Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Only Fans to ban porn ...

87 replies

MurielSpriggs · 19/08/2021 23:43

... after pressure from payment processors (banks)
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/aug/19/onlyfans-to-ban-adult-material-after-pressure-from-payment-processors

Am I being unreasonable to have mixed feelings about this?

Less porn. Less objectification of women. Less women being drawn into sex work.

Or one "no-contact" option removed from such women (and men). And whether the outcome is right or wrong, I'm a bit uncomfortable about banks controlling what is and isn't available online.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 20/08/2021 17:30

Only fans also isn't prostitution anymore than page 3 models posing is prostitution.

Page 3 was dropped after heavy campaigning about it being sexist and degrading to women so probably not a good example to use if you’re trying to make out OnlyFans is fine.

LopsidedWombat · 20/08/2021 16:45

The porn aspect aside, I think this highlights a larger problem which is lots of people earning a living via online platforms that then suddenly change their policies and/or algorithms, potentially leaving these people financially up shit creek. Also agree with the concerns about banks controlling what is available online.

DingDongThongs · 20/08/2021 16:31

Dumbasses! Change your payment providers!

QuizzlyBear · 20/08/2021 16:30

@MackenCheese

Er... and why was this announced on the radio news? My ds13 would've immediately googled it 🙄🙄😳
If you have a 13 year old son, trust me he already knows about it.
Boatonthehorizon · 20/08/2021 16:13

@Hemingwaycat Its made (creating) porn accessable to thousands of young women. And sold the idea as feminist and empowering.
Thousands of ordinary young women getting their private parts out for money. Not celebrities.
Its USP is that every young woman can now produce her own porn. And why not?

abcdeg · 20/08/2021 16:11

@Proudboomer

Thinks place is just so full on contradictions. First thread So only fans porn should stay as it is a safe way for young women to work in the porn industry. Second thread Should I leave my husband for watching porn?

So porn is ok as long as it is not your husband watching it?

Well, it's clear they're not the same people saying these two statements. I'm okay with porn as a concept, but I'm aware that lots of it is unethically produced and distributed

I don't have a problem with my partner being aroused by other people

People who are are strongly against porn in their relationship probably aren't going to be advocating for only fans to remain

abcdeg · 20/08/2021 16:08

It’s the whole principle of prostitution that’s exploitative.

Maybe I just don't get it, but how is selling foot pics that people masturbate over exploitation?

Only fans also isn't prostitution anymore than page 3 models posing is prostitution. People got aroused off that, too.

Most on OF have no physical contact with their subscribers. They don't think they're being exploited [obviously not all, but many women like what they do]

Where is the exploitation occurring for the women who like to put content out and make money off of it? Not saying it should be glamourised to young girls, but why is it blankety exploitative as a platform, to release content on?

Proudboomer · 20/08/2021 16:07

Thinks place is just so full on contradictions.
First thread
So only fans porn should stay as it is a safe way for young women to work in the porn industry.
Second thread
Should I leave my husband for watching porn?

So porn is ok as long as it is not your husband watching it?

Hemingwaycat · 20/08/2021 16:06

I’ll be honest, I don’t really know what OnlyFans is. From what I gather it’s z list ‘celebs’ making extra cash selling naked photos, am I right? I heard Kerry Katona was on it and boaked a bit, surely barely anyone wants to see that.

There’s endless free porn sites anyway so no idea why anyone pays for it.

PhoenixFreesias · 20/08/2021 16:03

On the one hand, I think this is overall the right decision. Content featuring minors and other extreme acts is just unacceptable. How quickly the sex side of OF exploded during the early stages of the pandemic and how quickly that became seen as a mainstream option was very damaging.

On the other hand, I do think that a lot of people have come to rely on it for income during uncertain times. Basically they now have six weeks notice to find other alternatives. It worries me how much more exploitative some of those options will be, especially with he time of desperation that kind of time pressure brings.

The employment market is in many ways a lot better in a lot of countries than at the start of the pandemic, so there are better choices available in some places now, but not everywhere and not for everyone.

Whatinthelord · 20/08/2021 16:00

I think a lot of people are doing OF work who would never do direct sex work or other type of work like cam girl work.

I think it’s been advertised as an easy option to young girls.

I personally will be glad if they change to not allow spicy content (though not sure what else people would be paying to see).

Boatonthehorizon · 20/08/2021 15:59

Sex work damages women and is exploitation. I dont want my daughter growing up in a world where getting naked and selling her body online is seen as a sensible career option.

newnortherner111 · 20/08/2021 15:59

I'd prefer the site to close down altogether, but this is a step in the right direction. It will reduce the objectification of women but not by a great deal. I'd bet there will still be some very small outfits worn.

NoNotYou · 20/08/2021 15:58

God I'd love to earn money on OF. If only someone wanted photos of me Sitting on the Sofa eating a Magnum, or Washing Up in odd Marigolds

noblegiraffe · 20/08/2021 15:57

There are sex workers who earn plenty and enjoy their way of acquiring money

That doesn't validate the existence of the sex industry. It's like the people complaining that some girls lost their jobs when they stopped paying women in underwear to parade around at boxing matches as if that made it the wrong decision.

As for people saying 'oh, girls will be forced onto seedier websites' - well lets get rid of those too? However, I don't think those seedier websites are promoted in the mainstream media quite as heavily as OnlyFans has been.

DdraigGoch · 20/08/2021 15:56

@YellowDingy2

I'm not convinced this is a good move for women. OF seems to be a way for some women to have complete control over the sex work they do, which has historically not been the case. I don't think removing that opportunity will be a positive change.
It's not necessarily 'complete control' though. There are plenty of ways to record what is onscreen. Once something is on the Internet, it's out there. There's no taking it down and it leaves you vulnerable to blackmail. It could also affect your career (if you are in teaching, politics, or something and some footage from your student days surfaces).
Carboncheque · 20/08/2021 15:53

’Sex work’ isn’t actual work. It’s exploitation’

That damages women as a whole.

Only Fans were also taking 20% of ‘content creators’ earnings. Saying they were quite reasonable as pimps go is a weak defence.

Soontobe60 · 20/08/2021 15:52

@pollypokcet

This absolutely. ‘Sex work’ isn’t actual work. It’s exploitation, however which way people try to dress it up as being empowering and letting women be in charge of their own bodies.

Sex work varies from anonymous foot fetish pictures to drug-addicted women on street corners with pimps. A lot of sex work is exploitative but who's to say it all is? There are sex workers who earn plenty and enjoy their way of acquiring money

It’s the whole principle of prostitution that’s exploitative.
Soontobe60 · 20/08/2021 15:50

@Unfashionable
I’m not ‘defending porn’. I’m defending the rights of women, many of whom may not be well educated or may be lone parents, to have the freedom to choose to work in the sex industry, if such work suits their circumstances. Highly educated, privileged feminists should try harder to understand the lives and career options of those less fortunate than them

So it’s ok for poor, less educated women and girls to be exploited because they’re ‘less fortunate’? Fucking hell, next you’ll be promoting child Labour for families who are on Universal Credit!
No woman should have to resort to prostituting herself in order to keep a roof over her head and food in her children’s bellies. Suggesting that it’s a valid option is about as anti feminist as it gets. We should be fighting for single parents to have better support to enable them to improve their lives, career options and housing choices - not tell them ‘ok dearie, if you want to take your kids on holiday, all you need to do is post a few explicit shots of yourself online’.
Absolutely shocking take!

pollypokcet · 20/08/2021 15:49

This absolutely. ‘Sex work’ isn’t actual work. It’s exploitation, however which way people try to dress it up as being empowering and letting women be in charge of their own bodies.

Sex work varies from anonymous foot fetish pictures to drug-addicted women on street corners with pimps. A lot of sex work is exploitative but who's to say it all is? There are sex workers who earn plenty and enjoy their way of acquiring money

Soontobe60 · 20/08/2021 15:43

@TryingHarderToday

Unbelievable how many are defending porn here. Are you completely unable to understand systematic class analysis?
This absolutely. ‘Sex work’ isn’t actual work. It’s exploitation, however which way people try to dress it up as being empowering and letting women be in charge of their own bodies.
SimonJT · 20/08/2021 15:41

@MotionActivatedDog

Theres loads of stuff on there that isn’t remotely sexual, that side of it is still fairly new. I subscribe to a crocheter on there, a friend is a PT and he has subscribers to his PT service on there.

I had no idea there was anything other than porn on OF. I’ve only ever heard it discussed in that context. So it is essentially YouTube?

More like Patreon, OF has been around since 2016 and was a way for people to make money out of hobbies, but also for people wanting to work in the arts who would make skits etc. I think the sex stuff only really started to boom during the pandemic.
abcdeg · 20/08/2021 15:41

@TryingHarderToday

Unbelievable how many are defending porn here. Are you completely unable to understand systematic class analysis?

Wait... do you think this is a move to eradicate porn? All it does is mean viewers go back to tube sites which reshape without permission and takes control away from women who put out videos/etc

This only fans argument we're having now has literally nothing to do with porn vs no porn. You can be anti porn and still think OF is better than a tube site that rips off/copyrights videos, or a dodgy man filming women

The regulation of videos was an issue for the platform, but broadly, it's better for women to be in control.

Gimlisaxe · 20/08/2021 15:37

If they are going to do this, does it mean something is going to happen to twitter?

I understand its a different model, but I clicked on a trending name and saw a video that no one should have to see involuntary and it makes me wonder if pressure is going to be apply to them as well somehow

SirenSays · 20/08/2021 15:34

Can't say I'm surprised, PayPal has always been awful to sex workers.