Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to handle FILs comment?

59 replies

stilling0 · 20/08/2021 12:57

Me and fiance have a 7 year old together.

Fiance's father was emotionally abusive towards him when he was growing up, but his dad apologised and we let him have a relationship with DS.

DS goes to MIL and FIL often, yesterday he went there, and when fiancè picked him up. He was quiet. He eventually told us that FIL told him he can't have his nails coloured in with pen as it's for ‘girls’. Fiancè confronted him and he said that DS will turn out to be gay if we let him Hmm

MIL then stuck up for FIL and told fiancè to stop overreacting!

Fiancè has said he doesn't want FIL anywhere near DS, which won't be possible as he'll be there whenever he sees MIL, and fiancè doesn't mind MIL seeing him/ taking him places.

What do we do?

OP posts:
godmum56 · 20/08/2021 14:43

@AmyDudley

Granny/Grandpa are old so they have some funny ideas. They're wrong, but when they were young that's how people thought.

Please don;t say this - don;t keep perpetuating the myth that old people are homophobes/racists or whatever.
I'm in my 60's I have never been homophobic, my parents were born in the 1920's they were never homophobic.

It's not an 'old person' thing, it's an ignorant stupid thing.

By all means tell your children that some people have strange ideas and that those ideas are based on lack of knowledge and general unpleasantness, but don't tell them that this is how old people thin because it isn't true and as well as being ageist, it minimises bigotry by citing age as a excuse when it isn't.

On your point OP - I would tell FIL that he keeps his unpleasant and ridiculous opinions to himself or he won't be seeing your child. I doubt you'll be able to change his views - you can't argue with stupid, but you can tell him you won't tolerate such things being said around your child.

yup, same here. You might just as well say "all teenagers are junkies" "all council estates are urban jungles" and so on. Its factually innaccurate and just plain rude.
Mummyoflittledragon · 20/08/2021 14:35

@TiredButDancing

Comments like this are ridiculous, annoying and pathetic. However, I'm not sure that it needs to be complete No Contact as a result. Frankly, we've had the odd thing from my parents or ILs and we've always found it quite easy to say to the DC, "Granny/Grandpa are old so they have some funny ideas. They're wrong, but when they were young that's how people thought." And feel free for DC to see you telling ILs that their attitudes are ridiculous.
This is the sort of thing I used to do with my mother. “Grandma does think some really strange things. We know that bla bla bla”. And I’d say it in front of her.

This sort of crap gives you an excellent opportunity to reinforce family values. Obviously if it happens all the time then that is a separate issue. I would be monitoring the interaction.

2bazookas · 20/08/2021 14:28

If MIL wants to see her GC (and her son), she can come to your place, without FIL. Simple.

NerrSnerr · 20/08/2021 14:28

It's obviously not about one single comment and homophobia is not acceptable whatever the age.

Do you rely on MIL for childcare?

5zeds · 20/08/2021 14:28

Surely you disagree on all sorts of things? Just tell your son you think he’s wrong.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 20/08/2021 14:24

I'd respect my partner's view and go with what he wanted.

My feeling on it is - Clearly it's not about this single comment. This comment has simply brought back a childhood filled with emotional abuse and he's realised that his father will start on his child and he will not allow his father to treat his child the way he treated him.

WomanStanleyWoman · 20/08/2021 14:21

Haven't read the full thread

Really? It was literally one page long when you posted.

WomanStanleyWoman · 20/08/2021 14:19

@TiredButDancing

Comments like this are ridiculous, annoying and pathetic. However, I'm not sure that it needs to be complete No Contact as a result. Frankly, we've had the odd thing from my parents or ILs and we've always found it quite easy to say to the DC, "Granny/Grandpa are old so they have some funny ideas. They're wrong, but when they were young that's how people thought." And feel free for DC to see you telling ILs that their attitudes are ridiculous.
As a one-off, I probably wouldn’t be ‘going NC’ either - but the OP mentions a long history of emotional abuse. Perhaps this incident is a warning sign for her husband.
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/08/2021 14:17

In it's own, I think this is an over reaction to go no contact. Unfortunately lots and lots of people have rigid gener role expectations, I've heard stuff from nursery, teachers, friends and family that I'm uncomfortable with. Even if your son wanted to buy some kids nail varnish, no doubt it would be under the 'girls' section of a shop. You can't just go no contact with everyone who's views you disagree with. Although I think these views are ultimately harmful, so many people hold them that no matter how much you tell him otherwise and try and protect him from bigoted outdated views, your son will likely come back from pre school or school one day and say 'nail varnish / long hair / dresses are for girls'. The homophobic comment is awful but again I think it might be better to confront it and explain to your son why you think its wrong.

Having said all that, there is obviously a huge backstory here and it must be hard for your husband to have any kind of contact with someone who was abusive, and his mum who enabled the abusive, and if this is the straw that broke the camels back then that's completely understandable and it might be best to stay away from him as he sounds like a nasty person so is unlikely to bring anything positive to your childs life long term. Only you and your husband know if having contact with his dad is worth it to have a relationship with his mum.

WhoopsieFairy · 20/08/2021 14:15

@TiredButDancing

Comments like this are ridiculous, annoying and pathetic. However, I'm not sure that it needs to be complete No Contact as a result. Frankly, we've had the odd thing from my parents or ILs and we've always found it quite easy to say to the DC, "Granny/Grandpa are old so they have some funny ideas. They're wrong, but when they were young that's how people thought." And feel free for DC to see you telling ILs that their attitudes are ridiculous.
Haven't read the full thread but this is such good advice in my opinion. So much better than holding furious grudges. I've been in a similar position and trying to find a way to remain in contact with PIL despite hurtful (and plain stupid and wrong) comments. Thanks for this balanced view TiredButDancing.
ittakes2 · 20/08/2021 14:13

I think all this aggression is not helping. Your finance 'confronted' him. If someone confronts someone the person being confronted tends to either be taken back surprised and on the back foot or they leap to defend themselves. Neither is helpful to an adult conversation.
I would wait until things calm down and then offer to have a mature chat and see if things can be worked out. If not, than you have your answer but all this knee jerk stuff is not good for your DS. He will realise that telling you something triggered a family fall out and now he is not allowed to see his grandparents. Maybe he is OK about this. Maybe he is not. But what you are risking is next time you push him for an answer he won't give it.
The comments about nail colour were ignorent and dated - but I think with this sort of thing education is the next step not no contact.

Brollypackedforscottishholiday · 20/08/2021 14:02

Please stop sacrificing your ds to appease an abusive man.

Howshouldibehave · 20/08/2021 14:02

Do you rely on MIL for childcare?

Lookingoutside · 20/08/2021 14:01

Tell DS in front of FIL that he can have what he wants on his nails and that there’s no such thing as ‘for girls’ or boys.

That way you don’t have to engage in a row that is very unlikely to change FIL’s mind. Or would there be consequences? Him being emotionally abusive I guess that is a distinct possibility.

Good luck with him. It sounds hard Flowers

meow1989 · 20/08/2021 13:57

On its own I think that it would be strike one and close monitoring but with the history of e.a with dh I would be supervising contact at the least.

If ds asks then you need to make it clear this is not his fault but the fault if his grandfather.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 20/08/2021 13:56

What do we do? You let your OH lead, he kows what his dad is like and how much/little his mum will do to ameloriate his actions.

Your real problem is that you, and possibly OH, know FIL is a wretched excuse of a man, but you seem to think MIL is worthy of your respect. Is she?

Did she stop FIL when he was emotionally abusive to his own son? No!

She certainly wasn't when he emotionally abused his grandson?

It wouldn't be an over reaction to remove both of them from your son's life completely or in part.

I don't imagine your son will miss them once he no longer has to put up with such crappy comments.

Whatinthelord · 20/08/2021 13:56

Op have you explained the comment to your son?

In your shoes I’d explain about homophobia and how silly it is that some people say unkind things. Maybe explain that when grandad grew up everyone expected boys and girls to wear certain clothes, but how that’s changed now but grandad has still got old and unkind ways of thinking.

I’d focus on how sad it is that grandfather hasn’t learnt to be accepting and kind and how lucky you are that you are able to accept people and be kind to them….so he knows the comment shows a lacking in his grandfather and not in him!

Claypotkitchentable · 20/08/2021 13:48

Reminds me of my father in law calling my son a poof when he was about 7. I’ve never forgiven him.

rothbury · 20/08/2021 13:40

MIL can see DS without FIL - she just comes to yours or you see her elsewhere.

I can't see the problem.

Whatinthelord · 20/08/2021 13:38

I agree with your fiancé.
He not only made a homophobic comment, it was a comment aimed to belittle your son and what if it subsequently turns out your son is gay…what message does he take from that.

Alongside the history of abuse to your fiancé and the fact they haven’t accepted what they said was wrong it’s really not making them look like they’re suitable to look after your son anyway/

If your son has experienced abuse from this person as a child I would follow his lead as he will be more than aware of how it effects a child.

Also if you let this pass there I would have thought there will be other comments in the future.

TiredButDancing · 20/08/2021 13:26

@AmyDudley

Granny/Grandpa are old so they have some funny ideas. They're wrong, but when they were young that's how people thought.

Please don;t say this - don;t keep perpetuating the myth that old people are homophobes/racists or whatever.
I'm in my 60's I have never been homophobic, my parents were born in the 1920's they were never homophobic.

It's not an 'old person' thing, it's an ignorant stupid thing.

By all means tell your children that some people have strange ideas and that those ideas are based on lack of knowledge and general unpleasantness, but don't tell them that this is how old people thin because it isn't true and as well as being ageist, it minimises bigotry by citing age as a excuse when it isn't.

On your point OP - I would tell FIL that he keeps his unpleasant and ridiculous opinions to himself or he won't be seeing your child. I doubt you'll be able to change his views - you can't argue with stupid, but you can tell him you won't tolerate such things being said around your child.

Well, I take your point, but my children's grandparents are all in their 80s except MIL and she's 79 ! Grin

I do see your point that not all old people will feel the same, of course, but there often is a generational "norm". Doesn't mean it can't or shouldn't be challenged.

firstworldproblemsagain · 20/08/2021 13:22

FIL sounds a bit pathetic and nasty. Add that to a history of abuse and nope I wouldn’t be leaving my DS there.

AmyDudley · 20/08/2021 13:20

Granny/Grandpa are old so they have some funny ideas. They're wrong, but when they were young that's how people thought.

Please don;t say this - don;t keep perpetuating the myth that old people are homophobes/racists or whatever.
I'm in my 60's I have never been homophobic, my parents were born in the 1920's they were never homophobic.

It's not an 'old person' thing, it's an ignorant stupid thing.

By all means tell your children that some people have strange ideas and that those ideas are based on lack of knowledge and general unpleasantness, but don't tell them that this is how old people thin because it isn't true and as well as being ageist, it minimises bigotry by citing age as a excuse when it isn't.

On your point OP - I would tell FIL that he keeps his unpleasant and ridiculous opinions to himself or he won't be seeing your child. I doubt you'll be able to change his views - you can't argue with stupid, but you can tell him you won't tolerate such things being said around your child.

User112 · 20/08/2021 13:19

Do you realise your dad belongs to a different generation? While I understand your viewpoint, can you not have a peaceful discussion with him explaining things nicely?

Bluntness100 · 20/08/2021 13:16

In itself it’s not a nc issue but if he is homophobic, which I assume he is, then I’d likely distance myself and my child. I’d not leave him there alone.