Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister and I just had a blazing row - am I wrong?

116 replies

Forever27 · 21/08/2021 14:07

Normally we get on fine and I love her dearly, she is my only sibling after all but we've just had a huge argument which resulted in her storming out of my house and sending me multiple texts saying I'm a "nasty person". For context - my parents have helped both of us financially but in different ways. They gave me a cash gift of £5,000 and they paid for new furniture for my sister when she moved into her new house. This was because she lived with my parents previously so didn't have any furniture of her own. They gave me cash as I'd already been renting for many years before buying my flat and I was taking my furniture with me. I used the £5,000 to bump up my deposit and pay the solicitors fees.

I'm not exactly sure how much they spent on my sister as I've never asked. Quite frankly, I don't care as it's not a competition. They've helped both of us when they weren't obliged to (we're both adults after all) and for that I'll always be grateful. My sister moved last year and I moved around 6 months ago and ever since she's been really "off" with me. She's made several comments about how lucky I am that our parents helped me which of course is true, but they've also helped her to Hmm. She would have been sitting on garden furniture in her living room if it wasn't for our parents. Once they'd (sister and her partner) paid the deposit, mortgage fees etc they were skint.

Whilst I'm grateful and feel extremely lucky that my parents helped me, technically they didn't need to as I had the money to buy already saved up. They helped because they wanted to.
My sister came over earlier for a brew and mentioned again how lucky I was that our parents had helped me otherwise I wouldn't have been able to buy "my lovely house" (her words, not mine) which is clearly not true. She knows that to. I'm not sure how she can begrudge me the help when they helped her too?! I don't think she has any right to be pissed off but if she is she needs to take it up with our parents, not me. I don't bring the subject up as I know it will cause arguments but she can't help herself making shitty comments.

AIBU?

OP posts:
SmokeyDevil · 21/08/2021 15:29

What she asked for in furniture could have easily gotten to more than 5k very easily. A corner sofa alone could end up being £1500 by itself. Doesn't have to be obviously, but considering how immature the sister seems to be, I doubt she picked bargain or second hand stuff. More along the lines of similar posters on here who think nothing of spending £200 on a lamp shade.

Either way, it's your parents that she needs to take it up with, not you. Your parents sound like they were trying to be fair. Like my in laws, if they pay a bill for one child, they'll give the other child the same in money.

If the sister is really upset about it, she could always give back all of her furniture, you give back your 5k and she furnishes her own home. Somehow I doubt she will do that.

Fairyliz · 21/08/2021 15:29

Sorry it’s not really clear if she knows they gave you £5000. Perhaps she is looking at your lovely flat and thinking they gave you the deposit so say £30k?

elfycat · 21/08/2021 15:27

My parents paid of the remaining few thousand of my sisters mortgage (using an inheritance) so they could focus on starting a family (adoption as IVF didn't work for them). My other sister and I were sent cheques for the same amount - which we used to reduce our mortgages, but could have blown on a holiday or anything.

When my DAunt died a few years later my father split her £18k between us - £6k cheques each, and the mortgage-free sister said 'oh that's what it's like to receive money'.

We'd been given exactly the same money overall, but the difference between being freely given a cash gift, and having the gift-money directed at one repayment felt very different to that sister. She wasn't ungrateful, or resentful - just observant about the difference we know we were all fortunate

It might be that you had the cash equivalent of her 'gift' - furniture can be expensive if there's lots to buy, but doesn't look or feel the same as actually having the £££ in the bank. And since it wasn't explicitly made to be equal I can see how your sister might feel, while at the same time it's not your fault. It might be unequal in which case it was your parents that made that error, and still nothing to do with you.

WTF475878237NC · 21/08/2021 15:26

I've never believed fair means completely the same.

It would have been ridiculous to buy £5k in furniture if she didn't need it. It makes more sense to me that they bought her some furniture and will give her more money if she needs it in the future. But regardless, none of this is your issue! She needs to moan to your parents and is obviously jealous of where you are in life.

Samafe · 21/08/2021 15:22

Were there other times, when your parents sort of helped you more than her?

I have a brother, and i know my parents helped my brother way more financially for a series of reasons.
Now my brother is getting married and they told me "they are helping him" without giving me a precise number.
I assume it will be more than the 500£ they gave me because of the history we have, but I might be completely wrong!
Maybe your sister does not know the numbers and she is assuming...?

Tocktock · 21/08/2021 15:19

With my kids, if I had the spare money and somebody needed say a new bed, I'd pay for it then probably ask around to see if anyone else needed anything of similar value ( or more likely, I'd keep a general tally so that over time they all get the same amount)

anonforamo · 21/08/2021 15:15

Not your fault at all op. Sounds like in her mind she's made it bigger than it is, that they 'handed you the money for the house' and she got a bit of furniture. Obviously that's not correct and she's stretching the reality a bit. What she asked for is quite a bit of furniture, I'd be surprised if it didn't come in at least close to yours.

I wonder if she knows what hers came to, say maybe it was under 4k or around there so feels like they should have made up the difference.

In some ways I wonder had your parents said they'd love to help with furniture, and since they gave you 5000 they will provide the same budget and sister can use how she needs, well that would have prevented all the ill feeling. In some ways it's just wording but in other ways it really prevents fall outs and feeling like one is favoured etc.

