Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children can go a couple of hours without eating

363 replies

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/08/2021 19:26

Not sure if this is just the people I hang out with but every park play date I go on at the moment (there’s quite a few- child is 4), the other parent brings with them copious amounts of snacks.
I’m in no way a food nazi, my child has a morning snack, the odd ice cream when out on hot days, a biscuit pudding after her dinner - I always carry water and an apple- but even I think she can manage 2 hrs in a park without me having to produce a family size bag of crisps, popcorn, a fruit shoot, a haribo.
I’m really fed up of it, firstly because I’m the grinch who says “no” when my daughter asks if she can stuff her face 2hrs before dinner and secondly, because then (unsurprisingly) the other kid sits there eating rather than playing.
If you take a picnic amount of food to a 2pm play date- pls why?

OP posts:
Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 20/08/2021 20:41

I have a friend who does this. If we go for lunch or breakfast with the kids she gives them at least 2 snacks at the table while they wait for their food. No surprise they are overweight. Think it's to keep them quiet to be honest. I also know people who give constant snacks between meals. I look after kids and some kids are sent with doue the food I would eat during the day, and their parent do expect them to eat it all.

54321nought · 20/08/2021 20:39

[quote shouldistop]@54321nought well if you're talking in evolutionary terms then small children would still be breastfeeding as the norm and certainly wouldn't be fasting. [/quote]
not at primary school age, before than, yes

Starjammer · 20/08/2021 20:39

@54321nought

Grazing is not a bad habit or something to be avoided. Some people are just grazers - that's how they prefer to eat. It's not inherently better or worse than the social construct of breakfast, lunch and dinner.

Its a whole lot worse - every single snack causes an insulin spike, specific meal times are far healthier.

And yes, intermittent fasting would be more natural in evolutionary terms, much bigger meals, and far fewer of them

I don't agree about the grazing. I think for young children, you let them eat in whatever way suits them best rather than trying to force them to eat at arbitrarily specific times and wondering why they don't want to eat their dinner or lunch or sitting pleading with them to finish the peas.

People get so worked up about food and then you get anxious children who are being pressured to eat food in ways and to schedules that don't suit them. If three meals a day works well for you, great. If it doesn't and something else does, great. It balances out.

54321nought · 20/08/2021 20:38

I agree with you op, I have been out with many family friends over this summer holiday, and in the last 10 years or so it seems to have become the norm to offer children regular snacks.

I can't imagine why, its a lose-lose situation for everyone - cost, health, inconvenience of carrying them around, but everyone appears to be doing it now

I would say all of the children I have been out with are chubby, but because they ALL are, they all also look completely average

shouldistop · 20/08/2021 20:38

@54321nought well if you're talking in evolutionary terms then small children would still be breastfeeding as the norm and certainly wouldn't be fasting.

Comedycook · 20/08/2021 20:38

@Fernando072020

I always carry water and fruit with me incase my 13 month old gets hungry 😆😆 Not a massive feast though.
Exactly what the op says she takes
Comedycook · 20/08/2021 20:37

@constellationstation
What snacks do you take? Family sized bags of crisps, popcorn and sweets? I think the op isnt objecting to snacks per say but the amount and type.

Fernando072020 · 20/08/2021 20:37

I always carry water and fruit with me incase my 13 month old gets hungry 😆😆
Not a massive feast though.

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/08/2021 20:36

[quote shouldistop]@54321nought most small children would be hungry after 4 hours. That's perfectly normal. [/quote]
This. He's FIVE for goodness sake. 4 hourly food is completely bog standard.

54321nought · 20/08/2021 20:35

Grazing is not a bad habit or something to be avoided. Some people are just grazers - that's how they prefer to eat. It's not inherently better or worse than the social construct of breakfast, lunch and dinner.

Its a whole lot worse - every single snack causes an insulin spike, specific meal times are far healthier.

And yes, intermittent fasting would be more natural in evolutionary terms, much bigger meals, and far fewer of them

Comedycook · 20/08/2021 20:35

Judging other parents because they don’t agree with your snack ban

The op never said she had a ban on snacks Confused

pleurotus · 20/08/2021 20:35

YANBU

If they were healthy snacks fine but haribos and crisps - no

shouldistop · 20/08/2021 20:34

@54321nought most small children would be hungry after 4 hours. That's perfectly normal.

Constellationstation · 20/08/2021 20:34

I take snacks to the park for my son and when I pick him up from school. Their stomachs are smaller and need filling more regularly than adults, it’s also pretty grim dealing with a small hangry child.

Feeling annoyed about other parents taking snacks, because of having to sit there awkwardly or deal with your own whiny children is pretty pathetic. If you’re so intent on being snack-free then just be confident in your own convictions. Judging other parents because they don’t agree with your snack ban smacks of insecurity to me.

Gumboots29 · 20/08/2021 20:34

I’ve always done three meals with two small snacks as that’s what the HV told me when they were small! So a snack at 10ish and 230ish and we might have that in the park if we are out as it’s nicer (I’ll have a coffee and a biscuit/fruit too). So I can easily see why people take a snack to the park.

I do have friends that come loaded with crackers, biscuits, cakes, fruit etc and their kids will graze all morning/afternoon which works for them but would totally spoil my kids lunch.

54321nought · 20/08/2021 20:33

My 5 year old has lunch at 11:30 at school and i collect him 4 hours later at 3:30 so yes, I bring him food...!!!!!

why?

thats only 4 hours!

just why?

DaisyWaldron · 20/08/2021 20:32

I remember when DD was in her final two years of primary school. She was getting the same size food portions as a 5 year old, while having a massive growth spurt. She came out of school utterly starving every day, and did actually need food just in order to walk home without getting all hangry, let alone cycling straight from school to music lessons and sports clubs. I remember in her final year of primary school, when I was measuring her for school uniform, her waist measurement was age 9 and her height was age 13, so she really wasn't fat at all, just desperately trying to eat enough to fuel her rapidly-growing body.

Children aren't adults, and they don't have the nutritional needs as adults. Both of mine have had phases of rapid growth when they clearly needed far more calories than I do, despite being smaller.

Macaroni46 · 20/08/2021 20:32

I'm with you OP. Most of the time snacking is excessive and so unnecessary. What's wrong with children feeling a bit hungry? How are they ever meant to learn hunger cues if they're fed a constant stream of 'healthy' snacks?
One infant school I worked at, the head swapped the mid morning biscuit snack that was provided with fruit / veg. A few parents moaned but she stuck to her guns. Incidentally none of the kids minded.
After a week or so, the children were eating so much better at lunchtime (which led to better moods, behaviour and learning in the afternoons) and the amount of food waste at lunch was drastically reduced.
Unless there is a medical reason, it really will not do a child (or adult) any harm to feel a bit peckish!

Starjammer · 20/08/2021 20:31

Grazing is not a bad habit or something to be avoided. Some people are just grazers - that's how they prefer to eat. It's not inherently better or worse than the social construct of breakfast, lunch and dinner. Those are modern concepts (in evolutionary terms). Humanity previously ate to a much more intermittent fasting type schedule, where you might eat lots and then nothing for a while, and then eat more again, and it balances out. It's incredibly common in toddlers to do this - eat a lot when there's something they really like, and then pick and not have much for a while. My own DD often eats a lot in the morning - she might have three breakfasts some days! But then doesn't want anything else till dinner time.

I think people would do a lot better to stop fretting and worrying about what other people are doing and obsessing over children's food habits, as that's far more likely to give them issues with food v taking a snack to the park.

Comedycook · 20/08/2021 20:30

[quote DemBonesDemBones]@OnlyFoolsnMothers I just don't understand why you'd even think about that being a scenario. To make a point?! It's definitely not us snack providers whose children are going to have issues with food, I assure you. [/quote]
The op said she takes a piece of fruit and doesn't object to an ice cream...but family bags of crisps and big bags of Haribo are a bit much!

checkingforballoons · 20/08/2021 20:30

I’ve never encountered parents bringing family sized bags of crisps and sweets and entire picnics for their children to snack on between meals.
DS is 7 now but when he was smaller and we were out and about I’d usually have things like breadsticks, raisins, rice cakes etc that he could snack on whenever he liked. Pretty much every parent I know did the same.

Comedycook · 20/08/2021 20:28

@Tuliprain. I'm sorry to hear that and sadly not surprised. I get the feeling though that the op isn't judging random strangers though..It's people she knows and if their dc had diabetes I'm sure she'd know that. I think it's more the impact it has on her day out

ElvenDreamer · 20/08/2021 20:28

All children are different I guess. I have 3 kids, all are lean and active, and all 3 have 3 good healthy varied meals (decent size too!) and 2 snacks a day. Those snacks tend to be somewhere between 10 and 12, and between 2 and 3, so yes, if we are out at those times I take the snack! For context though, it's fruit or similar, they eat it and then carry on playing. If they don't eat they get hangry!

mrsm43s · 20/08/2021 20:28

I never gave my children snacks, at home or out. Not through any kind of superior parenting, but simply because I wasn't brought up being given snacks, and as a adult I don't snack, and it simply didn't occur to me that they needed snacks! Snacks simply aren't on my radar at all. Or at least weren't until I had teenagers. Now the boy snacks (cheese toasties mainly, but also egg/beans on toast, plus fruit and yoghurt) - the girl still sticks to 3 healthy meals.

Probably as a consequence of not having snacks, they ate well at meal times, and are not remotely fussy eaters. They were hungry for their meals and ate them. I have noticed a very big correlation between fussy eaters and constant snackers - but of course its difficult to see which came first. I guess if my children had picked at their meals, then I might try to get snacks in them. Obviously I would never refuse food if they said they were hungry, but I can't say that was something that happened often, probably not til DSs teenage growth spurt.

burritofan · 20/08/2021 20:27

I thought NHS advice was kids under 5 basically have tiny tummies and high nutrient needs, so space out meals and snacks? Probably all depends on age of the child; I wouldn’t take 2.5yo DD far without a snack and I generally underestimate how much she can stuff down her hollow legs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread