Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this Why We Eat Too Much is a fad?

137 replies

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 14:47

OK - probably provocative title, and I’m not trying to be goady or anything like that.

However, I’m losing weight. Every time I click on a weight loss thread this book is being pushed at people.

I remember this happening with Paul McKenna and more recently some Facebook weight group, then it was all about fasting. AIBU to think it’s another faddy thing?

Will have a look at the threads but does anyone want to convince me otherwise? Smile

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TammyTwoSwanson · 22/08/2021 21:50

@LineofFruity There is hope! Keep reading Smile

Jujujuly · 22/08/2021 20:31

It’s more complicated and nuanced than more calories = more weight gain because it also depends on an individual’s metabolism, which is affected by genetic and epigenetic factors, as well as what the additional calories actually are. I definitely know people who stay slim while eating loads of junk and others who struggle to maintain their weight. People are different. Hormonal factors also massively affect weight. I’m breastfeeding my second child and still half a stone up on pre baby weight. This was the same with my first and when I stopped bf I lost it all within a couple of weeks without any change in diet. I’ve exercised lots more this time and cut out all refined sugar and am still half a stone up. Expecting to lose it in a similar way again.

The core message of the book is to cook unprocessed foods from scratch which really seems like the opposite of faddy to me.

LineofFruity · 22/08/2021 17:47

Rainingonsaturday that’s a great loss! How long did it take and did you replace all meals?

He actually says in the book at one point that if you have been obese for a while (I think he said five years but can’t recall) and have diabetes for example, you won’t be able to fight against your weight set point. You will always eventually fail. I found that so disheartening. I did start researching surgery. I don’t see how it is possible for me to lose 3 to 4 stone. I’ve genuinely tried. I do a lot of exercise, always cook from scratch using fresh ingredients, but do eat some junk and drink Diet Coke… his book (which I’m still reading) made me feel it is actually hopeless. I hope it does give some hope in later chapters.

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 17:05

I don't think I said that eating excess calories does not cause weight gain though. I said it wasn't as simple as that. There's plenty of explanation of why in the article. And indeed in the book.

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 16:43

It isn’t because of apples, though. Neither statement is accurate.

Nobody said getting fat was actually to do with apples though, did they?

CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 16:37

@lazylinguist if increased calorie intake does not result in weight gain, please can you explain why the participants who ate 500 more calories (no matter WHY they ate them, the fact is, they did) gained weight while the participants who did not eat 500 extra calories did not gain weight?

Rainingonsaturday · 22/08/2021 16:35

Absolutely, someone doesn’t need to eat McDonald’s every day to get fat. It isn’t because of apples, though. Neither statement is accurate.

OP posts:
ConfusedParticle · 22/08/2021 16:34

shop not whop, haha!
prefer a tesco whop myself:)

ConfusedParticle · 22/08/2021 16:33

ive had a read of the weight loss section recently, and honestly there's some pretty faddy, obsessive stuff flying around. I know this will offend someone but it isn't meant too, I suppose if you're outside looking in, it can seem terribly fad driven.

each poster swears by this or that, nothing unusual there, but there's a very sycophantic element when everyone gets on the latest, obsessive food thing.

I can't judge personally, I'm a slim person who eats bread in moderation and I fucking love it, so what do I know?

I do think obsessive naval gazing over what we eat is somewhat disordered, culturally encouraged and really oppressive for women. One woman on those threads went out and spent over £200 on one Waitrose whop to test out a new low carb fad. Had no idea of her own body or it's requirements, just jumping on the fad bus.

It's so excessive and just another reason to overspend. Having said all that I am also a bit wanky as I only eat organic meat, but this is once in a rare while.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 22/08/2021 16:33

@Rainingonsaturday

To be fair, you need to eat more as you get bigger to continue gaining.

No way on this earth would someone get to say 18 stone just by eating one apple a day on top of 2000 calories!

The point I'm making is that it isn't all about people eating 5 x McDonalds a week and snacking constantly. It can be much more modest overeating - portions of a (healthy) meal regularly being that bit too large, having a pudding a bit too often, deciding to finish off the leftovers and that sort of thing.

Not necessarily the stereotype of an enormous person eating a family sized bag of crisps and a Mars Bar washed down with full fat Coke, which was what the quoted poster seemed to be getting at.

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 16:32

Yes, we've already talked about how different foods affect yoyr appetite. The article also says

The truth is that even careful calorie calculations don't always yield uniform results. How your body burns calories depends on a number of factors, including the type of food you eat, your body's metabolism, and even the type of organisms living in your gut. You can eat the exact same number of calories as someone else, yet have very different outcomes when it comes to your weight.

BIWI · 22/08/2021 16:32

@ThisIsSimplyBeyond

I haven't read it either, but I think it's brilliant. ⭐️
Grin

That's more like it ...

CecilyP · 22/08/2021 16:31

What's tricky is keeping the weight off, and cutting calories has been shown, time after time, to be ineffective in doing that. You're trying to sound all smart alecky, but actually you're just ignorant of the relevant research.

So what keeps the weight off then? Is it eating fewer calories, the same number of calories or more calories? Because it has to be one of the three, however anyone chooses to dress it up.

CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 16:29

Ok, from that article, it literally says here that the people who gained weight ate 500 MORE calories than the participants who didn't gain weight.

To think this Why We Eat Too Much is a fad?
lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 16:29

@lazylinguist I believe lots of people do. Is that not why 'intermittent fasting ' is so popular?

No, intermittent fasting isn't popular because people stuff their faces all day. It's popular because it's a simple-to-understand weight loss method which doesn't involve calorie counting or restricting food groups. Some people find it easy to stick to. It usually involves skipping breakfast, but in theory you could still 'stuff your face' throughout the rest of the day during your eating window. Or on your non-fasting days, if you're doing that version. It doesn't work for me, because it messes with my digestion. People fall off the wagon of course, like they do with all dieting methods.

Rainingonsaturday · 22/08/2021 16:27

To be fair, you need to eat more as you get bigger to continue gaining.

No way on this earth would someone get to say 18 stone just by eating one apple a day on top of 2000 calories!

OP posts:
CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 16:25

@IcedPurple I never said you should, I'm just saying eating less works. 😄 I'm sure there is plenty of 'anecdotal evidence' to tell you that but you do you!

SquirryTheSquirrel · 22/08/2021 16:24

@CirqueDeMorgue

Oh dear. I wonder why so many people lose weight when they stop stuffing their faces all day long then.

You know, I read a theory about why obesity wasn't such an issue in the 70s even though people weren't necessarily as health conscious, especially with regard to food. Simply, they weren't eating constantly like people do now. That checks out, imo.

The thing you're missing is that most people who are overweight don't become so in a small space of time.

To gain 1lb takes 3500 calories (roughly). So overeating by about 100 calories a day - that's a single apple, for example - you'd gain about 1lb a month. After a year you'd be almost a stone overweight. Three years on, you might be tipping into obesity.

I'm not denying there are overweight people who overeat by much more than that, but there's usually an underlying reason - depression, for example.

But whether a person overeats by a lot, or has gained weight slowly by overeating slightly over many years, characterising the overweight as people who 'stuff their faces' helps absolutely no one.

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 16:23

If you don't want to read the book, then how about this article from Harvard Medical School, explaining why the calories-in vs calories-out approach is, in their words, 'not only antiquated, but just wrong'.

IcedPurple · 22/08/2021 16:23

@CirqueDeMorgue

Ok *@IcedPurple* you take what you want! In my experience, cutting calories (the amount I ate) resulted in weight loss.
Give me one good reason why I'd take the 'experience' of an anonymous MN poster over carefully conducted researching involving thousands of people?
CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 16:22

Ok @IcedPurple you take what you want! In my experience, cutting calories (the amount I ate) resulted in weight loss.

CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 16:20

@lazylinguist I believe lots of people do. Is that not why 'intermittent fasting ' is so popular?

lazylinguist · 22/08/2021 16:20

"The book is wrong"

"Have you actually read the book?"

"No. But I know it's wrong anyway."

IcedPurple · 22/08/2021 16:20

@CirqueDeMorgue

If you say so *@IcedPurple*. I managed to maintain by being aware of how many calories I'm eating. It's been years now and my weight has remained more or less the same. I know others who had the same experience re weight loss. :)
It's not just me saying so. Decades of research have shown that cutting calories does not result in long or even medium term weight loss. I'll take that over the anecdotal 'evidence' and smiley faces of anonymous posters on MN.
CirqueDeMorgue · 22/08/2021 16:18

If you say so @IcedPurple. I managed to maintain by being aware of how many calories I'm eating. It's been years now and my weight has remained more or less the same. I know others who had the same experience re weight loss. :)

Swipe left for the next trending thread