Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My garden, my business?

116 replies

ImprobablePuffin · 19/08/2021 12:10

Background: I live in an HA property. I'm a SEN with two SEN children. They have a lot of sensory needs among many other things.

I would like to have a part of my front garden as a wildflower meadow, partly for sensory reasons, partly because I love nature and think it's far more beautiful than a perfectly kept lawn etc.

Anyway I tried to do this a couple of years ago but the neighbour (not HA - possibly relevant) complained to the HA about the 'overgrown' garden and I was threatened with an ASBO unless we cut all the wildflowers and grasses down (I didn't even know you could get an ASBO for this!)

So I cut all the flowers down and now the garden looks awful in my opinion. I don't have time to garden which is why I wanted a natural wildflower garden. Next door spend a lot of time tending their front garden, they are child free by choice and have time to do this. Having two SEN kids does not afford me this luxury, so out the front nothing pretty grows.
I also know some people think wildflowers look messy which is why I wonder if AIBU.

My question is AIBU for planting the wildflowers? WIBU if I did it again? Why does the neighbours preference trump mine? If I owned my property they wouldn't get a say, so why do they get a say just because I needed a HA property due to not being able to work because of the kids. It all just feels a bit unfair.

OP posts:
memberofthewedding · 19/08/2021 16:52

Have you tried approaching the HA, explaining that you and your DC have special needs, and asking for permission? Under the Equality Act they have a duty to make "reasonable adjustment" for disabilities. If you get their permission to grow wild flowers that will trump anything the whingey neighbour might say.

Saz12 · 19/08/2021 16:44

Honestly, you could have a very wild patch so long as you mowed perfectly symmetrical path, or spiral, or circle or other clear and definite shape through it. It makes it look deliberate and cared for rather than abandoned mess. It’s a bugger to lay it out the first time, but after that it’s much quicker than mowing the whole area would be.

Just sprinkling flower seed over established grass and never mowing it won’t make for a good wildflower patch.

RampantIvy · 19/08/2021 16:25

If you don't work and your children are at school how are you not finding the time to do a bit of gardening?

I like the wild flower look, but I agree that you need to tame some of your garden so it doesn't look neglected.

Tal45 · 19/08/2021 16:12

The beautiful flower meadow pictured is unfortunately not going to come back year after year unless the soil is ploughed or it is resown so unlikely to be suitable for the time poor OP or even the average garden. They are annuals that have evolved to reseed in a ploughed corn field, they need the earth to be disturbed. That's why so many wild meadows are rubbish the second year.

A flower meadow doesn't mean no work - especially when you have to cut it and it's thigh high. I have perennials - ox eye daisies, musk mallow, scabious, yarrow, vetch, knapweed, forget me nots, buttercups, campions etc and have to cut the grass heads back so they don't self seed and take over during the summer and then cut the whole thing back early September. If your flower meadow is in small areas such as beds I think it's really important to ensure it is more flowers and less grass or it looks a mess - if it's a bigger area you can get away with more grass and perhaps mow a path through it to show it's not just been left when there aren't many flowers blooming.

I would consider not worrying too much about wild flowers and just grow some reliable perennials or reliable self seeders if you're just doing it in borders - the insects don't know the difference as long as they can get to the nectar. Good old nasturtiums are really easy to grow from seed and like poor soil that hasn't been improved, I've had huge success with growing calendula from seed as well in my heavy clay soil that I struggle to grow anything in, musk mallow I think is gorgeous and also grew easily from seed. If you have a shady part then the bees love pulmonaria and it doesn't need any looking after or you could grow some herbs, chives, thyme, rosemary, mint (mint is a bit of a thug though so watch out there!) and all are popular with bees.

chesirecat99 · 19/08/2021 15:22

the bits that need mowing get mowed

That's the thing, wildflower meadows do need cutting still, OP.

chesirecat99 · 19/08/2021 15:19

@LemonSwan

Use pictoral meadows mixes - they are designed for an extra long season so you dont get that messy bit mid summer onwards.

Use a few bits of turf round the edges. So you have a grass edge which you can mow occasionally. This makes it look neat, cared for and purposeful.

Yes, Pictorial Meadows have great mixes. OP needs a perennial mix if she wants it to come back year after year without needing to clear the earth and reseed annually. She will still need to weed out any self-seeded undesirable plants and grass that will outcompete the wild flowers she wants and cut it back and clear it several times over the summer.

Also, you can't mix them with grass like the OP says she did. Her DC won't be able to play in it without damaging it either. They do have some mixes that can take light pedestrian use though.

www.pictorialmeadows.co.uk/product-category/perennial-meadow-seeds/

Goldbar · 19/08/2021 15:15

I think you need to edge it properly so you're clearly defining your garden and it's separate from your neighbour's. I'd get some wooden garden edging and use it to make a couple of wildflower 'beds' with a defined shape. Then I'd use some scrap or reclaimed wood or garden tiles to make a path in between the beds and have a spot for a garden bench or chair.

someonelockthefridgealready · 19/08/2021 14:59

I would use that information posted up thread to make a case for having a wildflower garden and try going to the HA first to get them on board before doing it.

LemonSwan · 19/08/2021 14:49

Use pictoral meadows mixes - they are designed for an extra long season so you dont get that messy bit mid summer onwards.

Use a few bits of turf round the edges. So you have a grass edge which you can mow occasionally. This makes it look neat, cared for and purposeful.

IntermittentParps · 19/08/2021 14:41

The HA were going to give me an ASBO but I basically explained about the situation with the kids etc and she said she would 'sort it' so I didn't get one
I'm a bit confused. Do you mean you would have been allowed to keep the wildflower garden?

SilverDragonfly1 · 19/08/2021 14:18

I live in an HA house and have rewilded the front garden- not the back as that would not be good for poo picking (we have a dog and foxes also like to visit us). It would also be too easy for potentially poisonous plants to seed there- front garden is much smaller and can be properly managed. You do need to actively manage wild gardens to ensure nothing is taking over but it's much more enjoyable than trying to keep everything pristine as you're working with nature, not against it.

I keep an 18 inch wide 'courtesy strip' along the path and the side adjacent to the pavement strimmed short so that no one walking by or making deliveries needs to worry about pollen or wet plants on their clothes.

If the HA made a fuss, I think my answer would be along the lines of 'sure, as soon as you've fixed all the dangerous, crumbling concrete which is what actually makes the garden look crummy, I'll be happy to compromise'. Also how would you get an ASBO? It's some long grass, not mattresses and rat-attracting rubbish!

Hekatestorch · 19/08/2021 14:13

Wild flower gardens do take quite a bit of work though.

I think its just difficult to imagine because we aren't there

On the one hand you could imagine a lovely wildflower meadow type effect. On the otherhand, it could really easily just look like no one's bothered and its neglected.

If you can balance it so you have the wildflowers, but also keep bits neat, it should be a wint win for you

ImprobablePuffin · 19/08/2021 14:11

@Chloemol

Yes YABU. Whilst I understand what you want to do wildflowers look messy, and most front gardens are not wildflower meadows. If you want to do it at the back, where no one sees then ok

If you don’t have time to do the grant garden grass it so you only need to mow and put wildflowers in pots. Or pave it over

Eurgh but paving it over is literally the worst thing you could do environmentally and I refuse to do that because my neighbours are dicks.
OP posts:
ImprobablePuffin · 19/08/2021 14:09

@zingally the HA absolutely do not help you if you say you are struggling. I've tried. My kids couldn't go in their own garden for 3 years because HA refused to help me make it safe for the kids.

OP posts:
ImprobablePuffin · 19/08/2021 14:08

@zingally

There is a difference between "wild flower meadow", and "I haven't got time to mow."... Be really, really honest with yourself. You don't need to say it here, but which is it?

Problem is, in a HA house, there is a certain amount of "you have to toe the line." For the sake of a once a fortnight mow, it's really not worth getting on the HA mental list as "difficult neighbours".

There's absolutely nothing wrong with you having a conversation with the HA, and being honest and saying "I'm having trouble keeping on top of the garden, because of XYZ reason." They WILL help you, and appreciate the honesty.

Ok being really really honest with myself....I like wildflower gardens. It's not a case of not mowing, the bits that need mowing get mowed I just wanted some wildflowers in the existing beds because I don't have time to faff about and I'm very pro bee conservation
OP posts:
chesirecat99 · 19/08/2021 14:06

The HA are being unreasonable if you have a well maintained wildflower bed.

TBH though, if you just chuck a packet of wildflower seeds and grass down, they probably will soon look a mess and be a nuisance invading your neighbours' gardens and little help to the bees after the first year.

A wildflower meadow like Wimowehwimowehwimowehwimoweh posted takes maintenance, @ImprobablePuffin. You'll have to dig it up every year. Poppies, cornflowers and all those beautiful wild flowers are pioneer species so they need bare earth for their seeds to grow next year, otherwise they will outcompeted by grass and less "pretty" wildflowers. Although they will probably find the find the bare earth they need in your neighbour's neatly tended flower beds Grin

Although we need to plant native species to support bees, bee bombs and those mixed packets of seeds that have grass seed mixed in are not a great way to do that and you will probably just end up with an overgrown mess the next year of mostly grass with few flowers and not the pretty wildflowers you want. Wild flower beds are certainly not low maintenance.

