Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance - AIBU to be upset about this?

208 replies

IveGotPieInMyEar · 18/08/2021 22:29

I’ll preface this by saying I know I am being unreasonable to expect anything in the first place, and have no right to anything, but with that being said AIBU to feel upset?

My mother recently inherited from my grandmothers passing. My mother has discussed sharing out some of what she has received between me and my siblings, I have one sister and one brother.

Sister is a homeowner, and is looking to buy a bigger home, my mother has offered her £20,000 towards this.

Brother currently renting, mother has offered him £15,000 towards a deposit to get on the housing ladder.

I was offered £4000, which I think is the maximum yearly amount you can put in a help to buy ISA.

I have health problems which restrict my earning potential at the moment, I don’t own a home, currently in council housing with no real chance of moving on for now so I do understand her reasoning for the amounts given, that it would be a waste for me to have 1000s hanging around when I can’t do anything meaningful with it. I was really grateful to be offered the amount I was and was feeling hopeful about making a start to improve where I am in life. However, now this offer for me has been withdrawn and my mum has decided to give more to my sister who is looking at a house which costs more than she was originally prepared to pay.

I’m feeling quite upset about being left out, especially when I was offered less than the others in the first place. I know I had no right to any of this money in the first place and it doesn’t really change anything for me, im still in the same position as I am now. However, my sister is the only one of us who is married, she has had £5000, towards her wedding from my parents and around the same amount when she purchased her first home. I feel like the help already given has been unfair, and if my mum wanted to share, the amount she was prepared to give should have been split 3 equal ways or nothing given at all?

OP posts:
AnotherEmma · 19/08/2021 08:02

I think this is just one example as part of a long history of your mother treating you and your siblings differently. It sounds as if she plays favourites, and you might find it helpful to read about the golden child v scapegoat dynamic. Based on what you've already told us I think it's clear that your mother is dysfunctional and toxic. I strongly advise you to read "toxic parents" by Susan Forward. You might also find it helpful to read the Stately Homes threads and post on the thread or start your own thread in Relationships.

I don't think there is any point challenging your mother about her decision regarding this inheritance. I don't think she will listen to you or change her mind. If she was capable of doing that she wouldn't have behaved this day in the first place.

I think you should take this as confirmation that your mother is never going to treat you fairly and in the way that you deserve. And use this opportunity to rethink your involvement with her. If I were you I would step back, stop giving her things (money, time, help, etc) and try to stop expecting/hoping for things from her.

Flowers
RichTeaTime · 19/08/2021 07:59

Surely she thinks that any money she gives you will result in your benefits being docked so basically she will give it to the Gov. Whereas your sister will have something tangible for the money.
It also sounds like you are the black sheep and sis the favoured one - which she has made loud and clear.
Can you not buy a part rent part buy home in the area, is that impossible if you are on benefits. If that were possible she might be more likely to give you money - or could you have bought a car so you could visit her more often (not really).

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 19/08/2021 07:58

I agree it should be equal but maybe she’s planning to add more to the issue next year etc. She obviously wants it to be spent on property and stable homes for the future which is a great idea and currently with you working part time and so would struggle with a mortgage deal that isn’t possible. I wouldn’t want it to go to waste on general spending and treats when it can be used so much better.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 19/08/2021 07:49

It's not the cash - it's the hurt at the disparity.

Your mother is doing a dreadful thing. I could understand it if (say) you were the one doing well financially, and the others needed a boost, but it's actually the opposite.

I would be very hurt by this.

billy1966 · 19/08/2021 07:39

So she has sneakily borrowed money from you for your sister and never paid it back and is now doing this.

What an awful excuse she is.Flowers

Stickyjamhands · 19/08/2021 07:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

minatrina · 19/08/2021 07:17

Goodness, how awful! I'd be so upset, mostly just because I'd feel unloved! Surely the only thing you can do in your mother's situation is split the money equally between your children? And to offer you a pittance (in comparison to siblings) just to rescind the offer?!

I agree with previous posters, even if she has it in her head that this money should only be used for buying property, surely you could agree to sensibly invest your portion until the time comes?

Aside from your relationship with your mother, surely your mother must realise she's also created a situation that's going to breed resentment amongst siblings?!

