Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

. . . to think parents are being naive about our "inheritance"?

314 replies

OhFFSNotAnotherVirus · 21/08/2021 08:04

Just pondering . . . for some reason it's niggling at me, maybe because I find their lack of understanding frustrating!

I also want to point out that I in no way "expect" anything from my parents - I've been financially independent since I was 18 and I'm proud of what I've achieved by myself.

Parent are 65, I have one brother and one sister. Parents gave my brother their life savings (close to £100k) so he could buy a nicer house than he could afford by himself. Parents told me and my sister that they would change their wills to leave their house (a small townhouse worth about £200k) to the two of us, to make it fair.

I don't think it is fair, though. Chances are the house will be sold in the future to pay for their care. They seem blissfully unaware that this is a possibility - or a likelihood - and seem almost smug about having done the right thing by all three of their children. I've brought up the possibility that the house might need to be sold to pay for care, but they dismissed this, saying absolutely not, they wouldn't be going into a home, they'd rather go to Dignitas first . . .

I'm saying nothing further, there's no point and I know there's no entitlement here. But AIBU to be a bit . . . Hmm?

Oh and this all happened a couple of years ago and they haven't changed their wills anyway Grin

OP posts:
diddl · 21/08/2021 09:38

I'm not sure how many years back LAs go for deprivation of assets-it can be quite a few I think.

As for signing a house away & paying literally no rent-that only "works" I think if the people you are renting from have bought the house from you.

I know that things can't always be equal-one of mine has always struggled academically so could in the future have less earning potential for example so ideally they could be given more as a house deposit.

I suppose it depends where you live, but 100k is (to me) one hell of a deposit, especially compared to nothing!

Plus now is when it might be most beneficial for everyone.

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 21/08/2021 09:37

@MargosKaftan

Yes, theres a chance it will go on care.

Theres also a chance that by the time they die, they haven't needed to spend anything on care (or can cope with someone coming in), and the house is worth a hell of a lot more than £200k.

Which currently all three siblings will benefit from because the parents haven’t even changed their will!

On here there’s always an expectation that people should just meekly put up with their parents behaving so appallingly with regards to their assets. It’s not materialistic or rude (as we’re often pushed to think) to question such outrageous favouritism to one child. I would calmly talk to your parents about the situation, how staggeringly unfair it is and question if they’re content with that. If nothing changed I’d distance myself from them and reevaluate the relationship -not to be money grabbing but because I wouldn’t tolerate my parents showing such favouritism to another sibling. They do that and they reap the consequences.

Chunkymenrock · 21/08/2021 09:36

I may be a lone voice, but I see it as my parents' money being absolutely nothing to do with me as it's theirs to do with exactly as they please. If I was lucky enough to inherit half a house, I would see it as an amazing bonus and be delighted. If I inherited nothing, then I inherit nothing. It was never my money in the first place.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 21/08/2021 09:35

@NeverTalkToStrangers

People don’t go to Dignitas with dementia - it just doesn’t happen for all sorts of reasons. People on here often say it’s their answer to the need for elder care and I always read it as “la la la I’m not listening”.

However only a minority of people will be in care homes for long enough to eat through the value of even a modest house. The odds are against the longer lived of your parents being in that position, although it’s still a real possibility.

More to the point they should make a sodding will (with a note included for the record saying “this doesn’t mean we have disinherited because we don’t love DB - it’s just that we gave him his money early”).

An aunt had dementia and my DM (her sister) often used to say that if she ever got like that, she’d take an overdose. And she meant it.

Of course, when she did eventually develop dementia, she refused to believe that there was anything wrong with her. And it wasn’t denial as such - she simply couldn’t remember, at any given moment, that she couldn’t remember anything - if that makes sense.

The GP had told her quite early on that she’d got Alzheimer’s, and she appeared to accept it, but she’d completely forgotten by the time she got home maybe 15 minutes later.

billy1966 · 21/08/2021 09:35

Very unfair.
Your brother is a piece of work taking your parents savings and your parents are beyond stupid to have done it.

The fact they have not transferred ownership of the house tells you that it is unlikely a real intention.

This type of unequal treatment makes me boil.
In effect it penalises those that have worked hard to provide for themselves.

I certainly wouldn't be quiet about it.

It is THEIR money, but what they have done is unfair and they should know that is what you think.

They are entitled to do it.
You are entitled to your opinion of it.

That money will likely be worth double that in 10 years.

Flowers
Antsinyourpanta · 21/08/2021 09:33

And the inheritance tax threshold including property is iirc over 900k (the 2nd of my parents died a couple of years ago and I'm pretty sure that's what they said)

CutePanda · 21/08/2021 09:33

@sashagabadon I have a slightly different point to make and in support of the parents. I think they need a bit of the benefit of the doubt. They’re trying to do what they think is best. It’s hard when you have 3 different kids at different levels in adulthood. You want to be fair to them all but It’s not obvious how to do this completely fairly with limited assets and without them falling out.

But OP’s db has had his cake AND is eating it. He chose to prioritise travelling the world instead of buying a house. Why is he more deserving than his sisters who chose to prioritise having a home?

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 21/08/2021 09:32

@millenialblush

Also you will lose a decent chunk of that to the taxman. House inheritance isn't that simple. And I also agree with the above poster that inheritance shouldn't be unequal
If the estate is 200k, none of it will be paid in tax. It'll fall within the him rate band.
Antsinyourpanta · 21/08/2021 09:30

I'm assuming the house will appreciate in value though (although so will the 100k the brother already has)

CutePanda · 21/08/2021 09:30

@ancientgran Depends on family circumstances. My DD will inherit more than her brothers for a variety of reasons that aren't relevant here. So the men won't get it all in this family.

Unless you have a bad relationship with your sons, why would you favour your Dd and leave all your assets and savings to her?

BettyCarver · 21/08/2021 09:28

First off, no one has a right to expect an inheritance.
But most parents no doubt do want their children to inherit their estate and it beggars belief in situations like the OPs where it's done in such an unfair way. People make different life choices... the OPs brother clearly prioritised travelling over settling down and getting onto the housing ladder - which is fine, his choice, and no doubt he had a great time. To consider him more deserving of inheritance because of this is really quite spiteful and unfair to the other siblings who made different life choices. It's also pretty much guaranteed to destroy family relationships going forward

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/08/2021 09:25

@sashagabadon

I have a slightly different point to make and in support of the parents. I think they need a bit of the benefit of the doubt. They’re trying to do what they think is best. It’s hard when you have 3 different kids at different levels in adulthood. You want to be fair to them all but It’s not obvious how to do this completely fairly with limited assets and without them falling out. Gotta agree with other re. The £1 token rent, at the very least it should be market rent and actually paid not just a wink wink situation and then the person receiving the rent has to declare it as income and pay tax etc on it. They also have to show yearly accounts and pay for maintenance etc like a landlord would.
The son chose it. He wasn’t sick, disabled or escaping an abusive relationship. He chose to travel for decades when the majority of people do it for a couple of years then settle down.

Parents could have given him a small amount (say 20K) that would have gotten him a small starter flat. They didn’t need to fund an entire house / flat on a lower mortgage.

They are unfair in rewarding him for his life choices and punishing his hardworking sisters.

If it were me I’d take great pleasure in sticking the boot in when the time came - but then again my grandparents culturally prefer boys and made it obvious since the day I was born so… completely no bias there :)

CounsellorTroi · 21/08/2021 09:23

@GrandmaSteglitszch

Dignitas didn't accept people who are just old & inform. They have to be terminally ill. Also in sound mind.
This isn’t true. A 23 year old who was paralysed following a rugby injury went there in 2008. Also conductor Sir Edward Downes and his wife ended their life together at Dignitas in 2009. Lady Downes was 74 and terminally ill, her 85 year old husband was not but was dependent on her following a hip replacement and increasing blindness and deafness. So you don’t have to be terminally ill to go to Dignitas.
CutePanda · 21/08/2021 09:20

YANBU. Whether it is £100 or £100k, I would expect the same amount as my siblings! It needs to be divided equally. The £100k in savings should be divided equally 3 ways. The house sale should also be divided equally in 3 ways. I would raise this to my parents without siblings present.

Jennybeans401 · 21/08/2021 09:20

This is true. If your df or do marry a younger partner in the future due to bereavement this could radically change your inheritance. Not a conversation anyone wants to have but this does happen a lot.

Choux · 21/08/2021 09:18

@ThatMortgageDilemma

For someone who is not expecting anything from their parents, you seem to be quite annoyed at the situation.

I know my parents want that whatever is left after they die is split equally between their children. In reality I know (and have accepted) that the house won't be worth much and that it will be used to fund my parents's care. Anything left over should go to my younger sister who is the one who has been the one taking care of them and most of their needs while my older sister and I have been living abroad.

I might be the one in higher need (divorced single mum and a crap salary) but definitively, I am not the most deserving.

My MIL on the other hand... can't talk for 20 minutes without mentioning inheritance and all the things she plans to do to provide for DS. I know however that she has a very expensive lifestyle and that other properties she planned to leave to her children have long been sold to maintain that lifestyle. So every time she starts talking about inheritance, I just smile and repeat "we are not expecting anything from you". And I really mean it.

So your parents and in-laws are either spending the money themselves or treating all children equally. No wonder you do not have an issue with it.

OP is seeing her parents treat her brother differently DESPITE them saying they intend to treat all children equally. Brother has £100k and that OP may end up with nothing. That is why she is feeling unhappy and she has every right to feel that way. It's an emotional response to their actions.

She is not 'annoyed' and the opening line of your post is frankly a bit goady.

knittingaddict · 21/08/2021 09:18

@LookItsMeAgain

I don't know if this would be possible or even legal but could they sell the house to you and your other sibling (the one that didn't get the 100k) now and then you agree that they can live there for as long as needs be and it becomes your asset not theirs if costs for care homes comes into it. Then at that stage you can sell the house/rent it/renovate it/whatever, and split the proceeds with that same sibling? They would have to cover bills for utilities and such but they are doing that anyway, right?
Assuming you don't mean sell it for the going rate and why would you, that has been very clearly covered in this thread already. It doesn't work. Deprivation of assets.
PawPawPaw · 21/08/2021 09:17

You are NBU for sure.

Your parents have shown unwarranted favouritism towards your seemingly feckless DB. He has received his inheritance. There is considerable risk that you will not.

Assuming they have made wills leaving their house to you and your sister (and not left everything three ways) they could still live 30+ years. You will be OAPs yourselves before seeing a penny of your inheritance, if you live long enough.

They are seemingly completely ignorant of the eye watering costs of care in later life and how quickly it will burn through any inheritance

If either or both goes into a care home the fees are at least £1000 per week. If they can’t pay the Council will put a charge on the house. Four years of care at today’s prices and that’s your inheritance gone.

The cost of care in the home is £40 per hour (where I live). Two or more visits a day equates to the same burn rate as residential care with the same consequences.

What if one dies and the other remarries a younger partner. Under the inheritance Act the surviving spouse is entitled to at least an lifetime interest in the house.

Given these uncertainties I would try to persuade them to have a family meeting with a solicitor specialising in inheritance planning. Others rightly mention depravation of assets but given their youth and assumed good health you might have a small window right now to transfer the beneficial ownership of the house to you and your sister leaving your parents with a life interest. This at least would secure your inheritance. You do need to take legal advice first.

sashagabadon · 21/08/2021 09:15

I have a slightly different point to make and in support of the parents. I think they need a bit of the benefit of the doubt. They’re trying to do what they think is best. It’s hard when you have 3 different kids at different levels in adulthood. You want to be fair to them all but It’s not obvious how to do this completely fairly with limited assets and without them falling out.
Gotta agree with other re. The £1 token rent, at the very least it should be market rent and actually paid not just a wink wink situation and then the person receiving the rent has to declare it as income and pay tax etc on it. They also have to show yearly accounts and pay for maintenance etc like a landlord would.

LookItsMeAgain · 21/08/2021 09:15

I don't know if this would be possible or even legal but could they sell the house to you and your other sibling (the one that didn't get the 100k) now and then you agree that they can live there for as long as needs be and it becomes your asset not theirs if costs for care homes comes into it. Then at that stage you can sell the house/rent it/renovate it/whatever, and split the proceeds with that same sibling?
They would have to cover bills for utilities and such but they are doing that anyway, right?

PeterPomegranate · 21/08/2021 09:14

“ It’s inequality, the man gets it all. The girls kept dangling so they they have someone to look after them.”

Yes it does look like this.

I would be annoyed too. Especially as they haven’t even changed their will!

Of course people can leave their money however they like but it does tell a story about how they see the world / feel about things and you can’t help but react to that.

bubblebubblebubbletrouble · 21/08/2021 09:14

I would be annoyed too OP but I think for the sake of your own well-being I would just accept it and move on. If you get something in the future -bonus.

In terms of avoiding paying for care - if our care system is so underfunded won't your relations end up in the crappiest cheapest care home the council can find with no choice if you rely on the public purse to pay??? That could be a heck of a culture shock for someone used to a £1m lifestyle??
Joe Bloggs on 18 yo min wage forced to do a care job they don't want to by DWP just to get UC to be able to live vs a wonderful carer like my friend who adores her residents goes over and above every single day to make their final years as special as possible. I know what I would choose for mine & it wouldn't be inheritance.

ponyexpress22 · 21/08/2021 09:14

How absolutely bloody unfair. I'm angry on your behalf op. They've given golden boy everything.....if they wanted to part with their life savings, split it three ways or not at all.

knittingaddict · 21/08/2021 09:12

My parents are mid 80's and late 80's. Mum is disabled and has dementia. Dad is disabled and very frail. Neither are coping well in the house and my dad is coping really badly with my mum. They are still insisting that they will never go into a home, despite not accepting any outside help to stay in their home a bit longer. My brother lives locally and helps them a lot, but my dad can be incredibly rude to him and my sil.

They will be going into a home. All they are doing is fighting the inevitable. My sympathy is almost rock bottom. Can you tell?

SilverDragonfly1 · 21/08/2021 09:12

@Yourstupidityexhaustsme

Your parents need to sign their home to you and your sister. If they survive for seven years without needing care/dying it cannot be taken for care nor is it regarded as a deprivation of assets. The name evades me but it’s a legitimate inheritance scheme.
We may have found the perfect username/post combo here.