Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think, if you run over a cat, you don't just dump it on the pavement and fuck off

218 replies

inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 18:28

God, it was awful.

DD (13) and I were just behind a car that ran over a cat, the poor little thing had a serious head injury (completely unsurvivable) and was convulsing in the middle of the road.

The driver and her passenger got out of their car, picked up the cat and unceremoniously dumped it on the pavement. I pulled up behind, got out to see to the cat (it very quickly passed away, fortunately) and asked if they were going to take it to the vet - the bloke said "I've got asthma" and they buggered off!

Fortunately another woman who was behind me also stopped and she offered to take the poor wee thing to the vet to see if it was microchipped as DD was extremely upset by this stage (she adores cats and it was a nasty thing to witness). So her and I wrapped it's body in DDs (knackered) sleeping bag which I happened to have in the boot and she took it.

I'm now sitting in the car whilst DD has her trampolining lesson and am a little bit traumatised to be honest! And a bit bloody angry. I hold no grievance towards them about hitting a cat - shit happens, and it's one of the things you learn to accept is a possibility if you have an outdoor cat (which we do). But to leave a dying cat on the pavement after you've hit it is, I think, despicable.

OP posts:
Weeble09 · 18/08/2021 20:04

Some people are just vile dicks. I've been late for work, including shifts as a carer, when stopping to help injured animals (pets and wildlife). If there's only me to help, then work just has to take second place. I'm not going to leave an animal suffering if I'm even remotely able to help.

I'm also one of the people who volunteer to collect dead RTA cats and take them to be scanned, it's horrible to do especially when nobody has even had the compassion to move an animal to the side of the road. Even if you're allergic, or don't like animals, at least stop to move one out of the way of traffic.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/08/2021 20:03

I dont know. It's a nice thing to do. But the whole cats are free to roam / they are wild and have the right to shit in the garden / cat owners comparing them to foxes and badgers who shit everywhere in the wild...and then expect someone to treat your animal, who you have let out in the road, with much more compassion than a wild animal. Again although it's the right thing to do a lot of people will be too busy (eg if you were going to get pay docked or a warning if on the way to work) or just too squeamish

donenowplease · 18/08/2021 20:02

I couldn't personally give a fuck if you miss an appointment or have "allergies", if you hit an animal and leave it to die you are a dickhead.

So you think someone's a 'dickhead' for putting their cancer screening or job interview or flight or any appointment with our already overstretched and backlogged nhs, above a dead animal. Do you have any idea how long the wait is for very important nhs appointments, can be months or even years. And your lack of sympathy for people with allergies is far worse than peoples lack of sympathy for a dead cat. I hope you never have yourself or a loved on go into anaphylaxis or break out in hives and struggle to breathe from exposure Hmm

Of course it's sad when anything dies and I'm not surprised a young child is upset. But frankly life is busy, people have a million other things going on and human lives and the things needed to live it (jobs, medical appointments, punctuality etc) are in most cases a higher priority than a dead cat not being left on the pavement. It's not nice but it's life and practicality. If someone came on here moaning that they'd been disciplined at work for being late or had missed a medical appointment and couldn't get another for months, and their reason was they stopped for a dead cat they would be told to prioritise better.

Dontwatchfootball · 18/08/2021 20:00

Their behaviour was awful and completely out of line. As a pet owner, thank you for stopping and doing what you could. Thank goodness most people are decent and would not just walk away from this. A few years ago my neighbour found a dead cat by the side of the road. He and I split the block and knocked on every door to find the owners. They were so grateful to know what had happened, even if heartbroken about it.

Snugglepumpkin · 18/08/2021 19:57

I don't like animals (& I don't drive so I'll never be the one who hits one with a car) but if I was a driver I'd stop to check on the cat if it was still alive because it is an animal & I'd prefer it didn't suffer.

I wouldn't give a damn about the owners feelings though.
If they cared about the cat that much, it wouldn't be out on a busy road.
I have zero empathy for the human family who don't care where their pet shits because it's 'free to roam' but want people to care about their feelings when they let their pet come to harm by letting it out.

