Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister and I just had a blazing row - am I wrong?

116 replies

Forever27 · 21/08/2021 14:07

Normally we get on fine and I love her dearly, she is my only sibling after all but we've just had a huge argument which resulted in her storming out of my house and sending me multiple texts saying I'm a "nasty person". For context - my parents have helped both of us financially but in different ways. They gave me a cash gift of £5,000 and they paid for new furniture for my sister when she moved into her new house. This was because she lived with my parents previously so didn't have any furniture of her own. They gave me cash as I'd already been renting for many years before buying my flat and I was taking my furniture with me. I used the £5,000 to bump up my deposit and pay the solicitors fees.

I'm not exactly sure how much they spent on my sister as I've never asked. Quite frankly, I don't care as it's not a competition. They've helped both of us when they weren't obliged to (we're both adults after all) and for that I'll always be grateful. My sister moved last year and I moved around 6 months ago and ever since she's been really "off" with me. She's made several comments about how lucky I am that our parents helped me which of course is true, but they've also helped her to Hmm. She would have been sitting on garden furniture in her living room if it wasn't for our parents. Once they'd (sister and her partner) paid the deposit, mortgage fees etc they were skint.

Whilst I'm grateful and feel extremely lucky that my parents helped me, technically they didn't need to as I had the money to buy already saved up. They helped because they wanted to.
My sister came over earlier for a brew and mentioned again how lucky I was that our parents had helped me otherwise I wouldn't have been able to buy "my lovely house" (her words, not mine) which is clearly not true. She knows that to. I'm not sure how she can begrudge me the help when they helped her too?! I don't think she has any right to be pissed off but if she is she needs to take it up with our parents, not me. I don't bring the subject up as I know it will cause arguments but she can't help herself making shitty comments.

AIBU?

OP posts:
User135792468 · 21/08/2021 18:19

I would speak to your parents and ask them to address it with her. Make clear to them that your sisters perceived unfairness is actually causing issues between you both.

TonkinLenkicks · 21/08/2021 18:15

I don’t think you sound smug. Ridiculous suggestion. Agree you’re not in the wrong but she needs to speak to your parents.

ThinWomansBrain · 21/08/2021 18:13

Even if the value of each gift were similar, it seems odd that your parents didn't treat you equally - you got to make the choice of using the cash to increase the deposit, your sister didn't.
SHe might have chosen to make do with second hand, or less furniture, and used the cash - in her position I'd appreciate the gift, but feel a bit aggrieved that they'd treated you like an adult.
It could be as simple as having done it for your sister, it seemed less hassle to give you the cash equivalent, maybe they felt that her living at home for longer meant you 'deserved' more.
Hard for either to ask them without sounding ungrateful - but unfortunate that your parents generosity has resulted in resentment.

Twillow · 21/08/2021 18:09

Yeah, they appear to have favoured you. From the furniture you listed it would have to be extremely high end to be nearing £5000.
But was that what the argument was about, anyway? It's not clear what made her call you a 'nasty person'?

HavanaGoodTime · 21/08/2021 17:57

Your sister needs to give her head a wobble.

A few years back my car broke beyond repair and at the time we were struggling to afford a good replacement (7 seater required). My parents had some money they planned to give me and DB so they brought the timing forward, paid for our new car and DB got cash in the bank. DB used his to go on a huge holiday.

Fast forward a few years and they wanted to give us both another lump sum. Ours got spent on moving to a larger house, DB again went on a nice holiday and bought some nice luxuray items for himself.

Occassionally my brain tells me to be annoyed that he got 'fun' money and I got 'necessary' money but the reality is, I'm married with 4 DC, a mortgage and all the costs that go with that. DB is young, free and single with a small flat. We both got equal money but our circumstances that were of our own making impacted how that money could be spent.

So basically, your sister is being unreasonable - you chose cash as you had no need for furniture. your sister wanted flash furniture so chose that instead. the fact that she regrets her choice is not your problem.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 21/08/2021 17:31

Does she think they paid all of your flat deposit?

cookingisoverrated · 21/08/2021 17:23

@Givemebackmylilo

You're only confused because you got the higher amount of money. Bet you wouldn't be feeling the same if you'd been shortchanged
It's not clear OP did get more!

Sister lived at home saving money, presumably not paying rent.

Parents bought her all her requested furniture and appliances (it's quite a list!) for her house (not flat!).

Perhaps sis just thinks OP got more than she did. And irrelevant, anyway. Sis had a lot of help!

ineedaholidaynow · 21/08/2021 16:47

@Givemebackmylilo was she shortchanged though if she had been living at home longer

Givemebackmylilo · 21/08/2021 16:18

You're only confused because you got the higher amount of money.
Bet you wouldn't be feeling the same if you'd been shortchanged

Icantbelieveitsnotnutter · 21/08/2021 16:06

Op she sounds a bit like my younger sister. Our parents try to treat us equally and she still resents ME when she's ballsed things up in life, expected them to be there for her and acts entitled. I have to watch what I say and do around her as she acts jealous. It really upsets me as I've often protected her against grim friends and boyfriends and totally want the best for her. I give her a wide birth when she gets petty Sad

SoundBar · 21/08/2021 16:05

She might not know the exact amount they gave you. She might be assuming they gave you 15, 20, 50k!

My lunatic DM lent us some money towards house deposit and charged us interest as we paid it back monthly. She never told DB the amount. Found out later DB had assumed DM gave us 50k Hmm yeah right.

Years of passive agressive weirdness on that one until I clocked maybe he didn't know the facts

GlaskinsPerpetual · 21/08/2021 16:02

@TempName01

Can’t you message her and say ‘look sis, I’m really confused why you are angry about the money our parent gave me for the house as I was led to believe you were given an equal amount for furniture, is that not the case?’
Agree with saying this
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 21/08/2021 15:57

Did she pay full market rate rent to your parents when she lived with them?

If not then surely they subsidised her housing costs, enabling her to save a deposit? And I'd guess that was more than the difference between her furniture and 5000?

In any case she should be taking it up with your parents instead of you. If it was a life changing amount then maybe you shouldn't accept before checking your sister is getting the same. But 5k isn't worth falling out over

TempName01 · 21/08/2021 15:56

She might think they gave you money for the whole deposit! Please just ask her

MargosKaftan · 21/08/2021 15:48

Also worth checking, she doesn't think you got those furniture items as gifts as well. Be clear you bought them yourself.

Chloemol · 21/08/2021 15:47

So when she brings it up again ask her how much all the furniture your parents bought her cost. Make the point she got goods you got cash

DGFB · 21/08/2021 15:47

I agree with telling her you got £5K and you thought she got the same. Then let her chat to your parents!

MargosKaftan · 21/08/2021 15:46

OK you need to ask her straight out - how much did mum and dad spend on furniture for you? Because they gave me £5k which was a lovely bonus, but not expected as id already saved my deposit and they said it was to be fair as they'd spent about the same on furniture for your house, and I'd had to buy my own already, so they gave me the cash rather than buy replacements I didn't need. Was that not true? Did I get significantly more than you?

See what she says when asked directly the value of her gifts.

Id also say you struggled as you paid full rent when you were saving, you assumed they weren't taking market room rent off you as well as bills money, were you wrong about that?

Tocktock · 21/08/2021 15:43

@UserStillatLarge

When did you buy your house? My parent gave my brother £5000 when he bought his house. They also gave me £5000 when I bought my house. In theory this is fair, but actually DB bought his house 10 years before I did and the £5000 from my parents was substantial percentage of the price. By the time I came round to buy, the £5000 was just a bit to add to the deposit I'd saved myself.

The gifts were not equal in value to the recipient (however much they may have been equal in money terms). I wonder if that's where OP's sister is thinking - that OP bought a lovely house with help from her sister and she's only been able to buy something lesser.

OP has a flat, it's the sister who has a house
cookingisoverrated · 21/08/2021 15:40

Your sister sounds like she got pretty much the same as you in the form she wanted it in. Plus she's in a house whereas you're in a less expensive flat, so she's just being a cow, frankly.

India92 · 21/08/2021 15:40

God some people are so ungrateful and selfish.

OP you have done NOTHING wrong. Your sister sounds entitled, and shouldn't expect anything from her parents as she is a fully grown adult. What was wrong with the furniture they got her? That helped her massively, and it is what she needed at the time.

Bet your parents would be so upset if they knew her response.

WTF475878237NC · 21/08/2021 15:36

Jealous of your perceived relationship with your parents perhaps?

UserStillatLarge · 21/08/2021 15:35

When did you buy your house?
My parent gave my brother £5000 when he bought his house. They also gave me £5000 when I bought my house. In theory this is fair, but actually DB bought his house 10 years before I did and the £5000 from my parents was substantial percentage of the price. By the time I came round to buy, the £5000 was just a bit to add to the deposit I'd saved myself.

The gifts were not equal in value to the recipient (however much they may have been equal in money terms). I wonder if that's where OP's sister is thinking - that OP bought a lovely house with help from her sister and she's only been able to buy something lesser.

justamomentplease · 21/08/2021 15:34

@elfycat

My parents paid of the remaining few thousand of my sisters mortgage (using an inheritance) so they could focus on starting a family (adoption as IVF didn't work for them). My other sister and I were sent cheques for the same amount - which we used to reduce our mortgages, but could have blown on a holiday or anything.

When my DAunt died a few years later my father split her £18k between us - £6k cheques each, and the mortgage-free sister said 'oh that's what it's like to receive money'.

We'd been given exactly the same money overall, but the difference between being freely given a cash gift, and having the gift-money directed at one repayment felt very different to that sister. She wasn't ungrateful, or resentful - just observant about the difference we know we were all fortunate

It might be that you had the cash equivalent of her 'gift' - furniture can be expensive if there's lots to buy, but doesn't look or feel the same as actually having the £££ in the bank. And since it wasn't explicitly made to be equal I can see how your sister might feel, while at the same time it's not your fault. It might be unequal in which case it was your parents that made that error, and still nothing to do with you.

I kind of get this.

My in laws very generously offered to pay for us to have a new kitchen when we moved house. DH accepted, I was much more reluctant especially when it became apparent that it was conditional on us using DH's brothers partners company who I really didn't want to use because I absolutely don't believe in mixing business and family. We could choose what we wanted, but we had to use this particular workman and I knew it'd be trouble but there would be nothing we could do about it. I was right, and it caused no end of arguments and I wish I'd have put my foot down and said no thank you.

DHs brother (same one) was given a cheque for the same amount as our kitchen. Fine, all fair. But a while after we were having dinner and he and his partner were talking about how they were going to use their money to do X and Y and I must admit I did think (not say!) 'well it's ok for you, you might have been given the same as us but at least you're free to do what you want with it!'

Forever27 · 21/08/2021 15:33

Lots of comments, trying to keep up.

I am older, I'm 27 and she's 24. She lived with our parents up until she moved out last year. I moved out when I was 21 and rented a tiny flat up until 6 months ago. I believe she did pay a contribution to living there although I'm not exactly sure how much, again it's not something that I asked about. She has a good job and earns around 30k which is good for our area and her age. She also lives with her partner who earns a decent wage too. I don't want to give too many details (or more than I already have) but her house was very close to 200k as where my flat was 95k, big difference imo. If she is jealous, as some posters have said then I have no idea why!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread