Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do people afford kids?

337 replies

crumbsnamechange · 19/08/2021 12:02

I feel like I'm missing a massive trick here!

DP and I earn around £72k jointly (I earn the bulk of that at £48k, but have ~£250 per month student loans, and high pension payments, and pay slightly more of the cut of the rent than him). DP is expecting to earn a higher salary in about 18 months' time, but it's not guaranteed, and it's uncertain how much higher.

If I went on maternity leave say within the next year, that would leave us with a severe shortfall as DP's salary alone plus maternity pay wouldn't sustain us (we live near London so our current joint income only just covers huge rent and current outgoings with a bit of savings).

How do people manage it? I've been reading on other forums about how you just make do, you sacrifice your lifestyle and don't go out as much etc. so more money for rent and baby, rely on relatives etc. so not paying huge nursery fees all the time etc. It just seems so hard, a huge stress, and unsustainable. And that's before I even consider the effect a baby would have on my career. Would it be foolish to consider a baby now since I don't even know how we would afford it?

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 19/08/2021 14:14

I agree re maternity leave not being the problem (as you can have a short leave of money is tight) but the childcare afterwards is what you need to look at.

Pigeonpocket · 19/08/2021 14:14

Some people can afford kids on less money because they either live somewhere with a much lower cost of living, have family help with childcare, have a mortgage from a few years ago when house prices were lower, or get help in some other way.

Other people who have none of those things afford kids by cutting back a lot or changing something (house, career). If you can't afford a baby with your current lifestyle, then you change your lifestyle if you want a baby.

We earn a little bit more than you combined, but can't afford another mat leave unless we leave London. So we're leaving London. To buy a place that's smaller than the one we currently rent because we can't afford more on one salary or two salaries plus multiple nursery fees. Hopefully it's only temporary until the kids are in school and childcare is less of an issue, and we can get our careers back on track.

Viviennemary · 19/08/2021 14:13

I reckon it's where you live that's the problem and also the person doing the childcare would usually be the lower earner. You need to writd down all outgoings. See if any savings can be made and if you are spending money on unnecessary stuff.

rubyandbel · 19/08/2021 14:13

Put some money away before hand to cover any shortfall. Childminders are often cheaper than nurseries and offer so much for your little one. Remember you will receive 30 funded hours once your child turns 3. You can baby stuff virtually new on marketplace or ebay. Consider a mortgage holiday and go on price comparison sites for utilities. No greater feeling than your own child. Good luck

Incywinceyspider · 19/08/2021 14:08

You'd manage. Your employer will pay your pension contributions and you won't put any money into savings. So there's a bit to start off with.

Baby stuff is quite cheap second hand. You also don't need all the stuff that the Internet tells you you need.

Would shared parental leave be an option?

You have 10 KIT days you can be paid for.

To be honest the question is not whether you can afford maternity leave. You can stagger through for 9 months/a year. The question is whether you can afford the childcare when you go back to work. That's where the money really goes!

Booboosweet · 19/08/2021 14:06

The biggest outgoing is childcare and wrap around care. It currently costs us 800 euro amonth for someone to bring her to school and collect her and have her in the afternoons. This will continue until she's 12 and can lock up and get to and from school herself. No way could we afford for one of us to be a stay at home parent though. We both earn the same amount 50000 euro a year because we do the same job. We couldn't afford to give that up because we need to think about pensions and the future. I also want to give her a deposit for a house. So it is very expensive for about a decade but after that you'll reap the financial benefit of having two parents in work and your dc will benefit too.

kikisparks · 19/08/2021 14:02

We suffered from infertility and loss so ended up having 4 years to save- we can now cover the shortfall between my salary and maternity pay and should still have extra savings left over for holidays, baby items and emergencies.

We did have some savings to start with but used some on home upgrades etc over the years. If I’d gotten, and stayed, pregnant straight away we’d have had to delay those improvements, saved hard for 9 months and I’d probably have had to take a shorter maternity leave and maybe even put things on a zero percent credit card. We earn an equal amount each though, if my DH was a much lower earner I think we’d do shared parental leave and he’d take some of it.

Mary46 · 19/08/2021 14:02

It does mean a big lifestyle change. Its alot factors op cost of rent etc. I have 2 teens but I took time out as creche was alot for 2. Depends some people have good family support to help. But 2 incomes is better but I dont regret my time out.

nanbread · 19/08/2021 14:02

When I had DS1 I earned about 42k and DH earned around 32k, so similar amounts to you.

I asked my employer for better maternity pay and they obliged, giving me 50% pay for 4.5 months after the initial 6 weeks. Worth looking into? It wasn't their policy and was purely at discretion of manager based on the individual which I think is wrong, but always worth asking.

We lived v v frugally when was pregnant and on mat leave.

We bought everything 2nd hand, unless we borrowed or procured it for free. Bagged some real bargains.

I went back to work after 9 months (more like 10 once I'd factored in accrued annual leave) so always had some income even if only from maternity pay.

Remember your pay is likely to go up alongside your costs going up.

GreenTortoise · 19/08/2021 14:00

@Malin52

Don't have kids is the answer. It's not mandatory. Have a wonderful life without them and feel safe in the knowledge you are doing the best thing for the environment and climate change.
Oh give over! I hope you don't drive a car or eat meat.

You're wrong anyway. More countries now have policies to protect the climate. You forget that when our children are grown or grandchildren many changes would've already been made like
electric cars etc.

To say what you did is not only false. It's also wrong.

Our future generation aren't the ones ruining the planet. That's been done by the selfish generations before them. They are literally our future.

Dishwashersaurous · 19/08/2021 14:00

13:53Sceptre86 how do you feed four people, including having a takeaway for £100 a Month?

That's 3.6 per meal assuming no snacks. (4×30×3 meals a day)

Biancadelrioisback · 19/08/2021 14:00

We earned about £50k between is (split equally) so when I went on mat leave it was a bit of a disaster.
I got £550 a month on SMP and my share of the outgoings was £500, so I had £50 for the month. Was awful but we just about managed it. No luxuries were had until after I got back to work

JeVoudrais · 19/08/2021 13:59

I earn £47k DH earns £35k. Or I did, I've just gone back four days so earn more like £38k now.

We own we don't rent which was important to me before DC. My parents were awful with money and I wanted the stability of owning even with a mortgage before having a baby.

DH can't do part time in his job but I'm the 'better' parent for more time with DD anyway, in that I desperately want time with her having spent all of her life with her whereas DH is used to being the parent not around as much. We only have one day off altogether a week so this means we only need nursery for three days which costs about £615 a month with the tax free childcare element. We have a car on PCP at £350 a month. When that's up I'll pay the balloon payment to keep it but we will be £350 better off a month and won't get another PCP of that price if at all. Things like that we will cut back on but it doesn't really bother me, we had the cash free before and we don't now. Our mortgage is £1200 a month and our pets are our vices and not very cheap. Other than that we don't less expensive lifestylesz

Charbead49 · 19/08/2021 13:59

Combined income £150k, partner on 90k. We have 3 kids under 4 and live in London.

Savings before we had taken helped as we bought our house before children, mortgage less than renting i think.

I take mat leave, 6 months paid, 6 months unpaid but have always taken the full year.

We use a nursery a free days a week. Kids have been full time when I was working full time which is hard.

Mscarna · 19/08/2021 13:58

You have to adjust things, sometimes drastically. I went from a City job to being a part time carer a long way down the trainline from London. Schools become an issue once they're 3. Something has to give ultimately. I don't know any couples where they both continued to work as they did before DC. But it's all worth it.

Greytminds · 19/08/2021 13:57

Ah yes and this time around I’m taking 9 months off and DH will take 3 months so the salary impact is minimised.

Parkingt111 · 19/08/2021 13:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

sar302 · 19/08/2021 13:56

We worked out how much money I would get across Mat leave in total, then divided it by the 12 months. So that when I had more money the first 6 months we put some of that away and used it to top up the last 6 months when I went down to statutory and then nothing.

It meant that our overall income dropped for the year, but didn't drop off a cliff at the 6 month mark.

The couples I know where women were higher or equal earners split maternity and paternity leave (dad took over at about the 6 month mark) and then both dropped a day, so we're only paying for childcare 3 days a week. Obviously not possible in all jobs.

If you do decide to move further out, remember to take the cost of commuting into account. We moved out of london and rent dropped by £400, but commuting costs went up by £400, so there was no saving there. We just got more house for the money.

ballroompink · 19/08/2021 13:56

Ok so when we had DC1, DH and I both worked full time and earned 25k each. When I was pregnant we saved as hard as we could. I didn't get enhanced maternity pay and my statutory pay only just covered all our outgoings. I only took nine months off for this reason as we couldn't afford for me to take unapid leave. We lived very frugally while I was on mat leave - no holiday, no luxuries, we bought second hand baby stuff where we could. We opted for a childminder when I went back to work full time as we couldn't afford nursery. Even when DC1 was a toddler we holidayed with family, didn't really spend much on clothes, days out, etc. If we wanted to do any home renovation we couldn't afford to do that AND have a proper holiday. For DC2 we earned slightly more but again had to save hard while I was pregnant and couldn't take unpaid leave, etc. DH loves a spreadsheet so we worked everything out re: what we could afford every month. Again I bought plenty second hand and used all hand-me-downs from DC1. We had to leave at least a 4.5 year age gap between kids as we couldn't afford to pay two lots of full time childcare at once.

We are much more comfortably off now so things are very different. We live in a cheaper area than you so your housing costs are a massive factor here (mortgage is £700 a month; it was £450 when we had DC1) so moving, if possible, could make things easier for you?

Greytminds · 19/08/2021 13:56

How old are you @crumbsnamechange? I’d be keen to be clear of student debt and in a position to buy a house before having a child ideally, but not at the compromise of leaving it so late that there are fertility risks.

Being close to friends is really important. Being at the heart of the action becomes much less so when you have kids! Suddenly nice parks and good primary schools are your main requirement!

I started ttc at 32 and (for non-age related reasons) didn’t have DD until almost 38. I’m pregnant with #2 now at 41.

The advantage of having children so late is that we are homeowners with a small mortgage, lots of savings and established careers. I have carried on working 4 days a week and am the higher earner on a salary package worth around £120k - having been promoted and increased my earnings by more than 30% since having DD1 - it doesn’t have to be the death of your career! I saved up enough to fund maternity leave without having to worry and will do the same this time. DH earns half what I do, and tends to have more flexibility so picks up more of the domestic jobs.

Sleepyquest · 19/08/2021 13:54

You save for a year beforehand to cover the shortfall whilst you're off

ElizaDoolots · 19/08/2021 13:53

It can be tough. I’m the higher earner and DH really doesn’t want to take any leave as he’s still trying to build his career. So it makes maternity leave difficult because our household income drops massive whilst I’m out. We’re managing it by saving a decent amount before mat leave, cutting back expenses where we can, and I’ll be going back to work a bit sooner than I’d like to. In an ideal world the lower earning man would take some time out, would your DP consider this?

Childcare is also obviously a massive expense. We earn a bit more than you (£110k combined) and find paying for full time childcare for 2 children is still a massive hit and means we have to make sacrifices elsewhere. Those costs drop a lot after they turn 3 and then when they go to school so we figure that we just need to tighten our belts for a few years.

There are lots of different ways of managing it, and on your salaries I definitely think it’s manageable, but even on a good income you’ll need to compromise on something and you need to decide what that’s going to be. For us, the main compromise is not having the big house that we could get so we keep our mortgage payments low and only having one cheap car.

Howshouldibehave · 19/08/2021 13:53

If money is tight then it might have to be a very short maternity leave-you don’t have to take 9 months/a year. I went back when DC1 was 16 weeks. Luckily, only part time.

Save like mad now as well which will help cover the gaps in your salary when you’re on a reduced salary.

Have you looked at childcare-this was £30 a day when I was looking and that was 20 years ago and outside London! Work out the sort of monthly cost you’ll have and then you’ll have some figures to play with.

Kids are expensive!

Sceptre86 · 19/08/2021 13:53

We have the same income but live in Scotland and own one car between us and have a mortgage at £750 a month. We budget so food shopping is rarely more than £100 a month. Both dh and I make packed lunches. We both cook from scratch and have a takeaway once a week.We haven't had a holiday abroad in 6 years but pre covid have enjoyed lots of uk weekend breaks. With the kids we still go to softplay, parks , the cinema etc. We just cut our cloth accordingly and manage to save. We have two kids with our third on the way. I didn't buy anything secondhand with our first but did reuse all our big purchases with our second although this time one or two of the big items has needed replacing. I have bought some new clothes for the baby but not many as I have a lot of neutral stuff from my older two and plenty of 'girl', 'boy' clothing as the eldest are a dd and then ds. I still have a monthly facial and get my hair done every 3 months, dh gets his hair done more regularly. Neither of us has expensive hobbies or spends shed loads on clothes.

I was the higher earner when we were expecting our first child and saved throughout the pregnancy. I am now part time and dh earns 2.5x my wages. One of my working days is at the weekend so dh has the kids and we save on childcare. He is able to work from home on my two other workings days so we save money and he is able to do pick ups and drop offs.

My maternity pay is no where near generous, 3 months full pay and then smp for a further 6. I am lucky that dh is now a high earner enabling me to take the full year off and I also save whilst pregnant so we don't struggle with expenses.

sqirrelfriends · 19/08/2021 13:52

For me it was either waiting until we had a good pot or just making it work. "Making it work" to me wasn't an option, I didn't want to have the stress of struggling financially along with the stress of a new baby. I made sure we had enough saved that didn't have to worry about maternity leave and at least the first year of childcare.

I think a lot of people cope on low incomes, but they receive income support (as they should), but being in the middle, on an good enough income to not receive any help can make things uncomfortably tight.

Swipe left for the next trending thread