Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children can go a couple of hours without eating

363 replies

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/08/2021 19:26

Not sure if this is just the people I hang out with but every park play date I go on at the moment (there’s quite a few- child is 4), the other parent brings with them copious amounts of snacks.
I’m in no way a food nazi, my child has a morning snack, the odd ice cream when out on hot days, a biscuit pudding after her dinner - I always carry water and an apple- but even I think she can manage 2 hrs in a park without me having to produce a family size bag of crisps, popcorn, a fruit shoot, a haribo.
I’m really fed up of it, firstly because I’m the grinch who says “no” when my daughter asks if she can stuff her face 2hrs before dinner and secondly, because then (unsurprisingly) the other kid sits there eating rather than playing.
If you take a picnic amount of food to a 2pm play date- pls why?

OP posts:
chaosmaker · 20/08/2021 21:03

@PointeShoesandTutus

I think you have to be mindful of peoples’ individual circumstances.

Saying the worst case scenario is a fainting child in a flippant way isn’t nice. My child has fainted. Multiple times. We’ve had many hospitals admissions and tests. Until you’ve ever seen your toddler pass out, I don’t think you can really comment.

We take snacks. Not sweets or crisps and pop as routine snacks due to DDs medical needs, although we do always have a flapjack or sugary snack in the bag for an emergency, but we’d always have cheese, fruit, water, yoghurt or similar. If you don’t want to give your child snacks that’s cool, but don’t judge me and mine.

Don't think anyone mentioned medical needs. That is a different thing altogether.
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/08/2021 21:03

@PointeShoesandTutus

I think you have to be mindful of peoples’ individual circumstances.

Saying the worst case scenario is a fainting child in a flippant way isn’t nice. My child has fainted. Multiple times. We’ve had many hospitals admissions and tests. Until you’ve ever seen your toddler pass out, I don’t think you can really comment.

We take snacks. Not sweets or crisps and pop as routine snacks due to DDs medical needs, although we do always have a flapjack or sugary snack in the bag for an emergency, but we’d always have cheese, fruit, water, yoghurt or similar. If you don’t want to give your child snacks that’s cool, but don’t judge me and mine.

Very sorry for what you’ve been through, but you appreciate you are most likely in the minority. And no I’ve never seen my child faint, have multiple seizures yes but never faint.
OP posts:
c24680 · 20/08/2021 21:03

Only thing I bring to the park is a drink and an apple, my daughter is 3, she doesn't really snack and if she does it's just fruit. It does mean she eats her lunch and dinner with no bother, I do get annoyed when we're out with kids that just graze all day because like you said your child can't help but ask for food!

AliasGrape · 20/08/2021 21:02

The mumsnet anti-snack, 'I'm a better parent because I make my child wait for dinner' thing always really.confuses me.

The NHS and the various child.nutritionists I follow recommend snacks for.children 1-5 at least (and I've not seen anything to suggest that they dont advise them over 5 but then mine is still very little so haven't really looked).

If your child eats well and a good variety at mealtimes then great, perhaps they're less important. But many children eat smaller meals and need snacks between to keep them going, plus snacks can be a good way to increase variety and add different nutrients to their diet. Which does mean they need to be healthy in the first place of course, not the crisps and haribo mentioned in the OP.

PointeShoesandTutus · 20/08/2021 21:01

I think you have to be mindful of peoples’ individual circumstances.

Saying the worst case scenario is a fainting child in a flippant way isn’t nice. My child has fainted. Multiple times. We’ve had many hospitals admissions and tests. Until you’ve ever seen your toddler pass out, I don’t think you can really comment.

We take snacks. Not sweets or crisps and pop as routine snacks due to DDs medical needs, although we do always have a flapjack or sugary snack in the bag for an emergency, but we’d always have cheese, fruit, water, yoghurt or similar. If you don’t want to give your child snacks that’s cool, but don’t judge me and mine.

ChrissyPlummer · 20/08/2021 21:00

It definitely wasn’t the norm when I was growing up in the ‘80s. We always had to wait for mealtimes so we didn’t ‘spoil’ our lunch/tea. That was totally normal among my peers. That said, we usually had a break time biscuit at school in the morning.

When we were older and at high school, we did used to have toast and cereal on getting home.

chaosmaker · 20/08/2021 21:00

All the continual eating is why there's an obesity epidemic. Only storing up problems around food for later.

gemloving · 20/08/2021 20:59

We have breakfast, and leave straight after & sometimes stay for 2-3h but I premake the snack the night before. It's usually cucumber, carrots or tomato.

I always keep a small chocolate as I struggle with a meltdown in public and bribery works lol

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/08/2021 20:57

Aside from the general health side to this debate, I also want my child to know she can enjoy an activity for the activity- not because it comes with a side of snacks.
You can enjoy the park for the park
You can go to a trampoline park without a litre size slush puppy

OP posts:
Greenrubber · 20/08/2021 20:56

I'm with you OP I usually have an apple in my bag of she is hungry
I hate the amount of sweets that get dished out at the park

shouldistop · 20/08/2021 20:52

@54321nought experts usually suggest that natural term weaning would be around age 7 actually.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/08/2021 20:52

@SunbathingDragon

Why do you hang out with these people since you clearly don’t like them or agree with their way of parenting?

I really can’t see how it impacts you if other children are fed snacks or not.

I can disagree with someone’s parenting and like them as a person. It does affect me for the two reasons mentioned, it puts me under pressure from DC who thinks I’m being mean and secondly we have to wait whilst her friend shoves down Doritos before resuming play. Oh and something doesn’t need to directly affect you to have an opinion
OP posts:
LadyPoison · 20/08/2021 20:52

Neither my husband nor I were brought up in the snack culture - in fact my school forbade eating outside the school whilst in school uniform (ordinary state school too).

My own children weren't routinely fed snacks either and neither of them ever fainted from hunger.

SlipperyDippery · 20/08/2021 20:52

Honestly the amount of fucking food police on this thread is so depressing.

It is literally none of your business what other people feed their children.

Starjammer · 20/08/2021 20:51

I'm disputing that it really matters when it comes to toddlers. I think the best way is to provide healthy and nutritious food on a schedule that works for your child and where they want to eat it and enjoy it, whatever that might be. Children are individuals, not a homogeneous group where everyone has the same needs. You just do what suits your child and don't worry about what other people are doing.

TiredButDancing · 20/08/2021 20:49

I thin it's a hangover from when children are younger and often do go from completely fine to STARVING in 10 minutes. I know with DS we found this happened - we were still in routine of snacking but it started to impact his meal times. So we stopped the snacking.

I think the posters saying it's not good, and probably encourages fussy eating are right. I also think it's very difficult if your child is a bit odd with food to say no to snacks if it's the one thing you know they will eat. It does feel a bit chicken and egg really. Having said that, I don't take snacks for DD and she's still a fussy eater. And a bit overweight which I am fairly certain is because her diet isn't correctly balanced rather than because she eats too much. So food is a minefield!

54321nought · 20/08/2021 20:48

@Starjammer

My DD loves peas so no struggles there Grin

I don't think that grazing on healthy food during the day v eating three square meals and two snacks a day makes any tangible difference to the wellbeing of a healthy toddler, no.

But it causes insulin spikes, which will eventually lead to obesity, heart disease, diabetes etc,

That is both "grazing" and the two snacks.

I agree both your options are bad! just feed a child meals!

What are you disputing, that grazing and snacks cause insulin spikes, or that insulin spikes cause horrendous health issues?

(and are the main cause of death in the developed world)

SunbathingDragon · 20/08/2021 20:47

Why do you hang out with these people since you clearly don’t like them or agree with their way of parenting?

I really can’t see how it impacts you if other children are fed snacks or not.

DGFB · 20/08/2021 20:47

I bring food to the school gates, my kids are starving and we eat dinner at 6. I don’t care what you think? Yes I’d also bring snacks to a 2pm play date because they have a snack at 3pm.. in between lunch at 12 and dinner at 6. I think 6 hours without food is too long. Are you saying I’m a bad parent?
All healthy weight kids here

Disfordarkchocolate · 20/08/2021 20:47

Mine came out of infant school really hungry. As long as the they ate a proper meal later I didn't care and I wouldn't judge either.

SpidersAreShitheads · 20/08/2021 20:46

I can't say I've ever thought to judge another parent giving their child a snack.

I also can't say I really care what any other parent thinks about snacks I may or may not give to my child.

Starjammer · 20/08/2021 20:43

My DD loves peas so no struggles there Grin

I don't think that grazing on healthy food during the day v eating three square meals and two snacks a day makes any tangible difference to the wellbeing of a healthy toddler, no.

Pissinthepottyplease · 20/08/2021 20:42

My 5 year old has a snack mid afternoon now, she didn’t used to buy a mixture of having an afternoon snack at school, lots of exercise in the holiday coinciding with a growth spurt and a toddler who needs an afternoon snack means she now has a snack.

54321nought · 20/08/2021 20:41

I don't agree about the grazing. I think for young children, you let them eat in whatever way suits them best rather than trying to force them to eat at arbitrarily specific times and wondering why they don't want to eat their dinner or lunch or sitting pleading with them to finish the peas.

What don't you agree with? That every single snack causes an insulin spike? Or that constant insulin spikes are dangerous and cause long term health issues?

These are biological facts, and you not agreeing with them as no effect what so ever on their validity, however much you struggle to make your child eat peas.

burritofan · 20/08/2021 20:41

not at primary school age, before than, yes
Isn’t primary school age 5, and natural weaning from breastfeeding 6-7, in evolutionary terms?

Swipe left for the next trending thread