TractorAndHeadphones · 18/08/2021 19:55

@inigomontoyahwillcox

If it's alive, yes, wrong to leave it.

It was alive when they left.

But you said the injuries were unsurvivable - so it would have been dead by the time anyone got to the vet, wouldn’t it?
PeterCorbeau · 18/08/2021 19:55

If I really, honest to god had no time because I was doing something so utterly important and the cat had definitely passed away, I would:

See if someone else driving past could assist
Call a local vet
Post on a local FB group asking for assistance

If the cat was alive, I'm not going anywhere till someone else is on the scene and able to assist. If it's totally rural, then I'll pick the cat up and just have to be late. I'm not leaving someone's pet alive in agony because I have 'an appointment'.

CausingChaos2 · 18/08/2021 19:52

@Knittingupastorm

if you can’t have the cat in your car, then ring someone who can.

Such as? Hypothetically, say I had an urgent hospital appointment I absolutely couldn’t miss today, I wouldn’t have had anyone who I could ring who would come out and pick up a dead cat for me. DH can’t drive due to a medical condition, PILs are away, parents live far away, friends are either at work or at home with young kids. I could (and would, in this hypothetical hospital appointment scenario) ring a vet, but that’s all.

If you haven’t got any friends or family to help then yes, a local vets will usually pop down if they can spare the staff. Alternatively post on the local community social media page - there’s usually a kind hearted soul who will pick them up to take to a vet.

It’s a bit macabre but there’s also a Facebook group called ‘deceased cats UK and IRL’ who have thousands of volunteers who will go and collect if you make them aware.

At the minimum please move them out of the road so their owner has some closure and a chance to say goodbye.

Nonicknamesforcatapillars · 18/08/2021 19:51

I once witnessed the car in front of me hit a cat and just drive off without even stopping. Poor little thing was convulsing in the road, but by the time I’d managed to pull in and get to it, it was gone.

I picked it up and put it in the grass. It was just outside a house so I knocked to see if she knew who’s it was, it was hers. It was all pretty traumatic tbh. Another chap who was out walking his dog and I wrapped it in a blanket so she wouldn’t have to do it. The poor little cat was a bit of a mess, and put it in her front garden.

I couldn’t believe anyone would hit a cat and just drive off without even so much as moving it out of the road, let alone make an attempt to find the owner or take it to the vets. It’s disgusting.

IlseLey · 18/08/2021 19:50

I've had some thoughts about cats this week after finding another one eating from my food waste bin that was put out for collection. The last time a cat had been eating my Christmas turkey leftovers that had been stored in my garage for at least two weeks - I haven't seen that cat since.
I grew up rurally and we had many animals including cats. Since I left home, I have lived in cities and suburbs and I cannot understand people who leave cats to roam around these environments; there are so many dangers and poisons they can encounter. I feel very sorry for domesticated animals who have come to harm accidentially or otherwise, but I won't be placating the owners who have allowed this harm.
Cats have a right to roam freely for a reason.

Trinacham · 18/08/2021 19:48

@inigomontoyahwillcox

If it's alive, yes, wrong to leave it.

It was alive when they left.

I know, I read that.

I'm saying it is wrong to leave a cat alive. It is not if it is dead..

So basically, they shouldn't have left it, no!

Heathofhares · 18/08/2021 19:47

@DrManhattan

Asthma is a bullshit excuse- doesn't stop him ringing someone who can come and help.
Who exactly are you supposed to ring in this situation?
Knittingupastorm · 18/08/2021 19:45

if you can’t have the cat in your car, then ring someone who can.

Such as? Hypothetically, say I had an urgent hospital appointment I absolutely couldn’t miss today, I wouldn’t have had anyone who I could ring who would come out and pick up a dead cat for me. DH can’t drive due to a medical condition, PILs are away, parents live far away, friends are either at work or at home with young kids. I could (and would, in this hypothetical hospital appointment scenario) ring a vet, but that’s all.

CausingChaos2 · 18/08/2021 19:45

Yanbu. That must have been really traumatic to witness. I hope your DD isn’t too badly affected by it.

Thankfully I’ve never actually seen a cat being hit but I’ve picked a few up afterwards that have already died. It’s upsetting that so many people drive past and half the time just leave them in the road to be driven over again. It’s someone’s loved pet and even if you don’t like cats, show some empathy to their human family.

PeterCorbeau · 18/08/2021 19:44

I can genuinely only think of a handful of occasions where I would have been totally unable to stop and go out of my way for 20 mins or so if I'd hit and killed someone's beloved pet (regardless of whether it was avoidable or not). If I had to be 20 mins late somewhere, so be it. I was late for work when I hit a deer once (or the deer hit me, if anyone has seen Gilmore Girls!). It was injured and fell down at the side of the road, and I waited until help came for it. It's not like I'm hitting animals every day of the week - I've hit one once in 20 years of driving.

I wonder if this is the same reasoning behind those stories of people who fall over or become ill and spend 10 mins lying on the ground with people walking past them? Everyone is in such a hurry with their important lives, apparently...

inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 19:40

If it's alive, yes, wrong to leave it.

It was alive when they left.

OP posts:
inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 19:38

Who would you ring?

Maybe they had nobody to ring - but I would certainly show some bloody sympathy for the creature before jumping in my car, like, maybe, you know, asking another member of the public if they could assist?

The driver was being guided by the man (her passenger), I think maybe she was in shock (trying to be generous here), but she didn't utter a word and was scurried back into the car by him.

I've just remembered something, sorry - no trying to drip feed - just things coming back to me, I'm sure I saw him drop a fag and stub it out on the road. Doesn't give much credibility to his asthma claim - arsehole.

OP posts:
Trinacham · 18/08/2021 19:37

(For the record, I have indoor-only cats)

NotMyCat · 18/08/2021 19:37

People should always stop if you can, and move the cat to the side of the road if you can't get it to a vet or do anything
It means that when people like me go out to collect and get the cat scanned for a chip to try and reunite with owners that there is something left to scan. Also we take to the vet or scan because some councils collect the cat and dispose of them without checking for a chip and owners are left with no closure (there is a law being debated about this at the minute)

Trinacham · 18/08/2021 19:37

If it's alive, yes, wrong to leave it.

If dead though, there are occasions where people can't stop, ie driving to work with no time to spare. They should at least stop and move it to the kerb of course.

Whatinthelord · 18/08/2021 19:35

@WaltzForDebbie

As someone who has to go to regular medical appointments with 3 of my kids I wouldn't stop if it meant them missing an appointment. One of my kids nearly died last week so we're not talking about unimportant routine appointments. So, no I might not stop depending on the circumstances.
This is a good point. We have no idea where this guy was off to or what his personal circumstances are. He might simply be a duck head who didn’t care or he might have been someone with somewhere important to be or lots of other stuff going on.
PeterCorbeau · 18/08/2021 19:34

It's shitty behaviour. Even if you have asthma, it doesn't stop you being a compassionate human being and trying to find someone to help you out. Honestly think people who hit someone's pet and don't seem to give a crap must have something wrong with them.

Wimowehwimowehwimowehwimoweh · 18/08/2021 19:34

Someone hit my cat and shoved him on the pavement.

I got a phone call saying ‘I think someone’s just been to see you about your cat’…..they hadn’t.

The call was from a lovely lady who had seen the accident and, who the driver had told, they would pop round and see me to let me know. The driver had just buggered off but I am eternally grateful to that lady.
I was able to go and pick him up, another 5 minutes and DH would have driven past him with DC in the car and that would have been a horrible way for them to find out.

CirqueDeMorgue · 18/08/2021 19:34

As pp pointed out it has nothing to do with the dignity of the animal. It’s about humans. Plenty of people would get het up about pets but happily consume animals (and feed their pets animals) that have been reared and killed in inhumane ways.

I don't disagree with you OP but this really is a perfectly fair point.

Knittingupastorm · 18/08/2021 19:34

@Sirzy

Also some roads sadly simply aren’t safe to stop on.
That’s true, I wouldn’t just stop on a busy dual carriageway with no hard shoulder.