Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

. . . to think parents are being naive about our "inheritance"?

314 replies

OhFFSNotAnotherVirus · 21/08/2021 08:04

Just pondering . . . for some reason it's niggling at me, maybe because I find their lack of understanding frustrating!

I also want to point out that I in no way "expect" anything from my parents - I've been financially independent since I was 18 and I'm proud of what I've achieved by myself.

Parent are 65, I have one brother and one sister. Parents gave my brother their life savings (close to £100k) so he could buy a nicer house than he could afford by himself. Parents told me and my sister that they would change their wills to leave their house (a small townhouse worth about £200k) to the two of us, to make it fair.

I don't think it is fair, though. Chances are the house will be sold in the future to pay for their care. They seem blissfully unaware that this is a possibility - or a likelihood - and seem almost smug about having done the right thing by all three of their children. I've brought up the possibility that the house might need to be sold to pay for care, but they dismissed this, saying absolutely not, they wouldn't be going into a home, they'd rather go to Dignitas first . . .

I'm saying nothing further, there's no point and I know there's no entitlement here. But AIBU to be a bit . . . Hmm?

Oh and this all happened a couple of years ago and they haven't changed their wills anyway Grin

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 24/08/2021 17:34

@cabingirl based on the guidance that probably doesn’t count. As the house passed from your mother to you upon her death. It legally has nothing whatsoever to do with your father.
I could be wrong however.

Moulesvinrouge1 · 24/08/2021 17:26

@Bobbybobbins

I find the avoidance of paying for fare very depressing. I want my parents (if they need it) to have the best possible care in their final years. The council funded care should be reserved for those who genuinely can't pay for it themselves.
I find it sad and selfish too. Disabled children all over the UK are being deprived of suitable educations and cash strapped schools are flying by a wing and a prayer but you hold on to your nice lump sum, eh, and everyone else can pay for you.
HollyGrail · 24/08/2021 17:17

Is DF paying you rent as it is not his house?

Curlygirl06 · 24/08/2021 17:10

@cabingirl same situation here, my dad may need care soon but the part of his house that is in trust for us children can't be touched, as it's not his. My mum and him owned the house as tenants in common so mum could will her part to us on the proviso that dad could live in the house.

Halliabaloo · 24/08/2021 17:05

My mother-in-law goes on and on about leaving her estate divided equally which is very sweet of her. It really does grate my gears when one of her children has had childcare from her that would have cost approx £200,000 in the real world, (and I’ve had a barrage of snide remarks over the years about being a SAHM, though now the main earner.)

No, it’s not fair or equal, but is it worth the fallout if you say anything? If it’s not just keep quiet!

Broccoli123 · 24/08/2021 17:04

@GnomeDePlume it's on my to do list. There are certain things they've done which I'm fairly sure aren't legal but I'm unsure if anything can be done without costing a huge amount in legal fees, which is money I don't have.

cabingirl · 24/08/2021 16:55

[quote GingerAndTheBiscuits]@TractorAndHeadphones

As far as I have seen it’s not whether they have a condition that needs care. If anyone is of sufficiently advanced age then it’s deemed deprivation of assets
If it’s a 70 year old (no matter how spry) it would definitely be deprivation.

That’s not the case. The local authority has to show

(a) whether avoiding the care and support charge was a significant motivation in the timing of the disposal of the asset; at the point the capital was disposed of could the person have a reasonable expectation of the need for care and support?
(b) did the person have a reasonable expectation of needing to contribute to the cost of their eligible care needs?

Simply being a certain age would not be a deciding factor. The guidance gives an example of a person buying a car and then giving it to their daughter two weeks later, after they go into a care home. If the person already knew they were going to be moving into the home, it could be deprivation of assets. If the person (be they age 30 or 50 or 90) was in good health at the time of purchase but then fell downstairs or had a stroke or was hit by a car, it wouldn’t be deprivation because they didn’t have a reasonable expectation of needing to contribute to the cost of the care at the time of purchase. But the local authority would probably look at it very closely to be sure.

It’s all set out here: www.gov.uk/government/publications/care-act-statutory-guidance/care-and-support-statutory-guidance in Annex E and most councils will also have their own policies available.

For the poster who mentioned putting property in trust, that is a specific example given in the guidance of a deprivation of assets. Councils are broke. They will (rightly) look for any way to reduce their financial liability. They will examine any and all cases of possible deprivation extremely closely.[/quote]
What about this situation?

DM dies and leaves her half of house to child with the understanding that DF will continue to live and maintain house for as long as he is alive.

DF needs care home over 11 years later. Is the 50% share of the house left to child protected? At time of DM death there was no sign of need for care home but DF was 71.

toconclude · 24/08/2021 16:41

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

toconclude · 24/08/2021 16:35

@MargosKaftan

Yes, theres a chance it will go on care.

Theres also a chance that by the time they die, they haven't needed to spend anything on care (or can cope with someone coming in), and the house is worth a hell of a lot more than £200k.

This. I've said it before and will say it again: only 15 pc of over 85s are in care homes. They could sever the joint tenancy if they wanted so that on one death half the property becomes yours and sister's.
GnomeDePlume · 24/08/2021 16:01

B & C both say everything they've done has been with the approval of a solicitor so it may be legally right but it certainly isn't morally right.

It might be worth checking this with a different solicitor. If the solicitor has failed in their duty then there may be recourse.

Of course, if it is legal then you will have to swallow it but at least then you know you did what you could.

Broccoli123 · 24/08/2021 14:07

It was a similar situation in our family except B had benefited greatly from A during their lifetime and ensured that the trust was set up so that they could continue to do so after their death.

It's now nearly all gone thanks to their wanton spending and some spectacularly bad business decisions. A wouldn't be at all happy that it wasn't used for its intended purpose and that I didn't have the same financial assistance that B & C both had.

B & C both say everything they've done has been with the approval of a solicitor so it may be legally right but it certainly isn't morally right.

GnomeDePlume · 24/08/2021 13:59

There's no point at all leaving someone money if they can't access it and have no control over what's done with it.

I totally agree.

My DM has apparently decided to leave the bulk of her estate to her DGCs (fine, her prerogative). Unfortunately she is very much influenced by DB1 who sees her estate as 'DF's Money' and wants the money to be kept together and held in a trust which he wants to control - not for him to benefit but for him to prevent the money being spent.

Curlygirl06 · 24/08/2021 13:02

I've said this before and I'll say it again. My mum's will overly favoured my brother (favourite). We were all in the same life stages, house, jobs, mortgages, children. Eventually it's sorted and now back to equal shares as it has been up until her and dad changed their wills in favour of golden boy. No family arguments, no reason to do it. I've asked my dad several times why and he can't give a reason, just it was what my mother wanted.
It's caused a huge family rift that still has lingering effects, and makes me sad that my parents thought more of him than us.
I've given my children different amounts relating to house purchases but it's clearly stated in the will how our estate is to be divided if there's any left, so as to make it fair. They have a letter we've written explaining it in easy terms, rather than in legalese and they were given the letter now so that if they think it's unclear or unfair they can discuss it now. I never want my children or step children to feel that they matter less to us, as I felt with regards to my parents. It's shit.

Broccoli123 · 24/08/2021 12:09

@GnomeDePlume that's exactly the issue. It's in the will that I benefit but it was put in the control of B & C who clearly couldn't care less whether I benefit or not as long as the money is there when they want it.

There's no point at all leaving someone money if they can't access it and have no control over what's done with it.

GnomeDePlume · 24/08/2021 11:57

@Broccoli123 I think your experience exemplifies why it is so dangerous to assume in a will that X 'will do right' by Y. If you want Y to benefit then you have to write that down.

Wills get written and then tend to languish often for decades. It is easy to say that people should re-write their wills as circumstances change but often they dont realise out out of date their wills have become. They remember the intention rather than the detail.

Broccoli123 · 24/08/2021 10:20

Thanks @GnomeDePlume. It's an awful feeling knowing your own family have completely screwed you over. My life would have been very different if I'd inherited directly rather than in the way it has been done.

Neither B nor C will be alive by the time I get whatever is left, which will likely be nothing, and they have both done very well out of it.

I wouldn't mind if it was their money. They'd be entitled to do whatever they liked with it. But it wasn't and was left with the intention of benefitting all of us.

GnomeDePlume · 24/08/2021 09:49

@Broccoli123 my sympathies

This is why I think complicated wills are a minefield. They set out with all good intentions but the result ends up being the opposite of the intention.

Wills get old and out of date. I know that ours written when DCs were small were totally inappropriate once DCs were adult. We had identified one of my DBs as responsible for our DCs in the event of our deaths. Now that he is a middle aged man I am not sure I would even want him to be responsible for our cat!

Muchmorethan · 24/08/2021 09:48

My parents were Joint Tennants as is more the "norm" for married couples.

A few years back they changed it to Tennants in Common and each left their 50% split between my sister and l.

Dad then died less then a year later and so now Mum owns 50% and my sister/ I own 25% each. We are on the deeds.

The difficulty l personally had was when my XH left and we got a divorce as l actually owned 25% of my Mum's house and he was entitled to some of my "assets".

DynamoKev · 24/08/2021 09:22

I also want to point out that I in no way "expect" anything from my parents - I've been financially independent since I was 18 and I'm proud of what I've achieved by myself.
So which is it?
Are you only expecting something because someone else might be getting it?

tenredthings · 24/08/2021 09:21

It isn't fair but it's not worth the headspace. We diligently worked and saved and are careful with budgeting and are therefore deemed not to need support from the in-laws whereas siblings who partied, spent money on personal growth adventures got massive 'loans' to help them on there way.

Broccoli123 · 24/08/2021 09:14

@Pazuzu the trustees are also beneficiaries, just to complicate matters. In any case, the properties and money related to the trust are now gone so even if a solicitor did confirm that their actions were illegal in some way I wouldn't get the money.

GnomeDePlume · 24/08/2021 09:04

@BettyCarver we are now second time around on will making. Made our first when DCs were small. We then remade our wills a few years ago when DCs were young adults. I'm glad we did as rereading our wills made me realise that they were well out of date.

We are being very open with DCs. There will be no nasty surprises.

This openness is important to me. My DM is playing secret squirrels with hers. If what I have been told turns out to be true (bequests to all and sundry, a small complicated trust fund) then DBs and I as executors and trustees (if that is also what she has finally written) will be left with a nightmare to execute but no actual benefit.

I try not to think about it too often unless my blood pressure needs raising!

BettyCarver · 24/08/2021 08:09

@GnomeDePlume I was hesitant to write my will; it forces us to think about a time when we won't be here which isn't easy. But like you, I was glad when I did it and it was actually a very positive experience. Dh and I have very simple wills, leaving everything to the surviving partner and when they die, everything shared equally between our children.

Pazuzu · 24/08/2021 08:05

@Broccoli123, see a solicitor. Trustees shouldn't be acting for their own benefit.

As for the OP issue, yes it's unfair and it's very much geared towards getting home care from the daughters.

From an estate planning point of view, some of the advice on here is awful. It's clearly not a true gift for IHT purposes (as all benefit has been retained by the parents) and the council WILL be all over it in relation to care home fees as there's a good chance due to age etc that they'd consider it a deprivation issue.

If there is a decently sized asset in question and the council consider that fees are payable by the individual, if the fees aren't paid, then the council can petition for bankruptcy. At that point it's hunting season on the asset and the Insolvency Act is very much on the side of creditors.

GnomeDePlume · 24/08/2021 07:31

If all the wise provisions were actually put into wills rather than just being thought about there would be far fewer upset relatives.

I found the process of writing my will very helpful. It forced me to think things through. Having seen a couple of tricky family wills DH and I have opted for simplicity. DCs know that if they get left anything after care has been paid for then it is windfall. It will only happen once.