Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children can go a couple of hours without eating

363 replies

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/08/2021 19:26

Not sure if this is just the people I hang out with but every park play date I go on at the moment (there’s quite a few- child is 4), the other parent brings with them copious amounts of snacks.
I’m in no way a food nazi, my child has a morning snack, the odd ice cream when out on hot days, a biscuit pudding after her dinner - I always carry water and an apple- but even I think she can manage 2 hrs in a park without me having to produce a family size bag of crisps, popcorn, a fruit shoot, a haribo.
I’m really fed up of it, firstly because I’m the grinch who says “no” when my daughter asks if she can stuff her face 2hrs before dinner and secondly, because then (unsurprisingly) the other kid sits there eating rather than playing.
If you take a picnic amount of food to a 2pm play date- pls why?

OP posts:
Glitteryone · 21/08/2021 13:05

OP I agree. This drives me mad!!!!

Seahawk80 · 21/08/2021 12:57

I totally see your point OP, my son is skinny and does not stop. I normally take something for him (or a packed lunch if we might stay longer) but only if he asks and only something small. My friend always has mountains of snacks and then my son gets upset that he doesn't have a bag of haribo or whatever. The same friend constantly moans that her child doesn't eat properly and is baffled when he won't eat dinner after having 3/4 snacks 30 mins before!

shrodingersbiscuit · 21/08/2021 12:46

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ.

ichundich · 21/08/2021 12:38

@shrodingersbiscuit

Oh there’s an awful lot of nutribollocks on this thread.

The insulin spike model of ob*sity has been disproven. High carb diets are actually linked with improved insulin sensitivity.

Homeostasis is a thing. You don’t oscillate wildly between low and high blood sugars or insulin levels - you’d die. Sugar doesn’t cause diabetes (1 or 2) and nor does body fat. Some fat distributions (visceral) are linked with it, but it’s multifactorial (type 2 - type 1 is pretty much genetic). Some fat distributions are actually protective, mainly subcut hip and thigh fat.

Hanger definitely is a thing! Your brain runs on pretty much pure glucose. If you aren’t giving it enough glucose it can’t work properly. That can manifest in lots of different ways - fainting, irritability, difficulty concentrating, tiredness etc.

A kid looking chubby doesn’t mean they are unhealthy. Fat is an endocrine organ, not an inert lump. Subcutaneous fat isn’t bad - It produces and stores a lot of things including growth hormones so it makes sense that children, who are growing, build up some fat sometimes and then use it (and it’s stored growth hormones) to y’know, grow.

One third of normal weight adults have a level of visceral fat that classes them as metabolically unhealthy - and at risk of heart disease, type 2 diabetes and cancer. Bear that in mind the next time you’re berating someone with obvious fat store for ‘stuffing’ ‘guzzling’ ‘quaffing’ or ‘shoving’ the food you wouldn’t think twice about a slim person eating.

Oh, and BMI is a load of shite. Here endeth my sermon.

There is an awful lot of bollocks in this post.
SlipperyDippery · 21/08/2021 12:36

@MolyHolyGuacamole

Because my child has type 1 diabetes and running around playing can cause blood sugars to drop quite dramatically.

Oh god there's always one. Obviously if you have health issues that need to be regulated with food, this isn't about you

In fairness, the OP specifically asked for reasons why people take snacks to play dates:

“If you take a picnic amount of food to a 2pm play date- pls why?“

So that poster is perfectly entitled to answer the question.

Notimeforaname · 21/08/2021 12:28

Oh I know somebody who does this to their children.Its mad.

I'd never heard of a 'second breakfast' before this family.

These kids have 2 or 3 breakfasts, then late morning snack.

Then for lunch they are followed around and tormented to eat, for a couple of hours or however long it takes them to finish.

Then afternoon snack.

Then dinner is horrendous, constantly on them to ''eat..eat it, finish it'' can go on for hours too.

Then dessert.

Drink and snack before bed.

These children are constantly eating or having food shoved at them.

All the food is healthy homemade..weighed out to the gram, no sweets or junk allowed.

But the WHOLE day is about fighting with the children to eat eat eat. Confused

The mother goes on about how food is such a chore and a battle and why are they like this Shock

shrodingersbiscuit · 21/08/2021 12:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ.

Comedycook · 21/08/2021 11:40

@MolyHolyGuacamole

Because my child has type 1 diabetes and running around playing can cause blood sugars to drop quite dramatically.

Oh god there's always one. Obviously if you have health issues that need to be regulated with food, this isn't about you

I know right! It's pretty obvious that the op isn't talking about those with medical issues and clearly no one thinks that they're unreasonable if a child has diabetes or any other medical condition.
MolyHolyGuacamole · 21/08/2021 11:37

Because my child has type 1 diabetes and running around playing can cause blood sugars to drop quite dramatically.

Oh god there's always one. Obviously if you have health issues that need to be regulated with food, this isn't about you

MolyHolyGuacamole · 21/08/2021 11:34

@PurpleVerbena

Cue fat kids eating snacks on demand. It is NOT necessary. If a child has 3 meals a day, there is absolutely NO need for 'snacks'.
Confused
MolyHolyGuacamole · 21/08/2021 11:31

I'm with you OP. I'm a nanny to toddlers and when I take a snack out, it's a rice cake or something similar. But there's a nanny we meet with that does a full on banquet, 3 different snack options plus fruit, sometimes has 'leftover breakfast' as well. I have to tell her no thank you because she just offers to mine and I want them to eat their lunch! I sometimes feel it's a competition to have the best snacks with some people, but I have no issue saying no thank you and telling the children that it's lunch time soon.

NatashaRf · 21/08/2021 11:10

Although to be fair popcorn isn't a terrible snack (unless it's sugar coated)

But we have friends who a park visit will be penguin bars, crisps, haribo and an ice cream if they van is there.

NatashaRf · 21/08/2021 11:09

@shouldistop

No exactly. I was making a similar point to you.

Your snacks aren't the popcorn/sweets that the OP was talking about.

I meant that if you start your day with sugar/refined carbs then you are going to crash and be hungry quickly and life becomes a cycle of needing sugar to keep energy up. Which is why 'everyone' is getting fatter and has less energy.

I was that person for most of my life. So I totally get it. You're genuinely hungrier and more tired so eat more to compensate. It's a vicious circle. So the kids aren't lying that the need the snacks due to the average western diet being so poor these days.

shouldistop · 21/08/2021 10:57

@NatashaRf my child has one or two snacks a day. He doesn't have sugary cereal or Nutella or white bread. His snacks are either fruit or tomatoes and crackers etc.
He's starting to often not need his morning snack now at the weekends now that he's 5 so I assume it's because he's naturally able to have a bigger breakfast now he's bigger himself.
Everyone's different and it's not either 3 strict meals a day with nothing in between or feed your child tonnes of crap.

Mamabear12 · 21/08/2021 10:50

I bring snacks bc when my kids get hungry they turn into monsters. And they always get hungry for snacks at 2/3pm. So yes; I would have to give them a snack when out. But not the junk you describe. Not all kids need this. My kids take after me with fast metabolisms and they really just get hungry. They are slim and active. My friend, who has a slow metabolism (she is open about it and struggle w her weight) has kids who never seem hungry! So everyone is different, while one child can easily go hours w out foods, others need something.

NatashaRf · 21/08/2021 10:37

I totally agree with you.

The entire country snacks too much. It's why so many children and adults are overweight/obese.

Humans don't need to be having food every hour they're awake.

If kids (or adults) are "hangry" unless they have a snack that's full of sugar/carbs then it's only proving that their meals aren't adequate nutritionally.

Of course kids get hungry/irritable if they're starting their day with sugary cereal or Nutella on white bread etc.

We've really lost our way with nutrition and food.

3WildOnes · 21/08/2021 10:05

@Ritasueandbobtoo9 I am one who had admitted that I bring snacks or a picnic to a park play date. Partly because it is a way of getting my kids to come and have a 5 minute sit down if they are getting over excited and partly because I associate socialising with eating.
My children aren’t stuffed with crap. If they aren’t hungry then they won’t eat. They eat some unhealthy foods but mostly eat a healthy balanced diet. They are all slim. I don’t think you can blame obesity on snacking. I live in the lowest area for childhood obesity (or at least one of) in the country, almost all children will have a snack at school and after school.

ichundich · 21/08/2021 08:58

There is nothing wrong IMO with eating a piece of fruit of vegetable between meals, maybe even a slice of toast / plain rice cake / boiled egg, etc. But Haribos and crisps to keep going between meals?! And whilst it might seem fine for kids to do it (because they're still very active), it sets them up for bad habits and will lead to weight gain later on in life.

Theoldcuriosityshop · 21/08/2021 08:47

God knows how people would have managed during the war when food was rationed. I remember rationing in the early 50s still. There was barely enough to eat at meal times let alone snacks. We weren't all keeling over through lack of food.

NerrSnerr · 21/08/2021 08:43

@wombatspoopcubes

I don't care what other people feed their kids and when. I do wonder sometimes why so many adults can't go for a half hour walk without bringing a bottle of water. Why don't they drink a glass before they leave?
Because they prefer to drink while they walk? How is when someone drinks water an issue at all?
Terhou · 21/08/2021 08:40

In my experience regular snacks equals a happy time. Ever had a hangry toddler on your hands? Urgh. If theu are running around at a park or soft play then they tend to work up an appetite very quickly but be too distracted to realise until the hamger hits.

But the answer to that is not bags of sweets, crisps and popcorn. In my experience, the answer is making sure they've had a good breakfast/lunch before going out, and maybe taking a bit of fruit with you.

HintofVintagePink · 21/08/2021 08:32

I think some parents are just blind to their children being overweight. I have one who is always joking about her child being ‘a giant’ and ‘solid’. Well yes, because she is being fed high calorie snacks every 2 hours or so, plus meals. Each play date involves lots of food. It isn’t necessary to have a bag of crisps, breadsticks and a packet of sweets to run around the park!
Also agree with the PP about eating in the street. No one is that close to starvation they have to walk about eating.

DysmalRadius · 21/08/2021 08:22

Parents have a responsibility to raise their children with healthy eating habits

But given that its largely the generation that didn't snack that are obese now as adults, what are those habits?

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 21/08/2021 08:19

@Oblomov21

Isn't this interesting. People being offended that parents feed their kids snacks. Blimey.
It’s not about this, it’s about parents unhealthy and distorted thought processes around food which means that children are stuffed with crap when they don’t need it.
wombatspoopcubes · 21/08/2021 08:18

I don't care what other people feed their kids and when. I do wonder sometimes why so many adults can't go for a half hour walk without bringing a bottle of water. Why don't they drink a glass before they leave?