Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do people afford kids?

337 replies

crumbsnamechange · 19/08/2021 12:02

I feel like I'm missing a massive trick here!

DP and I earn around £72k jointly (I earn the bulk of that at £48k, but have ~£250 per month student loans, and high pension payments, and pay slightly more of the cut of the rent than him). DP is expecting to earn a higher salary in about 18 months' time, but it's not guaranteed, and it's uncertain how much higher.

If I went on maternity leave say within the next year, that would leave us with a severe shortfall as DP's salary alone plus maternity pay wouldn't sustain us (we live near London so our current joint income only just covers huge rent and current outgoings with a bit of savings).

How do people manage it? I've been reading on other forums about how you just make do, you sacrifice your lifestyle and don't go out as much etc. so more money for rent and baby, rely on relatives etc. so not paying huge nursery fees all the time etc. It just seems so hard, a huge stress, and unsustainable. And that's before I even consider the effect a baby would have on my career. Would it be foolish to consider a baby now since I don't even know how we would afford it?

OP posts:
Tessabelle74 · 21/08/2021 13:28

OnlyFoolsnMothers
We get £32 a week tax credit and £63 a week child benefit on top, but of course it's possible. Neither of us smoke, we have a bottle of wine occasionally. We don't have expensive hobbies, our cars are both 15 years old so no finance on them. We budget carefully for birthdays, each child has a day out and gifts to celebrate for example, this week we had a day in Great Yarmouth including the pleasure Beach, and we buy Christmas gifts through the year. I do the shopping, usually averages around £70 a week as I cook from scratch. Our kids have everything they need, as they are our priority. That may mean I have holes in my shoes for a month or 2 if they need something and my husband no longer has a wardrobe full of designer clothes, but we wouldn't change a thing

WhatAShilohPitt · 21/08/2021 13:17

I’m actually surprised that more people don’t think seriously about the financial commitment of having children - it seems to be pretty common to assume that they’ll be healthy parents who will stay in work and they’ll cross that very remote bridge of illness / unemployment etc if they ever get to it. Covid showed how quickly that can change.

I mean, if you want to commit to a mortgage, the lender will make sure you aren’t overstretching, that you can afford repayments and that if you lose your job you’ll have insurance to cover the payments or your house gets repossessed. But with children, lots of people have several of them without knowing what they’ll do if they hit a period of unplanned financial worry. I can’t imagine having several children without a good chunk of savings to fall back on. So no, YANBU. You’re sensible!

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 21/08/2021 13:05

@Tessabelle74

We have 4 kids and a combined income less than half of yours. Since having kids we have had one of us working nights the other days, one doing weekdays the other weekends and more recently my husband is a full time nurse so I pick up bank care shifts on his days off and have a small cleaning job in school hours to avoid childcare costs. We go camping for our holidays usually, have booked all inclusive for a week in Spain next year though. We run 2 cars, have a mortgage and rent as we have a shared ownership property. We have to be careful with what we spend and we manage. But we don't live in London so I'd guess that makes it easier
Still not sure how that’s possible- even with cheaper outside London costs
Tessabelle74 · 21/08/2021 12:57

We have 4 kids and a combined income less than half of yours. Since having kids we have had one of us working nights the other days, one doing weekdays the other weekends and more recently my husband is a full time nurse so I pick up bank care shifts on his days off and have a small cleaning job in school hours to avoid childcare costs. We go camping for our holidays usually, have booked all inclusive for a week in Spain next year though. We run 2 cars, have a mortgage and rent as we have a shared ownership property. We have to be careful with what we spend and we manage. But we don't live in London so I'd guess that makes it easier

Saladcreamormayo · 21/08/2021 11:05

I was actually better off after having children due to working in minimum wage jobs my income was boosted by receiving extra tax credits (child tax credits also child benefit). My eldest is now a teen but has never been abroad just short holidays in the UK. My children always have new clothes but not expensive clothing usually primark or george, matalan etc. We manage just fine. You will too your income is far far higher than ours.

csigeek · 21/08/2021 00:58

You save enough money to cover your reduced payments whilst on maternity. Either that or you end up in debt.
I am the higher earner and I made sure we had enough in savings to cover the shortfall of maternity pay when it reduced from full pay.
I guess that only works when you’re planning a family, as it sounds like you might be, and not if a surprise baby arrived.

calvados · 21/08/2021 00:08

Not saying that this is right for everyone but I took a lodger in. The extra income made all the difference. Lodger was female and was away every weekend and home late on week nights. People recoil at the thought of a lodger but it’s the easiest way to make an extra income without having to do a single thing!

17358anotherplanet · 21/08/2021 00:06

Forgot to mention - 5.5 year age age between DD1 and DD2 so never had to pay 2 x nursery fees!

17358anotherplanet · 21/08/2021 00:00

DH and I have 2 DD. I am the sole earner, whilst my husband runs a charity on a full time basis from which he draws no salary. I got 4 months mat leave at full pay; statutory thereafter. So I took 4 months mat leave for each DD and not a minute more. All grandparents live abroad so full time nursery a must. Eldest DD at school and late stay a must. DH does the drop offs and collections, but gets to work 9 to 5 nonetheless. I commute 4 hours per day (pre pandemic) but have been doing drop off and some collections for the past 18 months WFH and have loved it. And we both work at night when DDs in bed. Clubs to cover Christmas / Easter / Summer hols. It’s tough and exhausting and expensive. But it works if you want it to.

TokenGinger · 20/08/2021 23:41

I really feel for people who are tied in to such high rental costs. It's ridiculous.

When I was pregnant, our joint income was around £54k, and now it's around £65k.

The key to surviving on maternity pay for me was, whilst I was pregnant, I put aside the money each month that I'd have to pay in nursery fees eventually to use when on maternity leave to boost my pay.

Also, my company's policy was generous; 6 weeks at 90% pay then 33 weeks at 50% pay plus SMP (approx £600 a month), so I think I lost round £500 a month. But I made it work.

After maternity pay, we then had nursery fees to consider. We're lucky in that my mum minds him two days a week, and we have nursery 3 days a week, which with the government discount, costs us £470 a month, so £235 each. Our mortgage is £420 a month though so we're very lucky in that respect.

becausemymumsaidso · 20/08/2021 23:25

I was the higher earner, nearly 50k p.a self employed. no maternity package so smp. saved like crazy for 5 months. moved from London to suffolk, reduced living costs significantly, but really, your priorities change once you have a baby. hairdresser appointments are few and far between, shop in aldi, cat boot sales for toys. my husband is a sahd and I'm now employed on less then 30k about to go back to uni too. you just make it work. a child needs your time not money. hence why my husband quit work to avoid putting our child in nursery. I also work a lot from home so I can be around.

TerraNovaTwo · 20/08/2021 22:58

You just do. It's not as if you need to pay school fees and medical aid like most parents do in many other countries. When you are a parent your priorities change. You should, or ought to, change your mindset when you have DC.

DC don't need hundreds spent on them, all they need I to be clothed, fed, a warm and loving home, for affection and for you to spend time and give care and impart good values. Confused

squishysquashy · 20/08/2021 22:56

In our case we bought a house in cheaper area of outer London beforehand. No car.
My job paid 6 month full pay maternity and 3 month half pay - public sector. DH who is lower earner took a few years sabbatical as SAHD.
I got a promotion a year later. DH went back part time.
For DC2 DH stayed at work which more than covered part time childcare (waited until DC1 was starting school to have DC2).
Public sector also good on WFH/flexi hours so minimised after school childcare costs.
DH now earning very little setting up own business but mortgage is half what the rent would be and we have no childcare costs as both at school so it's manageable.

BookishKitten · 20/08/2021 22:33

We have a salary only slightly higher than yours and we pay mortgage on a house. We decided to move out of the London area for the baby-years. Best decision ever. Public transport is great into/out of central London, and the money you save will coves expenses. Our child was in full-time nursery since he was 1 year old. With what we saved we are now living in a 3-bed house with garden. You need space and safe space when you have small kids. As soon as they grow older you can then move back to a more central area of London.
With tax free childcare you get between 15% off your nursery fees, and from age 3 nursery fees fall to about 60%. So if you’re savvy with money and decide to be disciplined with your spending you should have more than enough to have at least a couple of children.

Givemebackmylilo · 20/08/2021 22:30

[quote SHONNYSMUMMY]@crumbsnamechange I felt compelled to answer.. You have a joint income of 70k plus, the question here is what's a priority to you..

I earn 42K live in london very central location with market rate rent I raise my child alone no child support. There is no scrimping... We holiday in lush destinations not by credit card or falling short elsewhere. I also have student loan and a decent pension paying into.

At the end of the day it about what you truly desire because if your worried about salary during maternity of which some will be full pay imagine when you have to pay for childcare👀[/quote]
42k would've barely covered the rent on my tiny 2 bed London flat

SHONNYSMUMMY · 20/08/2021 22:28

@crumbsnamechange I felt compelled to answer.. You have a joint income of 70k plus, the question here is what's a priority to you..

I earn 42K live in london very central location with market rate rent I raise my child alone no child support. There is no scrimping... We holiday in lush destinations not by credit card or falling short elsewhere. I also have student loan and a decent pension paying into.

At the end of the day it about what you truly desire because if your worried about salary during maternity of which some will be full pay imagine when you have to pay for childcare👀

muffindays · 20/08/2021 21:55

I'm a LP and get by on around £24k. Cut your cloth according to your income. I'm amazed when people say they can't get by on a joint income similar to your own. Ok, I am quite careful with money, don't often go out to eat / drink etc, and always buy second hand clothes, use Gumtree for things I need etc, shop around for gas elec etc. I manage modest holidays too. When I see what others spend money on I am often amazed. And I consider my income to be relatively good (although many people won't feel the same way). Challenge yourself to cut down where you can. You might be surprised how much you could cut back.

monotonousmum · 20/08/2021 21:48

We have a similar wage between us, and I am the higher earner (about the same split as yours), but my company offer an excellent maternity package. And I was lucky enough to sign up for the old childcare voucher scheme just as eldest was born (before it closed to new people) and have been saving that amount even when we weren't using childcare.
We bought a 1 bed flat (before kids) in zone 2 in a really fun area, but a considerable amount of equity so much lower mortgage. Honestly, the fun area was useless once we had kids. We held on for as long as possible and then the move out of London when it made sense to us.
Even on a high wage you have to plan and balance every £. But we live a good life, and could definitely make cut backs.
Save hard. Make sacrifices. Move to a 1 bed if you can - look at close areas to where you are but little cheaper. Put every penny you save on the rent difference into savings.
Once pregnant I saved a lot on alcohol alone!!
2 big things making it more difficult for you - maternity pay and rent costs. It's hard to know a companies maternity policy before starting with them, but see if you can find one with better mat pay.

Once the baby is here, could you/your partner condense hours and do 4 day weeks? Different days off so you only have to cover 3 days childcare.
Grandparents are a huge help to us, not sure we'd manage without them. I wouldn't recommend moving away from them.

Look at your long term plan. It might be tough for a few years, but only in comparison to what you have now. You earn enough to make it work, and when the kid turns 3 it gets easier.

conjourbonjour · 20/08/2021 21:34

“nursery spaces are heavily subsidised after age 3” - sadly no, this is not actually the case. Price does go down but it’s still a huge expense!

Covidconfuse · 20/08/2021 21:32

“Are there any examples of two reasonably high-earning parents who have made it work? I feel like I've always been surrounded by high-earning dad and part-time or low-earning/SAHM, and would love some different inspiration.”

Not sure if we count as reasonably high or not but I earn £49k and DP earns £65k. We had our first baby when I was 38 and DP was 45. The advantage we had was DP got on the property ladder at 19 and I got on the property ladder at 29. We have 3 properties between us now. Student loans both paid off long ago.
My work has a generous maternity package - 6 months full pay - and generous annual leave which means after mat leave I used my annual leave accrued to effectively work part time for a year while on full pay. DP is self employed so his hours and days are flexible. So we only pay for 3 days a week childcare and look after DC ourselves 2 days a week. Most baby stuff was given to us by friends or we got cheap. We shop at Costco and are too knackered to go out and do much these days so are saving more than before DC. Am pregnant with no.2 and planning to take another full year of mat leave and then go back part time but on full time pay until my leave runs out. By that point our oldest DC will be eligible for some free childcare hours, and nursery fees reduce the older they get. Our main luxuries are a weekly cleaner and the odd takeaway but we live pretty frugally now, me because I always have (instilled into me by DM) and both of us now because there is little energy for anything besides TV these days

cuckooplusone · 20/08/2021 21:25

I know quite a few couples who are both in professional roles who both work four days a week and then pay for nursery for 3 days. Don’t forget it’s quite short term, just a couple of years, assuming you have a full year of maternity, nursery spaces are heavily subsidised after age 3.

You will manage fine if it’s what you want to do!

oblada · 20/08/2021 21:11

Move somewhere cheaper? I'm not sure if want to be in London unless our income was rly high.
I earn about 45k gross, DH is in 65k gross approx. We have 4 children. We're late thirties. When we had our first I was on 22k and then 25k and DH was finishing his PhD and then on similar amounts. But we're in the north west.

Now that I've finished with my pregnancies i can re focus on my career a bit as it did slow down naturally but I don't regret it one bit. I still have plenty of time!

RedStef1983 · 20/08/2021 21:02

I started saving for maternity leave as soon as we started trying for a baby. I fell pregnant quicker than expected but was able to save £10k. With that added to my mat leave package we managed comfortably throughout my Mat leave and had £3k left when I went back to work. My partner and I discussed finances and spoke to a number of nurseries regarding their fees, and then worked out the minimum I needed to earn to pay our bills, accommodate nursery and still have a life. I was fortunate that I was able to go back to my previous job on 4 days a week. It’s true what they say - you just amend your lifestyle to accommodate. I earn £44k a year, my husband £31k. We claim child benefit of £85.

RowanAlong · 20/08/2021 21:00

Radically reorganise your spending, and move to a cheaper area, before you have kids..

DrSbaitso · 20/08/2021 20:55

@crumbsnamechange

Lol I've never been able to justify the cost of a jacket from Jigsaw nor have I stayed at a boutique hotel in the last 6 years! Grin I do spaff far too much money on Asos and travel though (or at least I used to). I can definitely see where I can shave off about £300 a month on my spending, taking my remaining money up to about £800-£900 a month but this still wouldn't quite cover nursery fees plus baby expenses in London. I'm going to have to really push DP for that promotion...
How do you and he feel about him going part time and taking some shared parental leave? It would have to be a heck of a promotion to get him up to your salary; you earn twice what he does.