Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone else considering switching to a life of militant environmentalism

164 replies

Saveourearthuk · 20/08/2021 23:43

Me and DH are absolutely petrified and can no longer in any good conscience collide in the selfish shitshow that is modern life destroying the plannet. We are thinking of in the next few years
-selling most/all of our possessions
-selling the house
-moving to a small shack in the woods
-we would forrage for food and drink from a well
-we would use no modern technology and essentially shun the outside world.
While this might seem radical we are willing to bravely make this sacrifice to save our glorious planet. Is anyone else considering this?

OP posts:
Bucanarab · 21/08/2021 03:22

You'll get a lot of stick OP but honestly, 10-30 years from now we'll all be utterly fucked so any practice you get in self sufficiency will be invaluable.

Imtootired · 21/08/2021 03:20

By militant I thought you meant blowing up a fossil fuel power station. That would actually be doing something. Attempting to live outside of society won’t achieve anything even if you do succeed

Valorgreen · 21/08/2021 03:12

Nah. Until the big companies get their act together even if I lived the rest of my life carbon neutral, it would be pissing in the ocean.

Interestingly, I feel exactly the same when it comes to women's rights. There's absolutely no point in me pretending that women are equal when the big boys don't have their act together. Instead I'll just wait for them to lead the way and until then I'll expect women to remain in their "place".

HarrietSchulenberg · 21/08/2021 03:06

You could make a start by recycling your phone or laptop or whatever you're using to access MN. That would be a start - recycle the components and use less energy to charge the things. But do let us know how it goes, especially when 1000 other people also build cabins in your woods and start pissing in your water supply because they also haven't thought about it properly.

FiveShelties · 21/08/2021 03:05

Sounds a fantastic idea - enjoy.

crazycanuck · 21/08/2021 02:52

Ah, I see Lovefall mentioned them further upthread

crazycanuck · 21/08/2021 02:48

A couple in BC did something similar for a year. But the plot they are on is VERY fortuitously located. www.cheknews.ca/chek-upside-one-year-later-we-check-in-with-pender-island-couple-living-solely-off-the-land-859874/

TreeSmuggler · 21/08/2021 02:44

Yes, but militaristic in the sense of becoming an activist, protesting, organising, going to jail, running for parliament or taking a company or the government to court over environmental crimes.

firstimemamma · 21/08/2021 02:27

No, I could never live like that. I don't eat meat, do refill shopping / minimal plastic, never fly, don't often drive, use cloth nappies / wipes and hardly ever buy new clothes. Took over a year to make all these changes and that's enough for me.

Aquamarine1029 · 21/08/2021 02:24

Don't be ridiculous. You will achieve absolutely nothing.

WhereYouLeftIt · 21/08/2021 02:22

@Saveourearthuk

Me and DH are absolutely petrified and can no longer in any good conscience collide in the selfish shitshow that is modern life destroying the plannet. We are thinking of in the next few years -selling most/all of our possessions -selling the house -moving to a small shack in the woods -we would forrage for food and drink from a well -we would use no modern technology and essentially shun the outside world. While this might seem radical we are willing to bravely make this sacrifice to save our glorious planet. Is anyone else considering this?
"we are willing to bravely make this sacrifice to save our glorious planet."

Oh FFS, what twaddle! 'Bravely.' Did you hold the back of your hand to your forehead and sink onto your fainting couch as you said this? You sound as if you are drunk, and maybe you are - drunk on being a melodramatic drama llama misunderstood heroine.

What you are describing bears no relation to 'militant environmentalism'. That would involve actually doing something; protests, campaigning, lobbying, being prepared to go to prison for chaining yourself to the railings. Not thinking how romantic it would all be to withdraw into the woods. (Spoiler alert - you're more likely to pick up a waterborne disease and malnutrition with your pie-in-the-sky plans.)

sst1234 · 21/08/2021 01:46

You should seek proper help for feeling like this. Seriously it’s not normal or healthy.

IdblowJonSnow · 21/08/2021 01:18

Nope! Because in the scheme of things it won't achieve anything. we all need to be making massive changes which most people will only do when it's been imposed on us.

safariboot · 21/08/2021 01:13

That cannot be a model for everyone. By separating yourself from society in this way, I doubt you'll have a role in shaping it to become better.

Ironically considering this site's focus, the single best thing you can do for the environment in the long term is don't have any (more) children. Or pets. (Well, actually the best thing is probably to kill a lot of people, but I'm not encouraging that!)

After that it's living car-free, avoiding air travel and indeed any long-distance travel, and going vegan.

And if by doing that you set a good example and lead others to follow, you just might do more than by reclusing yourself from society.

ineedaholidaynow · 21/08/2021 00:54

I assume this is what all the protestors next week will be doing

Ieatmarmite · 21/08/2021 00:52

I know of someone who tried to do similar. Ended up depending on friends for charity.

A lifestyle you suggest sounds idyllic but would be hard work - imagine a cold, snowy January day. What will you forage? How will you find enough to eat & keep warm. In the past hunter-gatherers migrated to ensure they had a supply of food - following herd migrations etc. How will you provide fuel for cooking etc - true you can coppice trees but what if more of us decide to do same- wouldn't be enough trees to keep us all. Tree wars instead of oil wars? Are you planning seasonal work to earn even a modest income to buy things you need? How will that leave you time to forage for the calories you need to stay alive without vitamin deficiencies etc? What if more of us decide to forage? Plants, fungi, wild game etc would be decimated in no time. Are you going to be like the person I referred to previously - freeloading off friends who have to stay part of modern society so they can support you as well as themselves?

I suppose I'm different from you - I also want to stop climate change, want rewilding, want to preserve/restore the environment, believe we have a responsibility to the Earth & all that lives here - but I put my faith in technology to help do those things.
I want more money put into research for "clean" energy, research into bacteria to clean up water courses, more organic & sustainable agriculture & more permaculture, less factory farming, land reform to make it easier for small, sustainable groups to produce local food for local markets etc. Much better, imo, to campaign & work for those things than try to drop out.

DanielTigersMummy21 · 21/08/2021 00:36

How is that militant? I don't get it.

AlwaysLatte · 21/08/2021 00:29

On the basis that small shacks in the woods near wells are not readily available, I'd say no! But definitely carry on the other stuff - minimal air travel, no single use plastic, recycle or reuse wherever possible, etc. Don't put plastic grass in your garden! Eat more vegetarian/vegan meals than lest ones.

PickAChew · 21/08/2021 00:28

How would selling your house and the things you already have help the environment?

What consequences would you forsee from all 63 million brits moving into the woods and foraging?

LoveFall · 21/08/2021 00:22

I think that is a terrible idea. But if you are committed to changing your lifestyle, then think it through more carefully.

For example, there is a young couple who decided to live completely off their land and things they foraged or caught in the sea. They did it successfully for a year.

www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/pender-island-living-off-the-land-1.6128690

GingerBrod · 21/08/2021 00:15

Presume you are joking, but there are people who live off grid but use technology and solar power etc.

Anyway, it's the big corporations that need to make changes.

OneTC · 21/08/2021 00:14

Nah

dreamingbohemian · 21/08/2021 00:14

YABU

Running away solves nothing

The kinds of radical change we need can only be put in motion by the leaders of the most powerful countries and corporations. We need political activism, economic pressure, boycotts etc. Not people living in the woods while the world burns.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 21/08/2021 00:13

I hope you also weave your own yoghurt...
Unfortunately not😔 i am fully eartan though. I only eat soil and what i can grow. My cave is very good for mushrooms, which i unfortunately hate😔
Worth the sacrifice tho

SeaDreaming · 21/08/2021 00:01

@SchrodingersImmigrant

Tsk tsk.

Amateur. I sold ALL my possesions, I use rhubarb leaves to.make myself a cover for private areas, my home is a cave like thing I dug in the woods myself and fortified it with locally sourced fallen timber. My want to be so so so carbon neutral, was really being tested by my love of internet. By the sheer power of want I managed to create a somewhat telepathic skills so I can now browse online just by thinking about it hard enough.
Now THAT'S carbon neutral.
Also by foraging, you are taking valuable food from wildlife. Shame on you

I hope you also weave your own yoghurt...