I'm sorry OP, it's not just about the money is it, I'd just feel so hurt SadThanks

moose62 · 19/08/2021 07:12

It is nothing to do with the money really, it is more the difference with how your mother is treating you and where you obviously come in the pecking order. That is not acceptable and if she can't see it your siblings ought to point it out! Unless you want to carry on being treated as a third class citizen you need to make it very clear to her how unfair she is

Positivelyrandom · 19/08/2021 07:11

YANBU to be cheesed off. I really don’t understand why parents cause so much heartache by not giving equal monetary gifts. They may think that considering different circumstances is wise, but it never turns out to be so and always upsets their children. I’m sorry you’ve been treated like this. On the other hand, as one pp noted, it might be for the sake of benefits. Can you ask her directly what were her reasons? Try to stay calm. You may discover that she was thinking deeply about you all along.

Sciurus83 · 19/08/2021 07:10

Don't be a martyr, discuss it with her

SpeakingFranglais · 19/08/2021 07:09

@NeverTalkToStrangers

Are you getting benefits which would be affected by savings?
This is what I thought
drpet49 · 19/08/2021 07:04

** YANBU

Offering you less to start with was a really shitty thing to do but to then withdraw the offer is plain cruel.**

^This

Billybagpuss · 19/08/2021 06:36

You do need to say something though all the resentment will eat away at you. Although it may backfire.

THisbackwithavengeance · 19/08/2021 06:10

You need to talk to your mum.

Calmly. No need to go in all guns blazing or spoiling for a fight. .

Tell her you feel that you are being unfairly treated.

And see what she says to that.

My initial thought was that if you are on means tested benefits and in a secure council tenancy with HB, she might think you need it less than the others.

But I'm not your mum so I don't know!.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 19/08/2021 06:08

Eeek, just read the bit where she's already had money off you to give to your sister - wtaf??

Did she ever pay that back? I'd be asking for that back at the very least - fucking hell! Shock

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 19/08/2021 06:05

YANBU, that's shockingly unfair of her. :(

Catflapkitkat · 19/08/2021 05:26

I think this is beyond cruel. Like others have said I cannot imagine a doing this with my children - unless there was an issue like drugs/drink/gambling but even then I would earmark it for help or better times.

What is your relationship like with your siblings? How can they think this is fair?

When your Mother told you this, was it gave to face? How did you react? Did you say anything?

againreallyplase · 19/08/2021 04:42

I don't know how I could continue a relationship with any of them after that. I'd cut her off.

Bogeyes · 19/08/2021 04:37

What an awful thing to do? I have experienced this in smaller incidents. My MIL thought highly of her sons than her daughter and the daughter did all the shopping and daily chores. Oh yes...they were her favourites but she never heard what they said about MIL behind her back They were ungrateful entitled pigs.

Billybagpuss · 19/08/2021 04:33

Did your mum ever pay you back for the loan you gave?

BruisedPear · 19/08/2021 04:02

Sorry OP YANBU how unfair!
Your mum really is being unreasonable. I would challenge her on it if I was you. Just because you live in council housing doesn’t mean you can’t invest the money or have it as a safety net.
I would side eye my siblings if they were aware of the arrangement and didn’t speak up for me or highlight how unfair it was.
If your mum feels she is right to leave you out, I would go low contact and definitely leave her elderly care to my siblings.
Sending hugs don’t let them make you feel shitty Flowers

fiveminustwocats · 19/08/2021 02:42

YANBU - your mother sounds horrible. I would be remembering this when she needs help in the future. In fact I would go further and take a huge step back from being involved in her life at all.

I am so sorry you have such a shitty parent OP Flowers

Bananasarnie · 19/08/2021 02:03

I think it’s terribly unfair on you. Do you think your siblings could have influenced your mothers decision? Influencing where the money went to their advantage?

If your mother is older and not as astute she may not realise this, nor thought about how her decision has affected you.

I have a brother who has never worked, never intends to work and yet he has persuaded me to give him money, very convincing at the time when I was on a low. He went on to inherit a 6 figure sum from a second cousin of ours he befriended. I can now see what he is after where my father and uncle are concerned.

Nothing I can do about it though because he has such a strong influence over them.

Thehop · 19/08/2021 01:32

Talk to her about it, Definitely. It’s really awful.

aloris · 19/08/2021 01:26

"There has always been a bit of inequality, I’ve always been the one they’ve expected the most from and given the least back too. My mum has borrowed money off me before because she wanted to give my sister some but didn’t have enough to give her herself. I didn’t know this was why she wanted money at the time and haven’t lent her any more since then, I’m not sure if that’s why. But she’d never ask anyone else, it was always me."

I'm sorry you have been treated this way by your mother. Is there a way you can speak up and say that you are not happy with the unequal treatment? It's true that it's her inheritance to do with what she wishes, but when her unequal gifting of the inheritance is combined with her using your meagre savings to help her other children, maybe you need to just voice that it makes you feel "less than," and that it comes off a bit cruel.