Puffalicious · 21/08/2021 15:14

[quote viques]@HurryUpAndWait23

OP says she used the five grand to “bump up her deposit”and pay her solicitors fees. So the money clearly went towards paying for an appreciating investment rather than a pile of depreciating firewood. As I said, I know who got the better deal.[/quote]
Absolute nonsense. The OP paid for her own furniture previously. If her sister had paid for her own furniture she'd probably have had £5000 too. It's not the OP's fault they spent the money on different things. As a PP said, the sister could have used the money in the same way and saved up with her partner for furniture (as most people have to. I had a 2nd hand sofa for 5 years in my 1st flat and cast offs from everyone and anyone).

This is small potatoes: my DF left a will giving all of us children (5 of us) different amounts and our children wildly different amounts. Like a lovely game of pick your favourite child / grandchild.

RosieLemonadeAndSugar · 21/08/2021 15:13

I'm sure your parents know exactly how much they spent on her furniture and that's how they came up with a grand total of £5,000.

They didn't just pluck that figure out of thin air. It seems she just thinks because you were in a better position initially that this extra £5,000 has helped you even more but that's no-ones fault that you were in a better position first!

She just sounds jealous but you need to speak about it WITH your parents so they can clear up how much they gave you both.

RuggerHug · 21/08/2021 15:13

Was she paying rent to your parents when she lived with them? Could she see it as they took from her to give to you when you didn't need it?

PearlyBird · 21/08/2021 15:10

By the sounds of it you had both got yr houses when your parents offered money but you very very slightly (cant have been by much) reduced yr mortgage repayments by upping yr deposit.

So the gift keeps giving in yr case but i cant imagine that after solicitors fees, the small amount you upped yr deposit could have reduced yr mortgage repayments by ver much!

HurryUpAndWait23 · 21/08/2021 15:09

I agree tocktock. She still would have bought a home without the 5k, and by the sounds of it had all the furniture already.

Tocktock · 21/08/2021 15:08

[quote viques]@HurryUpAndWait23

OP says she used the five grand to “bump up her deposit”and pay her solicitors fees. So the money clearly went towards paying for an appreciating investment rather than a pile of depreciating firewood. As I said, I know who got the better deal.[/quote]
So do you think the parents should have given sister more, for a deposit and a bit of 'depreciating firewood'?

Personally I think OP was in a better position due to her own previous choices, and the parents just gave an equal or almost equal amount. Being given furniture money would free up sister's other funds anyway.

Forever27 · 21/08/2021 15:07

@Knittingupastorm neither of those. My parents asked her how they could help and she said that she needed new furniture and then gave them a list. She chose everything she wanted and they paid for it.

OP posts:
PearlyBird · 21/08/2021 15:06

Yr sister used up yr parents generosity less sensibly perhaps?
But she was already moving to a new house. And altho7gh houses appreciate, your sister needed money for furniture at the same time she bought the house, not ten years earlier

Forever27 · 21/08/2021 15:05

@viques my parents asked her how they could help and her answer was "furniture". If she had asked for cash then my parents would have given it to her, but she didn't.

OP posts:
SausageRollFan · 21/08/2021 15:03

Yanbu. I agree with others you need to ask her what her problem is and if she thinks you got more or something.

My lovely mil has helped out my partners siblings in the past and whenever she does she gives her other children the same amount of £/cash equivalent to keep it all even. Sounds like your DP's have done the same .

viques · 21/08/2021 15:03

@HurryUpAndWait23

OP says she used the five grand to “bump up her deposit”and pay her solicitors fees. So the money clearly went towards paying for an appreciating investment rather than a pile of depreciating firewood. As I said, I know who got the better deal.

DancesWithTortoises · 21/08/2021 15:02

You aren't coming across as smug at all, OP.

Some posters just post trying to upset. Ignore them.

Your sister seems a bit potty to keep bringing it up.

QueenBee52 · 21/08/2021 14:59

[quote Forever27]@ToykotoLosAngeles apologies you're right I have said both. Mine is a flat (I live alone) and my sisters is a house. My flat is lovely and I'm very happy here but her house is lovely too, nicer in fact. [/quote]

she sounds unhinged ... has she perhaps asked your Parents for more money and been knocked back 🤔

Tocktock · 21/08/2021 14:59

It sounds to me like your parents gave you and your sister a similar amount. We looked at a corner sofa about 3 years ago and it was just shy of 3k. Add to that the price of a bed ( our king-size mattress alone was £800 pounds in 2014.
I'd say your sister has decided for herself that you got more than you did, because she didn't know about your savings.
The only solution is for the pair of you to be honest, ime.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 21/08/2021 14:58

[quote Forever27]@ToykotoLosAngeles apologies you're right I have said both. Mine is a flat (I live alone) and my sisters is a house. My flat is lovely and I'm very happy here but her house is lovely too, nicer in fact. [/quote]
I see! I asked in case you have a much bigger and nicer home that she's jealous of.

FrenchBoule · 21/08/2021 14:58

Sister could have had second hand furniture and boost her deposit with the money.

HurryUpAndWait23 · 21/08/2021 14:56

@viques

While your asset is appreciating in value. Her furniture, however much it cost, is depreciating.

I know who got the better deal.

But the OP saved up for her own deposit.

That's got nothing to do with it.

Forever27 · 21/08/2021 14:56

@ToykotoLosAngeles apologies you're right I have said both. Mine is a flat (I live alone) and my sisters is a house. My flat is lovely and I'm very happy here but her house is lovely too, nicer in fact.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread