Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do people afford kids?

337 replies

crumbsnamechange · 19/08/2021 12:02

I feel like I'm missing a massive trick here!

DP and I earn around £72k jointly (I earn the bulk of that at £48k, but have ~£250 per month student loans, and high pension payments, and pay slightly more of the cut of the rent than him). DP is expecting to earn a higher salary in about 18 months' time, but it's not guaranteed, and it's uncertain how much higher.

If I went on maternity leave say within the next year, that would leave us with a severe shortfall as DP's salary alone plus maternity pay wouldn't sustain us (we live near London so our current joint income only just covers huge rent and current outgoings with a bit of savings).

How do people manage it? I've been reading on other forums about how you just make do, you sacrifice your lifestyle and don't go out as much etc. so more money for rent and baby, rely on relatives etc. so not paying huge nursery fees all the time etc. It just seems so hard, a huge stress, and unsustainable. And that's before I even consider the effect a baby would have on my career. Would it be foolish to consider a baby now since I don't even know how we would afford it?

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 19/08/2021 12:37

Yes my husband and I, I went back to work three months after we had our daughter, we paid childcare and it was fine, we were skint for a period obviously, you need enough savings behind you to survive maternity leave. All our child responsibilities were split Ie pick up drop offs bed times etc.

WeAllHaveWings · 19/08/2021 12:37

All money in and out becomes family money - none of this who pays how much of the rent/bills. You also need to be on the same page where you want to plan for a child and do what is needed.

Huge spreadsheet capturing all family money and all spending in detail and transparently. Work out together how you can strip back absolutely everything that is non essential. No new cars, fancy mobile phones, expensive entertainment packages, holidays, work lunches all add up, coffees, going out, new clothes that aren't really needed etc. Review all direct debits/outgoings and see if you can get better prices. Work out where the money is going and how to stop/reduce spending it. Work out how much money you need (as a family) to cover maternity leave and first months of childcare and start saving.

Babies aren't that expensive if you don't get sucked into the £1000 designer prams etc, save your money for the big costs which are loss of earnings during maternity leave and childcare. We saved to afford my maternity leave (basic package) and I went back after 7 months.

For childcare, dh worked 1 day at the weekend and took off one day mid week to save nursery fees. When I went back I used accrued holidays to work 4 days a week for nearly the first year - so the first year we only paid for 3 days a week nursery. Also changed our working hours to reduce hours in nursery (he started late to drop at nursery, I started early and finished early to do the pick up). Look at childcare vouchers and any relatives that might help to reduce costs.

It is a complete change of lifestyle financially for most people when you are paying for childcare, but you do it if you want a child.

Jerseygirl12 · 19/08/2021 12:36

OP would you like to buy a property before having a baby?

user97495 · 19/08/2021 12:33

In contrast to @Brimorion we (accidentally) managed it by having children prior to being high earners. I fell unintentionally pregnant just out of uni but on reflection it worked out very well for us. We were eligible for tax credits for the majority of the childcare years, I worked part time whilst studying to quality in my field which enabled me to be home part of the week but still advance my career, did a lot of my uni reading on the commute! I developed a huge amount of resilience having young kids whilst studying and working. Earnings increased, tax credits decreased until we were self sufficient so a pay rise was never really a pay rise in disposable income but was satisfying all the same. We were able to buy a home in our 20s when youngest got 30 free hours, and the forever home not too long after in our early 30s.

By the time they started school (when I actually find childcare more difficult, cheaper but more challenging to find sufficient care) I was qualified and senior enough to own my diary so now work very flexibly around the kids.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, there is no one size fits all, of course research and prepare as best you can, but there will be a way to have a child in your situation. Most of us make sacrifices of some kind and you will find a way that works for you.

Meloncurse · 19/08/2021 12:32

All the couples I know (including me) where the earnings split is the female earning double the male have elected not to have children.

CalmDownFaye · 19/08/2021 12:29

You have them....realise you can't afford them...then you're stuck with them so you manage! On 72K there will be a way. We moved out of London to have DC2 which made a big difference.

Theforest · 19/08/2021 12:29

We used savings to cover maternity leave shortfall.
Then you adjust outgoings when you go back to work. We had childcare to pay as well as going part time. But it works. Life changes when you have a baby and spending priorities change too.

meow1989 · 19/08/2021 12:28

Dh and I earn a little over what you do, dh earns slightly more. I took 12 months maternity plus 4 weeks annual leave and spread ny payments over the whole year so there wasn't a sudden dip. I think I spent about 6k which I had saved to supplement (leaving me with not much left in savings!).

We managed fine and still did groups, days out etc and had holiday (in uk) that first year.

Ds is now 3 and we have just paid his last nursery fees. Dh is a teacher which helps with the summer holiday child care. I work 3 days a week (did 4 pre ds). We have fabulous families who do a day child care each.

I don't think we could comfortably afford another child right not so are sticking with one at least for the moment!

Nc4post99 · 19/08/2021 12:27

I think some of the issue in your situation is that you live around London OP, as I’m sure you’re aware other parts of the country and you’d be quite comfortable. From my understanding childcare costs in London/ London area are equally high.

So I guess there are a few things, would moving away from London be an option career wise? Can you wait it out for your salaries to increase? That one does depend on maternal age (to an extent). Can you move to a cheaper area etc?

I think it also depends on your mat pay where you work, if your place of work offers just SMP you’ll feel the hit even more than say 6/7 months full pay. If you get 6/7 months full pay then it’s a case of during pregnancy and that full pay time to squirrel as much away as you can to cover that shortfall until you can return to work. Would shared parental leave be an option?
Then back in work; can you condense hours to have a lieu day in the week for you and your partner to take instead of childcare? Do you have family close to help? Does your work have any sort of daycare facilities? You do get child benefit too, although it’s not a huge amount. There’s also 20% tax free childcare for if both parents are working. This saves us about £200 a month. You can get healthy start vouchers, think it’s £10 a week (someone correct me if I’m wrong)

It’s also worthwhile noting, yes there are expenses with a baby but you don’t need absolutely everything the baby market makes you believe you do. A lot can be bought 2nd hand (exception of a car seat and cot mattress, maybe cot too due to safety standards). My child is still young but I would say the ‘expensive’ days are pretty much until they start school at 4/5, then they get greater wear out of their clothes and they’re in school and can do breakfast and after school clubs for a relatively lower cost.

DH and I live in the Midlands, cost of living is still much higher than the ‘average’ as are house prices In our area, but it’s nowhere near London costs and it’s affordable for us. We own our own home (on mortgage). We earn slightly more than you mentioned £78k DH 46 and me the rest (although I do get sizeable bonuses which help too) but we do manage ok. I have a toddler and I’m pregnant with our second. When the second starts childcare is where we’ll start to really feel the pinch. Things like holidays are obviously the first to go, and we’ve started to realise how much money we fritter away on shite (like takeaway or poorly planned meals, and last min food shops). So we try to limit ourselves to one takeaway/ meal out a month and we menu plan and shop at lidl and bulk buy our meat, easily this way we save £200 a month. Same with days out, we limit our paid for days out to once a month (by paid for i mean a day at the local children’s museum which is £30 for 2 parents and one toddler, more expensive treats are only special occasions). We have a terrible habit of buying DC something every time we go out so for numerous reasons we have to nip that in the bud.

It’s worth noting that some of it is economies of scale too, that the higher your salary the more costly your lifestyle and the more you are inclined to spend. But I’m 100% with you, it’s tough!

OatyLatte · 19/08/2021 12:26

We saved up before I went on mat leave, economised, bought lots of stuff second hand. We're now in the crap phase of paying for 4 days per week childcare but it will get better when they turn 3. It's all doable, you just won't have the disposable income you once had.

DrSbaitso · 19/08/2021 12:26

Tbh, baby stuff isn't the issue. You can easily buy it cheap second hand or get it on Freecycle, and you'll probably find lots of people give you things too. The issue is more long term earning loss, childcare and, though I'm not there yet, activities for older children and teens.

But like I said, most people manage it and most people don't earn huge amounts. You earn more than average but I understand it doesn't go so far in the South East.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 19/08/2021 12:25

We had a cheap mortgage at the time. Only earnt about 35k between us. Ds went to ft nursery, no family help, but we got about £100 a month in tax credits at the time towards it. Our childcare bill has gone way down now he is at school. We could not afford another however. Even though we earn more we would be worse off.

Rannva · 19/08/2021 12:25

[quote crumbsnamechange]@DrSbaitso that's what I suspected, which worries me, because it would mean DP would do the bulk of the childrearing/responsibilities, and he'd have to make earning sacrifices to do so.

Are there any examples of two reasonably high-earning parents who have made it work? I feel like I've always been surrounded by high-earning dad and part-time or low-earning/SAHM, and would love some different inspiration.[/quote]
We're both FT high earners, but I stopped work at the birth of the first and went back when the second started school, so 9 years out in all. I used the time to retrain in something more lucrative. I also had them sooner, starting at 25, so I was ready to re-enter the workforce at 34. It would have been harder starting older.

Some parents will balance it so they both take a small cut in hours/pay and care for the child, others have the lower earner stop, saving the childcare costs (which are usually multiple times a low-earners salary), and others take the hit of the childcare costs which can be astronomical, especially in London.

In your situation where you simply cannot afford to pay the bills if you’re on leave… that suggests you might be a bit overstretched with the rent. You can’t afford the time off - you’d be in the same situation if you had to go off sick, so that’s pretty precarious. Any chance of ownership or downsizing?

But also I'm in the North and wanted children very much, so I didn't look at the numbers too closely. Got job, bought house, stopped job, got new job... it just all worked out in the end.

idontknowwhyibother · 19/08/2021 12:24

You make it work. I can't see how you can't afford a baby on 70k a year when there are families on 12k or less and manage okay with their kids?
Sounds like you don't want one rather than not being able to afford one.

NatMoz · 19/08/2021 12:24

I am pregnant and between us we earn £66k (not including overtime/bonus). I plan to return part time so our salary will drop to £58k with no overtime from me and maybe a bonus from him.

We have been overpaying our mortgage by £800 a month so the drop in salary/childcare fees (2 days a week) should hopefully balance out.

I've also been saving for maternity. I do get a really good mat leave but will need to cover 3 months SMP and a couple of weeks unpaid to get me up to a full year so have been saving. I've put away £5k so far with about 5 paydays to go.

Shariotlion · 19/08/2021 12:23

You start saving! i had considerably less disposable income, less salary and more than likely the same outgoings as you.. i managed to save 5K for my maternity leave and it lasted me the whole year.

DrSbaitso · 19/08/2021 12:23

[quote crumbsnamechange]@DrSbaitso that's what I suspected, which worries me, because it would mean DP would do the bulk of the childrearing/responsibilities, and he'd have to make earning sacrifices to do so.

Are there any examples of two reasonably high-earning parents who have made it work? I feel like I've always been surrounded by high-earning dad and part-time or low-earning/SAHM, and would love some different inspiration.[/quote]
Well, how does he feel about it? Or you?

I know several families where the woman was the higher earner and the man has taken the career hit. I've worked for several women in that situation, they were my bosses, and they were also great parents. It's not as common as the other way round, but it's not jaw droppingly unusual. Remember that providing for your family is also a very integral part of parenting.

I do appreciate this can be a very hard decision though. You could look into both going part time.

If you really want a child, you do make it work. Most people have kids and most people aren't rolling in cash.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 19/08/2021 12:22

Having kids involves sacrifices. It could very to career, or financially (such as paying for a nanny) or moving to a cheaper part of town.

You'll get Child Benefit. (Until you start earning 50k and it will decrease... its based on the higher earner). You'll qualify for tax free childcare.

You mention rent...are you wanting to buy? Mortgages can be cheaper than rent.

Charlotte2020 · 19/08/2021 12:22

You go out a lot less, buy less clothes and shoes as a result. If you are sensible you don't t need to spend a fortune on baby clothes and toys etc.
Our joint income is £80k (bristol based) and we've been saving for nursery since DD was born. Money will be slightly reduced (I'll go back to work PT) but we're pretty comfortable at the moment. Like PPs have said, what you spend your spare cash on before a baby is often not an option afterwards!

Yellow85 · 19/08/2021 12:21

A bit of everything you’ve mentioned tbh. We saved up around 6 months of bills to cover the shortfall of smp v normal salary for the 9 months or so of may leave. I literally did nothing when I was off that wasn’t free! My parents were.l great at the odd lunch/coffee out and went to loads of local authority baby groups like book bugs in the library.

Once back at work, we did 3 days nursery and 1 at grandparents. Extremely lucky GP’s are either retired or part time. I dropped a day and stayed at home with kids. I’ve only just gone back to 5 days now my youngest started school this week.

Our lifestyle, going out etc had already naturally started to change which is why we knew it was the right time for a child. But yes, my social life went out the window. Still is if I’m honest, but I’m a particularly ‘hands on’ mum so some of that is brought on myself 😂

Brimorion · 19/08/2021 12:18

We’re both high-earning, but we became so by postponing having a child till we were financially comfortable and senior enough to be flexible at work. We had one child when we were both 40.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 19/08/2021 12:17

Savings, and stopping at one. We were together and stashing money for 14 years before we had DS.

I'm down to 3 days for now but will go back to FT in 2 years when DS is 5/at school. DH changed his hours initially to cover some of my working hours.

Honestly though if we would have both had to keep doing 9-5 with DS in full-time nursery in order to pay mortgage etc. I probably wouldn't have had a baby. DH's income covers most of the bills and mine covers nursery plus a bit extra.

MyGrassIsBrowner · 19/08/2021 12:16

You just do. You make it work. I'll be honest, my DP earns 25k I'm a SAHP. We dont live lavishly, but we have a very nice 3 bedroom house. Mortgage is cheap, North Lincolnshire based. We spend within our means, own a lot of second hand stuff we buy off FB Marketplace that is practically brand new. We dont go abroad, but we save and enjoy holidays around the UK. We have a nice big family car. We dont necessarily make huge sacrifices to our own lifestyle but we do have to pre-plan what we do and what we're going to be able to spend. We manage our outgoings well and live within our means. Me being a SAHP means we dont pay out for childcare right now, but in the future I will probably get a part-time job and use the free hours for nursery. I'm 33 weeks pregnant with baby no.2 now. It will be hard work, but then again, we're having another girl so she's getting all of my DDs newborn stuff, we actually haven't had to buy a thing new as we have everything we need already. It's doable.
God what I'd love to be having a household income of 72k a year though, lol. X

Muddydoor · 19/08/2021 12:16

How does anyone afford anything? Its about priorities. Start looking for a nursery while pregnant and go back to work dead early if money is your priority. Or make changes.

movingadviceneeded · 19/08/2021 12:15

You make it work. I had an enhanced mat package but still had 4 months on SMP. You don't really socialise, probably aren't drinking much, babies bits are much cheaper second hand, etc. I was the higher earner and took 11 months off; 4 months on full pay / annual leave, 3 months on half ish pay and 4 months on SMP. We saved £7-8k before I went on mat leave to make up for the pay gap and just makes it work - came out of it with £4K savings still.

I went back part time and am now not the higher earner which has stung a bit, but we've still managed to save for a mortgage deposit whilst I've been part time. Also love in London (new house is not in London Grin).