Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone else considering switching to a life of militant environmentalism

164 replies

Saveourearthuk · 20/08/2021 23:43

Me and DH are absolutely petrified and can no longer in any good conscience collide in the selfish shitshow that is modern life destroying the plannet. We are thinking of in the next few years
-selling most/all of our possessions
-selling the house
-moving to a small shack in the woods
-we would forrage for food and drink from a well
-we would use no modern technology and essentially shun the outside world.
While this might seem radical we are willing to bravely make this sacrifice to save our glorious planet. Is anyone else considering this?

OP posts:
BahHumbygge · 21/08/2021 09:38

Read The Way Home by Mark Boyle. He bought some land in rural Ireland, lives completely off grid (ie not even having solar panels or a wind turbine) completely without technology. He does go into the nuances of what he means by “technology” in the book. So he doesn’t have a mobile phone, social media, electricity, gas, running water, but he does avail himself of the Irish postal service. He was featured on one of the Ben Fogle episodes of people living in the wild, aired around Feb 2021 if you want to have a look.

LoislovesStewie · 21/08/2021 09:33

I'm more interested in what food you think will be growing for you to forage?

FuckingFabulous · 21/08/2021 09:28

I find it amusing that you're turning to the internet, either from a phone or a laptop, in order to ask this question.

Perhaps you should try this for a month at a time. Maybe in the winter. There are plenty of absolutely fucking mental hellhole retreats that offer this sort of experience. See how you feel after a month in a forest shack, grubbing for roots and fungus, smashing the ice on your water source every morning in December. It'll be a good test for you and you'll find out pretty quickly whether you want to compromise on your morals and just be diligent about your carbon footprint in your modern convenient house or whether you really want to step back 1,000 years.

RightYesButNo · 21/08/2021 09:25

Erm… why do you need a shack when you already live under a bridge?

YouShouldLeave · 21/08/2021 09:21

@User112

Hello OP, my husband and I have the same thoughts. However, we have 3 kids to think about. So we are trying to achieve some kind of balance. It’s hard, we feel SO GUILTY when we put out rubbish bins.
Shouldn’t you feel more guilt about the three kids?
NoWordForFluffy · 21/08/2021 09:20

@MuscleTherapy

Yeah, I give you 3 months.
Months?! I'd say days!
ohfook · 21/08/2021 09:20

Op is blatantly taking the piss. It wouldn't be a brave decision it would just be a pointless load of virtue signaling. Nothing will change until governments and major fossil fuel industry players make meaningful changes and the way that we measure our economic success stops being defined by year on year growth. The whole of the U.K. could piss off in the woods and forage for food and it would just fuck over the eco-system and over crowd the woods!

queenMab99 · 21/08/2021 09:19

Your shack will be burnt to the ground by forest fires, caused by climate change, and your well will no doubt be polluted by runoff from a slurry pit.Sad Flowers

PalmarisLongus · 21/08/2021 09:16

It can be done OP. But you'd need a few million in the bank to begin with.

Buying the woodland is not cheap.
Building an environmentally friendly house that has zero impact is not cheap and almost impossible.
Laying roads to the cabin in the woods is not cheap. So on and so on.

By the time you've got the land, cut the trees to build with, cut the trees to make a road, flattened land for farming, sorted irrigation, got a path to a water source, disturbed the natural habitat and built on the land, you'll have to live another 50 years without breathing, peeing, eating or farting just to offset the environmental damage you've both caused to the woodland to set up the environmentally friendly cabin.
Good luck though.

TheKeatingFive · 21/08/2021 09:13

I don’t think foraging is a safe or realistic long term solution OP. Do you know anything about foraging? Especially in winter?

Eating only locally produced food would be better.

chestnutshell · 21/08/2021 09:09

@Audit I do understand that of course which is why I don’t eat meat/fish, only buy clothes I plan on keeping for a long time, drive an EV etc etc. But I still feel like what I do is small when realistically we don’t have time for simple ground up supply-chain pressure. We need governments to take initiative now.

TheresGoingToBeTears · 21/08/2021 09:06

@Antsinyourpanta

To be fair the OP hasnt been back so maybe theyve given up their tech already....before finding out whether it was an unreasonable suggestion....?
😀
Antsinyourpanta · 21/08/2021 09:04

To be fair the OP hasnt been back so maybe theyve given up their tech already....before finding out whether it was an unreasonable suggestion....?

TheresGoingToBeTears · 21/08/2021 09:02

I love all the environmentalists telling us to give up our cars, stop flying, stop eating meat, live in the woods etc etc.
In the meantime, they're posting on MN using their mobile phones or iPads or PC's that were presumably made in China and transported thousands of miles etc etc.
Yet they don't see the irony.

Mindyourbusiness22 · 21/08/2021 09:00

Why is this a YABU/YANBU?? It’s your choice, each to their own.

badpuma · 21/08/2021 09:00

The only way that would have any benefit on the environment is if it reduced population numbers.

Environmentally, it is best for people to live in flats in cities as that minimises travel and land take.

MrsFin · 21/08/2021 08:57

@Saveourearthuk

Me and DH are absolutely petrified and can no longer in any good conscience collide in the selfish shitshow that is modern life destroying the plannet. We are thinking of in the next few years -selling most/all of our possessions -selling the house -moving to a small shack in the woods -we would forrage for food and drink from a well -we would use no modern technology and essentially shun the outside world. While this might seem radical we are willing to bravely make this sacrifice to save our glorious planet. Is anyone else considering this?

Can you imagine how full the woods would be if we all did that?

It's not practical large scale, or even on any scale really.

Will you still be requiring the services of the NHS at some point? The NHS you won't need paying for if you're not earning/paying taxes?

Marriedtothesilverfox · 21/08/2021 08:55

It doesnt sound very practical. I dont think you’ll last long on foraged food.

Oogachuckachopsy · 21/08/2021 08:55

Crack on. But any money you’d either be dead within the week from eating something poisonous, or booked into the local Travelodge.

liveforsummer · 21/08/2021 08:54

That's not what militant means. What long term benefit/impact on the planet do you feel you as an individual doing this will have? Why get rid of things already made and bought - surely best to use them all till the end of their lives and never buy more? Do you have any concept of the reality of your idea? I'd assume not!

bagelsandoranges · 21/08/2021 08:54

Troll thread. "militant environmentalism"??!
That's clearly DM speak....

ufucoffee · 21/08/2021 08:53

Nope

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 21/08/2021 08:52

God no.

Audit · 21/08/2021 08:51

@Saveourearthuk

Me and DH are absolutely petrified and can no longer in any good conscience collide in the selfish shitshow that is modern life destroying the plannet. We are thinking of in the next few years -selling most/all of our possessions -selling the house -moving to a small shack in the woods -we would forrage for food and drink from a well -we would use no modern technology and essentially shun the outside world. While this might seem radical we are willing to bravely make this sacrifice to save our glorious planet. Is anyone else considering this?
With which institute would you invest the money and where would they place it?

Which leaves do you use to wipe your arse in Winter when it’s frosty?

What is an effective natural tampon?

When your eyesight fails what do you use to help you see enough for foraging?

Audit · 21/08/2021 08:47

@chestnutshell

No but I do understand the feeling of utter hopelessness in the face of climate change. I hate that I’m so complicit in the destruction of the planet and I’m taking steps where I can. Part of the helplessness I feel though is that my personal contribution is so flippin small and until governments and multi-nationals do something drastic, what I do is futile.
Corporations only produce because of demand. Changing our product use and buying habits will have a material effect on production.