Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents don’t think I should have another baby

292 replies

Mummy940908 · 19/08/2021 12:07

My fiancé and I want to try for another baby. We have a 5year old and 2 year old twins. Only issue is my parents seem to think we shouldn’t have any more especially my dad. and they just kick off about it without anyone even mentioning it. I can’t do right for doing wrong when it comes to my parents. If it was my younger sister 16,it’s a different story and the best thing ever. Any advice on how to tell them we are pregnant when the time comes would be appreciated or what you would do in this situation as it’s really not helping my anxiety. I want to add we also DONT rely on them for childcare or financial purposes EITHER. If anything it’s my mum relying on me for babysitting my 2 youngest sisters 8,9.

OP posts:
SudokuZebra · 20/08/2021 11:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DemBonesDemBones · 20/08/2021 10:48

@GreyhoundG1rl yet you've decided all sorts of negative things based on the same information. This is a really horrible thread, with a couple of really judgemental and nasty contributors. I'm going to hide it now.
Good luck op!

Legoisawesome · 20/08/2021 10:40

Oh weird I have no idea how this has posted on the wrong thread 😂 skills

Legoisawesome · 20/08/2021 10:39

Talk to the mum, explain about your child additional needs and ask if they are ok with that or would they prefer you come along incase anything happens. My experience is some people are fine with it and others feel out of their depth and without asking you won’t know. Both of my children are neurodiverse.

Lavender24 · 20/08/2021 10:36

@Booboosweet

Sounds like you have enough on your plate and your parents are giving sensible advice.
Yes, this.
Erwhatno · 20/08/2021 10:22

Well quite

Mreggsworth · 20/08/2021 09:23

@Jamdown123

I have compassion for those on the planet already and for future generations. When I have a child I want that child to live a long fulfilling life, away from threat and terror and I want that child to be able to have a child who has the same. The more people who decide to have multiple children, the more that slips away. I think it's far more compassionate to worry about the children already on the planet and the future of the human race than it is to worry if you should be having multiple children.

And you dont need to justify anything. I dont care how many children you have, me alongside many others believe that its not ideal for people to have more than 2, but have any point have I asked for you to explain why you or anyone has had more than 2?

Someone posted in response to the OP that they should consider the environment impact before having more kids. That was met by very illogical arguments such as "bet those who say that go abroad on holiday" or "well people already exist so you might aswell have as many children as you like" - I was simply pointing out those arguments are empty and meaningless.

No one is asking you (well I'm not) to justify having multiple kids, if they make you happy, that works best for your family and life style then great, really. But some have without being asked got defensive and tried to justify having multiple children and minimising the environmental issue. There is literally no way of justifying your decision as being anything but negative for the environment, if you have multiple children and are happy with your decision, just don't bother commenting on the environmental issues associated with multiple children.

NewlyGranny · 20/08/2021 09:10

My experience of having and raising twins was that it made me super organised! You just have to be. I remember having the massive end to end double pushchair out of the boot, tackled up and both babies strapped in while my friend with one baby was still faffing about.

It's nobody's business but yours how many children you have. For every couple who want three or more there are people deciding against parenthood altogether. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Jamdown123 · 20/08/2021 09:04

They may grow up and decide they don't want to work or just have lots of children themselves

Which means they are less valuable human beings?

This thread is a true stinker.

I really hope all of those posters who have said x number of babies is too much for the earth to sustain, do not have ANY children at all. That would make sense to me. End your line here.

I'm not going to read this thread again, it's horrendous. I wonder how I can stop the notifications coming through....

lynsey91 · 20/08/2021 08:56

@LilQueenie

Hmm To those saying 4 kids is too many and its bleeding the world dry may I remind you that we have lost 4.4 million in the last year and a half.

What can you get from a 4th kid that you can't get from 3? Well another human being who deserves as much love as the rest. You might even get an adult in 18 years who creates a live saving drug or some other useful idea to help humanity or YOUR kids.

OP It kind of reads that your parents are concerned that you might not be able to manage so many young kids and that leaves them without a babysitter for your siblings.

We may have lost 4.4 million but the world is still far too overcrowded. Why do people pretend it isn't?

No one NEEDS 4 children, they don't even need 3. The more children you have the less time and attention you can give each one. It's pretty obvious really.

Some people try and justify having so many children by saying "they may grow up to cure cancer/solve all the climate change problems blah blah blah". The chances are pretty remote. They may grow up and decide they don't want to work or just have lots of children themselves

UserStillatLarge · 20/08/2021 08:32

@GreyhoundG1rl

I'd say she's doing an excellent job, actually. You have no idea what sort of job she (or anybody else) is doing based on a few lines on an Internet forum.
Agree. It really annoys me when posters say "you're doing an excellent job" when actually we know nothing at all about how good or otherwise the OP's parenting is.
GreyhoundG1rl · 20/08/2021 01:04

I'd say she's doing an excellent job, actually.
You have no idea what sort of job she (or anybody else) is doing based on a few lines on an Internet forum.

DemBonesDemBones · 20/08/2021 00:22

All these 'you have enough on your plate' comments are rage inducing. YOU might 'have enough on your plate' with 3 children, but there are many people that don't find it that difficult. Some of us gasp enjoy our children. Some find parenting easier than others. Indeed, the op looks after her younger siblings as well as her own children. I'd say she's doing an excellent job, actually.

Booboosweet · 19/08/2021 23:53

Sounds like you have enough on your plate and your parents are giving sensible advice.

Jamdown123 · 19/08/2021 23:42

[quote Mreggsworth]@Jamdown123

Can you not see the massive flaw in the argument "well if you exist and are exuding CO2 then why can't I bring multiple more CO2 exuding humans to the world" ?

So just because we exist, its hypocritical to have an opinion that having multiple children is bad for the environment? So only those who decide to kill themselves can express concern that the world is overpopulated Hmm

And if everyone just kept having multiple children just on the rare chance that theyll be the solution when theyll more likely be part of the problem the world would be even more screwed.

If you want 3,4,5,6 children etc, go ahead and do it because it makes you happy, but just dont in anyway try to justify the decision as being anything but damaging to the earth and future generations.[/quote]
Can you not see the massive flaw in the argument "well if you exist and are exuding CO2 then why can't I bring multiple more CO2 exuding humans to the world" ?

I can't see the flaw in the argument, no. If you're here why can't our children be here?

So just because we exist, its hypocritical to have an opinion that having multiple children is bad for the environment? So only those who decide to kill themselves can express concern that the world is overpopulated hmm

Now THAT does seem logical.

I think people can live responsibly, and they should. But I don't presume to know how they will live or prejudge them, as you clearly do.

I have had more than two children and I care so little for your narrow-minded opinions that I wouldn't try to justify my decisions to you. You clearly have little compassionate ability, or the ability to put yourself into another person's shoes, or to imagine a life different to yours with different motivations, needs and desires.

It's pitiful that you even write about human beings as no more than damaging to the earth. How dare you talk about anyone like that? Really? Crass and morose.

Mreggsworth · 19/08/2021 23:05

@Jamdown123

Can you not see the massive flaw in the argument "well if you exist and are exuding CO2 then why can't I bring multiple more CO2 exuding humans to the world" ?

So just because we exist, its hypocritical to have an opinion that having multiple children is bad for the environment? So only those who decide to kill themselves can express concern that the world is overpopulated Hmm

And if everyone just kept having multiple children just on the rare chance that theyll be the solution when theyll more likely be part of the problem the world would be even more screwed.

If you want 3,4,5,6 children etc, go ahead and do it because it makes you happy, but just dont in anyway try to justify the decision as being anything but damaging to the earth and future generations.

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 19/08/2021 22:55

@2bazookas

it’s really not helping my anxiety.
Maybe your mental health is the reason they think you've got enough on your plate already.?</div></div>

Offensive.

They’ve clearly stated their (🤨) financial situation puts them off a fourth grandchild. People with anxiety make perfectly good parents.

2bazookas · 19/08/2021 22:52

it’s really not helping my anxiety.

Maybe your mental health is the reason they think you've got enough on your plate already.?
Puzzledandpissedoff · 19/08/2021 22:39

It's not immature to be in a long term relationship and decide to have a fourth child

TBF we don't know if it's a long term relationship - or whether the fiance's the father of the other DCs - or if anyone works - or whether they manage okay with the existing DCs - or what the DF's doubts are really based on

So really it's all very much based on principles rather than being able to offer specific advice

Kitdeluca1 · 19/08/2021 22:39

When the time comes I just wouldn’t tell them at all, let them realise your pregnant in due course. If they ask why you didn’t tell them just say well I knew you wouldn’t be happy for me so I saved myself the upset. End of, your an adult don’t let your parents control what you do and don’t let them make you feel bad either.

Jamdown123 · 19/08/2021 22:39

@Babdoc

SudokuZebra, having an extra child causes an average 58 tonnes of CO2 equivalent carbon footprint per year, for every year of the child’s life. That’s far worse than flying for one foreign holiday annually, or eating locally farmed meat, or any of your other examples. The extra child will grow up to need a whole extra house, transport, electrical goods, furniture, heating, entertainment, fuel, etc etc. It is beyond selfish and irresponsible, with the planet facing global climate change and severe over population, to have more than two children.
Yet you are here? Aren't you a CO2 exuding human being too? Have you any plans to do anything about cutting down your CO2 to zero?

imagine calling the child an 'extra' child. Maybe the BABY WILL GROW UP TO BE PART OF THE SOLUTION.

LilQueenie · 19/08/2021 22:38

Hmm To those saying 4 kids is too many and its bleeding the world dry may I remind you that we have lost 4.4 million in the last year and a half.

What can you get from a 4th kid that you can't get from 3? Well another human being who deserves as much love as the rest. You might even get an adult in 18 years who creates a live saving drug or some other useful idea to help humanity or YOUR kids.

OP It kind of reads that your parents are concerned that you might not be able to manage so many young kids and that leaves them without a babysitter for your siblings.

Jiggyjigsaw · 19/08/2021 22:29

Is the fiance the father of the other kids?

Cheeseplantboots · 19/08/2021 22:09

@SudokuZebra

Erm, the queen has four children and no one is calling her environmentally irresponsible 🙄

People on Mumsnet are completely weird about having children op. They insist that any child is a disaster.

Having ten kids which all get taken into care at birth ? Irresponsible. A fourth child in a happy family unit ? Not irresponsible at all.

And I'd be very, very interested to know if the posters who are criticising the environmental aspect are vegetarian, not flying, using public transport and sourcing locally. I somehow doubt it 🙄

@SudokuZebra - the queen had her children 60/70 years ago! I seriously doubt anyone back then would be thinking about climate change when having kids 🙄
Buttercup54321 · 19/08/2021 21:53

None of their business. Are they always so controlling?
Your life, your choice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread