Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christening’s and Godparents - How many did you have? (If applicable!) Is 6-8 too many?!

143 replies

ChristeningConundrum · 20/08/2021 23:03

OH and I are planning to have a christening for our DC at some stage but the main decision of how many godparents we have is a big stumbling block. I would like 6 but ideally 8. Simply because each person is important to us (obviously!) and it would be very difficult to narrow down the number of people. For example, 2 of them are siblings and it would be like choosing one over another which we wouldn’t do. If we have 6 it would be 4 from my side and 2 from OH’s side. I would prefer 8 so that we both have 4 from each of our families.

OH says either number is far too many and that ‘it’s just not the done thing’. That’s his only reason for not liking the idea, he thinks it’s strange. He has no objection to any of the prospective godparents and likes/loves them all.

I know it would be a lot but does it really matter if it’s not what most people do?
I feel it’s could be compared to the number of bridesmaids someone might choose, it’s up to the individual/couple.

We are older parents, our DC is long awaited and has brought so much happiness to us and both of our families. It means a lot to me to have a christening and choose godparents who are important to both of us. OH wants our DC to be christened and apart from that and the number of godparents he’s not got much to say about what we do with the arrangements.

BTW, we are very average people, no delusions of grandeur or anything like that! I don’t know why I think it’s important to say that but I do.

I thought I’d ask MN what the general consensus is so that we can gauge what is ‘normal’ and go from there, so here I am!

If you happen to have lots of godparents for your DC’s I would love to know how many!

Sorry it’s so lengthy and far too many exclamation marks!!!!

Lastly, I see the irony in asking MN what’s ‘normal’ and what other people have done whilst also saying does it matter what other people do!

OP posts:
GreyhoundG1rl · 21/08/2021 00:23

@PickAChew

You make them sound like bridesmaids.

I've managed to be a godparent 3 times over. I'm an atheist. I'm still in in contact with one godchild - my niece who, as an adult, is also atheist. We talk about pokemon and autism.

Atheist. Godparent. Not two words that usually belong in the same sentence, really.
EBearhug · 21/08/2021 00:23

Three is your number. Six or eight is bonkers. And ‘traditionally’ for a girl the 3 would be 2 x women and 1 x man. For a boy 2 x men and 1 x woman.

This. And not family - family members are already part of their life.

I'm not a godparent to anyone, but it doesn't mean I don't care about any of my friends' children.

stardust40 · 21/08/2021 00:21

Our vicar said to have whoever we liked! Dd1 had 4 ( my sister and hubby and the DJ brother and wife). Dd2 had 6 as we had two close friends (a couple) who were involved with her. The more special people in their lives the better 😍

PickAChew · 21/08/2021 00:21

You make them sound like bridesmaids.

I've managed to be a godparent 3 times over. I'm an atheist. I'm still in in contact with one godchild - my niece who, as an adult, is also atheist. We talk about pokemon and autism.

GreyhoundG1rl · 21/08/2021 00:18

Some people do choose godparents who will be in a position to open doors for their dc or be financially generous - as Kimdeals noticed at the christening she wrote about.
Oh, I know. Some people are definitely beneficial to have in your life Wink. It's just a devious way of inveigling them in Grin

Redglitter · 21/08/2021 00:18

6 - 8 is ridiculous. 2 or 3 is the norm.

Scarby9 · 21/08/2021 00:14

I have 3 godparents.
I am also one of 3 godparents to each of my 4 godchildren.

Woolver23 · 21/08/2021 00:10

My kids weren't christened but I was: I have three godparents. I think two or three is normal, judging from the christenings I've been to.

Eight is more than a little bit bonkers; why don't you save some of your choices in case you do have any subsequent children, or give them other roles in your kid's life? Eg guitar teacher, baking companion, art tutor, even just fairy godmother. Play to their strengths, pay them for their time if necessary and hope they'll strike up a lovely relationship.

It wouldn't make me feel very special to be asked to be godparent and then to find out I was one of eight! Infact I would wonder if the parents were just doing it for presents for their kids and babysitting offers!

ImNotWhoYouThinkIam · 21/08/2021 00:09

I was always told 3 was traditional as well. (2 men and a woman for a boy and vice versa). Raised Anglican.

That said. DS1 had 3 Godparents. One sadly passed away when he was a baby.
DS2 only had 2 to begin with (i think, if he had 3 I can't remember who the 3rd was) and, again lost one as a baby.

