Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do people afford kids?

337 replies

crumbsnamechange · 19/08/2021 12:02

I feel like I'm missing a massive trick here!

DP and I earn around £72k jointly (I earn the bulk of that at £48k, but have ~£250 per month student loans, and high pension payments, and pay slightly more of the cut of the rent than him). DP is expecting to earn a higher salary in about 18 months' time, but it's not guaranteed, and it's uncertain how much higher.

If I went on maternity leave say within the next year, that would leave us with a severe shortfall as DP's salary alone plus maternity pay wouldn't sustain us (we live near London so our current joint income only just covers huge rent and current outgoings with a bit of savings).

How do people manage it? I've been reading on other forums about how you just make do, you sacrifice your lifestyle and don't go out as much etc. so more money for rent and baby, rely on relatives etc. so not paying huge nursery fees all the time etc. It just seems so hard, a huge stress, and unsustainable. And that's before I even consider the effect a baby would have on my career. Would it be foolish to consider a baby now since I don't even know how we would afford it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Angliski · 27/08/2021 08:50

My DH is Sahp. I run my own company so have much more flexibility than most but nursery is the big hit. We found three mornings was about right for everyone’s sanity and general level of house tidiness! Plus with a lockdown baby, it was his chance to at least socialise as playgroups etc still not open round our way.

I work 3 days. Each of us has a day where we are responsible for ds with no nursery. DH has two days when nursery is on and I have one. That seems to work well. The gp surgery cannot seem to accept that DH is primary contact and refuse to call him about anything.

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 27/08/2021 08:34

@twinningatlife

*We as grandparents provide all the childcare. If you REALLY want a baby, you will be prepared to make compromises and sacrificies.*

So YOU save them the best part of £1-£2k per month on childcare

They haven't compromised at all or sacrificed anything. YOU have

I know right?! What planet are some people living on! I could walk around in sack cloth and live off gruel and I still couldn’t save the equivalent of completely free childcare Confused Not sure it’s my place to sacrifice my parents’ retirement on their behalf though!
maddening · 27/08/2021 07:59

Lower your pensions for 18 months, put that aside.

Does your company offer enhanced maternity? My company is 6 months full pay, then the rest stat. If you have similar you could take 6 months and then what is saved from not putting in pensions could cover dh paternal leave for 6 months as you would have saved for 18 months, 9 months of.pregnancy and 6 months full pay maternity. Hopefully by then dh has increased his earnings also which will also be needed for childcare anyway.

For us I had vol redundancy which was a years salary with no tax, so I did get a other year off, so when I went to a new job ds was able to go to a pre school at just over 2yo, that was £29 pet day 8-6 so more affordable and childcare vouchers meant we saved some tax. It was slightly cheaper after he was 3. I live in the northwest though so probably cheaper childcare.

BabyLeaf · 27/08/2021 07:46

@twinningatlife

*We as grandparents provide all the childcare. If you REALLY want a baby, you will be prepared to make compromises and sacrificies.*

So YOU save them the best part of £1-£2k per month on childcare

They haven't compromised at all or sacrificed anything. YOU have

That was the most tone deaf comment in the entire thread.
twinningatlife · 27/08/2021 06:20

@crumbsnamechange

Our high rent really is the problem, added to that DP's current low income. I find myself caught between a rock and a hard place though. If we move to a cheaper area (further away from London) then we will have high commuting costs, be more tired (from baby and long travel times), and will still have nursery fees to consider as well as living in an area that is not nearly so fun. I honestly don't see how it's doable. The nursery fees are horrifying me! Sad

Your posts are hilarious - how about YOU get the promotion and yeah living somewhere "fun" goes to the bottom of the priority list If you want to afford children 🤦‍♀️

twinningatlife · 27/08/2021 06:17

We as grandparents provide all the childcare.
If you REALLY want a baby, you will be prepared to make compromises and sacrificies.

So YOU save them the best part of £1-£2k per month on childcare

They haven't compromised at all or sacrificed anything. YOU have

starlight13 · 26/08/2021 11:17

It depends how old you are really as need to be seriously thinking about having a family by mid thirties. That has usually given you 10-12 ish years of working etc behind you. Get on the housing ladder as soon as possible and remember that there is more to life than a career. Anything could happen tomorrow, live in the present and know that plenty can be achieved and a happier life is possible on much lower incomes.

namechange7865 · 24/08/2021 09:51

@Angrywife I can see where your user name comes from, with that and your ignorant vitriol towards others I think it's safe to say you are not very satisfied with the decisions you have made, happy people don't point fingers like that, but at least that negativity is around your kids all the time, lucky them!

ChameleonKola · 24/08/2021 08:57

@Angrywife

We stayed in a cheaper house with a cheap run around car, 3 night caravan holidays in the UK. A decision made before we had children to make it possible for me to give up work and stay at home with them. So many around us moved in to expensive houses, mortgages at the high end of what they could afford, had a car each and foreign holidays and weren't prepared to give them up so went out to work, spent a fortune on nurseries and continued their old life with a baby in tow. Priorities. My babies were mine, not my house or my car or my career.
Nasty judgmental comment. Their babies were their priority too and they were doing everything they could to give them the kind of life they wanted for their children. A nice place to live in a good area, travel experiences. Your babies weren’t any more your priority than theirs were theirs just because you chose a different life.

As a SAHP I hate parents like you spouting this crap. People with careers and nice homes aren’t screaming that those things are more important to them than their kids. They’re working and providing a nice place to live FOR their kids 🙄

Angrywife · 23/08/2021 14:54

We stayed in a cheaper house with a cheap run around car, 3 night caravan holidays in the UK.
A decision made before we had children to make it possible for me to give up work and stay at home with them.
So many around us moved in to expensive houses, mortgages at the high end of what they could afford, had a car each and foreign holidays and weren't prepared to give them up so went out to work, spent a fortune on nurseries and continued their old life with a baby in tow.
Priorities. My babies were mine, not my house or my car or my career.

ChameleonKola · 22/08/2021 09:38

@GinPin2

Daughter and Son in Law, both working, on about £30 total. Have 22 month old.

Expecting 2nd baby soon.

All baby equipment donated by his brothers and her sisters who all have 1 girl, 1 boy each.
Have been collecting nappies free off marketplace.
Clothes have been passed to the toddler and her sibling from her cousins and friends, as have toys. Or new as presents. Also lots of knitting and sewing has been done for the babies.
Not entitled to help from foodbanks but local churches have got together to provide a 'cheap shop' with free bread, fruit and veg left over from supermarkets available to anyone on limited disposable income, but not means tested like foodbanks.
Also use OLIO, open to anyone as its purpose is to stop food waste. Pick blackberries etc. Make jams & other preserves.
Lucky enough to live near the beach so seaside days. Camping holidays etc.
We as grandparents provide all the childcare.
Have their own home.
Both have to wear uniforn at work and they live in the country so do not feel the need to spend much on clothes.
Don't go out much but they consider themselves very lucky !
If you REALLY want a baby, you will be prepared to make compromises and sacrificies.

Funniest post I’ve seen all week. Of course they consider themselves lucky. They’re only managing to raise a child thanks to the enormous generosity of others, and continuing to have a second anyway. Don’t kid yourself that your last sentence applies to people who actually have to fund the child themselves.
Redwinestillfine · 21/08/2021 22:22

Work out your maternity shortfall and save up first. We saved to cover my share of bills and economised, bought second hand, budgeted etc. You can opt to save more so you ko more of your lifestyle but babies tend to cramp your style so you'll need less.

Cluelessgardener · 21/08/2021 22:14

Very similar situation to you with me being the higher earner. We saved up for a year and I took a full years mat leave. I didnt spend loads during my year off but had enough to cover the additional costs (because SMP didn't even cover the mortgage).

In all honesty you just make it work, but if you're planning ahead that means you have time to save.

Howshouldibehave · 21/08/2021 22:08

Daughter and Son in Law, both working, on about £30 total

I really would struggle on that!

GinPin2 · 21/08/2021 22:05

And keep hens so have ready supply of eggs.

GinPin2 · 21/08/2021 22:04

Daughter and Son in Law, both working, on about £30 total.
Have 22 month old.

Expecting 2nd baby soon.

All baby equipment donated by his brothers and her sisters who all have 1 girl, 1 boy each.
Have been collecting nappies free off marketplace.
Clothes have been passed to the toddler and her sibling from her cousins and friends, as have toys. Or new as presents. Also lots of knitting and sewing has been done for the babies.
Not entitled to help from foodbanks but local churches have got together to provide a 'cheap shop' with free bread, fruit and veg left over from supermarkets available to anyone on limited disposable income, but not means tested like foodbanks.
Also use OLIO, open to anyone as its purpose is to stop food waste. Pick blackberries etc. Make jams & other preserves.
Lucky enough to live near the beach so seaside days. Camping holidays etc.
We as grandparents provide all the childcare.
Have their own home.
Both have to wear uniforn at work and they live in the country so do not feel the need to spend much on clothes.
Don't go out much but they consider themselves very lucky !
If you REALLY want a baby, you will be prepared to make compromises and sacrificies.

Howshouldibehave · 21/08/2021 18:42

@panauchocolat

Exactly, same situation as me. How come you think that 70k is not enough…. Me and partner are also around 35k together and managed to buy a house… it is a struggle every single month to be honest but please stop moaning that 70k is a bad earning… there’s so many people worst than you ! Just don’t have kids because you will be completely screwed financially ! That’s it !!!!
Well, this is clearly very dependant on where you live!

How much was your house and what are your mortgage payments? I suspect they are v different from what the OP can get near to their work.

panauchocolat · 21/08/2021 18:39

Exactly, same situation as me.
How come you think that 70k is not enough….
Me and partner are also around 35k together and managed to buy a house… it is a struggle every single month to be honest but please stop moaning that 70k is a bad earning… there’s so many people worst than you !
Just don’t have kids because you will be completely screwed financially ! That’s it !!!!

Atla · 21/08/2021 16:42

Well I had NHS mat leave so income not zero. When I ds1 & 2 were babies we had no rent to pay as we lived in house inherited from MIL (jointly owned by DH and BIL and since sold/money used for deposit for our current house). DH was doing a MSc so money very tight for a year but it increased his earning power exponentially. We drove an ancient Clio. When I went back to work (30 hrs a week as a nurse) my wages barely covered childcare. We were entitled to some working tax credit and child tax credit back then plus child benefit.
For a long time we worked opposite each other, with me working nights and weekends to save on child care. I grew up in London and it is unfathomable to me how people in ordinary jobs (I'm counting myself in this) can afford rent these days, let alone buying property. Around 2005 I used to rent a 2 bed flat in zone 6 for £750 pcm - these days I bet it would be almost double that.

Howshouldibehave · 21/08/2021 16:22

See a PP explaining that their income went down to zero on mat leave but ‘we managed and I’d do it again!’ who curiously hasn’t replied to queries about how they managed...

Yes, I’d like to know his this can be ‘managed’ when your rent/childcare/bills are much higher than your income.

The ‘babies cost nothing and can sleep in a drawer till they’re 2’ brigade go extremely quiet when full time childcare costs are mentioned.

mnmumak · 21/08/2021 16:19

@WhatAShilohPitt

I’m actually surprised that more people don’t think seriously about the financial commitment of having children - it seems to be pretty common to assume that they’ll be healthy parents who will stay in work and they’ll cross that very remote bridge of illness / unemployment etc if they ever get to it. Covid showed how quickly that can change.

I mean, if you want to commit to a mortgage, the lender will make sure you aren’t overstretching, that you can afford repayments and that if you lose your job you’ll have insurance to cover the payments or your house gets repossessed. But with children, lots of people have several of them without knowing what they’ll do if they hit a period of unplanned financial worry. I can’t imagine having several children without a good chunk of savings to fall back on. So no, YANBU. You’re sensible!

Yeah, this. There are two types of people when it comes to this, the happy go lucky ‘it’ll figure itself out!’ type, usually backed by family money or practical support so winging it and it working out is all they’ve ever known. And the type who think carefully and cautiously because they know the buck stops with them.

See a PP explaining that their income went down to zero on mat leave but ‘we managed and I’d do it again!’ who curiously hasn’t replied to queries about how they managed...

Flyinggeese1 · 21/08/2021 15:35

OP I’m sorry if you’ve already covered this but I note you mentioned high pension contributions. Is it a possibility to reduce those during the ‘baby years’?

sleepyhoglet · 21/08/2021 13:46

Sorry, I realise you mention your salary in the original post. At under 50k you will get child benefit but once you go over that then it is gradually reduced.

sleepyhoglet · 21/08/2021 13:44

@crumbsnamechange I agree that your rent is prohibitive and a 2 bed flat isn't ideal for children anyway. Do you have the sort of jobs where you could move to another part of the country? What is your salary and what is your partners? I think the only way it would work is if you go back after 6 weeks and your partner takes the shared parental leave and is the main carer. Obviously very hard on you but financially the best. He might then be able to go back part time and maybe the in laws help with childcare- that's how I would do it.

TheKeatingFive · 21/08/2021 13:33

On that combined salary you should be able to manage.

You can drop/reduce your pension and SL costs on mat leave for starters.

If you’re the higher earner you might need to limit your leave and let DP take some or start childcare early.

Your outgoings during mat leave don't have to be high. You won’t be going out much anyway. Babies really don’t have to cost much despite all the marketing.

Can you rent somewhere cheaper?

Sounds like you need to run a few scenarios, but ppl do it on much much less, so there will be a way.