Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to support extinction rebellion - more London action tomorrow

996 replies

54321nought · 19/08/2021 23:40

I am not sure what, but I have seen their previous demonstrations, and support their cause.

We were given badges at one event, and travelled home on public transport wearing them, and received absolutely nothing but 100% support from other travellers, which was nice, as I expected some hostility, publicly wearing their badges while roads in London were closed by them

OP posts:
Darker · 23/08/2021 18:28

You are missing the point. XR are not running model sustainability demonstrations or educational workshops on ‘how to reduce your carbon footprint’.

They are trying to get governments and the fossil fuel industry to ACT NOW. Like, TODAY.

lannistunut · 23/08/2021 18:26

The difference it makes is that multiple people getting multiple taxis over a train taking lots of people at once is more harmful for the environment. So the methods extinction rebellion apply are completely counter productive! This is a pretty myopic way of looking at it though, you have missed the point of my post which is that fractional difference is not going to change anything - we need much much more meanngful policy shifts.

Bythemillpond · 23/08/2021 18:25

So taking a taxi or driving a car is not going to matter when XR are in town.

So why bother taking public transport at all

lannistunut · 23/08/2021 18:23

@opaleyes2

Do you realise the UK produces around 1% of emissions. We are amongst the last people on the planet who need to be going vegan and driving around like the Jetsons, whilst China 28% and USA 14% continue to cough out pollution and have no intentions whatsoever of addressing it.
It is sometimes about leadership though, and doing what you can.

I also feel that China are correct to view the switch to renewables as being about power security as well as climate. We would be so much more secure if not dependent on pipelines and drilling in remote parts of the world.

The desire to continue with oil is about entrenched economic interests, not what is best for the UK population.

opaleyes2 · 23/08/2021 18:22

@lannistunut

How is holding up traffic and preventing people from using "cleaner" forms of public transport such as trains helping the environment? The point is what we are doing about climate change now is so pathetic, what difference does it make if some people need to get a taxi today instead of the train?

I have been asking myself - is there a climate emergency? Yes. What do we need? Total overhaul of heating, transport, construction, manufacturing... Is this going to happen?

There are people on this thread talking about recycling ffs. We have been talking about recycling for thirty years. It is going to take a bit more than me diligently washing out my yogurt pots.

The difference it makes is that multiple people getting multiple taxis over a train taking lots of people at once is more harmful for the environment. So the methods extinction rebellion apply are completely counter productive!
opaleyes2 · 23/08/2021 18:17

Do you realise the UK produces around 1% of emissions. We are amongst the last people on the planet who need to be going vegan and driving around like the Jetsons, whilst China 28% and USA 14% continue to cough out pollution and have no intentions whatsoever of addressing it.

lannistunut · 23/08/2021 18:12

How is holding up traffic and preventing people from using "cleaner" forms of public transport such as trains helping the environment?
The point is what we are doing about climate change now is so pathetic, what difference does it make if some people need to get a taxi today instead of the train?

I have been asking myself - is there a climate emergency? Yes. What do we need? Total overhaul of heating, transport, construction, manufacturing... Is this going to happen?

There are people on this thread talking about recycling ffs. We have been talking about recycling for thirty years. It is going to take a bit more than me diligently washing out my yogurt pots.

woodhill · 23/08/2021 18:09

@mustlovegin

a lot of the pollution in Asia is our pollution, which we outsource

So the billions of people in Asia don't eat, don't travel, don't consume? All production is for the UK? Have you been to Asia OP?

Fgs most countries consume apart from China not just the UK

USA, Australia for example

BelleOfTheProvince · 23/08/2021 18:04

Hope not. Expect they'd leave the layers of paper there.

lannistunut · 23/08/2021 18:03

[quote EstuaryBird]@lannistunut
@SelkieQualia

Yes, apologies you are quite correct and I will asked for the post to be withdrawn.

I may be a poor peasant from East London but I can own up to a mistake.[/quote]
I am peasant too, never apologise for that Grin

Andante57 · 23/08/2021 18:02

I’ve just seen them playing musical chairs - mostly adults, one child from what I can see - the musical accompaniment being a mournful lament on panpipes.
There’s something a bit weird about adults playing children’s party games.
What next? Pass the parcel?

BelleOfTheProvince · 23/08/2021 18:02

So you need to piss off less than 96.5 percent of the population?

Take a look at the poll op and ask yourself if you have the support you need.

opaleyes2 · 23/08/2021 17:58

How is holding up traffic and preventing people from using "cleaner" forms of public transport such as trains helping the environment? I can't imagine why anyone would want to support a group that are clueless idiots at best and down right raving hypocrites at worst. The various celebrities who endorse this whilst driving multiple cars and flying private jets are truly sickening. Prince Harry, Lewis Hamilton etc.

EstuaryBird · 23/08/2021 17:56

@lannistunut
@SelkieQualia

Yes, apologies you are quite correct and I will asked for the post to be withdrawn.

I may be a poor peasant from East London but I can own up to a mistake.

DoubleShotEspresso · 23/08/2021 17:38

@CloseEncountersOfTheTurdKind thanks for this that's very encouraging. Was so scary for my child too.

DoubleShotEspresso · 23/08/2021 17:35

@54321nought who on Earth appointed you God? What an entitled, selfish and pointless post! "Since when do you get to decide which "bad inconveniences" us lowly folk should endure? How dare you !

lannistunut · 23/08/2021 17:31

@BelleOfTheProvince

To be honest 3.5 % of people changing the world is fucking terrifying. I'd assume there's a hell of a lot more than 3.5% of people who champion less than noble causes.
To get 3.5% turning out, you would need a lot more than that generally supportive as it is only a small group of any mindset who will take direct action.
lannistunut · 23/08/2021 17:29

@EstuaryBird

SelkieQualia

You know China is the world's leader in renewable energy right?

Really?………

That chart says they only investigated 21 countries - was China one of the 21?

China is investing heavily in renewables, we can define 'leader' in terms of % or actual amount.

BelleOfTheProvince · 23/08/2021 17:23

To be honest 3.5 % of people changing the world is fucking terrifying.
I'd assume there's a hell of a lot more than 3.5% of people who champion less than noble causes.

EstuaryBird · 23/08/2021 17:20

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Darker · 23/08/2021 17:08

Interesting article here on 3.5%. From 2019 but still relevant.

www.bbc.com/future/article/20190513-it-only-takes-35-of-people-to-change-the-world

EstuaryBird · 23/08/2021 17:08

@ChaneySays

My partner spent years working for the UKs biggest waste/recycling company and always said these people would make a MUCH bigger environmental impact by simply going around and removing the black bags which people put in recycling bins at work.

Over 40% of their dry mixed recyclables used to go to landfill due to contamination as the tip won't accept it with black bags in and can't pick them out by hand for risk of needles etc, and because it's not really viable once they get mixed in.

Millions of tons of cardboard/plastic across the UK getting buried each year and then more trees are cut down to replace it. But rooting through bins doesn't seem quite as revolutionary does it!

Thank you @ChaneySays

This is the most useful post on this whole thread….certainly more useful than anything I’ve heard from the XR supporters.

I didn’t know this and I will now make it my business to ensure that I spread this information. It’s easy to do and it makes a difference without causing any harm to anyone. Perfect 😊

lannistunut · 23/08/2021 17:05

@mustlovegin

They might not get a choice tbh

How about contraception, to start with?

Confused not much use for the people already in existence, is it?
BelleOfTheProvince · 23/08/2021 16:59

The rationale behind xr seems to be that you only need 3.5 % of the population involved in protest to effect change.

I don't know how they came up with those figures, as it seems to me surely other control factors need to be taken into account. For example women's rights gained significant progress because both world wars required them.to step onto roles traditionally meant for men. Presumably this made it hard to role back, particularly as some families would have been better off financially with women taking paid work.

If you only need 3.5% on favour then I would expect to see less favourable changes being enacted.
I bet there's at least 5% of the country that are anti Vax.
Or BritainFirst type movements.
I bet around 3.5% of the country are vegan or vegetarian. If we march could we get the government to stop meat production?

I doubt it.

I would assume that 3.5 need to march but the majority need to back them.
Xr seem to think a few outliers gluing themselves to trains will break the system.
Not sure why they think that.

Merrymumoftwo · 23/08/2021 16:50

In the days of the suffragettes disruption worked because there was very little affect on the lower classes. They specifically targeted locations that gave the impact they wanted www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/transformingsociety/electionsvoting/womenvote/overview/startsuffragette-/
Disruption tactics today have little affect on the people with the power to promote change on a global level . For example group glues themselves together under a lorry and stops traffic. Most vehicles will leave their engines running, harming the environment, a core of protesters will leave behind rubbish and all this is caught and promoted by main stream media. Add to this numerous examples of people losing pay, not getting to essential medical appointments and it results in a failure for XR to promote hood practice and a win for those who have no real desire to make rapid change

Swipe left for the next trending thread