Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

. . . to think parents are being naive about our "inheritance"?

314 replies

OhFFSNotAnotherVirus · 21/08/2021 08:04

Just pondering . . . for some reason it's niggling at me, maybe because I find their lack of understanding frustrating!

I also want to point out that I in no way "expect" anything from my parents - I've been financially independent since I was 18 and I'm proud of what I've achieved by myself.

Parent are 65, I have one brother and one sister. Parents gave my brother their life savings (close to £100k) so he could buy a nicer house than he could afford by himself. Parents told me and my sister that they would change their wills to leave their house (a small townhouse worth about £200k) to the two of us, to make it fair.

I don't think it is fair, though. Chances are the house will be sold in the future to pay for their care. They seem blissfully unaware that this is a possibility - or a likelihood - and seem almost smug about having done the right thing by all three of their children. I've brought up the possibility that the house might need to be sold to pay for care, but they dismissed this, saying absolutely not, they wouldn't be going into a home, they'd rather go to Dignitas first . . .

I'm saying nothing further, there's no point and I know there's no entitlement here. But AIBU to be a bit . . . Hmm?

Oh and this all happened a couple of years ago and they haven't changed their wills anyway Grin

OP posts:
knittingaddict · 22/08/2021 08:20

@thecatsthecats

I can see my parents ending up making a mistake like that.

They own two houses plus have significant funds for care, but they have a misguided sense of what is fair and desirable by all parties.

One house - where my sister and I grew up - is theoretically worth up to treble the other, but in reality needs hundreds of thousands of pounds worth to reach that value on the market (as evidenced by the house next door). Realistically only worth twice as much.

The other is old fashioned but could be sold fairly quickly.

My sister and I would like to rent out our old house and then I would live in it (sister wouldn't want to live there). My brother has no sentimental attachment to either house and would just want the money.

Yet he's been made executor, and we're pretty sure they've split the whole thing three ways. And now they're talking about making direct provision for portions of the houses to grandchildren! Just asking for trouble, and given my brother is an awkward sod, will cause no end of rows.

Selling the properties and splitting the procedes 3 ways is a totally fair and reasonable thing to do. You aren't being hard done by.
knittingaddict · 22/08/2021 08:18

@CleanQueen123

To be honest *@TractorAndHeadphones* I was surprised as well. I was pretty certain they'd decide it was deprevation of assets but they didn't.

They did go over everything and speak to her doctors and the solicitor who advised and organised the house transfer.

They definitely wouldn't have just taken my mother's word for it that it hadn't been deliberately planned.

You did say that your mum lived in the house. That might have made a difference too. How long did she live there for? Did she own her own home? The answers to those questions may help to understand the decision.
SilverGlitterBaubles · 22/08/2021 08:08

It's worth remembering that the current rules could change by the time OPs parents pass on. Those who try to play the system and avoid tax and IHT could be caught up in changes later on. Although from experience it is more like to be those who can well afford to pay that go to the greatest lengths to avoid it, not ordinary families like OPs.

3ismylot · 22/08/2021 07:31

There is definitely a lot of the generation who do not understand how it all works.
MIL updated her will a couple of years ago and kept on about how DH and I were joint executors and would get everything etc, however, everything is her bungalow, which she took out equity release on about 8 years ago, so realistically all she is leaving us is the hassle of sorting it all out when she passes as there will be no value left with the extortionate interest rates of equity release!
DH and I just smile and nod when she talks about it as no point in bursting her bubble that she will leave us a good inheritance as it's too late for her to change anything anyway.
DH and I have never expected an inheritance anyway so it's just kinder to let her think she has done something nice.

1forAll74 · 22/08/2021 02:45

Last time I read about dignitas, it cost about £ 7000, That was ages ago, it's probably double that now.

DoWhatYouWantToAndShh · 22/08/2021 02:00

@starpatch

I don't think this will work Ginfilledcats. The local authority can still consider the house for care. Even for inheritance tax it doesn't work as they are still living in it.
Yeah loads of people do this and actually it isn't just a case of 7years, £1 rent, all sorted. When it comes to care they'll look at assets and housing and if it appears you've deliberately hidden assets or substantially reduced your savings etc, then they can still count it.

