Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to support extinction rebellion - more London action tomorrow

996 replies

54321nought · 19/08/2021 23:40

I am not sure what, but I have seen their previous demonstrations, and support their cause.

We were given badges at one event, and travelled home on public transport wearing them, and received absolutely nothing but 100% support from other travellers, which was nice, as I expected some hostility, publicly wearing their badges while roads in London were closed by them

OP posts:
54321nought · 21/08/2021 09:08

@SofiaMichelle

By far the single biggest thing that can be done to help with climate change and the environment is to reduce the wold's population.

I hope none of these work-shy privileged arses have produced more than 1 'replacement' offspring each?

We all know the answer to that though, don't we...

Every time anyone says "work-shy" they are showing themselves to be ignorant and prejudiced

Not only have we already established that many activists are employed, or retired after a life time of work, the activism itself is very hard work, time consuming, difficult, stressful.

As for being privileged, many make HUGE sacrifices to take part, and do so because it is more important than personal comfort, freedom or wealth, and do so for their children and grandchildren

I do wonder why people keep wanting to repeat "WORK-SHY! PRIVILEDGED! WORK-SHY! PRVILEDGED! WORK-SHY!"

apart from being blatantly untrue, and showing you up to being someone who has no idea what they are talking about...

I do wonder if it is

a) because people cannot actually answer their point, so prefer just to shout insults, and chose these one in the hope that it might make people turn against them, if they don't know any better

b) because people are trying to justify their own personal damage to the planet by implying that they can't help protect the environment because they are very busy and poor, when they are most likely to be exactly as busy and poor as the people they are saying this about?

c) because they just can't be bothered to think through what is happening to the environment, and the implications

OP posts:
twinklystar23 · 21/08/2021 08:58

I live in a small town the council wanted to put a gas generator near a school XR got involved with the local protest and managed to prevent this going ahead.

bagelsandoranges · 21/08/2021 08:52

So many people live life selfishly... Oh that person did a good deed and is trying to support a worthwhile cause? Im going to project my own issues onto them. Really typical that they all flock to this thread as if they'll somehow convince those with clarity (backed up by facts) what's what GrinHmm

54321nought · 21/08/2021 08:51

@BelleOfTheProvince

Also, university educated means nowadays you had the money to pay the fees. It's not really a good measure of intelligence anymore. (But a pretty accurate gauge of class!)
That's a bit of a circular argument, as the main definition of middle class is "went to university"

And anyone can go to university, if they are intelligent and work hard, and get loans

So your definition of "middle class and privileged" is "intelligent, hard working and chooses to take out the loans to go to university"

And, decades ago, when the currently retired generation went, if was free, - and far more people from lower income families went, so the definition would simply be "intelligent, hardworking and chose to be educated"

so your objection to these particular ER activists is that they are intelligent, hardworking, chose to be educated, then worked for 40 or 50 years......

OP posts:
BelleOfTheProvince · 21/08/2021 08:46

Which is why I'd expect xr campaigners to practise what they preach.

Some do. Most don't.

BelleOfTheProvince · 21/08/2021 08:45

According to most studies the single biggest thing you can do is switch to a plant based diet. Not sure if population is excluded though as obviously we can't do anything about people already born.

"According to Project Drawdown, the third- and fourth-best climate change solutions are reducing food waste and eating a plant-rich diet. (The top two solutions aren't things the average person can easily control: refrigerant management and onshore wind turbines.)

But wait, there's more! Researchers in a 2018 Oxford University study said, "A vegan diet is probably the single biggest way to reduce your impact on planet Earth, not just greenhouse gases, but global acidification, eutrophication, land use, and water use. . . . It is far bigger than cutting down on your flights or buying an electric car, as these only cut greenhouse gas emissions."

SofiaMichelle · 21/08/2021 08:31

By far the single biggest thing that can be done to help with climate change and the environment is to reduce the wold's population.

I hope none of these work-shy privileged arses have produced more than 1 'replacement' offspring each?

We all know the answer to that though, don't we...

Polkabott · 21/08/2021 08:06

One of the organisers LinkedIn is amusing, she used to design leather and fur garments for the high Street. Sounds super sustainable. Admittedly a while ago and people change, but I'm sure in the right circles her performative activism that costs the country millions drives sales for her sustainable fashion brand.

Hypnoshiding · 21/08/2021 08:03

Retired GPs who managed to go to uni 50 years ago. A prime example of how retired and privileged go hand in hand.

Also, is there a difference between people who like to read that didn't go to university and people who like to read but did go to University?

Do you assume these retires GPS are correct about everything, all them time?

LoislovesStewie · 21/08/2021 07:59

@NantesElephant

FWIW, my neighbours who join XR actions are in their late 60s, retired GPs. My impression is that there are a lot of university educated people in the XR movement who read a lot, can understand scientific literature and therefore have a good understanding of how screwed we are.
Both my DH and I are working class; we went to university when about 5% of the population were lucky enough to get there. FWIW we went to a university that was well known for its left wing agenda. So, yes we understand a lot, neither of us support ER. We dislike the way that it disrupts ordinary working class people going about their lawful day-to-day activities, we believe that a lot of them just want to create chaos and most don't actually have a clue about what they want anyone to do to make the world a better place. Oh, and being in any profession doesn't give that person either any more idea of what is going on in another field of expertise or any more right to protest than someone with no professional qualifications or for that matter a working class person. We can all read.
BelleOfTheProvince · 21/08/2021 07:50

A new report by Greenpeace has concluded that lost and discarded fishing gear makes up the vast majority of large plastic pollution in the oceans. An estimated 640,000 tonnes of ghost gear enters the ocean every year, equivalent in weight to more than 50,000 double decker buses.

So best avoid the fillet o fish while you're out protesting too.

BelleOfTheProvince · 21/08/2021 07:48

Maybe that was true in the early 2000s. I'd be interested to see the data.
Certainly none of the lower middle class teens I know are off to university this year. They've got apprenticeships or jobs. I doubt they'll be taking time off to mooch around at festivals protests.

torquewench · 21/08/2021 07:45

3 billion (in case anyone's actually interested in the answer).

lannistunut · 21/08/2021 07:34

@BelleOfTheProvince

Also, university educated means nowadays you had the money to pay the fees. It's not really a good measure of intelligence anymore. (But a pretty accurate gauge of class!)
Far more working class people go to university now than previously.
BelleOfTheProvince · 21/08/2021 07:32

If people are that clever I would hope they use their gifts to find solutions to climate change- one university near me developed buses run on biofuel. Much more useful than stopping traffic and a better use of time and resources.

BelleOfTheProvince · 21/08/2021 07:30

Also, university educated means nowadays you had the money to pay the fees. It's not really a good measure of intelligence anymore. (But a pretty accurate gauge of class!)

BelleOfTheProvince · 21/08/2021 07:28

@NantesElephant

FWIW, my neighbours who join XR actions are in their late 60s, retired GPs. My impression is that there are a lot of university educated people in the XR movement who read a lot, can understand scientific literature and therefore have a good understanding of how screwed we are.
GPS that don't realise if you block roads emergency services can't get through? Glad they weren't my GP. You'd think with that many intelligent people they'd be able to come up with a more effective strategy than 'stop public transport'.

Have you seen that video? Are those teens being effective campaigners?

NantesElephant · 21/08/2021 07:17

FWIW, my neighbours who join XR actions are in their late 60s, retired GPs. My impression is that there are a lot of university educated people in the XR movement who read a lot, can understand scientific literature and therefore have a good understanding of how screwed we are.

NantesElephant · 21/08/2021 07:15

People have died and others lost everything in wildfires this year due to man made climate change and you’re here arguing. You don’t have to like XR, but that doesn’t excuse you from doing nothing. Get off your phone and take action.

torquewench · 21/08/2021 07:09

@maddening

Restrictions could be taxes for example, limits on sales, banning certain plastics that can't be easily recycled.
Whether they're "easily recyclable" or not is irrelevant if they don't get put in a recycling bin. Indulge me a little here. Have a guess at how many plastic bottles will be produced for just one item for one manufacturer over the next 4 years.
BelleOfTheProvince · 20/08/2021 21:32

First question: Why are you here today?
Response: to bunk off college.

Yes it's certainly environmental issues driving these young people.

Interested in how these attitudes are approached in xr. Or is it tolerated because quantity of protesters is valued over quality.
ugtest.pmadata.org/sugihbareng/download/5MNfbWMTDjg.xhtml

Hypnoshiding · 20/08/2021 21:01

@54321nought

The op pointed out that 'most' people involved with the worked 40 years and are retired. The fact that they have, most likely retired young means they still have a privileged position over the people's whose lives they are disrupting

40 years is the minimum I would have expected a retired person to have worked.

I am sure some have worked 40 years, and some 50, or more.

Many ER activists are very elderly, retired people, that is the point - so it is complete nonsense to say they need to get a job!

And of the younger ones - many do have jobs, and take annual leave to protest

Again, do you have stats? Demographics?

You said they worked 40 years. It's like you can't grasp you can be retired AND ne privileged and not realise (or care) about people living pay check to pay check. Or you can't be a lawyer and not realise, that actually some people will be fucked if they can't get to work for a day or two or more.

All the groups you have mentioned can definitely be privileged and nort understand the fairly devastating impact their 'disruption' has.

If most of the people at those 'disruptions' were retired then they are extremely privileged. Because the vast majority were not 60 plus. Or do they stay behind. Just send out some younger folk to actually do the disrupting.

And also, if they have an army of retired professionals at their finger tips, you would think at least a few of them would have tbe brain to realise they aren't winning people over and actually hurting some of the most vulnerable.

And yes, I guess some will be taking annual leave. Great for them, they are getting paid. Bet they wouldn't take it unpaid, though.

Since you know so much about them the inner working and demographics. Why are you asking if its unreasonable me to support them. You already do.

54321nought · 20/08/2021 20:44

The op pointed out that 'most' people involved with the worked 40 years and are retired. The fact that they have, most likely retired young means they still have a privileged position over the people's whose lives they are disrupting

40 years is the minimum I would have expected a retired person to have worked.

I am sure some have worked 40 years, and some 50, or more.

Many ER activists are very elderly, retired people, that is the point - so it is complete nonsense to say they need to get a job!

And of the younger ones - many do have jobs, and take annual leave to protest

OP posts:
Hypnoshiding · 20/08/2021 20:35

@LoislovesStewie

Hypnoshiding I worked in local government. Not in a high position at all. And I don't support extinction rebellion.
Your support, or lack of, isn't really the issue.

Being able to retire at 58 is a privileged position in today's society in the UK. Especially, in comparison, to the people who were missing days pay because of XR.

The op pointed out that 'most' people involved with the worked 40 years and are retired. The fact that they have, most likely retired young means they still have a privileged position over the people's whose lives they are disrupting.

You may not have been senior, but you can't pretend that being able to retire at 58 isn't a privileged position.

Which was op was saying 'these people aren't privileged, they are normal people. But, that were able to afford to retire from their mid 50s.'

Which brings us back full circle to the fact that many of the people at XR protests seem to not realise (or don't care) about their impact on the people they are stopping getting to work, who can't afford to just miss a day.

That's why I asked the question 'who retires at 56', because the answer is people in a fairly privileged position. Which is the point she was disputing.

I am not saying you don't care about people struggling, BTW. Simply that ops argument that these aren't, in the main, privileged people makes no sense.

Andante57 · 20/08/2021 20:31

@maddening

Restrictions could be taxes for example, limits on sales, banning certain plastics that can't be easily recycled.
Ok, but then why governments aren’t doing this. If I ask why it’s not happening here everyone will say is because the Tories are so useless - ok, so why aren’t the EU or countries like Sweden and Norway imposing these restrictions? Maybe other countries have less desire for endless useless plastic tat.