Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

. . . to think parents are being naive about our "inheritance"?

314 replies

OhFFSNotAnotherVirus · 21/08/2021 08:04

Just pondering . . . for some reason it's niggling at me, maybe because I find their lack of understanding frustrating!

I also want to point out that I in no way "expect" anything from my parents - I've been financially independent since I was 18 and I'm proud of what I've achieved by myself.

Parent are 65, I have one brother and one sister. Parents gave my brother their life savings (close to £100k) so he could buy a nicer house than he could afford by himself. Parents told me and my sister that they would change their wills to leave their house (a small townhouse worth about £200k) to the two of us, to make it fair.

I don't think it is fair, though. Chances are the house will be sold in the future to pay for their care. They seem blissfully unaware that this is a possibility - or a likelihood - and seem almost smug about having done the right thing by all three of their children. I've brought up the possibility that the house might need to be sold to pay for care, but they dismissed this, saying absolutely not, they wouldn't be going into a home, they'd rather go to Dignitas first . . .

I'm saying nothing further, there's no point and I know there's no entitlement here. But AIBU to be a bit . . . Hmm?

Oh and this all happened a couple of years ago and they haven't changed their wills anyway Grin

OP posts:
Billandben444 · 24/08/2021 07:20

OP, I can see why you are upset by this but I think your parents felt they were being fair to you all in a misguided way and, as pp have said, their house should be worth way more when the time comes. Care home fees notwithstanding, it is important that they rewrite their wills and I think some not-so-gentle reminders are in order along with 'shall I make that appointment then?'. Perhaps they don't want to dwell on their future deaths and think they've got years ahead of them...?

GnomeDePlume · 24/08/2021 06:48

@tigger1001

At the end of the day it's up to the individual how any inheritance is split. And as it's their money, that's entirely how it should be. The people who inherit (or not in some cases) should have no say in it.

While I can understand what you are saying I do think that sometimes wills get written with too little thought given to how they can be executed.

Complicated wills get written which deal with the immediate situation in front of the testator. At that moment one beneficiary may seem to be more fortunate than another and the testator seeks to 'even things out'. The testator then sits back thinking they have been fair and that the intention to be fair is what will be executed rather than the precise wording of the will.

Of course it is the precise wording of the will which gets executed which can, by the time the will gets executed, be grossly unfair.

MurielSpriggs · 23/08/2021 23:24

Afraid this doesn't work. For care costs it's counted as a deliberate deprivation of assets and for tax it's a gift with reservation so ineffective. I wouldn't make any plans on getting the cash from that house if I were you.

@Ginfilledcats
As usual, probably as well to be wary of free advice from strangers on the internet, but in the circumstances you describe it's more than likely that this will work from the point of view of putting assets beyond the reach of the local authority for care fees. There is provision for having gifts added to "notional capital" for means testing for care fees, and also for the donees of the gift to be pursued. But in the circumstances you describe where the donor is fit and healthy at the time of the gift those powers are very unlikely to arise.

There are plenty of other reasons why that sort of gift might not be a good idea. And the "reservation of benefit" (living there for no real rent) means that it won't help with IHT planning. But it's quite likely to save you care fees.

Goldensyrupissticky · 22/08/2021 15:53

I have a very similar situation. My parents have given my sibling 1/4 million to as a gift deposit. This isn’t my sibling’s first house, or their partner’s. They both work and have a decent income. The difference being, I think, is my DS inherited some money when his parents died so I think my parents decided to even things out…actually I have no idea why. I have been told that the will states I should get the same amount but to be honest that isn’t the point. Realistically, that money won’t be there after both parents are gone, the expenses etc paid off, taxes paid. But what upsets me is the fact that my DF asked how I felt about this (shocked) but the house had already been bought so I am not too sure why he felt to ask my view. It is a significant amount of money, theirs to spend but they will miss that when the expense of end of life kicks in. I understand that even the solicitor questioned the wisdom of the amount.

It has left a nasty feeling, it is very obvious who is the preferred child, I might be more spiky but have always been there when they have needed support.

I completely understand where OP is coming from. It isn’t the money, it is the underhand nature of it. I have never been helped in the same way, nor do I want to. Just seems crazy to give a deposit to someone for a housing upgrade who doesn’t need it, except to have smaller monthly payments.

ancientgran · 22/08/2021 13:06

@ancientgran

Tigger1001 What if one grown up child has significantly cared for one or both parents? Given up a significant amount of time to do so? The parents may feel that leaving that person more is fair. That an inheritance being equally split in these circumstances will cause resentment and hurt just as much as a seemingly unfair split of it does.

That is so true and I agree it is entirely fair to give that supportive child more than the others.

I just wanted to add to this.

My mother was significantly older than her two siblings. When she was a teenager my grandmother was very ill. Grandfather was overseas so my mother had to give up her job and for 2 years she nursed her mother while also being "mother" to her younger siblings. Many year later GM died, she had a few thousand and she left it to my mother. I thought it was fair, my mother gave up 2 years of her life and became a 24/7 carer to her mother. Her siblings were very upset about it which I thought was terrible as what would have happened to them if she hadn't looked after them, a home or foster care. If it had been split it would have had about £1k each. GM stated in the will why she was doing it.

Equal definitely doesn't always mean fair.

findtheirsocks · 22/08/2021 13:03

Oh dearie me @ancientgran Grin
I could copy and paste your posts and type 'touched a raw nerve' at the end if I couldn't respond intelligently and resorted to make a childish comment instead. It means nothing.

OP - I completely understand why you feel hurt by your parents inequitable treatment. It's astonishing that loving parents could give their savings of £100 k to one child simply because he wanted different things out of life and chose 'experiences' rather than buying a house. It's also incredibly naive of them because as others have pointed out, they may need those savings in future.
It's also pretty astonishing that your brother was happy to accept all their savings, knowing they might need them and also that there was no guarantee his siblings would ever receive an inheritance. I guess some people are just selfish and will comfortably take take take while seeing their siblings not being treated fairly

ancientgran · 22/08/2021 12:36

[quote findtheirsocks]@ancientgran still trying to tell other posters what they think .... Grin[/quote]
No, reading what they write.

WutheringTights · 22/08/2021 12:35

@Ginfilledcats

My in laws have put their house in my husband and his sisters name (they're early 60s) and pay a token rent if £1 a month. This bypasses the house being used to pay for their care as long as it's in their sons name for 7 years before any costs are needed.

My parents are going to do the same I think.

Afraid this doesn't work. For care costs it's counted as a deliberate deprivation of assets and for tax it's a gift with reservation so ineffective. I wouldn't make any plans on getting the cash from that house if I were you.
findtheirsocks · 22/08/2021 12:24

@ancientgran still trying to tell other posters what they think .... Grin

ancientgran · 22/08/2021 12:15

[quote findtheirsocks]**@ancientgran: @findtheirsocks So you accept one had an advantage over the others?

No, I don't. You can choose to put whatever spin you like on someone else's posts, but that's precisely what dh and I have striven to not do. We have always aimed to meet our children's differing needs while treating them as equitably as we can.

You seem determined to nit pick over people's posts simply because you hold a different view from the majority on this thread who think the OP is right to feel hurt.

To put it bluntly, there is absolutely no way any parents can treat their children exactly equally in every way. For a start, a first born gets years of undivided parental attention. When baby number 2 comes along, should the parents farm out child number 1 for a couple of years in order to even things up and give child 2 a couple of years of undiluted time and energy? Hmm And if the value of one child's Christmas presents comes to £97:20 and another's comes to £97:90, does the parent stick 70p or some cheap bit of plastic tat in the stocking to even things up? Hmm

The point I made is that when it comes to big, significant issues then it's likely to cause great hurt if one child is significantly favoured over others. We didn't let our ds2 live here at a vastly subsidised rate (which interestingly you're desperately trying to tell me we did!) precisely because it would have sat very uncomfortably with us to treat our children so differently.

To return to the OP (which after all is the focus of this thread, not you or me) the situation is that she and her sister prioritised getting on the housing ladder early while their brother prioritised the experience of travel. Both choices are valid, both require some sacrifices and both bring benefits. The parents then give the brother £100k to 'even things up' Hmm I'm not sure in what universe anyone can think that's a reasonable way for a loving parent to behave. A decision like that is inevitably going to make the sisters feel hurt and sidelined.

And before someone bleats 'it's not all about money' - well surely as a living parent, you want a your children to live enriched fulfilling lives? A significant inheritance facilitates choices. Maybe the sisters who've worked hard and prioritised a house and mortgage might want the experience or travel now, or in a few years time. Maybe they'd like to change from their career and do something which pays less but brings them personal fulfilment. They don't get that opportunity because the parents have naively thought they are 'levelling things up'. [/quote]
Touched a raw nerve there didn't I.

tigger1001 · 22/08/2021 11:49

@knittingaddict

I think if you want to reward a child for doing things for you then you should do that while you are alive. Then you treat them all the same in the will, which is the last thing you ever say to your children.
I disagree.

That's just too black and white for me. And life just doesn't work that way.

Maybe the elderly parents don't want to gift money while they are alive to ensure they have enough to live on for however many years.

Maybe the care comes while the parents are elderly and the parents don't want to "buy" care from their grown up children.

Maybe there has been significant falling out between child and parent.

They might have reasons as to why they don't leave their estate equally between grown up children.

Broccoli123 · 22/08/2021 11:29

I think inheritance causes no end of issues. I'm in a situation where relative A left me a significant sum of money but in trust with relatives B & C in charge and I don't inherit until C dies.

In the 20 years since A died the money has been spent by B & C without any involvement or consultation with me.

As things stand, by the time C dies I'll likely be in my 50s or 60s and be lucky to get 50p.

That's absolutely not what A intended. It should have been enough money to purchase a house and give me an income. Due to various circumstances I'm unlikely to ever be able to afford to buy a house without this money so there is certainly resentment that B & C have taken away this opportunity.

findtheirsocks · 22/08/2021 11:27

@ancientgran: @findtheirsocks So you accept one had an advantage over the others?

No, I don't. You can choose to put whatever spin you like on someone else's posts, but that's precisely what dh and I have striven to not do. We have always aimed to meet our children's differing needs while treating them as equitably as we can.

You seem determined to nit pick over people's posts simply because you hold a different view from the majority on this thread who think the OP is right to feel hurt.

To put it bluntly, there is absolutely no way any parents can treat their children exactly equally in every way. For a start, a first born gets years of undivided parental attention. When baby number 2 comes along, should the parents farm out child number 1 for a couple of years in order to even things up and give child 2 a couple of years of undiluted time and energy? Hmm And if the value of one child's Christmas presents comes to £97:20 and another's comes to £97:90, does the parent stick 70p or some cheap bit of plastic tat in the stocking to even things up? Hmm

The point I made is that when it comes to big, significant issues then it's likely to cause great hurt if one child is significantly favoured over others. We didn't let our ds2 live here at a vastly subsidised rate (which interestingly you're desperately trying to tell me we did!) precisely because it would have sat very uncomfortably with us to treat our children so differently.

To return to the OP (which after all is the focus of this thread, not you or me) the situation is that she and her sister prioritised getting on the housing ladder early while their brother prioritised the experience of travel. Both choices are valid, both require some sacrifices and both bring benefits. The parents then give the brother £100k to 'even things up' Hmm I'm not sure in what universe anyone can think that's a reasonable way for a loving parent to behave. A decision like that is inevitably going to make the sisters feel hurt and sidelined.

And before someone bleats 'it's not all about money' - well surely as a living parent, you want a your children to live enriched fulfilling lives? A significant inheritance facilitates choices. Maybe the sisters who've worked hard and prioritised a house and mortgage might want the experience or travel now, or in a few years time. Maybe they'd like to change from their career and do something which pays less but brings them personal fulfilment. They don't get that opportunity because the parents have naively thought they are 'levelling things up'.

jayritchie · 22/08/2021 10:57

Why did your brother allow his parents to give all their savings at that age? Do they have very good pensions? If not it’s a crazy thing to do.

ancientgran · 22/08/2021 10:57

@knittingaddict

I think if you want to reward a child for doing things for you then you should do that while you are alive. Then you treat them all the same in the will, which is the last thing you ever say to your children.
It doesn't have to be the last thing you ever say to them. Write a letter to go with the will.
ancientgran · 22/08/2021 10:56

Tigger1001 What if one grown up child has significantly cared for one or both parents? Given up a significant amount of time to do so? The parents may feel that leaving that person more is fair. That an inheritance being equally split in these circumstances will cause resentment and hurt just as much as a seemingly unfair split of it does.

That is so true and I agree it is entirely fair to give that supportive child more than the others.

ancientgran · 22/08/2021 10:54

@findtheirsocks So you accept one had an advantage over the others? Let's face it you didn't charge him what it would have been costing the others for rent, heating, food etc. Yes it is normal to give according to need and the same goes for inheritance. I've said one of mine is getting more than the others, not in the will but getting help now for a specific reason. which isn't relevant here. The others don't have the same reason/need so she is getting about £25k to £50k more than them. According to many on here that should be reducing what she gets when we die. I don't agree. Just like you gave your son a subsidised place to live because he needed it she is getting money that will help her with something she needs.

I've done a massive amount of childcare for one set of GC, they happen to live near to me and the others are 200 miles away. I will have saved their parents thousands of pounds over the years, reduced nursery fees, no need for breakfast/afterschool care, no need for holiday clubs. Should I work out what I saved them and give it to the others? Am I being unfair, should I have said no because I couldn't do the same for the others.

I have a friend who got into a massive state as one of her kids went to uni and the other didn't. Oh dear the younger one got about £10k to help her through uni, should she give the older working one with her own home £10k to make it fair. I told her in my opinion she shouldn't, the money was for a specific reason that only applied to one of them. A few years passed and the older one decided on a career change and went to uni and got her £10k when it was appropriate. What would they have done if they had just willy nilly given her £10k to be fair? Would she have had to struggle when she went to uni or would they have had to give them both another £10k.

It just gets silly. Support kids as they need it, money doesn't mean love or caring.

By the way my other kids know what I'm doing and agree it is appropriate although they all say I should spend my money and leave them nothing which is the right attitude in my book.

Life is more complicated that how much you get in inheritance. I got nothing from my parents when they died. I got lots of love and care and support when they were alive which is far more valuable.

knittingaddict · 22/08/2021 10:51

I think if you want to reward a child for doing things for you then you should do that while you are alive. Then you treat them all the same in the will, which is the last thing you ever say to your children.

tigger1001 · 22/08/2021 10:45

@findtheirsocks

Whenever threads about unfair inheritance crop up, there are always a few people saying how awful and grabby it is and that no one has a right to expect anything.

They are entirely missing the point. A parent might leave their entire estate to a donkey sanctuary. The children may think it's odd, but they are being treated equally; there isn't the hurt of seeing one sibling being favoured.

It honestly seems astounding that any decent parent could wilfully treat their children in such an unfair way. I understand that in rare situations, one sibling might be undeniably 'more needy', such as one sibling being extremely disabled, unable to work or live independently and the other siblings all being healthy. However even in a situation like this, it may not be the wisest choice to leave everything to the disabled child because a large inheritance might impact on the funding they would receive for care.

Anyhow, that's an extreme and relatively rare example. The main point is that the vast majority of cases are far far more nuanced. Differences in the circumstances of adult siblings are usually a result of many factors. People have different priorities... some will prioritise buying a house, some will prioritise 'experiences' such as travelling. Some will work harder than others. Some might prioritise earning a good salary in a high pressure job while others may earn considerably less doing something they absolutely love. An adult daughter might appear to be better off if they have just one child compared to their sister who's struggling with three or four little ones. But perhaps the woman with one child desperately wanted more. There is just no simple way of comparing how 'deserving' adult siblings are I can completely understand why it can destroy family relationships if parents write their will in such a completely inequitable way.

And of course, alongside this is the fact that no one knows what's round the corner. That adult son or daughter who's been sidelined in the will because they seem to be 'fine' might get sick, have an accident, be made redundant...

It's actually a really cruel thing to do to treat your own children so unfairly. I have 4 adult children myself. They're not carbon copies of each other, they all have different personalities, strengths and weaknesses. One in particular has needed more emotional support along the way and also lived at home longer than the others, not moving out until his mid twenties due to a range of reasons; he suffered with depression and needed longer to take the step to independence. On the face of it, he might look the most 'needy'. But I would never ever do something so hugely inequitable like the OPs situation. When I or dh die, whoever is last to go, our house and assets will be shared absolutely equally 4 ways. Anything else would be cruel and likely to leave a legacy of massive hurt.

I don't think it's always that straight forward either. Life is rarely that black and white.

What if one grown up child has significantly cared for one or both parents? Given up a significant amount of time to do so? The parents may feel that leaving that person more is fair. That an inheritance being equally split in these circumstances will cause resentment and hurt just as much as a seemingly unfair split of it does.

At the end of the day it's up to the individual how any inheritance is split. And as it's their money, that's entirely how it should be. The people who inherit (or not in some cases) should have no say in it.

findtheirsocks · 22/08/2021 10:19

@ancientgran surely the question you raise is one that any decent parent of two or more children thinks about as an ongoing thing?

Pretty much from the day they're born, you aim to meet the differing needs of each child while striving to be equitable. I'd have thought that was fairly obvious!

It's absurd to think that every aspect of life can be carefully calculated and weighed up so that each child receives exactly the same input of time, parental energy etc. And I challenge you to find me any parent on earth who has calculated down to the pound exactly how much they have spent on each child over the years!

The point is that when it comes to huge and significant issues like inheritance, it's cruel to behave in a way which openly treats children differently, favouring one over others.

Btw, you seem to have assumed that in my personal circumstances my ds had some huge advantage over his siblings by living rent free at home for far longer than his brothers and sister. He didn't. We charged him a certain sum of money, partly because we felt it was important that as an adult in his early twenties he acknowledged this responsibility and partly precisely because of the point you raise. Paying for housing is a fairly significant thing, and it would have felt very unfair to his siblings to allow one son to live rent free while they were paying rent to live independently.

But yes, ultimately ds 2 had a few more years of living in the family home than his brothers and sister because as parents, we were doing our level best to meet his needs and be supportive parents without giving him some huge advantage over our other sons and our daughter. That's what parents do, isn't it?

ancientgran · 22/08/2021 09:38

@findtheirsocks

Whenever threads about unfair inheritance crop up, there are always a few people saying how awful and grabby it is and that no one has a right to expect anything.

They are entirely missing the point. A parent might leave their entire estate to a donkey sanctuary. The children may think it's odd, but they are being treated equally; there isn't the hurt of seeing one sibling being favoured.

It honestly seems astounding that any decent parent could wilfully treat their children in such an unfair way. I understand that in rare situations, one sibling might be undeniably 'more needy', such as one sibling being extremely disabled, unable to work or live independently and the other siblings all being healthy. However even in a situation like this, it may not be the wisest choice to leave everything to the disabled child because a large inheritance might impact on the funding they would receive for care.

Anyhow, that's an extreme and relatively rare example. The main point is that the vast majority of cases are far far more nuanced. Differences in the circumstances of adult siblings are usually a result of many factors. People have different priorities... some will prioritise buying a house, some will prioritise 'experiences' such as travelling. Some will work harder than others. Some might prioritise earning a good salary in a high pressure job while others may earn considerably less doing something they absolutely love. An adult daughter might appear to be better off if they have just one child compared to their sister who's struggling with three or four little ones. But perhaps the woman with one child desperately wanted more. There is just no simple way of comparing how 'deserving' adult siblings are I can completely understand why it can destroy family relationships if parents write their will in such a completely inequitable way.

And of course, alongside this is the fact that no one knows what's round the corner. That adult son or daughter who's been sidelined in the will because they seem to be 'fine' might get sick, have an accident, be made redundant...

It's actually a really cruel thing to do to treat your own children so unfairly. I have 4 adult children myself. They're not carbon copies of each other, they all have different personalities, strengths and weaknesses. One in particular has needed more emotional support along the way and also lived at home longer than the others, not moving out until his mid twenties due to a range of reasons; he suffered with depression and needed longer to take the step to independence. On the face of it, he might look the most 'needy'. But I would never ever do something so hugely inequitable like the OPs situation. When I or dh die, whoever is last to go, our house and assets will be shared absolutely equally 4 ways. Anything else would be cruel and likely to leave a legacy of massive hurt.

So how would you feel if 3 of yours said that one had more support from you and they wanted the cash equivalent? Subsidised housing for years more than them, worth a few bob? How far do we go with this childish "it's not fair."
CleanQueen123 · 22/08/2021 09:15

@knittingaddict my mum had only lived there in the two months prior to the stroke. However, she moved hundreds of miles to do this and gave up her rented properties.

Without saying too much as it would be outing it also wasn't a standard property so it wouldn't have been as simple as mum moving out and the place being sold.

It was also written into the paperwork that my grandmother had the right to remain on the property for her lifetime, with certain caveats. So they didn't do it with the knowledge or expectation that she would be going into a care home soon after.

I imagine all of that contributed to the LAs decision.

findtheirsocks · 22/08/2021 08:44

Whenever threads about unfair inheritance crop up, there are always a few people saying how awful and grabby it is and that no one has a right to expect anything.

They are entirely missing the point. A parent might leave their entire estate to a donkey sanctuary. The children may think it's odd, but they are being treated equally; there isn't the hurt of seeing one sibling being favoured.

It honestly seems astounding that any decent parent could wilfully treat their children in such an unfair way. I understand that in rare situations, one sibling might be undeniably 'more needy', such as one sibling being extremely disabled, unable to work or live independently and the other siblings all being healthy. However even in a situation like this, it may not be the wisest choice to leave everything to the disabled child because a large inheritance might impact on the funding they would receive for care.

Anyhow, that's an extreme and relatively rare example. The main point is that the vast majority of cases are far far more nuanced. Differences in the circumstances of adult siblings are usually a result of many factors. People have different priorities... some will prioritise buying a house, some will prioritise 'experiences' such as travelling. Some will work harder than others. Some might prioritise earning a good salary in a high pressure job while others may earn considerably less doing something they absolutely love. An adult daughter might appear to be better off if they have just one child compared to their sister who's struggling with three or four little ones. But perhaps the woman with one child desperately wanted more. There is just no simple way of comparing how 'deserving' adult siblings are I can completely understand why it can destroy family relationships if parents write their will in such a completely inequitable way.

And of course, alongside this is the fact that no one knows what's round the corner. That adult son or daughter who's been sidelined in the will because they seem to be 'fine' might get sick, have an accident, be made redundant...

It's actually a really cruel thing to do to treat your own children so unfairly. I have 4 adult children myself. They're not carbon copies of each other, they all have different personalities, strengths and weaknesses. One in particular has needed more emotional support along the way and also lived at home longer than the others, not moving out until his mid twenties due to a range of reasons; he suffered with depression and needed longer to take the step to independence. On the face of it, he might look the most 'needy'. But I would never ever do something so hugely inequitable like the OPs situation. When I or dh die, whoever is last to go, our house and assets will be shared absolutely equally 4 ways. Anything else would be cruel and likely to leave a legacy of massive hurt.

Figmentofmyimagination · 22/08/2021 08:42

When I read threads like this I’m struck by how naive people are about the care system and about infirmity.

Even leaving aside the moral dubiousness of shifting responsibility for a parent’s care onto the state, there is sadly (but hardly surprisingly, as in everything else we do in the uk) a fairly cavernous gap between the basic care the state is prepared to pay for and the quality of your parents’ lives if they can afford to pay for their own care. It is true that in nursing homes, you might well find (shock horror) that someone else is getting the same care that you are having to pay for, but ‘for free’. However, most people will be in residential care homes - not nursing homes.

Many fairly standard residential care homes are now so expensive that the council will go nowhere near them - and if you - as the child - have the cash (because it’s been ‘gifted’ to you) to make ‘additional voluntary contributions’, your parents will depend on you - and your then partner - agreeing to spend the money on them - and the council may also start to wonder how you have all this spare money.

More importantly, by handing over their savings/house and relying on the state, parents cede their autonomy and lose out on the chance to find the residential care that best suits their likes and dislikes, with the right staff ratio, located close to family, interesting activities etc and don’t spend their remaining days eg prematurely wearing an incontinence pad because there aren’t enough carers to help them to the toilet when they need a wee, sitting in a big living room against a permanent backdrop of monotonous daytime tv and waiting for the worst kind of school lunch to be served.

Before parents hand over their assets to children, they should tour some residential care homes. This disparity is only going to get worse, as a result of the funding crisis that covid represents.

countrygirl99 · 22/08/2021 08:36

@Yourstupidityexhaustsme

Your parents need to sign their home to you and your sister. If they survive for seven years without needing care/dying it cannot be taken for care nor is it regarded as a deprivation of assets. The name evades me but it’s a legitimate inheritance scheme.
Wrong