Clearly being Godparent to my DC is bad luck Confused

notanothertakeaway · 21/08/2021 00:09

Interesting thread

On another recent thread, the priest had suggested 3 godparents max, and lots of people suggested that was unreasonable to limit numbers

Here, the OP suggests 6-8, and lots of people suggest should be 3 max

UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2021 00:07

As far as I'm aware it's usually 2 men and 1 woman for a boy and 2 women and 1 man for a girl. I think 8 is over kill, personally. A DC doesn't need 8 adults to look after their spiritual well-being. Are they all equally religious? All as likely to put in the effort with your DC? The siblings will hopefully have a good relationship with your DC anyway and will be able to pass on their faith anyway. So if you just stick to the other 4 it is a bit nearer normal.

WaterIsBest · 21/08/2021 00:05

Thats crazy!
3 MAX !

Proudboomer · 21/08/2021 00:01

I have two godparents
My children have two godparents.

Surely if you are christening your child you have sat through many christenings so you know having 8 would be really unusual? What has your priest/vicar said about it?

DappledThings · 21/08/2021 00:01

3 is traditional: 2 godmothers and one godfather for a girl and vice versa for a boy.
Agreed. Not in every Christian tradition but certainly was the norm in my middle to high Anglican upbringing.

Our DC only have 2 each but it was hard to find people who we were close enough to to want to ask but also wanted to perform a religious role.

4 would be pushing it a bit. 6-8 is ridiculous.

Hathertonhariden · 21/08/2021 00:00

@GreyhoundG1rl

have godparents of different ages, with different skills and experiences You know it's not the primary function of a Godparent to impart skills and benefit of experiences, right?
Some people do choose godparents who will be in a position to open doors for their dc or be financially generous - as Kimdeals noticed at the christening she wrote about.
LemonRoses · 20/08/2021 23:56

Twin of same sex and one of opposite sex is the traditional norm.

saraclara · 20/08/2021 23:54

...and yep, GPs aren't family members. Family are assumed to have influence and show care anyway. Having GPs is about pinning down friends to be involved. So that might be an easy way to filter your eight possibles.

Hathertonhariden · 20/08/2021 23:53

Might be safety in numbers. I have 3 godparents, 2 friends of my parents and an aunt. The 2 friends are in touch with my parents but stopped sending birthday cards to me after my first birthday and I have no relationship with them. The aunt only sent a card/gift on my 18th birthday and we are not close.

It's not about getting a card, but it would at least indicate some level of interest even if they don't fulfill the role they pledged to carry out. This doesn't seem that uncommon an experience amongst my friends.

saraclara · 20/08/2021 23:52

I understood three to be the norm. Two of the same sex as baby, one of the opposite.

That's what it was when I was kid and went to church in the 60s anyway.

GreyhoundG1rl · 20/08/2021 23:51

have godparents of different ages, with different skills and experiences
You know it's not the primary function of a Godparent to impart skills and benefit of experiences, right?

SE13Mummy · 20/08/2021 23:51

DC1 has three (all practising Christians and regular church goers), DC2 had five (also all practising Christians and regular church goers) but one died a few years ago. None of them are family members and they all have their own ways of doing their Godparenting. DC2 ended up with five because we'd been told it was unlikely we'd be able to have DC2. Two of the Godparents were massively supportive during that journey and the CE church we attend had no issue whatsoever with the number of Godparents we'd chosen.

SageRosemary · 20/08/2021 23:50

Each of my DC has ONE godmother and ONE godfather. Our church requires godparents to have been both baptised and confirmed themselves. Like the ad says, "one is plenty".

Eight is -verging on ridiculous- too many.

BikeRunSki · 20/08/2021 23:49

@user1471457751

I've never seen more than 4. An easy way to cut it down would be to not include any relatives as godparents as they have an important role in your DC's life already
This, except I’ve never seen more than 3. Traditionally I believe 2 of the same sex as the chips, one of opposite sex.
Seasidemumma77 · 20/08/2021 23:48

I have 3 godparents. My dc have 4 each, 2 of my godparents are godparents to all of my dc. My goddaughter has 6 godparents. My dc and my goddaughter, have godparents of different ages, with different skills and experiences. Myself, my dc, and my goddaughter, all benefit from ongoing relationships with the godparents.

2pinkginsplease · 20/08/2021 23:47

I’d go for 2 or 3 any more is just ridiculous.

We didn’t choose our siblings as they already play an important part in our children’s lives as they are aunts and uncles already.

We had 2 godparents, my own aunt and uncle , none of my dh’s family are religious so couldn’t choose any of them and I wanted to choose people who were Christians. People who when they took the vows actually meant it,