Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Untrained neighbour dog. WWYD?

88 replies

ERest · 19/08/2021 20:25

Hello, thought I would get some opinions on the below scenario but not enabling voting as a twofold question. I live a few doors away from a family with one of those small cutey dogs, not sure what breed. It is however very fierce and frequently gets away from its owners to harass people. It has stopped me from getting down from my car before, after appearing from no where and running round my car while barking continously till the lady eventually emerged 5 minutes later to get it. That was not the first time either. This week however, it has chased my sibling twice on their way to work (she lives with me at the moment). We were all standing by the door as she left, 3 adults and my little one, so saw the entire scene unfold. The lady was walking the dog with her two kids. The older child, probably 6 or 7 was holding the dog. As soon as my sister got to street level and the dog sighted her, it tore after her and dragged the child down till she tripped. My sister had to take refuge on a car further down the street to get away from the dog! The owner just said: "the dog is just a baby, it won't bite" in a dismissive manner. This was really annoying to hear as this is a repetitive issue! To make things worse, the car owner has just come round to check if my sister was alright, but also to say her car has a scratch and it is due to be collected on Monday as it has been sold. She is planning to come back later with her husband as she is worried the buyer would not want it now. So for my AIBU which is twofold:

  1. What can be done about neighbours dog, especially if the same happens again? Can we report a dog for terrorising neighbours?
  2. If the car owner presents a bill for car scratches, who should pay it, my sister or would she be unreasonable to pass it on to the dog owner?
OP posts:
ERest · 20/08/2021 00:52

Thank you all for your comments, even those who feel my sister was overreacting. She was truly frightened of the dog, small or not and this was the second time it had chased her down the street so there was precedent for her to get away from it. I have seen the harm even small dogs can inflict and this one does not appear friendly at all. I know some dog owners don't get it and feel the same way this dog owner does, but your dog is not my friend and if it breaks away from you to rush toward a stranger in a run, that stranger must either be very comfortable with dogs or is probably frozen to the spot if they remain unmoved. She is still away at work, but I will show her this tbread when she returns so she can decide next best steps. It woild also depend on the car owners decision.
I think the lack of concern by it's owner is what made me start this thread. She basically shrugged it off as though it was not her problem, which makes me concerned we have not seen the last of this behaviour. by the dog. For everyone saying it's a little dog, just kick it away; you will probably be out enmasse to say YABU if the title of this thread was: My sister kicked a dog running at her today and the dog is hurt. Now the owner is asking her to cover vet bills.
The dog is not trained and is a nuisance. One should not wait to be bitten before this becomes obvious.

OP posts:
DinkyDiggies · 19/08/2021 23:54

I’m a dog owner and lover, but don’t necessarily think your sister was unreasonable to jump on a car. While I’d confidently take on a small dog, if you’d said ‘whacking great Alsatian/Doberman/Rottweiler’ then I’d definitely be jumping on a car to get away.
I think some people are more naturally frightened of dogs, and even a small one is scary.
Cultural sensitivity seems to be lacking in some of the comments as I’ve found people who may not be of White European heritage don’t have a culture of pet owning, and view our ‘cute little pups’ as dirty disease carrying beasts with the potential to savage one on sight.
I lived in Wembley for a while, and a crowded street would part like the Red Sea when I took my little King Charles Spaniel (who was the kindest sweetest looking little dog you could ever wish to see) down the road. A great tall youth jumped out of my way shouting ‘get that thing away from me’ when she walked past on a lead and turned as though to sniff him. I googled this and read that dogs are considered impure in Islam, and that ritual washing may be required after contact.
The dog has caused alarm and distress which is against the law. Report to police. If you receive bill for car, pass to dog owner. I would hope their pet is insured...?

bobandhisburgers · 19/08/2021 23:20

@DewDew83

There wasn't a car crash though DewDew. A woman jumped on it. Completely incomparable situation. Dog is a red herring. Now you're being daft. Are you really trying to say that, even if it wasn't for the out of control dog, she would have jumped on the car regardless?

The dog was dangerously out of control, within the meaning of the Dangerous Dogs Act. Clambering onto a nearby car, to avoid being bitten, is an entirely reasonable and understandable in the circumstances.

Yes, if the dog owners were sued directly by the car owners then I would expect them to argue that the reaction of jumping onto the car was an intervening event (for the purposes of denying causation) but I don't think they'd be successful.

Are you the sister?
DewDew83 · 19/08/2021 23:18

Very odd of your sister to climb onto a car.
If a dog actually attacked me or my child I’d kick it , not climb on a car

Climbing onto a car or other elevated service is sometimes recommended as a means of avoiding a dog attack (www.chp.edu/injury-prevention/safety/home-and-yard/dog-bites). Kicking one generally is not.

lyntheyresexpeople · 19/08/2021 23:14

@XelaM

Your sister is totally nuts. No normal person jumps ONTO someone else's car. That's not normal behaviour! The dog wasn't attacking her, just ran towards her. What is wrong with you and your sister?!
Yeah this.... I'd be raging if I was the car owner, especially in her situation where it's just been sold!
aerosocks · 19/08/2021 23:13

Contact the dog warden at the local council and tell them about it. They will know what to do.

Pottedpalm · 19/08/2021 23:05

My sister’s dog bit my ankle, fortunately I was wearing boots but I still felt his teeth. She thought it was funny and he was only playing. It wasn’t funny when he bit the dog-sitter on the hand the following week; she needed several stitches. The dog was put down that day. The vet said he suspected it was the onset of dementia.
I would never trust a dog, especially around children.

TacoSunday · 19/08/2021 22:28

Perhaps try carrying a dog deterrent spray in the short term (no idea if these work), but yes, the owner needs to be told to control her dog. I guess this is something the police would deal with if it is causing a nuisance generally. Speak to your neighbours to see who else has had a bad experience with the dog/owner.

Tigertigertigertiger · 19/08/2021 22:21

Very odd of your sister to climb onto a car.
If a dog actually attacked me or my child I’d kick it , not climb on a car

XelaM · 19/08/2021 22:17

Your sister is totally nuts. No normal person jumps ONTO someone else's car. That's not normal behaviour! The dog wasn't attacking her, just ran towards her. What is wrong with you and your sister?!

DewDew83 · 19/08/2021 22:12

There wasn't a car crash though DewDew. A woman jumped on it. Completely incomparable situation. Dog is a red herring.
Now you're being daft. Are you really trying to say that, even if it wasn't for the out of control dog, she would have jumped on the car regardless?

The dog was dangerously out of control, within the meaning of the Dangerous Dogs Act. Clambering onto a nearby car, to avoid being bitten, is an entirely reasonable and understandable in the circumstances.

Yes, if the dog owners were sued directly by the car owners then I would expect them to argue that the reaction of jumping onto the car was an intervening event (for the purposes of denying causation) but I don't think they'd be successful.

Frlrlrubert · 19/08/2021 22:09

Yes dog bites can be nasty even from small dogs, but not so nasty I'd jump on a car to escape. Wasp stings and cat scratches can be nasty and require medical treatment, but I wouldn't jump on a car to get away from a wasp or cat either. Bull on the loose, maybe.

Assuming I was dressed for work I'd push it away with my foot, it's unlikely to bite through a shoe too badly.

I mean if the sister is on blood thinners wearing ballet flats and was in fear of her life I'll take it back.

Scarby9 · 19/08/2021 21:45

All these people saying the sister was over-reacting.

Family friends have a six year old border terrier - so a small, cute looking dog they have had from a puppy. It is absolutely not under control and they just don't take it seriously.

I met them by chance and we went for a coffee outside a cafe. The dog barked the entire time and kept jumping up and attempting to attack any other passing dog. Luckily, his lead was trapped under the chair leg so he couldn't actually reach anyone else (or me!), but the noise was incredible and really disruptive for everyone around. Every now and then, one of the couple would say 'Shush' but otherwise nothing.

They called to see my parents, went down the side of the house to the back garden, let the dog off the lead and he ran round and round barking madly, straight through the flower beds, and knocking the top off the bird bath. When they eventually caught him, BOTH showed their hands/ forearms which were covered with bite marks from the previous week bad enough to have required medical treatment. 'Sometimes he gets a bit carried away'.

Yet they still say 'He's only playing / being friendly' and can't understand why we are so wary of him.

Untrained, out of control, small dogs are scary and can cause injury. It is reasonable to try to escape.

bobandhisburgers · 19/08/2021 21:26

There wasn't a car crash though DewDew. A woman jumped on it. Completely incomparable situation. Dog is a red herring.

Frlrlrubert · 19/08/2021 21:19

She jumped on a car? That's not a normal reaction to being 'attacked' by a small yappy dog.

The owner is an idiot but really, jumping on someone's car is an over-reaction.

acolderwar · 19/08/2021 21:13

@Blueuggboots

I think you need to get a grip, it's a dog, not a tiger!!!
😂
BeautifulBirds · 19/08/2021 21:12

How big is the dog that a person has to jump on a car to escape? A cutesy small dog could just been pushed away with a foot, maybe?

Waspsarearseholes · 19/08/2021 21:10

Bloody hell, what's it like inside some of these posters' heads?

DewDew83 · 19/08/2021 21:03

Let's say you're driving a car, when another car comes speeding down the road in the wrong direction. You make an instant decision to swerve out of the way to avoid a head on collision but, in doing so, you crash into somebody else's parked car.

Yes, you caused the damage, but you only did so because of the car that was going the wrong way. If you got sued for the damage to the parked car, you (or your representatives/insurer) would claim against the other driver, for indemnity.

Same principle here.

bobandhisburgers · 19/08/2021 21:01

@DewDew83

Of course your sister should pay for the damage to the car! She caused it!!!! And what caused her to cause it?
Oh don't be silly. She caused the damage. It doesn't matter that it was an accident while escaping a tally dog. She still caused the damage!
Nobranothanks · 19/08/2021 20:58

Tbh, in response to posters saying OP is over reacting - I would say that many owners of small dogs seem to find their behaviour funny instead of concerning! If my (large oaf) dog behaved like many small dogs do I would be accuse of owning a dangerous dog and have the police called...the works! Yet I encounter many, many people out and about whose toy/small dogs bark, chase, snap and snarl at both people and my dog whilst owners stand there laughing!

My young large dog (walked on lead) is frequently growled/snarled at/followed/snapped at by small dogs - he doesn't react because I've take extra care to socialise him well however if he were to one day get the hump with a dog snapping at him etc he will be blamed, not the instigator!

Hoppinggreen · 19/08/2021 20:58

@ERest

Thanks for the replies so far. For those asking why she would jump on the car, she was already past my door, so could not run back in and short of knocking on another door while the dog had a go at her, the car must have been the obvious choice in the heat of the moment. There are no shops around here as purely residences and a park in front of the houses. The owner did not even bother to run after her dog and walked sedately to get its lead while it ran round thhe car barking constantly.
She’s still responsible for any damage to the car
DewDew83 · 19/08/2021 20:58

Of course your sister should pay for the damage to the car! She caused it!!!!
And what caused her to cause it?

frumpety · 19/08/2021 20:56

Do you know what sort of dog it is ? I know you say it makes a lot of noise but has it bitten anyone ? Of course the owner should have it under control though.

ERest · 19/08/2021 20:48

Thanks for the replies so far. For those asking why she would jump on the car, she was already past my door, so could not run back in and short of knocking on another door while the dog had a go at her, the car must have been the obvious choice in the heat of the moment. There are no shops around here as purely residences and a park in front of the houses. The owner did not even bother to run after her dog and walked sedately to get its lead while it ran round thhe car barking constantly.

OP posts: