Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you cope with an alcoholic in the family

65 replies

BlueRocky · 21/08/2021 00:51

My brother is an alcoholic, has been for several years and has got worse over the lockdowns. The drink makes him nasty and short tempered, anything can set him off so all the family walk on eggshells around him.

Recently I've got to the point where I just don't want to be around him anymore. He frequently says horrible things to me and is so negative and self obsessed, I feel completely drained in his company. On a few occasions he's lost his patience with my dd, that was a real turning point for me. I don't want him around me or my child anymore and I told him this. I stand by my decision, it's my job to protect my child right? But my mum's reaction to this has really shocked me.

She says my db needs all our love and support right now. That he's trying to get better and I'm making things worse. She doesn't want to hear how upsetting this is for me, because that's "making things all about you". Is this really the right way to deal with an alcoholic? Should we continue to support them to the detriment of ourselves? I really didn't expect my dm to react in this way and it's made me question my whole judgement on the situation.

OP posts:
MulberrySquash · 22/08/2021 10:14

@Oneborneverydecade we've chatted previously (I name change a lot) and think it was on the alcohol board. I also feel the same guilt about sending DC to see their dad when he was clearly drinking and I'm just hearing now about how badly he treated them (DC didn't want me to feel guilty so didn't tell me)

Oneborneverydecade · 22/08/2021 09:40

@MulberrySquash my ex DH sadly passed away last year. He finally got sober some years after we separated but his health never recovered. DS was only 2 when we left but continued to see his Dad. AFAIK he never addressed his alcoholism with now teen DS, he only ever acknowledged it to me once via WhatsApp and he certainly never apologised for the heartache.

OP looking back I feel guilty for facilitating contact between DS and his Dad, looking back I must have dropped him off when his Dad had been drinking. I think I was brainwashed into thinking his behaviour was normal. On the positive side his GPs were there. I would distance yourself and your DC for their sake and wait for your mum to wake up.

How2Help · 22/08/2021 09:36

My MiL is an alcoholic and I have seen the terrible effects on the wider family. I have helped my DH reconcile his guilt at protecting himself by distancing. My lovely SiL has not felt as able to do it and the impact is terrible, and it does affect her children too. Hell would freeze over before any children I had went near my MiL. It is easier for me as I can be more detached, they (of course) cannot. That guilt of dammed if you do, dammed if you don’t is awful and so damaging.

My FiL is an enabler with his own difficulties which I am sympathetic to. I cannot fix him either. My priority is my DH, my SiL and her children. I am ruthless and heartless in this to protect them and I make no apologies for it.

I have no patience with people who advocate for drinkers and how family should support them as it is an illness. I don’t dispute it is an illness but I think that is a simplistic approach with no understanding of the nuances.

Protect yourself. Protect your child.

KohlaParasanda · 22/08/2021 08:58

Definitely on Team OP here. Your child is your responsibility, your brother is not, and stepping right back from him until he engages with stopping drinking is a wise decision. It also sets your daughter a good example of setting firm boundaries.

Your mum may feel very isolated supporting him on her own, but that's not a reason for you to be drawn into her co-dependent behaviour, and certainly not if it compromises your daughter's emotional health.

checkingforballoons · 22/08/2021 08:52

OP do whatever it is that you need to do to protect yourself and your DC and don’t feel any guilt about it.
My DF was an alcoholic for my entire life. It eventually killed him two years ago and I’m still untangling the impact his drinking had on me. I went pretty much NC for the last few years of his life and I remember a friend (who had had his own addiction problems) telling me that I was being unfair. That my dad would have been terrified of giving up alcohol, that he needed me and that he couldn’t help it. I asked him if my dad had a condition that meant he was completely unable to stop himself from punching me in the face every time he saw me, should I have put up with that too? So yeah, that’s my advice to you.

PumpkinPie2016 · 22/08/2021 07:49

YANBU to keep your daughter away (and you!) she doesn't deserve to be around that sort of behaviour.

Sadly, though she probably can't see it, your mum is enabling him by making excuses for him.

Can you contact alcoholics anonymous for some support for yourself? Also, can you suggest your mum does the same?

I have known two alcoholics. One was the father of a friend. He was a nice man underneath it all but drinking destroyed him. His wife asked him to leave eventually due to the impact it was having on her and their daughters. He went to live with his sister who tried to support him. Unfortunately, he couldn't stop and died of liver failure at just 50 Sad

The other was my Nan's partner. He made zero effort to do anything about his drinking, denied it when asked by doctors who were seeing him because of his numerous health problems caused by it. He died of an alcohol related condition eventually as well.

Unfortunately, with alcoholism, the person has to want to get better themselves. Until that point, little can be done.

Supersimkin2 · 22/08/2021 07:40

Your job is to protect yourself and the DC.

Damage limitation is the first role of anyone with the bad luck of an alcoholic relative.

The alcoholic and their enablers will swear blind their needs are the most important ones in the family. The alcoholic’s need is to drink and behave very badly, but they call this need ‘your love and compassion’. They only love and care for their lifestyle. They don’t care about you, and have no love or compassion or respect for anyone, particularly their families and children.

Keep the DC away. Don’t be in the position of relenting and realising what I’ve just said is true afterwards, which is an easy trap cos alcoholics and their wingmen lie. And lie.

Dozer · 22/08/2021 07:37

V sorry about your brother, and your mum.

Think you’re doing the right thing, setting boundaries for yourself and your DC.

HuntingoftheSnark · 22/08/2021 07:23

@MulberrySquash yes, very much so. AA is based on a 12 step programme of recovery which you work through with a sponsor over a period of time. There is no set time - it takes as long as it does for each step. You also have daily calls with your sponsor and are recommended to go to as many meetings as possible. To summarise, you acknowledge that you have zero control once you consume a drop of alcohol, you list all your resentments and all kinds of other issues you might have, you make a list of all you have harmed and step 9 is making amends to those people, except where to do so might injure them or others.

Obviously the amends are "living amends" and are ongoing, as are the steps - you don't get to do them and it's finished, like a project. I was a horrible alcoholic, the worst, and I absolutely understood that just because I thought "this time will be different", others around me had every right to be wary as they'd heard it all before. Even nearly 14 years down the line, I'm a day at a time - I have no desire to drink but I do think occasionally "I wonder if I could be a normal drinker now?" but my past experiences tell me otherwise and frankly, it's not worth it.

pointythings · 21/08/2021 22:18

Enablers tend not to see they're enabling. It took a lot for me to shake off the role of enabler, even more to cut loose from the codependency.

Addicts are inherently manipulative and are very good at it. Often no bullying is required because they are so skilled at emotional manipulation. You have a clear insight into the dynamic between your DM and your DB - sadly, there is nothing you can do to change it.

MulberrySquash · 21/08/2021 21:53

Could I ask a question of those who are now sober. Does AA/rehab/detox etc address any of the reasons a person drinks and try to get them to deal with them and also to make amends to those they have hurt whilst drunk, or is it just based on the physical act of getting someone sober?
Asking as the parent of DC with an estranged alcoholic father who has been through treatment many times but has not once tried to apologise to his DC for the awful things he put them through.

Apologies for hijacking the post OP.

BlueRocky · 21/08/2021 19:34

My dm doesn't see what she's doing as enabling him, but I would disagree. To me excusing his behaviour and shielding him from any consequences for his actions isn't helping. It's always been the way though, even before my db's problems with alcohol. It's incredibly frustrating for me and my other siblings.

I don't know if he's bullying my dm, but he's definitely being very emotionally manipulative, I worry for her a lot.

OP posts:
Topseyt · 21/08/2021 10:21

My BIL (DH's brother) is an alcoholic. Their mother was his enabler when she was alive although she did admit that she often just did it because she was actually frightened of him. He used to bully her too. Is your mother perhaps also in a similar position?

All you can do really is back off and cut contact, much as you have been doing. You need to protect your child and your own sanity. We have had virtually no contact with my BIL since MIL died over seven years ago now.

It's hard, and it feels brutal, but the other way lies madness.

Cocogreen · 21/08/2021 09:46

I worked with a woman married to an alcoholic.
He used to pick up the kids from school, nursing a can a beer while driving.
She tried to make it work for years.
Many Friday or Saturday nights she had to take him to emergency because he was constantly falling and getting injured.
Once it was in the middle of a busy road.
She moved their family to a large house so he could have his own living area and bedroom away from her and the two teenage kids.
Of course he constantly came into their part of the house, drunk and abusive, stinking.
After 15 years she saw the light, sold the house. He moved to a one bedroom flat and she had a decent life with her children.
Cut him off op, don't waste years like she did.

pointythings · 21/08/2021 09:28

You are right to detach. Your mother isn't fully engaging with Al-Anon - she is still choosing to be the enabler.

Please get some support for yourself so that you can cope with the guilt that is piled on you for having boundaries. Protect yourself and your DD from your brother.

I lost my husband to alcohol and I stayed with him for far too long. It damaged my DDs.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 21/08/2021 09:01

Ops mum wants to protect her child?

Isn't op her child also?

Unfortunately op you see where your mum's priorities lie and if she's a gaga over your dB as my mum was about my alcoholic, violent, selfish nasal gazing unpleasant dB...

Drop the rope now and give up.

Bryonyshcmyony · 21/08/2021 08:57

Oh sorry OP I regularly get asked for money and refuse and my parents think I'm awful because of it, I just pull up my mental drawbridge and concentrate on my own lovely family.

Bryonyshcmyony · 21/08/2021 08:56

It's most definitely a family disease. I have two alcoholic siblings and one ex addict now sober. Al Anon really helped me and part of it was completely stepping back from them. My dsis is now trying to get sober and it's bloody hard doing it with only NHS help (pretty shit tbh) and I respect her so much. We are talking daily having not spoken for years after one too many mad arguments when she was drunk. I'm preparing myself for it not to work, but she's quite far gone with some liver damage so I'm dreading it.

BlueRocky · 21/08/2021 08:50

Thank you for everyone's posts. I'm sorry to those of you who are in similar situations, or have lost someone to alcoholism. It's encouraging to hear from people in recovery as well, I hope that will be my db one day. I don't see any signs of him trying to deal with it, last time we were together he was drinking heavily. Hopefully I'm wrong though.

I hadn't heard alcoholism being described as a family disease before but it's so true. Part of my frustration is my dm's refusal to acknowledge the impact my brother's drinking is having on all of us. She is so protective of my brother and makes excuses for his behaviour. All her anger is directed at me at the moment. She is following al-anon, but selectively from what I can tell.

OP posts:
LimeRedBanana · 21/08/2021 06:23

Your priority is the only one who doesn’t have a say in this - your child. Not your brother and not your Mum.

PopcornMuncher · 21/08/2021 06:14

To those in recovery well done BrewFlowers

Agree that the only thing to do with an alcoholic is step away and let their rock bottom happen. I also know it's not that easy to do in practice. Definitely protect your DC and ignore your mum

HuntingoftheSnark · 21/08/2021 05:56

Another alcoholic in recovery here, almost 14 years down the line. It's not referred to as a family illness for nothing - you have every right to put whatever boundaries in place that you want to. As a PP said, Al Anon gives support for those with an alcoholic in their lives.

A member of my family had nothing to do with me for years while I was drinking, and continued their avoidance for several years into my recovery. I completely respect that decision.

Kanaloa · 21/08/2021 05:12

It’s very hard. Your mum is right that he needs help to get better, but that doesn’t involve you tolerating his nasty behaviour.

I would step away from him, but make him aware that when he’s willing to stop his abusive behaviour and start to look for professional help you are there to support him.

Nat6999 · 21/08/2021 04:40

My late dp was an alcoholic & much as I loved him so much I wish I had thrown him out much earlier, his drinking affected ds a lot, I have only found out since he passed away & ds has got older. I think there comes a time when you have to say enough is enough & either he gets helpb& gets sober or you cut him out of your life, as hard as that will be.

Galaxyinmypocket · 21/08/2021 04:39

Well done to those of you who have stopped! I have experience of both alcoholism and drug addiction within the family. I have seen and heard things I never should have as a child, it is so damaging. You are right to keep your child away from it all. There are support services available to help, you and your mum will not be able to fix him with love and kindness, it doesnt work like that.