Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children can go a couple of hours without eating

363 replies

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/08/2021 19:26

Not sure if this is just the people I hang out with but every park play date I go on at the moment (there’s quite a few- child is 4), the other parent brings with them copious amounts of snacks.
I’m in no way a food nazi, my child has a morning snack, the odd ice cream when out on hot days, a biscuit pudding after her dinner - I always carry water and an apple- but even I think she can manage 2 hrs in a park without me having to produce a family size bag of crisps, popcorn, a fruit shoot, a haribo.
I’m really fed up of it, firstly because I’m the grinch who says “no” when my daughter asks if she can stuff her face 2hrs before dinner and secondly, because then (unsurprisingly) the other kid sits there eating rather than playing.
If you take a picnic amount of food to a 2pm play date- pls why?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SunscreenCentral · 01/09/2021 20:53

I don't think you are BU op. I've also witnessed the constant feeding of children if they looked the smallest bit out of sorts/bored/had a tiff with playmate/interrupted the Mum chat

Colourcones · 01/09/2021 20:09

Its really quite a new thing this constant snacking. As children we had three meals a day and biscuit when we got home from school . We had walked the 2 miles home . That was that. We didn't ask for food because it wasn't provided.
I don't remember an over weight child. Now I see them constantly. But I was a chld of the 60s . (I'm not over weight now if that's relevant)

LetgoOrnot · 01/09/2021 18:29

My DD has a hip and leg problems so her weight is closely monitored, if she's too thin/underweight she's likely to fracture her hip or leg, if she's too fat/overweight she's likely to dislocate her hip or knee so you might see me giving her high calorie/surgary snacks to bring her weight up, I've actually been told by her physio to give her flapjacks, bagels, and full fat milk and milkshakes. Her weight has to be just right or we have weekly appointments to monitor her weight which takes time away from her education.

You don't know other peoples circumstances, if you politely asked me why she has to have such high fat and sugar snacks I'd tell you and DD would probably offer to share too.

GintyMcGinty · 01/09/2021 17:54

Call social services!

OMG imagine a parent feeding a child a snack in a park.

What is the world coming to?

Brokensunflower · 01/09/2021 17:48

I really hate seeing kids graze on junk constantly and It's never an apple or banana with water.

I also really hate seeing toddlers on pushchairs with their little hands stuffed into crisp packets. No need.

Bella43 · 01/09/2021 17:41

My ex was like this with his children and I never understood it. He'd take a packed lunch for them every time we went somewhere, including short visits to people's houses! What this led to was the children expecting to sit and graze wherever we went. I found it awkward sitting in people's houses watching them eat yoghurt and peeling boiled eggs but there we are. He thought it was normal to carry a rucksack filled with food everywhere 😕

piscis · 01/09/2021 08:21

*Its a whole lot worse - every single snack causes an insulin spike, specific meal times are far healthier.

And yes, intermittent fasting would be more natural in evolutionary terms, much bigger meals, and far fewer of them*

Exactly this.
Constant insuline release from the body causes insuline resistance, which in the long term leads to weight gain and obesity.
And after a fasting period naturally you'll eat a bigger meal after.

shrodingersbiscuit · 31/08/2021 09:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ.

ItsSunnyOutside · 31/08/2021 08:05

My dc is nearly 2 and more of grazer, which I think is 'normal' for a toddler, so we always have a lunchbox of snacks when we are out. Grapes/tomatoes/strawberries/cheese and cucumber, that kind of thing.

All children are different, have different appetites. I'm sure most kids would be fine not eating for a couple of hours, but it really isn't something I could get bothered about! None of my business.

VestaTilley · 31/08/2021 06:58

My 2 y/o DS eats well at meal times, but if he’s not at nursery we generally give him a pain au chocolat or yoghurt at morning snack time, then a pear or banana or satsuma at about 3pm. We all eat dinner together at 5.15pm or so.

I don’t think children need crisps or sweets except as treats, and grazing constantly ruins meals, but I definitely think ensuring regular meals and healthy snacks is very important to stop toddler meltdowns!

LobsterNapkin · 31/08/2021 03:31

It's difficult to speak to specific situations but in general I think a lot of parents have been given to believe that kids need food more often than they really do. And that in general, if a kid asks for food, they really need it. For a while grazing was pushed as a great way to eat, even for adults. Mostly though, it isn't.

chaosmaker · 31/08/2021 00:36

@MooBoom

I take a snack to the school gate sometimes like biscuits, because I know my DC doesn’t really eat well in school compared to home. She’s a slow eater and doesn’t eat the kind of portion at school that she’d have at home.

Also, I carry snacks with me if we’re going to the park or soft play etc. They don’t always get eaten but at least the option is there if DC gets peckish. Running around really encourages an appetite. I laughed a little at the family size popcorn and haribo - sounds like me 🤣

This is probably a problem of having MAT's where out of necessity lunchtimes are much shorter. There is a lot to be said for more local and smaller school sizes. Being able to eat your whole meal without rushing being just one of those things.
chaosmaker · 31/08/2021 00:34

@shrodingersbiscuit that may all be published in scientific journals but I like to see who is behind the science and both the diabetes and carb studies have long been superseded by recent studies. As usual with science you can pick whatever narrative you wish you push!

MooBoom · 30/08/2021 23:05

I take a snack to the school gate sometimes like biscuits, because I know my DC doesn’t really eat well in school compared to home. She’s a slow eater and doesn’t eat the kind of portion at school that she’d have at home.

Also, I carry snacks with me if we’re going to the park or soft play etc. They don’t always get eaten but at least the option is there if DC gets peckish. Running around really encourages an appetite. I laughed a little at the family size popcorn and haribo - sounds like me 🤣

shrodingersbiscuit · 30/08/2021 22:38

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ.

BananaMilkshakeWithCream · 29/08/2021 12:00

I just think it makes it seem more like a day out if you take a picnic. Plus, when DS was younger, I was a skint student. You could guarantee the one time I forgot food would be the time he’d be really hungry or we’d be caught out and be out much longer than planned. Better to be prepared than spend money I couldn’t afford 🤷‍♀️

kindlyensure · 29/08/2021 11:53

OP, you want to read a book called 'French Children Don't Throw Food' by Pamela Druckerman. She talks about exactly this. Is a v amusing read.

chaosmaker · 29/08/2021 11:50

@shrodingersbiscuit

Oh there’s an awful lot of nutribollocks on this thread.

The insulin spike model of ob*sity has been disproven. High carb diets are actually linked with improved insulin sensitivity.

Homeostasis is a thing. You don’t oscillate wildly between low and high blood sugars or insulin levels - you’d die. Sugar doesn’t cause diabetes (1 or 2) and nor does body fat. Some fat distributions (visceral) are linked with it, but it’s multifactorial (type 2 - type 1 is pretty much genetic). Some fat distributions are actually protective, mainly subcut hip and thigh fat.

Hanger definitely is a thing! Your brain runs on pretty much pure glucose. If you aren’t giving it enough glucose it can’t work properly. That can manifest in lots of different ways - fainting, irritability, difficulty concentrating, tiredness etc.

A kid looking chubby doesn’t mean they are unhealthy. Fat is an endocrine organ, not an inert lump. Subcutaneous fat isn’t bad - It produces and stores a lot of things including growth hormones so it makes sense that children, who are growing, build up some fat sometimes and then use it (and it’s stored growth hormones) to y’know, grow.

One third of normal weight adults have a level of visceral fat that classes them as metabolically unhealthy - and at risk of heart disease, type 2 diabetes and cancer. Bear that in mind the next time you’re berating someone with obvious fat store for ‘stuffing’ ‘guzzling’ ‘quaffing’ or ‘shoving’ the food you wouldn’t think twice about a slim person eating.

Oh, and BMI is a load of shite. Here endeth my sermon.

Sounds like bad science to me. Except for BMI being completely abitrary, it is.
chaosmaker · 29/08/2021 11:07

@flatdisco embarrassing in what sense of the word? I'm not embarrassed at all. Adverts tell people they must constantly eat. I thought that adverts aimed at children and the magic of pester power was meant to be taken off air in their viewing hours (whatever they now are). The OP is talking about the tons of rubbish that children are given to eat - not about giving them actual food to eat. Obviously different ages will eat/sleep etc differently when thay are very little.

Kanaloa · 22/08/2021 03:54

It isn’t other parents jobs to refuse their child fizzy drinks etc because you don’t allow your child them though. If you have a reason to refuse your child something then do so. The classic ‘I’m not Johnny’s mum, I’m your mum.’ Just because other children are allowed something doesn’t mean your child is allowed it, and just because your child isn’t allowed it doesn’t mean other children shouldn’t be.

UndertheCedartree · 22/08/2021 01:18

@DroopyClematis

At the KS1 school , that I worked in, children were offered free fruit both in the morning and afternoon. Most of the fruit had to be thrown away as the children wouldn't touch pears, carrots, sugar snap peas, tomatoes etc.. parents sent separate snacks... popcorn, cheesy biscuits, those stupid processed winders, even hummus with wraps. Some children came in with those compartment lunchboxes with hummus, breadsticks, grapes, baby bels, cheese strings , pepperamis etc...

Come lunchtime, these children ate nothing as they were full up from their 'snacks.'

Parents would complain about their children eating nothing at lunchtime.

School policy was a piece of fruit at break time.
Parents just took no notice and felt that their child must have every snack they'd want, irrespective of the fact that lunch was 45 minutes after playtime.

So so much school dinners went in the bin. So many children didn't eat their packed lunches.

If ever a member of staff said anything, along the lines of ' you won't have room for your dinner, or, ' just eat the grapes' we'd get a rollicking from a precious parent for any comment that we'd made.

I despaired.

The children wouldn't even eat pears and carrots? Wow. At my DD's infant school we all loved the fruit and veg that they were given at playtime as we didn't need to send anything in. Now my DD is in Juniors I find it much harder as sometimes my DD is hungry but most times not. If I send in fruit or veg and it is uneaten it is then spoiled and needs to be thrown away. I've never heard of anyone sending in a full packed lunch as a snack - that's crazy!!
birdglasspen · 21/08/2021 19:20

I agree it happens here, an hour before dinner other parents are stuffing their kids full of crap and offering it to my son....maybe their dinner is much later on..... but why they need crisps, biscuits and sweets to make it through a play at the park I don’t know! I’m with you OP, it’s crazy! And annoying as my son loves to take anything he can get ...not because I keep him in a permanent state of hunger but because he’s 4 and is unlikely to ever say NO to sweets and other rubbish! Also giving someone’s kids winegums just as they jump around on climbing frame is pretty stupid.... fun choking episode after child fell while on frame stuffed full of wine gums.....

Comedycook · 21/08/2021 19:17

I don't let him snack on shit though so he's offered healthy & nutritious snacks

In that case you're not one of the parents the op is talking about

MyFloorIsLava · 21/08/2021 19:10

@dopeyduck

Oh good, I'm one of those parents you hate! Because my toddler is unpredictable when he will or won't eat and I'd rather he ate something than nothing. Granted he's 1 not 4. I don't let him snack on shit though so he's offered healthy & nutritious snacks. Frankly I couldn't care less if he eats his snacks or his dinner, I'm happy that he has something nutritious to eat whenever he'll accept it.

Perhaps they hate you for being such a tight ass parent your child's not allowed a snack. Why do you need to judge them?

One year olds and four year olds are very different beasts though. At 1, they're not long past getting 6 or 8 bottles of milk a day. By 4, really they ought to be eating most of their calories as meals at meal times (side eyes own 4yo...) seeing as school starts at 4, and on a school day they'll get breakfast at home (presumably), fruit and milk mid morning then lunch at lunchtime and that's it.
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 21/08/2021 19:05

Perhaps they hate you for being such a tight ass parent your child's not allowed a snack perhaps you should learn to read threads before commenting!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread