Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this Why We Eat Too Much is a fad?

137 replies

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 14:47

OK - probably provocative title, and I’m not trying to be goady or anything like that.

However, I’m losing weight. Every time I click on a weight loss thread this book is being pushed at people.

I remember this happening with Paul McKenna and more recently some Facebook weight group, then it was all about fasting. AIBU to think it’s another faddy thing?

Will have a look at the threads but does anyone want to convince me otherwise? Smile

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 16:17

You believe that all people who are overweight 'stuff their faces all day long'?

JumpLeadsForTwo · 22/08/2021 16:16

@CirqueDeMorgue

Oh dear. I wonder why so many people lose weight when they stop stuffing their faces all day long then.

You know, I read a theory about why obesity wasn't such an issue in the 70s even though people weren't necessarily as health conscious, especially with regard to food. Simply, they weren't eating constantly like people do now. That checks out, imo.

Oh but it doesn't!!! If you read the book, it explains why obesity levels have rocketed since the 70s, and it isn't just that they weren't snacking and were moving more as is the older theory.
IcedPurple · 22/08/2021 16:15

@CirqueDeMorgue

Oh dear. I wonder why so many people lose weight when they stop stuffing their faces all day long then.

You know, I read a theory about why obesity wasn't such an issue in the 70s even though people weren't necessarily as health conscious, especially with regard to food. Simply, they weren't eating constantly like people do now. That checks out, imo.

There's no doubt that not 'stuffing your face' will result in short-term weight loss. That's the easy bit. Any diet will achieve that.

What's tricky is keeping the weight off, and cutting calories has been shown, time after time, to be ineffective in doing that. You're trying to sound all smart alecky, but actually you're just ignorant of the relevant research.

ThisIsSimplyBeyond · 22/08/2021 16:15

I haven't read it either, but I think it's brilliant. ⭐️

CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 16:12

Oh dear. I wonder why so many people lose weight when they stop stuffing their faces all day long then.

You know, I read a theory about why obesity wasn't such an issue in the 70s even though people weren't necessarily as health conscious, especially with regard to food. Simply, they weren't eating constantly like people do now. That checks out, imo.

Jujujuly · 22/08/2021 16:11

@CirqueDeMorgue it’s not about eating less at all - it explains why it’s what you eat not how much you eat that really matters.

It actually explains why numerous studies have proven that eating less doesn’t actually work.

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 16:11

No. Soo, it's not aimed at people who want to lose weight? And the author didn't profit from it? Wow.

Literally nobody said either of those things. Are you reading a different thread?

Rainingonsaturday · 22/08/2021 16:10

Well, maybe if it’s frustrating you that much that you are deciding people having a polite conversation are getting defensive, it’s best to leave us to it? I’d quite like to be able to read people’s replies without you jumping down my throat every time I post, tbh.

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 16:10

You don't understand why people claim to know that eating less helps with weight loss? 🤔 I mean, it's a tried and tested method...

Hmm I'm pretty sure Tammy meant she wasn't sure why someone would criticise a book without having read it. It's just rather arrogant tbh.

You don't understand why people claim to know that eating less helps with weight loss? 🤔 I mean, it's a tried and tested method...

Uh huh. What proportion of dieters does it work for... long term? The figures I've seen for that don't make it look very 'tried and tested' to me. Unless you mean 'tried, tested and found rarely to work'.

IcedPurple · 22/08/2021 16:09

You don't understand why people claim to know that eating less helps with weight loss? 🤔 I mean, it's a tried and tested method...

Tried, tested and proven not to work in the long term. Many times.

IcedPurple · 22/08/2021 16:07

@CirqueDeMorgue

Meh, 'burn' more calories than you consume, it's the only way you'll lose weight. Anyone who says otherwise is kidding themselves.
Why do people trot out this line as though it were some great pearl of wisdom?

The "a calorie is a calorie" theory has been disproved time and time again, as has 'eat less, move more'. It's simply not true. Our bodies aren't internal combustion engines. They're vastly more complex than tha.

CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 16:06

You clearly haven't read it, have you?

No. Soo, it's not aimed at people who want to lose weight? And the author didn't profit from it? Wow.

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 16:05

No, but it is often recommended on threads where people are trying or wanting to lose weight.

Yes, because it's not a diet book, but it is a book which explains a lot about why diets repeatedly fail. Understanding why your (perhaps almost lifelong) efforts have failed is helpful. As is having some general, pointers (rather than a strict regime) to help you work out how best to eat for you.

I read the book a few months ago. I started eating plenty, but only at meal times (no snacks), lots of veg, avoiding processed food as much as possible, and drinking more water (because I suspect sometimes I think I'm hungry when I'm actually thirsty. I made no attempt to eat low calorie, low carb, or low fat. I was definitely getting significantly slimmer (I don't weigh myself). It all went a bit to pot while I've been away on holiday, but I'm back to good habits now. I will not be doing another diet (except this one, if you want to call it a diet) ever again.

CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 16:05

[quote TammyTwoSwanson]@cirquedemorgue Nope. It's "eat better". Not less.

I really don't understand why people who haven't read the book would claim to know all about it. It's so weird.[/quote]
You don't understand why people claim to know that eating less helps with weight loss? 🤔 I mean, it's a tried and tested method...

BIWI · 22/08/2021 16:02

@Rainingonsaturday

It’s interesting as from my point of view I’m not being defensive, just talking nicely, but I’m finding you massively defensive! Perhaps we are misreading one another? Smile
Not defensive. Frustrated!
BIWI · 22/08/2021 16:02

@CirqueDeMorgue

It's one of many books aimed at people who want to lose weight, written by people who want to make money. It all comes down to the same thing which is essentially 'eat less.'
You clearly haven't read it, have you?
TammyTwoSwanson · 22/08/2021 15:58

@cirquedemorgue Nope. It's "eat better". Not less.

I really don't understand why people who haven't read the book would claim to know all about it. It's so weird.

JumpLeadsForTwo · 22/08/2021 15:56

This thread is clearly divided between
"I haven't read the book, but I'll give my opinion anyway and it's clearly a diet book, why bother when a calorie is just a calorie, I'll carry on dieting.."
And
"I have read the book, it isn't a diet book, but really informative and explains why a calorie is not a calorie, and why diets don't work in the long term.." Grin

CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 15:53

It's one of many books aimed at people who want to lose weight, written by people who want to make money. It all comes down to the same thing which is essentially 'eat less.'

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 15:52

He gives a few interesting examples in the book. One is the 'Biggest Loser' follow-up mentioned upthread. One is an experiment done in a prison, where prisoners were fed massive amounts of calories but all hit a point where even though they kept upping the calories, they stopped gaining weight.

The other example I remember is where he looks at the increase in caloric intake of American men during a period of time (1980s onwards), coinciding with the rise in obesity, which would appear to agree with the 1st rule of thermodynamics theory. But when you look at the figures, they don't add up. The weight increase is not anything like as high as the increase in calories suggest it should be. His point being that the body compensates a lot in order to deal with the excess calorie intake. As it does also if you eat too few calories.

Rainingonsaturday · 22/08/2021 15:51

It’s interesting as from my point of view I’m not being defensive, just talking nicely, but I’m finding you massively defensive! Perhaps we are misreading one another? Smile

OP posts:
BIWI · 22/08/2021 15:50

Of course it would be! Because it explains the science behind weight loss. (And why it's often so hard to lose weight).

I don't get why you're so defensive about this. It's not a book about maiming kittens or disembowelling puppies.

Rainingonsaturday · 22/08/2021 15:48

No, but it is often recommended on threads where people are trying or wanting to lose weight.

OP posts:
BIWI · 22/08/2021 15:46

Well, as many of us have said, this isn't a diet book! It's not trying to push anything.

It is, however, hugely informative. It's also easy to read too.

I'd seriously recommend it.

therearenogoodusernamesleft · 22/08/2021 15:45

I really didn't see it as a diet book. It's more of a sociological overview on why society has got bigger. Yes, there are learnings from it, but it's hardly a weight loss plan.