Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Untrained neighbour dog. WWYD?

88 replies

ERest · 19/08/2021 20:25

Hello, thought I would get some opinions on the below scenario but not enabling voting as a twofold question. I live a few doors away from a family with one of those small cutey dogs, not sure what breed. It is however very fierce and frequently gets away from its owners to harass people. It has stopped me from getting down from my car before, after appearing from no where and running round my car while barking continously till the lady eventually emerged 5 minutes later to get it. That was not the first time either. This week however, it has chased my sibling twice on their way to work (she lives with me at the moment). We were all standing by the door as she left, 3 adults and my little one, so saw the entire scene unfold. The lady was walking the dog with her two kids. The older child, probably 6 or 7 was holding the dog. As soon as my sister got to street level and the dog sighted her, it tore after her and dragged the child down till she tripped. My sister had to take refuge on a car further down the street to get away from the dog! The owner just said: "the dog is just a baby, it won't bite" in a dismissive manner. This was really annoying to hear as this is a repetitive issue! To make things worse, the car owner has just come round to check if my sister was alright, but also to say her car has a scratch and it is due to be collected on Monday as it has been sold. She is planning to come back later with her husband as she is worried the buyer would not want it now. So for my AIBU which is twofold:

  1. What can be done about neighbours dog, especially if the same happens again? Can we report a dog for terrorising neighbours?
  2. If the car owner presents a bill for car scratches, who should pay it, my sister or would she be unreasonable to pass it on to the dog owner?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EKGEMS · 20/08/2021 16:04

@XelaM Thanks for the clarification-I would've prolly yelled to dog owner "Control him or they're going to get kicked" and followed through and I love dogs

WiddlinDiddlin · 20/08/2021 15:44

@igelkott2021

Do be warned if it is a small fluffy breed, theres a good chance you won't be taken very seriously if the owner IS already taking action

Really? I find it's usually the smaller dogs that are yappy and snappy and the larger dogs just walk past you and show no interest whatsoever.

Yes it is often small dogs that are yappy.. thats not what I said.

I said IF it is reported, and they are already taking things seriously its likely further action won't be taken, because its a little dog.

If it were a big dog, even IF action is already being taken by the owners, theres a good chance dog warden would take things further, simply because bigger dogs are much more likely to do more damage, whether friendly or not, due to their size.

The law states that a dog must cause someone 'reasonable apprehension of injury'... a court may deem it NOT reasonable to be scared of a tiny fluffy dog in some situations.. (and they may think it totally reasonable in others), no matter how dog phobic the person making the complaint happens to be.

zingally · 20/08/2021 12:23

I'd just equip myself with some firm boots for next time I was out...

But perhaps more sensibly, report your neighbour for having a dangerous dog.

ERest · 20/08/2021 12:18

Thank you all for your thoughts, advice and views. They have been truly helpful including those that think it was an over reaction. We have now reported this to the council and they have confirmed they will pass it on to the dog warden as they agree this is a nuisance dog situation. They have also advised that we report it to the police as the owner does not seem to be able to control their dog.
We will deal with the car situation when/if they turn up.
I am unlikely to post any more updates except something unexpected happens. Have a lovely weekend, you lovely mumsnetters!

OP posts:
nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut · 20/08/2021 12:17

She jumped on a car to get away from a tiny dog? Seriously? Of course she has to pay for the damage, it doesn't matter how it happened.

Why on earth didn't she just kick it away from her? It's not exactly a Dobermann is it?

I love dogs but if an aggressive little one attacked me, I wouldn't be running from it or hiding in my car, just kick it, it'll think twice before doing it again.

LongTimeMammaBear · 20/08/2021 11:27

It does not matter if it was a large dog, small dog or puppy. It is aggressive and not under control of it’s owner. Your sister was frightened and did what she could to remove herself from any potential injury.

Most definitely report to police or dog warden. In fact, perhaps police to get a police report in regards to the damage to the car.

I think getting a dog repellent or dog horn to have in hand until this person sorts out the dog (if they ever do) as clearly they’re bad dog owners. Use the repellent or dog horn as needed. They’ll soon walk another route at least.

IridescentPurple · 20/08/2021 11:21

but I wouldn't jump on a car to get away from a wasp or cat either
But a cat or a wasp could follow you. There'd be no point.

IridescentPurple · 20/08/2021 11:16

She jumped on a car? That's not a normal reaction to being 'attacked' by a small yappy dog

Yes it is. Maybe unusual, but perfectly normal. I know two people who've had to do it.

bellabasset · 20/08/2021 11:13

The dog owner needs to be reported to the police as it was out of control and could have caused a more serious incident. When walking it's advisable to use a harness, and to be careful not to use an extendable lead in crowded areas.

I've had five dogs of my own that I was able to physically hold when lead walking. You have to accept that there are people who are nervous around dogs and be considerate.

Your sister will probably have to pay for any damage she did to the car at least initially but I think she should seek to reclaim it from the dog owner.

Angryfrommanchester1 · 20/08/2021 11:09

Yes to reporting. I’ve suffered from a chihuahua type dog chasing me and being aggressive and it’s very unpleasant, it’s known for being a nasty little sod and it’s owner indulges it.
TBH if i found myself in the situation where it did it again I’d kick it off me.

HarrisMcCoo · 20/08/2021 10:52

Report to your local dog warden. Out of control dogm

ERest · 20/08/2021 10:50

Thanks and we will wait to see what the car owner comes back with. They are yet to turn up, so may be getting quotes and all. Seems like the greater consensus is to pay for the scratches then pursue the dog owner for the cost as well as get the to train their dog either through the warden or a police report. I have no idea if we have a dog warden, but my council is not small so fairly sure we should.
I really don’t want to hit a dog as I love animals and so does my sister. We grew up with several, and I have seen many, many well behaved dogs on my walks which I even stroke where the owner is happy for me to, as I don’t stroke strange dogs even if they come up to me for one without permission.
This one does look really crazed, and walking about with an umbrella every time we leave the house for a walk is not practical to be honest as we are more likely to forget than not. They have only be here since the spring too, so too many incidences already which seem to be escalating. We will report this, so at least have some evidence if this continues or it escalates to a bite. It has chased my 8 year old previously and he had to run back home. I don’t want a Situation where we are now too scared to get exercise because a dog is only ‘yappy’ as some responses have indicated. I have also seen this dog fly out of their kitchen window to chase someone, as their house design has their kitchen facing the street and the large window is easily to climb out of if a table or chair is close to it.

OP posts:
SundaySheAteChocolate · 20/08/2021 10:40

@Yahtze

She fled from a ....Pomeranian puppy? This must be a wind up. Just because it barks doesn't mean it will bite. It's likely trying to play. The owner should be in control of it and it's not ok to let it bark at people but this seems like a massive over reaction. Just stand still and it will give you sniff and bugger off.
The sister ran and the dog ran after her, obviously the dog was going to chase.

I sympathise, but if people are that scared of dogs they could also help themselves by learning what behaviours are likely to get the reaction they don't want.

Flowerlane · 20/08/2021 10:19

You need to report the dog owner doesn’t matter if it’s a puppy or only little she has no control over it.

As for the car unfortunately I think your sister needs to pay for the damage caused. There is no way the dog owner will pay for it even if you asked her to as it was your sister who caused the damage not her or her dog.
I won’t lie if someone damaged my car because they were getting away from a dog and there was damage then I would ask them to pay for it. The car owner is the innocent party in all this that your sister has now involved, she needs to take responsibility for the damage she caused and pay up.

igelkott2021 · 20/08/2021 10:07

Do be warned if it is a small fluffy breed, theres a good chance you won't be taken very seriously if the owner IS already taking action

Really? I find it's usually the smaller dogs that are yappy and snappy and the larger dogs just walk past you and show no interest whatsoever.

igelkott2021 · 20/08/2021 10:05

@Blueuggboots

I think you need to get a grip, it's a dog, not a tiger!!!
Erm dogs have killed people!

OP do you have a dog warden at your local council? You can report it to them. Both on grounds of your own welfare (and your sister's) and the dog's, which isn't being trained.

WiddlinDiddlin · 20/08/2021 09:37

This is what the dangerous dogs act is for.

This dog is dangerously out of control in a public place, repeatedly, and you have feared injury - it will be up to a court to decide if your fear of injury was reasonable or not.

Pay the car person.
Take evidence of that bill to dog person.
Inform dog person that they have x days to pay up and that their dog is dangerously out of control which is an offence.

I'd contact the dog warden first and then the police if that doesn't result in action being taken.

It does sound like they've no idea they are committing an offence or that anyone might have a legitimate complaint, if the dog IS actually over excited and has no intention of biting, that might be understandable (many people do not understand that the law doesn't need a dog to bite or even to intend to, a playful happy dog CAN fall foul of that law), so I'd give them one further chance but if they refuse to pay up... I'd shop em to the warden and the police, yep.

Do be warned if it is a small fluffy breed, theres a good chance you won't be taken very seriously if the owner IS already taking action.

Sadiecow · 20/08/2021 09:32

@Nobranothanks

Tbh, in response to posters saying OP is over reacting - I would say that many owners of small dogs seem to find their behaviour funny instead of concerning! If my (large oaf) dog behaved like many small dogs do I would be accuse of owning a dangerous dog and have the police called...the works! Yet I encounter many, many people out and about whose toy/small dogs bark, chase, snap and snarl at both people and my dog whilst owners stand there laughing!

My young large dog (walked on lead) is frequently growled/snarled at/followed/snapped at by small dogs - he doesn't react because I've take extra care to socialise him well however if he were to one day get the hump with a dog snapping at him etc he will be blamed, not the instigator!

This is true!

However I think your sister will be responsible for the car damage .

Chickychickydodah · 20/08/2021 09:24

Carry a water pistol or a big stick, get someone to try to video it then report .

AdventuresDownRabbitholes · 20/08/2021 09:10

Report dog owner to relevant authority. Carry a stick or umbrella to fend it off in future. Report any and all subsequent attacks

Hitting a dog with a stick is going to inflame the situation - a dog that would never actually have bitten otherwise, but is attacked with a stick or umbrella, will be quite justified in attacking back.

There's no evidence this was an attack. By the OPs admission it is a Pomeranian puppy who has run around barking, quite likely in excitement. They're a breed that pretty much barks for the sake of it.

Itsokay2020 · 20/08/2021 09:08

Another dog owner here and this dog absolutely needs to be reported! It is completely unacceptable to have a dog that is out of control, in a public place. Shame on the (lazy) owner who has failed to train it and now has a feral dog on her hands! It doesn’t matter if it’s cute and fluffy, or big and surly, all dog owners need to take responsibility

Brefugee · 20/08/2021 09:00

In Germany this would be solved between sister and dog owner's third party insurance.

In this case I think your sister should cough up and try to recover costs from dog owner (or try to pass directly to dog owner). Either way car owner must be compensated from what I think I'd bizarre behaviour (although I do get sister was very frightened.

Report dog owner to relevant authority. Carry a stick or umbrella to fend it off in future. Report any and all subsequent attacks

AdventuresDownRabbitholes · 20/08/2021 08:52

@DinkyDiggies

I’m a dog owner and lover, but don’t necessarily think your sister was unreasonable to jump on a car. While I’d confidently take on a small dog, if you’d said ‘whacking great Alsatian/Doberman/Rottweiler’ then I’d definitely be jumping on a car to get away. I think some people are more naturally frightened of dogs, and even a small one is scary. Cultural sensitivity seems to be lacking in some of the comments as I’ve found people who may not be of White European heritage don’t have a culture of pet owning, and view our ‘cute little pups’ as dirty disease carrying beasts with the potential to savage one on sight. I lived in Wembley for a while, and a crowded street would part like the Red Sea when I took my little King Charles Spaniel (who was the kindest sweetest looking little dog you could ever wish to see) down the road. A great tall youth jumped out of my way shouting ‘get that thing away from me’ when she walked past on a lead and turned as though to sniff him. I googled this and read that dogs are considered impure in Islam, and that ritual washing may be required after contact. The dog has caused alarm and distress which is against the law. Report to police. If you receive bill for car, pass to dog owner. I would hope their pet is insured...?
This was what was in the back of my mind when I asked if the OP had any experience with dogs - a question she hasn't answered.

I live in an area that's similarly ethically diverse to Wembley. On one occasion little DDog wandered slowly in the direction of a park bench, because he wanted to sniff it (he has no interest whatsoever in strangers, it really was the bench he wanted to smell).

The four strapping young men all leaped on top of the bench. They were concerned he might attack them. It was very, very clear that none of them had even the slightest idea of how to read a dog's body language as DDog had done nothing to suggest he might attack.

Younger children in that park tend to be curious, and consider it a little daring to touch a dog. They often want to come and talk to me about him. I know DDog won't fling himself at them, but nor will he bite, so he's turned out to be quite good in that situation. I take the time to talk to children about letting a dog come to them / asking permission before touching a dog / gently stroking a dog on its back as being a good way to interact / dogs will sniff you because that's how they say hello. It invariably seems like brand new information to them.

It's pretty evident that lots of children from South Asian and middle Eastern backgrounds just aren't brought up with the sort of cultural knowledge about dogs that most others have.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 20/08/2021 08:46

Small dogs can be very aggressive. A JRT can be cutesy but watch them go after a rat. You shouldnt have to be chased by dog. However, jumping on a car is OTT and your sister needs to pay for that damage. If a small dog is that aggressive and is moving to bite you'd be justified in pushing it away firmly with your foot, which is what I'd have done.

If the dog keeps running at you off lead, I would report the neighbour to a dog warden who can maybe apply a bit of pressure, train the dog/keep it on a lead/use a muzzle or lose it.

SoupDragon · 20/08/2021 08:45

Taking an umbrella is probably easier than taking a stick (and looks less odd if you're going to work!).

Your sister needs to pay for any damage to the car if asked and would then probably need to go through small claims court if she wanted to claim it off the dog owner. The "fix on your doorstep" companies like Chips Away are very good and cheaper than a body shop.

Swipe left for the next trending thread