I understand why people do it but it might not work.

You must also make sure the new 'owner' of the house has I'm their will something allowing them to still live there, imagine you've signed your house over to your children, they die and it's technically now passed to your estranged DIL or grandkids etc.

joangray38 · 22/08/2021 01:44

@GreyhoundG1rl yep as she couldn’t go with her husband as he could be prosecuted for helping her she had to charter a private airplane , a DIGNITAS employee escorted her over , she had the injection and died. Then someone brought her cremated remains back to the U.K. they charge for everything.

GreyhoundG1rl · 22/08/2021 00:41

@frozenyoghurt4

YANBU. This is such extreme favouritism of one child over the others.
  1. Even in their ideal world where they would leave you two £100k each, £100k in 20, 30 or 40 years will not be worth what £100k today is.
  1. The power of £100k to change your life you're younger is not the same as the power of it to change your life for the better when you're older. It makes a difference how young you are when you get it.
  1. They can guarantee that they have £100k. They cannot guarantee they'll have £200k in the future. That makes a promise of £100k in the future worth less than a guarantee of £100k. This is basic economics.
Yes to all of this.
Babyroobs · 22/08/2021 00:32

Surely they can't just give away 100k. What if they need care in the near future?

frozenyoghurt4 · 22/08/2021 00:26
  1. The tax implications of getting inheritance vs a gift to help with a house are different.

I would be extremely annoyed with this favouritism and I would probably be in much less contact with my parents after this kind of treatment.

scarpa · 22/08/2021 00:24

Another one who finds people working out how best to avoid paying for care they can afford very depressing.

Keep that wealth in your family, cost the council a fortune to stretch the care budget thinner and thinner meaning shitter care for the people who absolutely couldn't afford it themselves (and won't get to stay in their nice house/pass something onto their kids).

(And I say this as someone whose reasonably well-off grandparents have sold their houses to pay for care, and now my skint parents won't inherit anything and nor will I or my siblings . And I am more than happy with that, because their assets paid for care that they needed instead of squirrelling money away to cheat a system designed to help the people who need it.)

frozenyoghurt4 · 22/08/2021 00:24

YANBU. This is such extreme favouritism of one child over the others.

  1. Even in their ideal world where they would leave you two £100k each, £100k in 20, 30 or 40 years will not be worth what £100k today is.
  1. The power of £100k to change your life you're younger is not the same as the power of it to change your life for the better when you're older. It makes a difference how young you are when you get it.
  1. They can guarantee that they have £100k. They cannot guarantee they'll have £200k in the future. That makes a promise of £100k in the future worth less than a guarantee of £100k. This is basic economics.
GingerAndTheBiscuits · 21/08/2021 23:47

@TractorAndHeadphones

As far as I have seen it’s not whether they have a condition that needs care. If anyone is of sufficiently advanced age then it’s deemed deprivation of assets
If it’s a 70 year old (no matter how spry) it would definitely be deprivation.

That’s not the case. The local authority has to show

(a) whether avoiding the care and support charge was a significant motivation in the timing of the disposal of the asset; at the point the capital was disposed of could the person have a reasonable expectation of the need for care and support?
(b) did the person have a reasonable expectation of needing to contribute to the cost of their eligible care needs?

Simply being a certain age would not be a deciding factor. The guidance gives an example of a person buying a car and then giving it to their daughter two weeks later, after they go into a care home. If the person already knew they were going to be moving into the home, it could be deprivation of assets. If the person (be they age 30 or 50 or 90) was in good health at the time of purchase but then fell downstairs or had a stroke or was hit by a car, it wouldn’t be deprivation because they didn’t have a reasonable expectation of needing to contribute to the cost of the care at the time of purchase. But the local authority would probably look at it very closely to be sure.

It’s all set out here: www.gov.uk/government/publications/care-act-statutory-guidance/care-and-support-statutory-guidance in Annex E and most councils will also have their own policies available.

For the poster who mentioned putting property in trust, that is a specific example given in the guidance of a deprivation of assets. Councils are broke. They will (rightly) look for any way to reduce their financial liability. They will examine any and all cases of possible deprivation extremely closely.

GreyhoundG1rl · 21/08/2021 21:52

@joangray38

My neighbour went to DIGNITAS - took months to go through all the psychological testing - prove she was of sound mind and illnesses had to be reassessed privately. Cost over £10,000 plus DIGNITAS don’t always accept you and will COVID people can’t easily access them.
£10k? Shock
tempester28 · 21/08/2021 21:16

If they are only 65 then it gets worse ha ha! You are probably right, but out of kindness, I would allow them their delusion. They now have three kids who own a house and that is probably what they see as equal. It is down to the fact that it sounds like your sister made better decisions earlier on in life and they have given your brother a leg up. On one level it is not fair but I would let it go for your peace of mind.

ancientgran · 21/08/2021 20:40

[quote phishy]@billy1966 my mum is scared of my brother and she says she has no power. It’s a messed up situation.[/quote]
She can change her will and not tell him, what can he do when she's dead?

joangray38 · 21/08/2021 20:36

My neighbour went to DIGNITAS - took months to go through all the psychological testing - prove she was of sound mind and illnesses had to be reassessed privately. Cost over £10,000 plus DIGNITAS don’t always accept you and will COVID people can’t easily access them.

phishy · 21/08/2021 20:25

@billy1966 my mum is scared of my brother and she says she has no power. It’s a messed up situation.

billy1966 · 21/08/2021 20:17

@phishy

No surprise that your brother the male got the £100k and you and your sister didn’t.

My brother is inheriting the family home and yet sisters and I are expected to do all the care for them.

It’s beyond rage inducing.

Why are you doing it? I just wouldn't do it.

Tell them to contact your brother.

billy1966 · 21/08/2021 20:14

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

tickledtiger · 21/08/2021 20:03

I don’t blame you for being upset!

Your brother probably put them under pressure… It’s such a gigantic amount of money.

They obviously realise it’s not equal treatment but maybe they feel awkward about it.

Grellbunt · 21/08/2021 20:02

@phishy

No surprise that your brother the male got the £100k and you and your sister didn’t.

My brother is inheriting the family home and yet sisters and I are expected to do all the care for them.

It’s beyond rage inducing.

I cannot believe people still do this in this day and age...
tigger1001 · 21/08/2021 19:16

@Ginfilledcats

My in laws have put their house in my husband and his sisters name (they're early 60s) and pay a token rent if £1 a month. This bypasses the house being used to pay for their care as long as it's in their sons name for 7 years before any costs are needed.

My parents are going to do the same I think.

I would take legal advise on that.

It certainly doesn't remove it from their estate for tax purposes and these type of arrangements have significantly been clamped down on to stop this very scenario.

CleanQueen123 · 21/08/2021 18:48

To be honest @TractorAndHeadphones I was surprised as well. I was pretty certain they'd decide it was deprevation of assets but they didn't.

They did go over everything and speak to her doctors and the solicitor who advised and organised the house transfer.

They definitely wouldn't have just taken my mother's word for it that it hadn't been deliberately planned.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 21/08/2021 18:42

@thecatsthecats

I can see my parents ending up making a mistake like that.

They own two houses plus have significant funds for care, but they have a misguided sense of what is fair and desirable by all parties.

One house - where my sister and I grew up - is theoretically worth up to treble the other, but in reality needs hundreds of thousands of pounds worth to reach that value on the market (as evidenced by the house next door). Realistically only worth twice as much.

The other is old fashioned but could be sold fairly quickly.

My sister and I would like to rent out our old house and then I would live in it (sister wouldn't want to live there). My brother has no sentimental attachment to either house and would just want the money.

Yet he's been made executor, and we're pretty sure they've split the whole thing three ways. And now they're talking about making direct provision for portions of the houses to grandchildren! Just asking for trouble, and given my brother is an awkward sod, will cause no end of rows.

You think your parents are wrong to just split their estate 3 ways? Wtf? Why on earth shouldn't they?

If you and you sister want to buy your brother out on the house you want, there's nothing stopping you. You're just pissed off that you're not getting special treatment.