain that loss. However those of use who have been on and off diets for years have messed up our set point and it is much much harder to stick to a diet and maintain a loss.

He’s a bariatric surgeon who over years and years of treating people who really struggled to lose weight actually researched WHY it’s so hard for some people.

I was on the first couple of threads on here about the book but I stopped reading them as they became too similar to diet threads and for me it’s not a diet book.

The reason for restricting processed foods and sugar etc is that they are rubbish for us anyway. It’s only in the last 30 years or so that we have such unlimited access to constant crap ‘foods’. We are living in a much more obesegenic environment. Also cheap processed oils used in food manufacturing has a huge impact too. All of this rubbish we eat has an effect.

It’s a really interesting book if you are at all interested in health but I don’t think it’s a diet book.

gwenneh · 22/08/2021 13:35

@lazylinguist

Meh, 'burn' more calories than you consume, it's the only way you'll lose weight. Anyone who says otherwise is kidding themselves.

Even if that were 100% true (which I don't quite think it is), it would still be a massive oversimplification. All calories are not equal. Different foods with the same calorie content have drastically different effects on your appetite, blood sugar levels, insulin production etc, and therefore have a big effect on your hunger and ability to control what you eat. Not to mention on your health.

A calorie is a calorie. Thermodynamics doesn't change.

The reasons different foods aren't equal is for exactly the reasons you describe, but all of those are important reasons BECAUSE they are the roots of why certain eating patterns cause us to consume more energy than we need.

The effects on our appetite from certain foods can make us eat more or less -- but it's still the consumption of more than we need that leads to weight gain.
The effects of certain foods on blood sugar levels leads to effects on appetite, which leads to the consumption of more fuel than we need.

Again, this is all coming with the caveat of "barring significant medical issues" which COULD cause problems. I'm one of those people on a whole host of medications just to get to the level playing field and I do have to be quite careful about what foods I choose, and how much. Most people don't, though.

I'm not saying metabolic changes from diet aren't real. They are. They're just the current hot topic for the diet industry (since around 2016 when that study around The Biggest Loser contestants was published) when in reality, for most people those metabolic changes don't count for as much as all that -- the science also shows that unless you are extreme dieting, adaptive thermogenesis changes are 1. minimal and 2. reversible

It is a nice way for people to say "but it's my metaaaaaaabolism" in the same way people used to say "but it's my thyyyyyyyroid" a few years ago, though.

Glintwithpersperation · 22/08/2021 13:16

Has anyone read both the Obesity Code (Fung) and why we eat too much. What are the differences in approaches / recommendations / science? (Perhaps I’m just being a bit lazy and should read it myself)

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 13:12

Meh, 'burn' more calories than you consume, it's the only way you'll lose weight. Anyone who says otherwise is kidding themselves.

Even if that were 100% true (which I don't quite think it is), it would still be a massive oversimplification. All calories are not equal. Different foods with the same calorie content have drastically different effects on your appetite, blood sugar levels, insulin production etc, and therefore have a big effect on your hunger and ability to control what you eat. Not to mention on your health.

JumpLeadsForTwo · 22/08/2021 13:07

@CirqueDeMorgue

Meh, 'burn' more calories than you consume, it's the only way you'll lose weight. Anyone who says otherwise is kidding themselves.
You clearly haven't read the book!
lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 13:07

I honestly wasn't trying to be goady! I just meant that people do get enthusiastic about weight loss methods that are working for them, so it's not really surprising if they somewhat vigorously recommend them to someone who starts a thread saying that their method has stalled.

There are lots of dieting methods. Some become very popular and then pass out of favour. I guess that whether you consider them fads or not depends on what you mean by a fad. It can just mean something that has a short phase of major popularity. Or it can imply that the thing is shallow, worthless, overrated. It's quite likely this book will pass out of favour quite quickly, to be replaced by the next thing. But that doesn't mean that the points it makes and the advice it gives are wrong. I mean - how can avoiding highly processed foods and sugar be bad advice?!

CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 13:03

Meh, 'burn' more calories than you consume, it's the only way you'll lose weight. Anyone who says otherwise is kidding themselves.

JumpLeadsForTwo · 22/08/2021 12:56

[quote Rainingonsaturday]@lazylinguist I’m not sure how to take that, as I do think you’re possibly not wanting an answer and just trying to be goady.

I have lost weight. I have lost over 4 stone in fact. But I hit a plateau. All I needed was a bit of encouragement, in that instance.

But it’s not really that. It’s as I’ve said I’ve been round the dieting block a few times and I’ve seen people enthusiastically recommend various books and methods and techniques and they’ve mostly all had their day in the sun then things have moved on.

@Chocaholic9 god love ya but no alcohol, sugar or caffeine is NOT eating whatever you want Grin[/quote]
It really isn't a diet book, more a discussion of the evidence behind why diets don't work, why there has been a significant increase in people's weights over the last few decades, and how to counteract the environmental changes which have driven the obesity epidemic. The fact that you say you have been on different diets in the past, and back on another one mean that they haven't given you sustainable weight loss, and the reason why is exactly explained in the book. Maybe actually read it, then decide it is rubbish or not!

Rainingonsaturday · 22/08/2021 12:35

@lazylinguist I’m not sure how to take that, as I do think you’re possibly not wanting an answer and just trying to be goady.

I have lost weight. I have lost over 4 stone in fact. But I hit a plateau. All I needed was a bit of encouragement, in that instance.

But it’s not really that. It’s as I’ve said I’ve been round the dieting block a few times and I’ve seen people enthusiastically recommend various books and methods and techniques and they’ve mostly all had their day in the sun then things have moved on.

@Chocaholic9 god love ya but no alcohol, sugar or caffeine is NOT eating whatever you want Grin

OP posts:
Chocaholic9 · 22/08/2021 12:14

The only way I have found to maintain a healthy weight is giving up sugar completely.... I also gave up alcohol and caffeine, using Allen Carr's books.

I now eat whatever I want (including plenty of carbs) but no sugar, alcohol or caffeine. I don't put on weight and my weight doesn't fluctuate.

54321nought · 22/08/2021 11:59

It isn't a "fad" - it is an explanation of the general progress in understanding of diet and obesity

It is a summary of all the other resources, research and advances made this century

None of his ideas are new, or even his ideas, many have been around for decades, growing in evidence base the whole time

It is an explanation of how science has developed and moved forward over the last 20 years, all peer reviewed, all now established and well understood science

Not that anyone can ever 110% guarantee that any scientific fact will never be disputed, that is the nature of science

But it is completely mainstream, that is why you are seeing it everywhere

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 11:54

@lazylinguist to give an example, a few months ago I hit maintenance mode and it just was not shifting. I posted a thread about it. I got a lot of replies urging me over but I was doing a totally different diet and my thread got buried a bit in people being a bit evangelical about it.

So you were asking for advice because your method was not working, or no longer working, and people enthusiastically recommended what was working for them? Doesn't sound like an unreasonable response tbh. What did you want them to say - keep doing your diet that's not shifting your weight?