Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

. . . to think parents are being naive about our "inheritance"?

314 replies

OhFFSNotAnotherVirus · 21/08/2021 08:04

Just pondering . . . for some reason it's niggling at me, maybe because I find their lack of understanding frustrating!

I also want to point out that I in no way "expect" anything from my parents - I've been financially independent since I was 18 and I'm proud of what I've achieved by myself.

Parent are 65, I have one brother and one sister. Parents gave my brother their life savings (close to £100k) so he could buy a nicer house than he could afford by himself. Parents told me and my sister that they would change their wills to leave their house (a small townhouse worth about £200k) to the two of us, to make it fair.

I don't think it is fair, though. Chances are the house will be sold in the future to pay for their care. They seem blissfully unaware that this is a possibility - or a likelihood - and seem almost smug about having done the right thing by all three of their children. I've brought up the possibility that the house might need to be sold to pay for care, but they dismissed this, saying absolutely not, they wouldn't be going into a home, they'd rather go to Dignitas first . . .

I'm saying nothing further, there's no point and I know there's no entitlement here. But AIBU to be a bit . . . Hmm?

Oh and this all happened a couple of years ago and they haven't changed their wills anyway Grin

OP posts:
Jasmine11 · 21/08/2021 08:39

If they were really serious they would put the house into you and your sisters name now so it is safeguarded for you. The fact they haven't changed their will yet either shows they have no real intention of making things equitable.

aiwblam · 21/08/2021 08:39

Alternatively the property increases in value and you and your sister end up with more than 100k.

I agree that it was not a very clever thing to do on their part but you’ll probably just have to crack on with your life and forget about it.

ancientgran · 21/08/2021 08:39

@millenialblush

Also you will lose a decent chunk of that to the taxman. House inheritance isn't that simple. And I also agree with the above poster that inheritance shouldn't be unequal
A £200,000 house won't lose a chunk to the taxman.
MrsLargeEmbodied · 21/08/2021 08:38

that is like a carrot they are dangling in front of you,
possibly elusive
can you have a conversation about it?

knittingaddict · 21/08/2021 08:37

I would be very unhappy too op. Before anyone tells me that you can't expect an inheritance, I know that. We are in our late 50's and early 60's and will receive nothing when all our parents have died. It's the unfairness of giving such a substantial sum to one and relying on a healthy old age to even out the imbalance. That's very naive.

My husband's father died when my husband was in his teens. His mother spent the last few years in a secure care home. My mum has dementia and will end up in a care home. My dad is in his late 80's and disabled and highly unlikely to manage at home. That's any of their meagre savings gone. I'm not at all bothered as I think people should use their money to make their lives better rather than pass it on. I just wanted to demonstrate that assuming you will have something to pass on to your children is misguided.

I'm sorry op.

CheeryTreeBlossom · 21/08/2021 08:37

@Ginfilledcats

My in laws have put their house in my husband and his sisters name (they're early 60s) and pay a token rent if £1 a month. This bypasses the house being used to pay for their care as long as it's in their sons name for 7 years before any costs are needed.

My parents are going to do the same I think.

This is not good to work to avoid either inheritance tax nor council assessment. They're not that stupid ...

The council can and will ask to see details of assets and how the parents afford to rent if not owning - this will then come up as a clear example of deprivation of assets. As mentioned 7 year rule doesn't apply for assessing care needs.

For inheritance tax, the 7 year rule only applies if it's a gift without reservation i.e. no strings attached. So parents would need to pay market rent on a normal tenancy contract for it to be a true gift, and not retain a beneficial interest. Continuing the live there for a nominal sum means it clearly wasn't a true gift.

Think your in laws and parents need to get some proper legal advice on this set up.

HaPPy8 · 21/08/2021 08:36

I think from what you have said they have tried to make your lives equal in the present, but I can understand it might grate a bit if you feel you worked hard while your brother had a good time. But thinking of it as them trying to make you equal now might be more comforting than thinking they favoured him!

Cam001 · 21/08/2021 08:34

My in laws have put their house in my husband and his sisters name (they're early 60s) and pay a token rent if £1 a month. This bypasses the house being used to pay for their care as long as it's in their sons name for 7 years before any costs are needed. if this were a legitimate action, don't you think everyone would be doing it? It's deprivation of assets.

OP you're not being unreasonable. Given average life expectancy they will likely live another 20 years, so your brother will have had the benefit of his 'share' for decades longer than you, and that's if there's anything left after care costs.

CarolineForbes · 21/08/2021 08:32

I hear you OP. My sister is similar to your brother and my parents have bankrolled her for tens of thousands of pounds. My mother denied for years that we’d all been treated differently but as my other siblings and I hadn’t been given any money it was demonstrably not true! She then started saying out of nowhere about changing her will to account for the difference in money given. I got the feeling she thought I’d be thrilled to hear this but even if they never need care I should hope I’d be in my seventies by the time they pass - what would I need their money for at that age? I needed help and support when I was started out not when I’m retired myself as I should hope I have my own plans in place by then! As with your parents she hasn’t changed the will anyway!

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 21/08/2021 08:29

@millenialblush

Also you will lose a decent chunk of that to the taxman. House inheritance isn't that simple. And I also agree with the above poster that inheritance shouldn't be unequal
Not if their only asset is £200k house. There will be no tax to pay. Even if you include the £100k they have given to the poster brothers, becuase they die within the 7 year limit for tax exemption they are still massively below the combined IHT allowance of £1m ( as it includes property) Not sure why you think they would have to pay tax
NeverTalkToStrangers · 21/08/2021 08:29

People don’t go to Dignitas with dementia - it just doesn’t happen for all sorts of reasons. People on here often say it’s their answer to the need for elder care and I always read it as “la la la I’m not listening”.

However only a minority of people will be in care homes for long enough to eat through the value of even a modest house. The odds are against the longer lived of your parents being in that position, although it’s still a real possibility.

More to the point they should make a sodding will (with a note included for the record saying “this doesn’t mean we have disinherited because we don’t love DB - it’s just that we gave him his money early”).

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 21/08/2021 08:28

Your parents need to sign their home to you and your sister. If they survive for seven years without needing care/dying it cannot be taken for care nor is it regarded as a deprivation of assets. The name evades me but it’s a legitimate inheritance scheme.

VladmirsPoutine · 21/08/2021 08:28

Yanbu it's utterly shit. I don't know that I wouldn't raise it again or at least point out that by giving your bro a 'head-start' his inheritance is of more value. And really who's to say that after all the costs etc you'd manage to sell the townhouse for a neat 200k. Sorry but they're being entirely unreasonable. My issue isn't so much the entitlement factor but the unfairness. I'd rather my siblings and I all received fuck all than one of us be given a lump sum. I couldn't let this go.

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 21/08/2021 08:25

@Ginfilledcats

My in laws have put their house in my husband and his sisters name (they're early 60s) and pay a token rent if £1 a month. This bypasses the house being used to pay for their care as long as it's in their sons name for 7 years before any costs are needed.

My parents are going to do the same I think.

The seven years thing is a very common misconception. The criteria for a local authority to consider such action to be a deprivation of assets (ie to get around the need to pay for social care) is:

(a) whether avoiding the care and support charge was a significant motivation in the timing of the disposal of the asset; at the point the capital was disposed of could the person have a reasonable expectation of the need for care and support?
(b) did the person have a reasonable expectation of needing to contribute to the cost of their eligible care needs?

Transferring the title of a property is a common deprivation of assets that councils will be wise too. Expect a savvy council to scrutinise it some detail if your in laws ever require residential care, and be mindful of the risk that your DH would be liable as the third party beneficiary of the asset if the council decides deprivation has taken place.

LemonTT · 21/08/2021 08:24

People who transfer assets are aware of the 7 year rule. At 65 there would be a fair chance that a least one would make it to their 70’s.

Lots of families plan this way and it works if you get good advice and guidance.

LionGiraffe · 21/08/2021 08:24

I’d be happy with the arrangement. Yes, there’s a chance the house might have to be sold but I wouldn’t assume that was a given - none of my grandparents needed residential care and they lived into their late 80s. Similarly, my in law grandparents lived independently into their late 90s.

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 21/08/2021 08:23

@Ginfilledcats

My in laws have put their house in my husband and his sisters name (they're early 60s) and pay a token rent if £1 a month. This bypasses the house being used to pay for their care as long as it's in their sons name for 7 years before any costs are needed.

My parents are going to do the same I think.

This doesnt workand is called deprivation of assets. The £1 rent proves this more than shores up "its legit"

Also Flowers for OP. It's shit and unfair... but that's life...

MargosKaftan · 21/08/2021 08:22

Yes, theres a chance it will go on care.

Theres also a chance that by the time they die, they haven't needed to spend anything on care (or can cope with someone coming in), and the house is worth a hell of a lot more than £200k.

Hoppinggreen · 21/08/2021 08:22

@Ginfilledcats

My in laws have put their house in my husband and his sisters name (they're early 60s) and pay a token rent if £1 a month. This bypasses the house being used to pay for their care as long as it's in their sons name for 7 years before any costs are needed.

My parents are going to do the same I think.

That’s called deprivation of assets and councils can and do go after people who have done this. In their early 60’s they might get away with it but if it looks like Care is imminent due to age or ill health the Council may still go after the house after death. Some Councils employ someone solely to do this
Smudgeis13 · 21/08/2021 08:21

Ginfilledcats. Your in-laws are mistaken. A Local Authority can, and do, go back many years to investigate deprivation of assets. The 7 year rule is about tax. Also if the in-laws rent their house, they must pay the going rate in rent or else this is deprivation of assets.

OhFFSNotAnotherVirus · 21/08/2021 08:20

Ah thanks everyone - I felt guilty for being irritated by the whole thing so it's reassuring to see that I'm not really being unreasonable!

Dignitas costing a fortune did occur to me, @Disfordarkchocolate, but honestly there's no point in talking to them about it any further, they are pretty settled in their minds and it's not the happiest of conversations to keep bringing up!

My brother decided to spend most of his twenties and early thirties travelling and never built up any savings, so when he decided to buy a house, financially he was "behind" where my sister and I were - we'd taken more prosaic routes in life and just worked/bought out houses in our twenties. So I think our parents thought they'd be making us "equal".

It is what it is . . . hopefully the whiny little voice in my head that pops up every now and again will go quiet and I can be philosophical about it!

OP posts:
SheWoreYellow · 21/08/2021 08:19

@malovitt

You only have to pay inheritance tax if the estate is over £1 million for married couples so it won't apply here.
£500,000 if you leave it to your children. £325,000 otherwise.
Kiduknot · 21/08/2021 08:19

Sorry that was to gin

Kiduknot · 21/08/2021 08:19

Deprivation of assets might come into play here. The 7 years is for inheritance tax. There is no time limit for clawback because of deliberate deprivation of assets.

starpatch · 21/08/2021 08:18

I don't think this will work Ginfilledcats. The local authority can still consider the house for care. Even for inheritance tax it doesn't work as they are still living in it.