Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Untrained neighbour dog. WWYD?

88 replies

ERest · 19/08/2021 20:25

Hello, thought I would get some opinions on the below scenario but not enabling voting as a twofold question. I live a few doors away from a family with one of those small cutey dogs, not sure what breed. It is however very fierce and frequently gets away from its owners to harass people. It has stopped me from getting down from my car before, after appearing from no where and running round my car while barking continously till the lady eventually emerged 5 minutes later to get it. That was not the first time either. This week however, it has chased my sibling twice on their way to work (she lives with me at the moment). We were all standing by the door as she left, 3 adults and my little one, so saw the entire scene unfold. The lady was walking the dog with her two kids. The older child, probably 6 or 7 was holding the dog. As soon as my sister got to street level and the dog sighted her, it tore after her and dragged the child down till she tripped. My sister had to take refuge on a car further down the street to get away from the dog! The owner just said: "the dog is just a baby, it won't bite" in a dismissive manner. This was really annoying to hear as this is a repetitive issue! To make things worse, the car owner has just come round to check if my sister was alright, but also to say her car has a scratch and it is due to be collected on Monday as it has been sold. She is planning to come back later with her husband as she is worried the buyer would not want it now. So for my AIBU which is twofold:

  1. What can be done about neighbours dog, especially if the same happens again? Can we report a dog for terrorising neighbours?
  2. If the car owner presents a bill for car scratches, who should pay it, my sister or would she be unreasonable to pass it on to the dog owner?
OP posts:
onelittlefrog · 20/08/2021 08:38

Your sister should offer to pay for the damage to the car. Jumping onto someone's car is not a normal reaction to this situation! Especially a small dog Confused I think she had a massive overreaction tbh.

As for the dog, have a serious talk with your neighbour about controlling it and keeping it on a lead. If it carries on then report to the council. Even a small dog can be reported as a dangerous dog, doesn't matter that your neighbour thinks its a "baby" if it is chasing and biting people that's not OK.

jessycake · 20/08/2021 08:25

I don't think your sister was unreasonable , I know lots of people who are terrified of spiders and although they can bite , they never chase you . I would take photos and get a few quotes , so you know you are not totally being ripped off , I think people can even come to the house and repair . A deep scratch to the metal is more expensive .

egfd2557 · 20/08/2021 08:20

Report the dog owner to the police, you can do it online. It’s illegal to have an untrained dog that chases people and tries to attack them. What if the next person it chases and bites is a small child? To own a dog you must train it to be socialised. Otherwise you are an irresponsible owner and you risk someone getting seriously hurt. Report it now.

Daphnise · 20/08/2021 08:14

It is absurd to jump on a car- wasn't there a bin she could jump in?

She should pay for the damage, and be trained.

KaptainKaveman · 20/08/2021 08:14

I second the recommendation to walk around with a big stick. Or metal pole.

Megameg56 · 20/08/2021 08:08

You and the dogowner handle this situation in the worst possible way.it appears,you are frightened of dogs and the little dog is anxious too.this combination always leads to problems.I suggest the following: make contact with the dogowner in a friendly understanding manner(you both want a happy outcome).explain your fears,but want to get to know the dog.A responsible dogowner will help with this(because she wants a positive outcome too).Once you familiarise yourself with the dog,it will stop "attacking" you.This all will take time,but leads to happy you and happy sister,happy dog/owner.

Or you and your neighbour make no effort and keep the situation as it is and feel angry and waste possibly police time.I wish you all the best!

DoWhatYouWantToAndShh · 20/08/2021 08:01

@Waspsarearseholes

Bloody hell, what's it like inside some of these posters' heads?
Very empty I assume.

Your sister should pay the repairs as it's not up to the car owners to chase payment but your sister should then go to yappy dog house and say tgeyve got 28 days to reimburse you or you'll file a dangerous dog complaint/small claims.

Small dogs can still inflict nasty bites, infection etc.

Fucking hate some dog owners.

icedcoffees · 20/08/2021 07:41

Surely you understand that an aggressive big dog is genuinely more dangerous than an aggressive small dog. It’s not rocket science.

Nobody is saying otherwise.

But small dogs do seem to get away with aggressive behaviour when large dogs wouldn't. An aggressive dog is aggressive whether it's a chihuahua or a Rottweiler.

Horst · 20/08/2021 07:38

Report the dog owner. Your sister should pay up. Technically she committed criminal damage to someone else’s property it doesn’t matter why she did it, she did it and the owner of the car would need to likely report to the police to claim off their insurance anyway thus your sister having a nice little visit. Not that they should have to claim off their insurance for your sister silly idea of an escape plan.

She had to know jumping on someone’s car was likely to scratch or maybe even dent parts.

BarkingUpTheWrongRoseBush · 20/08/2021 07:31

I no longer see a friend at her house due to her genuinely terrifying very small bitey little shit of a dog. So yes, small dogs can be dangerous.

And yes a kick would sort it out but I’m not going to kick a pet.

Climbing on a car is odd though.

I’d go over to the dog owners house and say it’s out of control.

Aprilx · 20/08/2021 07:26

@Nobranothanks

Tbh, in response to posters saying OP is over reacting - I would say that many owners of small dogs seem to find their behaviour funny instead of concerning! If my (large oaf) dog behaved like many small dogs do I would be accuse of owning a dangerous dog and have the police called...the works! Yet I encounter many, many people out and about whose toy/small dogs bark, chase, snap and snarl at both people and my dog whilst owners stand there laughing!

My young large dog (walked on lead) is frequently growled/snarled at/followed/snapped at by small dogs - he doesn't react because I've take extra care to socialise him well however if he were to one day get the hump with a dog snapping at him etc he will be blamed, not the instigator!

Surely you understand that an aggressive big dog is genuinely more dangerous than an aggressive small dog. It’s not rocket science.

In any case, it sounds like this is puppy enthusiasm and poor training rather than any danger. Jumping on a car is somebody being a drama queen and of course she should pay.

BritishSummertime · 20/08/2021 07:25

the car owner should claim from their insurers

And lose their no claims bonus through no fault.of their own and pay the excess? I wouldn't want to do that for a scratch.

It's not clear if the dog was just barking or barking aggressively, snarling etc. My friend has a little fluffy toy dog which barks when it sees new people but it's just excited and then rolls.onto its back for tummy strokes, very different to barking and snarling

MoreAloneTime · 20/08/2021 07:24

I'd be pretty freaked out if a dog ran after me barking and could well imagine panicking and climbing something. It's a dangerous situation and it doesn't sound like they are cut out to be dog owners.

lannistunut · 20/08/2021 06:51

Why wait for another incident? Report what has happened so far.

KangarooSally · 20/08/2021 06:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn deleted by MNHQ

lannistunut · 20/08/2021 06:41

I would report the whole incident, all of the dog incidents, to the police. It is illegal to have a dog dangerously out of control and that is what is happening. The car decision makes sense to me. Who has liability to pay for damage I do not know - it was not vandalism due to the reason for doing it.

If that dog was chasing a child there could be a road accident, it needs sorting out. All they need is a lead FFS.

icedcoffees · 20/08/2021 06:31

@Yahtze

She fled from a ....Pomeranian puppy? This must be a wind up. Just because it barks doesn't mean it will bite. It's likely trying to play. The owner should be in control of it and it's not ok to let it bark at people but this seems like a massive over reaction. Just stand still and it will give you sniff and bugger off.
Pomeranians can have nasty bites - as can all small/toy dogs.

Just because the dog is small doesn't mean it can't be vicious. The most aggressive dogs I know are Jack Russells and Dachshunds!

Yahtze · 20/08/2021 04:52

She fled from a ....Pomeranian puppy? This must be a wind up. Just because it barks doesn't mean it will bite. It's likely trying to play. The owner should be in control of it and it's not ok to let it bark at people but this seems like a massive over reaction. Just stand still and it will give you sniff and bugger off.

LemonLemonLemon · 20/08/2021 04:26

This annoys me so much. People seem to think that having a small dog absolves them of the responsibility of training it. I have a large GSD type dog - if she did this, I’m sure she’d be reported. Please report OP, as others have said, small dogs can still give a nasty bite - especially to children

messybun101 · 20/08/2021 03:54

I mean if the sister is on blood thinners wearing ballet flats and was in fear of her life I'll take it back.

Grin
crowsfeet57 · 20/08/2021 02:41

Presumably the car is insured. In this situation the car owner should claim from their insurers who will make a decision about whether to pursue the OP's sister to recover their costs.

The OP's sister could, at that point decide whether to claim the money back from the dog's owner, who should, as a minimum have insurance covering her for third party claims.

In the meantime the OP's sister should report the incident to the dog warden or the police. The dog was clearly out of control and I say that as a dog owner.

paddlingon · 20/08/2021 02:35

We have a dog so aren't anti dog.

But DH got badly bitten by a toy dog, he needed a lot of stitches.

Small dogs also have nasty bite capability.

XelaM · 20/08/2021 02:12

By the way (for next time) running away from a dog just makes it want to chase. That's not a good reaction if you want the dog to leave.

@EKGEMS That's quite a different situation. A Pit Bull can kill you. A small Pomeranian can't maul an adult woman

EKGEMS · 20/08/2021 02:00

I'd have called the police the second after your sister climbed down from her perch! My sister years ago got chased by a pit bull who broke out of his fenced in yard as she walked from a bus stop she ran into an intersection and a lady in her car let her jump inside to escape from being attacked. Until the authorities take control I'd carry a Louisville slugger with me

ERest · 20/08/2021 01:16

@Blueuggboots*@Hankunamatata @gardeninggirl68* views noted about the damage and the car owner is more than justified to be upset in this scenario. The aibu though is who about who is responsible for the scratches, as one action caused the reaction that led to the scratches.
I agree @DinkyDiggies. dogs frighten some people and most people who grew up comfortably around dogs do not understand this or see things beyond their context at times.
Thanks. @DewDew83
@XelaM actually, we don't know that wasn't its intention as she didn't wait around to be bitten.
@lyntheyresexpeople yes, I imagine the car owner will be upset, but my sister did not see the car and think:' ooh, that would make a lovely trampoline.'
Thanks @aerosocks @tac@TacoSunday. Good advice
@Waspsarearseholes*@Scarby9@Pottedpalm @Nobranothanks* thanks for understanding this!
@frumpety I am not sure. Looks like a pomeranian but I am not 100% certain. I can't know if it has bitten anyone yet as that would mean knocking on doors to ask as I doubt the owner would volunteer suchh information.
Sorry. If I have missed anyone's questions.

OP posts: