Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do people afford kids?

337 replies

crumbsnamechange · 19/08/2021 12:02

I feel like I'm missing a massive trick here!

DP and I earn around £72k jointly (I earn the bulk of that at £48k, but have ~£250 per month student loans, and high pension payments, and pay slightly more of the cut of the rent than him). DP is expecting to earn a higher salary in about 18 months' time, but it's not guaranteed, and it's uncertain how much higher.

If I went on maternity leave say within the next year, that would leave us with a severe shortfall as DP's salary alone plus maternity pay wouldn't sustain us (we live near London so our current joint income only just covers huge rent and current outgoings with a bit of savings).

How do people manage it? I've been reading on other forums about how you just make do, you sacrifice your lifestyle and don't go out as much etc. so more money for rent and baby, rely on relatives etc. so not paying huge nursery fees all the time etc. It just seems so hard, a huge stress, and unsustainable. And that's before I even consider the effect a baby would have on my career. Would it be foolish to consider a baby now since I don't even know how we would afford it?

OP posts:
Atla · 20/08/2021 20:55

We have 3 children, meant to say.

Atla · 20/08/2021 20:53

You can't have it all - it's all to do with priorities and what you actually want and what you are willing to compromise on.
I live in a much cheaper part of the uk (small mortgage), with probably similar combined salary. We have holidays in the uk, are able to afford days out etc but my car is 10 years old and we have been saving up for a new kitchen for at least 5 years and haven't got there yet!

I'm the lower earner and I have worked part time since ds2 was born - going back to full time soon as dd now in school - I have always been the one to make career sacrifices, as the lower earner, but it was what I wanted and it isn't forever. I'm a nurse though and it's the type of career where you can kind of pick up where you left off, and many people do.

Childcare costs are crippling. Some people space out babies so only paying 1 set of nursery fees at once. I started too late for that!

Galdos · 20/08/2021 20:50

Not read the whole thread. When I was a kid, 1970s, sending us all out to work. Now, due to blasted laws about (not) working below 18, indulging the little feckers.

Best thing that ever happened to me was a dead end job aged 15: spurred me to do other things!

SoundBar · 20/08/2021 20:34

YABU because your salaries are high OP. It might be the people around you or social media is skewing your view on things. You just have to do it if you want to be a parent. It will cost you time, money and sleep. So what? What else would you be doing? 5 years from now, 10 years from now, 20? What do you want in life?

crumbsnamechange · 20/08/2021 20:34

Lol I've never been able to justify the cost of a jacket from Jigsaw nor have I stayed at a boutique hotel in the last 6 years! Grin I do spaff far too much money on Asos and travel though (or at least I used to). I can definitely see where I can shave off about £300 a month on my spending, taking my remaining money up to about £800-£900 a month but this still wouldn't quite cover nursery fees plus baby expenses in London. I'm going to have to really push DP for that promotion...

OP posts:
Monday26July · 20/08/2021 20:34

[quote ToykotoLosAngeles]@Monday26July

Yes, this amuses me too! They ruin outfit after outfit with that awful yellow poo. It's generally good to have somewhere to put them in your living area such as a bouncy chair and we went through 2 of those as he grew. We needed a specially sized bedside cot which was £160 at the time (new on market) and then after 6 months a cotbed. Yes, you can get secondhand bot beds but a new mattress is about £70. He outgrew the newborn car seat at 5 months so we had to buy another, same with travel system at 18 months so he needed a buggy. The outlay in year 1 and 2 without childcare and food was well over £1500 and I breastfed![/quote]
It’s astonishing when people downplay the cost of children. I was one of the unlucky ones with insufficient milk supply, and being able to combo feed (rather than exclusively formula feed) cost me well over £400, not including formula itself. Breastfeeding cost me a fortune. I had to over demand from my body to be able to produce even a tiny amount which meant triple feeding, so I had to buy a pump. The manual ones didn’t work, no let down and shit supply, so I needed a double electric. The first one I tried was a cheap one that bruised me and as you can’t keep trying them as you can’t return them I ended up with a £250 one as it was the only affordable version of the hospital pump brand that had worked for me. We tried to rent from our local childrens’ centre but they didn’t have any available!

Then a couple of breastfeeding friendly tops, sports bras to cut into to make it hands free (when your supply is so bad you need both hands to force the milk out), nursing bras, nipple cream and pads, the increased calories (!), bottles, steriliser, formula, milk storage bags, bottle brushes...

If we hadn’t had any money then the option to bf would have been completely closed off to me. Of course my babe would have thrived on formula alone but that’s expensive too. There was no cheap way to feed my baby with my supply issues!

Nonicknamesforcatapillars · 20/08/2021 20:33

We had a joint income of £22k when dd1 was born 16.5 years ago.

We managed. Money was tight, but as I didn’t have a “career” as such I worked around the kids and so didn’t have to pay for much childcare. We were also young and didn’t have a good lifestyle we wanted to maintain. On that salary we managed to buy our first little 2 bed house. Babies are cheap, but childcare is expensive, so that’ll be your biggest out going, unless you have family willing to help out or one of you is willing to change career to do evenings and weekends around the kids.

There will never be a good time to have kids, but if you want them enough you will make it work. If you’re not prepared to make the sacrifices, maybe you just don’t want kids that much 🤷‍♀️ and that’s ok. Teenagers are way way more expensive than small children btw, but by that point you’re back to earning more and working more hours again. Our income now is 3 times what it was when dd1 was born, but we still don’t feel well off.

conjourbonjour · 20/08/2021 20:31

Despite the cringeworthy quotes you’ll read on IG. Sadly mate, you just can’t have it all. Personally, couldn’t think of anything worse than raising children in London, we moved to a town a fair way out of London with good links in. Our daughter goes to a nursery that is in a forest and comes home muddy every day, there are dog walks galore and we are in London with 45 mins if needed. Unfortunately kids are a sacrifice, but the reward is endless x

Howshouldibehave · 20/08/2021 20:30

@crumbsnamechange

Our high rent really is the problem, added to that DP's current low income. I find myself caught between a rock and a hard place though. If we move to a cheaper area (further away from London) then we will have high commuting costs, be more tired (from baby and long travel times), and will still have nursery fees to consider as well as living in an area that is not nearly so fun. I honestly don't see how it's doable. The nursery fees are horrifying me! Sad
How much would the commuting costs be-it’s worth working that out?

Think carefully about the ‘fun’ area you are in now as well. What do you like about it in particular? Will it be fun for a baby? Toddler?

Mine loved the park, the woods and the beach when they were little. Kooky cafes and wine bars were not so handy!

speakout · 20/08/2021 20:29

You must struggle on £72K.
How do you manage?

crumbsnamechange · 20/08/2021 20:29

@onlyfoolsnmothers we are saving to buy a house but only have about £12k so far, we're saving about £600 a month at present. We aren't eligible for Help to Buy or any other first-time buyer scheme as I'm already on the deeds of another property which I can't get out of for potentially years (v long irrelevant story) so anticipate renting for another couple of years at least. I imagine by then any mortgage we manage to get near London won't be much cheaper than our rent anyway. Sorry to be so negative...just feeling really stuck right now

OP posts:
Paint69 · 20/08/2021 20:27

My DH is the sole earner and earns below that and we manage just fine.. actually more than manage. We pay the mortgage, bills, food, activities and have spare for savings? But we've always saved to buy cars outright so don't have a monthly expense there.

HarrietsweetHarriet · 20/08/2021 20:26

You make sacrifices. You go camping instead of hotel holidays. You shop carefully and second hand. You reduce pension payments to absolute minimum. You don't have expensive hairdressing, nails , facials. You don't meet up with the girls for cocktails. You don't buy another irresistible little jacket from Jigsaw. You don't have impromptu weekends away in little boutique hotels...Believe it or not you can still have a fabulous time doing all the free / cheap stuff that's on offer, wearing what you have, buying less etc. If you're fortunate enough to fall pregnant and have a baby you'll find people are falling over themselves to give you things and a lot of the gear the media says you need for babies is really unnecessary. Lovely and trendy to have maybe , but not essential. The joy of a child outweighs the sacrifices a million times over but this is a very personal decision only you can make.

Peace43 · 20/08/2021 20:23

I was the higher earner so I went back to work pretty quickly and DDs dad was a SAHD for years. We also moved to a cheaper area and I saved hard for 3 years before having DD.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/08/2021 20:22

Do you have a plan to buy op?

ToykotoLosAngeles · 20/08/2021 20:22

@Monday26July

Yes, this amuses me too! They ruin outfit after outfit with that awful yellow poo. It's generally good to have somewhere to put them in your living area such as a bouncy chair and we went through 2 of those as he grew. We needed a specially sized bedside cot which was £160 at the time (new on market) and then after 6 months a cotbed. Yes, you can get secondhand bot beds but a new mattress is about £70. He outgrew the newborn car seat at 5 months so we had to buy another, same with travel system at 18 months so he needed a buggy. The outlay in year 1 and 2 without childcare and food was well over £1500 and I breastfed!

crumbsnamechange · 20/08/2021 20:17

Our high rent really is the problem, added to that DP's current low income. I find myself caught between a rock and a hard place though. If we move to a cheaper area (further away from London) then we will have high commuting costs, be more tired (from baby and long travel times), and will still have nursery fees to consider as well as living in an area that is not nearly so fun. I honestly don't see how it's doable. The nursery fees are horrifying me! Sad

OP posts:
RobertClementHughes · 20/08/2021 20:16

@crumbsnamechange I am a single parent and I earn the same amount as you (the 48k bit, not joint) part time. I have 3 dc, i own a nice but unexciting 4 bed detached in a lovely area. Comfy life but not lavish at all, high street/ebay clothes and modest car. I own it outright so there are no monthly bills and student loans are long hone (I'm 45)

I waited until I had got to a 50k full time salary before having children, when I returned from each maternity leave I worked part time to a varying degree and with inflation my wages have crept up to nearly where they were before. My costs have changed, but not gone down (or up) I suppose once I got over the nightmare years of paying for nursery.

The biggest factor I suspect is housing costs- the lovely area I live in is 2.5 hours from London. My mortgage is nowhere near as big as a 4 bed detached in a leafy city suburb.

Monday26July · 20/08/2021 20:16

@DingDongThongs

they don't need a lot. Babies need clothes, nappies and milk.
Lol, this kind of silly stuff always makes me smile. The amount of money it costs to keep a tiny baby in up to 84 nappies per week, buy formula and bottles and a sterilising method if you don’t or can’t breastfeed (and maybe a pump if you do), and kit them out in next size up clothes every month or two is significant.

But let’s not forget the fact that they don’t stay tiny babies for long. And for the vast, vast majority of people, they do want to be able to provide things like books and toys, baby groups (for the social aspect). The most significant factor is loss of earnings and the cost of childcare, but kids cost a bomb even if you do it as cheaply as possible.

Oh, they need furniture too, ya know, somewhere safe to sleep. And bedding for it. They don’t stay in a Moses basket for long.

Even if you manage to tell yourself that for you your baby was cheap, your baby got bigger and had more needs right? They all do. Not an ideal plan to have a child based on the myth that a baby doesn’t cost much and then wake up one day and realise your baby actually grows into a toddler and child...

Ralph871 · 20/08/2021 20:13

[quote crumbsnamechange]@DrSbaitso that's what I suspected, which worries me, because it would mean DP would do the bulk of the childrearing/responsibilities, and he'd have to make earning sacrifices to do so.

Are there any examples of two reasonably high-earning parents who have made it work? I feel like I've always been surrounded by high-earning dad and part-time or low-earning/SAHM, and would love some different inspiration.[/quote]
I have an almost 3 year old and a 16 month old. We are on joint income of roughly £75k and I am the higher earner (I earn around £50k) I work as a nurse full time and do three night shifts per week as it means I then only need to put the kids into childcare three days and despite only being there three days my nursery fees are £1200 per month. I'm permanently exhausted and constantly dream of another job but being the higher earner and with my husband on a fixed term contract it's not possible at the moment. I would also love another baby but finances will probably not allow until my husband is in a permanent job and by that time I'll probably be too old. At the point both my kids have their funded nursery place I'll definitely look into a job with more social hours and just take the pay cut.

LadyofMisrule · 20/08/2021 20:08

We were both reasonably high earners. I went back to work really quickly (just a few weeks) after each one. We initially paid a childminder, then they went to nursery. I work close to home, so was still able to express/ feed regularly.

JuliaBlackberry · 20/08/2021 20:00

The huge rent looks like your problem.
I had my first DC quite young, I was earning 25k at the time and my DH about 30k. At the time we lived in a flat with a mortage of about 600 pcm, I spread my enhanced maternity pay over a longer period which was an option with my work at the time. Went back when she was about 9 months old. We had another DC a couple of years later and hobbled through the two-in-childcare phase for a year before DD got some funded hours. We also then bought a do-er upper house which was cheap-ish and kept our mortgage payments a bit lower. They're 6 and 8 now, we both earn much more and are about to move into a much larger property - it's all a distant memory now but yeah, you tighten your belts and try and keep your housing costs low. A couple on 72k shouldn't really be agonising over the affordability of 1 child.

SeoultoSeoul · 20/08/2021 19:52

£60 a day! Really, tgats bargains! More like £80 here. Grin
We had 3 DC in 4 years. Our incoming was higher than yours OP but my salary would have been obliterated by child care costs so I gave up for a few years. We had no one to help.
We are determined to be here for our DGC and DH I'd planning to take early retirement next year to help our own DC out with their children, should they need it.

Howshouldibehave · 20/08/2021 19:39

@DingDongThongs

they don't need a lot. Babies need clothes, nappies and milk.
!!!

And of course, they need looking after, which can cost £60+ a day!

namechange7865 · 20/08/2021 19:21

they don't need a lot. Babies need clothes, nappies and milk

I disagree. They need 24/7 care which makes them very needy and expensive, either you outsource at an eye watering cost or take a big cut income (for many people at least). So let's not underplay the cost of having them.