Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids running at birds/ducks

209 replies

Mama1993 · 19/08/2021 21:38

Took my 3 y/o DS to the zoo today with his cousin. They were VERY excitable - running around laughing and jumping etc.

We sat down for our picnic on the grass. Lots of birds around. Now I know that children shouldnt run after birds as it distresses them but a lot of them do and don't seem to understand it's not a game.

My son was running around playing and he either ran towards a duck to run after it or was running and didn't see it (I didn't see fully) anyway he tripped on the duck which I saw and shouted 'CAREFUL!' albeit in a different language so other people wouldn't have understood.

Now this elderly woman who was sat on a bench with her husband started screaming at my DS 'HOW DARE YOU!' repeatedly. I was so shocked that I can't actually remember what else she said but she as angry!

I told her it wasnt on purpose but she was adamant that it was. I told her I knew my son and that he wouldn't deliberately kick a duck, to which she sarcastically replies 'do you???' over and over.

I don't like confrontation but AIBU to think this woman was well out of order shouting at a 3 year old?

I took my son aside afterwards and told him again how it's not nice to run at birds as it scares them. He was really upset by the whole thing (as I'm sure the duck was too! But it was 100% an accident)

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 19/08/2021 22:36

Op I'm on your side.

Its a big open space where families sit and habe picnics and the kids run around. If you don't want kids running around you, you find a picnic table.

That kind of space is going to have birds on. It isn't a designated piece of land for birds. Its free grass and the birds are hoping for lunch. Its ridiculous to think that no one should sit on the grass the zoo permits people to sit on because a bird might want to go on it too.

Its very unlikely for a small child to be able to get close enough to a bird to kick it and to actually land the kick given kids shitty coordination and birds not being overly tolerant of being near kids. So on the balance of probability, it sounds more likely he ran into it / fell over it.

You did the right thing by talking to him, but you weren't unreasonable to allow him to run around open grass meant for families to use.

Fudgein · 19/08/2021 22:35

I think you're getting a really hard time OP. Of course your child shouldn't chase birds but from your perspective he was running around playing & the birds just happened to be nearby. As soon as you noticed a problem you called him over and reprimanded him. I was out last week and a boy around 8 or 9 was chasing geese near a pond, being really vindictive. His parents didn't seem to care but when he came near us I asked him if he could stop which he did no problem. I would NEVER shout at anyone in public unless they were in imminent danger i.e. about to run into traffic, let alone a THREE YEAR OLD. It's not good that OP's son chased the duck (if he did) however that absolutely doesn't give a stranger a right to keep shouting at him imo.

CakeandGo · 19/08/2021 22:35

@supersonicginandtonic yeah but OP’s child hasn’t had a chance to kick ducks in ages because of covid.

You are wrong OP. You should have been watching your child and at 3 they should know not to do this. Poor duck. I hope it wasn’t injured.

BasicB · 19/08/2021 22:34

@HasselbackForLife

Oh my god Mumsnet brigade are ridiculous sometimes. The women was completely out of order to shout at you. Her reaction is never ok and she was incredibly rude. Your son was probably a bit too active but name a 3 year old that isn't?! Next time, sit a bit further away from the ducks. Lesson learnt. Don't let the 'up-tight-perfect-parents-with-perfect-children-who never-did-anything-wrong-ever' get you down.
Completely agree. This thread is insane
BasicB · 19/08/2021 22:33

@MareofBeasttown

I am clearly a lousy parent because I am on OP's side..Haven't small children already had a terrible time this last year without being chastised for running around? I don't think it is such " bad behaviour" either. Certainly not so awful.that it needs to be called out in public.
Me too! So far OP is a ‘lax parent’, another poster would have also happily shouted at her 3 year old, she needs to ‘control her child’….I assume each and every person has/had beautifully behaved 3 year olds who behaved perfectly all the time.

Of course it’s not OK to run at birds but the child is 3, and still learning Confused

Creamsoda77 · 19/08/2021 22:33

@HasselbackForLife

Also the whole 'control your child' thing is so unfeminist. It is never, ever said to a man. It's a way of making mums struggling with young children feel bad about themselves. Children do stupid things, get off your high, sad horse and stop blaming tired and stressed out mums
My reply would be the same if it were mother, or a father, you should never let a child run at an animal like that and harm it,never
HasselbackForLife · 19/08/2021 22:32

Also, also, also, I bet most of you eat duck at the Chinese! Unless your are vegan, I don't think you have any morals here at all

Stompythedinosaur · 19/08/2021 22:32

She shouldn't have shouted at a young child.