Why don't you come over to the gardening board and see if we can come up with ideas for a low maintenance, sensory garden of native flowers that won't revert to grass (no good for bees) and come back every year?

ImprobablePuffin · 19/08/2021 14:05

@IntermittentParps

Ridiculous. Wildflower gardens are becoming more and more important. In my neighbourhood there are lots, including on traffic islands and in council estates.

I also don't think you should have to muck about with borders and planters as people here are suggesting. Just plant them and fuck the neighbours. They need a life if they're so upset by someone else's flowers and tall grass.

When you say 'threatened with an ASBO' do you mean formally/legally? or just that someone said it to you? I'd be looking into/asking the council exactly what you can get an ASBO for.

Wildflower gardens just look messy, sorry. Nobody wants to live in a messy, overgrown area and if it brings the tone of the place down then you either need to tidy it up into a proper garden or give it up.
Hyacinth Bucket is here Grin

The HA were going to give me an ASBO but I basically explained about the situation with the kids etc and she said she would 'sort it' so I didn't get one
OP posts:
ImprobablePuffin · 19/08/2021 13:57

@pinkcircustop

Wildflower gardens just look messy, sorry. Nobody wants to live in a messy, overgrown area and if it brings the tone of the place down then you either need to tidy it up into a proper garden or give it up.
Sorry give up my house because I don't have time to garden?
OP posts:
ImprobablePuffin · 19/08/2021 13:56

@Dixiechickonhols

What does your tenancy agreement say? You must have been in breach of agreement for them to take action. Can’t you have wildflowers at back and have front in keeping with neighbours. Private owners it’s their house so can do what they like unless there are covenants.
No I can't keep the front 'in keeping' with the neighbours as I don't have the time to meet their standards.

Tenancy agreement was not breached. HA say they have to take complaints seriously no matter what they are.

For context, the same neighbours complained about the minibus (that comes and collects the kids for school as their school is an hour away) and the HA said because of the complaint the mini bus wasn't allowed down our road anymore. I kicked up a stink on that one because my children shouldn't have to suffer for the neighbours preferences

OP posts:
theemmadilemma · 19/08/2021 13:35

@LookItsMeAgain

Our local council has started planting wildflower beds in the central median of our local roads around here. It's lovely to see. They are exactly like the image that *@Wimowehwimowehwimowehwimoweh* posted up. Loads of colour. We've been narrowing the types of pollen that bees collect and that is impacting on the global environment. The more diversity there is the better. I would be telling the council and nosey neighbours that I'm doing my bit for the environment and for the planet and I'm not cutting down my wildflowers. Let them take me to court first!
Same here. Rotherham? They extended it again this year and it's just beautiful to see!
Hedgesfullofbirds · 19/08/2021 13:33

Well, isn't this a sad state of affairs - along with hedges constantly being manicured to 'perfection' by tidy minded 'gardeners' fake grass and paved front gardens, it is now infra dig to dare to have any wild flowers in one's garden! Thank the Lord I live very rurally with no neighbours and can leave my hedges uncut until autumn to allow birds to nest and support other wildlife. My lawns are full of clover, self heal, buttercups, black medic, trefoil and many other wild flowers and the garden is full of insects - I would have it no other way, even if I had moany neighbours.

DismantledKing · 19/08/2021 13:26

@EvenRosesHaveThorns

As for wildflowers bringing a place down... What a loathesome contempt for nature and plant life
This
Moonface123 · 19/08/2021 13:24

My front garden is full of foxgloves, Hollyhocks and poppies. They seed very easily, and the bees and butterflies love them. I do have a very very small lawn that l try and keep neat. I have small wooden hanging signs such wild and free, wild flower garden etc, to justify the relaxed natural look.

LookItsMeAgain · 19/08/2021 13:21

Our local council has started planting wildflower beds in the central median of our local roads around here. It's lovely to see. They are exactly like the image that @Wimowehwimowehwimowehwimoweh posted up. Loads of colour.
We've been narrowing the types of pollen that bees collect and that is impacting on the global environment. The more diversity there is the better.
I would be telling the council and nosey neighbours that I'm doing my bit for the environment and for the planet and I'm not cutting down my wildflowers. Let them take me to court first!

EvenRosesHaveThorns · 19/08/2021 13:21

As for wildflowers bringing a place down... What a loathesome contempt for nature and plant life

Swipe left for the next trending thread