Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance - AIBU to be upset about this?

208 replies

IveGotPieInMyEar · 18/08/2021 22:29

I’ll preface this by saying I know I am being unreasonable to expect anything in the first place, and have no right to anything, but with that being said AIBU to feel upset?

My mother recently inherited from my grandmothers passing. My mother has discussed sharing out some of what she has received between me and my siblings, I have one sister and one brother.

Sister is a homeowner, and is looking to buy a bigger home, my mother has offered her £20,000 towards this.

Brother currently renting, mother has offered him £15,000 towards a deposit to get on the housing ladder.

I was offered £4000, which I think is the maximum yearly amount you can put in a help to buy ISA.

I have health problems which restrict my earning potential at the moment, I don’t own a home, currently in council housing with no real chance of moving on for now so I do understand her reasoning for the amounts given, that it would be a waste for me to have 1000s hanging around when I can’t do anything meaningful with it. I was really grateful to be offered the amount I was and was feeling hopeful about making a start to improve where I am in life. However, now this offer for me has been withdrawn and my mum has decided to give more to my sister who is looking at a house which costs more than she was originally prepared to pay.

I’m feeling quite upset about being left out, especially when I was offered less than the others in the first place. I know I had no right to any of this money in the first place and it doesn’t really change anything for me, im still in the same position as I am now. However, my sister is the only one of us who is married, she has had £5000, towards her wedding from my parents and around the same amount when she purchased her first home. I feel like the help already given has been unfair, and if my mum wanted to share, the amount she was prepared to give should have been split 3 equal ways or nothing given at all?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Perky1 · 25/08/2021 17:59

I wonder if your dear grandmother would have wanted her money to be used in such a divisive way. I am sorry about this OP xx

savannahnights · 25/08/2021 00:51

@LemonSwan

Hmm sorry but I think I am going to go against the grain.

In my family we never just give money for the sake of it, its always for a need. Perhaps she shares this mentality.

An example - My parents gave us some extra cash for our first time buyer house c. 10k (5k to push us into a lower interest rate and another 5k to spend on renovating the bathroom). Thats what we needed - we didn't need more.

My sister is buying a flat in London. She needs tenfold what I do to make this work; and I don't begrudge that because she needs a home too.

Sure she could give up her career (London centric) and do something else but thats not really fair is it. I do what I love, why shouldn't she.

So I think you do have good reason to be annoyed that your mum borrowed money off you to give to your sister without asking. Thats not nice.

And you would have reason to be annoyed if she was giving them this money for any other reason bar housing. But as it stands if its for housing and you already have secure housing then I am not so sure sorry.

In OP's mother's case, it is no doubt based on favouritism (based on the OP's comments, the sister is clearly the golden child) since she's giving the most to the child who needs it the least because she can afford to buy a house without any additional help from her mother and has enough equity to get a good mortgage.
LovelyIssues · 21/08/2021 22:28

It should be split equally regardless of anyone's situation. Situations can dramatically change over the years

Hiphopboppertybop99 · 21/08/2021 21:36

Has your mum ever given you back the money she borrowed from you to give to your sister? If not I would be asking for this to be returned as soon as possible.
As many other PPs have said your mother's actions are very unfair. So what if your siblings are in a position to buy a house, why should funding that come from your share of an inheritance. What would they have done without the inheritance money? Your mother sounds awful.

Barmychick · 21/08/2021 18:12

I'm so sorry for the way your mother has treated you,You deserve much better and a better mother too! My friend is regularly treated like this and I have had this treatment within my own family. No more! Please reduce contact with these horrid narcisstic people I fear that they are unlikely to change and will only continue to hurt you if you allow it. Good luck op.

Scorpio75kaz · 21/08/2021 17:57

YANBU I’m so sorry you’ve been treated this way FlowersSad can’t imagine how crappy it must be making you feel x

nutellachops · 21/08/2021 16:14

OP she is wrong ,she should of given you all equal amounts regardless what you individually needed it for ....a gift is a gift.

Roxy69 · 21/08/2021 12:59

Really sad for you, it must be extremely hurtful however you try to look at it. I admit it would be hard to start a conversation about it. FlowersCake

WorkHardPlayHard1 · 21/08/2021 10:49

@Planttrees

This is awful and reminded me of this:
Best diagram I've seen x Star
WorkHardPlayHard1 · 21/08/2021 10:39

@Mirw

That's families. I have only ever had car insurance paid by my parents, apart from a loan of £300 for uni fees. My brothers have all had gifts of money from mother. My sister had a loan to help with her mortgage. See the pattern. Girls equal loans, boys equal gifts.

No point in wondering or greetin', just accept that is the way of some families and move on.

No way. You are enabling this unfairness by not speaking up. As other op has said show yours this thread too. I couldn't respect a parent who did this and it would def cause a rift in the family that am sure your parents would not want xxx
WorkHardPlayHard1 · 21/08/2021 10:35

@Billandben444

I hope the OP comes back after she's had a talk with her mother with the reasoning behind it all.
Me too!

Communication is key and potential for a lifelong fall out is clear if its not aired and resolved xx

NeverTalkToStrangers · 21/08/2021 10:19

If the OP is still thinking that the clause suggests that her DF “really” wanted the DGC to have the money I’ll give the example of my own very simple will.

It leaves everything to my DH, unless he doesn’t survive me, in which case everything goes in equal shares to our DC. If none of them survive me because we’re all wiped out in a plane crash or whatever then everything I own goes to my DSis. In DH’s will if the DC and I die his half of our considerable assets, along with his personal bank account, would go to his DB.

There’s no sense in which we “intend” to give my DSis and his DBs the money - they’re all financially independent adults. It’s simply a fall back position which prevents the money going to our elderly parents due to intestacy and funnels the money to the people who can make use of it.

pam290358 · 21/08/2021 09:24

There’s another aspect to this. Is your mum elderly or in poor health, because if she needed care in the near future, the LA could possibly decide that she had deliberately reduced her assets to avoid care fees. They could potentially come after anyone in receipt of the ‘gift’ to recover fees in certain circumstances. There’s also the matter of inheritance tax payable on gifts over £3000 in one year.

Chris08 · 21/08/2021 08:42

In all honesty if I were your sister I wouldn’t stand for such disparity as it could cause life long resentment. Your mum sounds heartless.

Billandben444 · 21/08/2021 07:50

I hope the OP comes back after she's had a talk with her mother with the reasoning behind it all.

Annieconn · 21/08/2021 04:42

Your mother should share it out equally. It's your sisters responsibility to sort her own house out.

calvados · 21/08/2021 00:00

Regardless of where your children are in life, whether they are married or single, whether they are home owners or renters, whether they are healthy or unwell, whether they are parents or childless; your children must be treated equally! Thus, yes you are right to be disgruntled OP. Show your mum this thread!

Erwhatno · 20/08/2021 23:31

That’s awful op. I couldn’t have a relationship with a mother and siblings like this.I’m so sorry Flowers

Theworldspinsonmyhead · 20/08/2021 23:13

That's awful. It should be split equally.

You could make your life far better with that, renovate your council house, get therapies or Heath care that assists you better than the nhs.

You absolutely deserve to be treated equally I'm so sorry Flowers

Unsure33 · 20/08/2021 23:04

Of course you would not expect anything UNLESS your siblings were getting gifts .

I would be furious and tbh never speak to my mother again . How cruel .

Frodogo · 20/08/2021 22:53

I can imagine some situations where your mother might be reasonable to not want to give you money, say if you had an addiction that meant you'd spend it all on self-destructive behaviour or were in a bad relationship where someone would take the money from you and waste it. But with no backstory of that sort, your mother is being horrible. Offering less, then changing her mind and offering nothing?

I'd have to tell her how I felt and why, even if I worried she'd think I was wrong to "expect" anything. I'd tell her how I felt, and after that, I'd put some serious distance between us. I'd want to deny her access to my life and any future opportunities to hurt me by the blatant disparity in how she treated me versus my siblings.

Mirw · 20/08/2021 22:51

That's families. I have only ever had car insurance paid by my parents, apart from a loan of £300 for uni fees. My brothers have all had gifts of money from mother. My sister had a loan to help with her mortgage. See the pattern. Girls equal loans, boys equal gifts.

No point in wondering or greetin', just accept that is the way of some families and move on.

Lindylindyloo · 20/08/2021 22:46

YANBU - awful treatment.

TimeIhadaNameChange · 20/08/2021 22:41

What is your mother's relationship like with you, and with your siblings? Does she think her relationship with you is the easiest? I'm wondering if something like that is behind it, that she feels she has to work harder to keep them close. I have something similar in my family, whereby my mum is so scared of losing my sister her wants get placed above all else. The sad thing is she doesn't see how much this has damaged our relationship.

Whatever the reason you have to say something. It'll eat you up if you don't.

purplebunny2012 · 20/08/2021 22:38

I think that's really terrible. My sister and I would definitely have received the same amount even though I'm married with a child and my sister is single but earns a lot more than I do.
Your mother is being thoughtless

Swipe left for the next trending thread