You shouldn't have allowed a situation where your child harmed an animal.

HasselbackForLife · 19/08/2021 22:31

Also the whole 'control your child' thing is so unfeminist. It is never, ever said to a man. It's a way of making mums struggling with young children feel bad about themselves. Children do stupid things, get off your high, sad horse and stop blaming tired and stressed out mums

SmidgenofaPigeon · 19/08/2021 22:30

Was the duck ok? You didn’t actually say anything about the poor duck, which suggests you’re not that bothered if he hurt it or not, accidentally or otherwise.

HasselbackForLife · 19/08/2021 22:28

Oh my god Mumsnet brigade are ridiculous sometimes. The women was completely out of order to shout at you. Her reaction is never ok and she was incredibly rude. Your son was probably a bit too active but name a 3 year old that isn't?!
Next time, sit a bit further away from the ducks. Lesson learnt. Don't let the 'up-tight-perfect-parents-with-perfect-children-who never-did-anything-wrong-ever' get you down.

54321nought · 19/08/2021 22:26

control your child

Mama1993 · 19/08/2021 22:25

I'm sorry if this is 'drip feeding' but I felt like I was waffling in OP.

He was 2 metres away at most, reason I didn't see fully was because I was sat on the floor and the pram was obscuring the view a bit. I saw him crash in to a duck which is when I shouted careful.

I explained to him afterwards why he shouldnt run at birds if that's what happened.

But he hadnt been running at any birds which is why I didn't think that's what he was doing. Of course I can't be sure what happened which is why I spoke to him afterwards and if I had certainly seen him run at it I would have told him to stop

OP posts:
Creamsoda77 · 19/08/2021 22:25

Yes, wanted to add 'tripping over' a duck meant he was far too close, maybe at 3 he doesnt understand but as a parent its your job to step in ??

MareofBeasttown · 19/08/2021 22:24

OP's poor kid will be Ted Bundy by the end of this thread.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 19/08/2021 22:23

@Figgygal

I absolutely hate seeing kids doing this You should have had him under better control sorry
This. If he ran close and fast enough to trip over it you can't blame people for thinning it was on purpose
Heronwatcher · 19/08/2021 22:23

She shouldn’t have shouted, but then she obviously genuinely thought that your son kicked the bird- unless you think she made it up which seems unlikely. I would suggest that you don’t make the lady a bad guy but use this as a lesson for your son about kindness to animals being important.

Movingsoon21 · 19/08/2021 22:22

Your lax parenting won’t do your kid any favours, OP. Watch him more carefully in future and stop him from misbehaving before he does it, not afterwards.

Woman shouldn’t have shouted at him but was right to pull you up on it. It’s your fault, not your 3 year olds.

Creamsoda77 · 19/08/2021 22:21

I cant bear seeing kids do this either and you should not have allowed it, the lady shouldnt have shouted though.

SoftSheen · 19/08/2021 22:20

Perhaps he did, in fact, kick the duck, which would explain the woman's reaction?

Either way, he shouldn't have been chasing birds, and you should have been watching him.

kittenkipping · 19/08/2021 22:19

She was wrong to shout I guess, but I'm of the opinion she saw what happened and you admitted you didn't. Saying "I know my child!" Is tedious, and bleated far too often. He's 3. Growing ,changing, impulsive and a born copy cat. You know him in that you may know he hasn't kicked a duck before- but it's ludicrous to suggest you know 100% that he never ever would. He's 3! Any number of reasons he might've done it. Oh- he says he tripped? Of course he's never lied and nor will he ever!

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 19/08/2021 22:19

Now I know that children shouldnt run after birds as it distresses them but a lot of them do and don't seem to understand it's not a game.

Well yes, that's why their parents have to tell them Confused.

MareofBeasttown · 19/08/2021 22:15

"How dare you?" shouted at a 3 yr old is extreme overkill.

supersonicginandtonic · 19/08/2021 22:10

The one things little ones have been able to do is run around 🙄

Planetsandstars · 19/08/2021 22:10

I think she was wrong to shout at your son, but I also really don’t think he ‘tripped over’ a duck.

I see children chasing pigeons a lot and while I’m no great fan of pigeons that’s really why I hate it, as I don’t want a flock of alarmed pigeons flying at my head.