Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think, if you run over a cat, you don't just dump it on the pavement and fuck off

218 replies

inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 18:28

God, it was awful.

DD (13) and I were just behind a car that ran over a cat, the poor little thing had a serious head injury (completely unsurvivable) and was convulsing in the middle of the road.

The driver and her passenger got out of their car, picked up the cat and unceremoniously dumped it on the pavement. I pulled up behind, got out to see to the cat (it very quickly passed away, fortunately) and asked if they were going to take it to the vet - the bloke said "I've got asthma" and they buggered off!

Fortunately another woman who was behind me also stopped and she offered to take the poor wee thing to the vet to see if it was microchipped as DD was extremely upset by this stage (she adores cats and it was a nasty thing to witness). So her and I wrapped it's body in DDs (knackered) sleeping bag which I happened to have in the boot and she took it.

I'm now sitting in the car whilst DD has her trampolining lesson and am a little bit traumatised to be honest! And a bit bloody angry. I hold no grievance towards them about hitting a cat - shit happens, and it's one of the things you learn to accept is a possibility if you have an outdoor cat (which we do). But to leave a dying cat on the pavement after you've hit it is, I think, despicable.

OP posts:
Whatinthelord · 18/08/2021 21:01

@SW1amp really…what you supposed to do if you find a dog and can’t find the owner then?

I posted on SM once when a dog was roaming our street. The owner came and got it but was very angry that I hadn’t got hold of the dog, even after I explained that the reason I didn’t get hold of the dog was because I was scared of dogs. As if it was my responsibility to keep HIS dog safe.

CosilyRosily · 18/08/2021 20:59

Our cat had been hit by a car and clearly died at the scene - someone (presumably the person who hit him) had picked him up and dumped him over an old ladies wall. Poor lady found him several days later decomposing and contacted us via the phone number on his collar. Meanwhile we'd spent the last week pacing the streets calling for him, printing posters and bothering our neighbours to check their sheds.

We all cried whilst burying him in our garden and all of our neighbours shared stories and photos of him they'd collected over the years. Accidents happen but pets become family members and the callousness of just dumping them is really jarring.

SW1amp · 18/08/2021 20:58

If you haven’t got any friends or family to help then yes, a local vets will usually pop down if they can spare the staff.

I’ve found 2 lost dogs over the last couple of years, neither wearing tags

I took both to the nearest vets. One turned me away at the door and told me to contact the council, the other took the dog in to check for a microchip but then refused to keep it and asked me to take it to Battersea dogs home.

I find the idea that a vet would send a member of staff out to a stretch of road to look for a dead body… unlikely

BoaCunstrictor · 18/08/2021 20:57

Hurt animal that might be able to be saved may be different, I agree.

Lockheart · 18/08/2021 20:56

@LidlMiddleLover

Driver was clearly totally unfeeling and a horrible person Hopefully karma catches up with him soon
It'll have a job given that karma is fictional.
Whatinthelord · 18/08/2021 20:54

@BoaCunstrictor

Yy tractor. One person's decision to keep a roaming pet imposes zero moral obligation on anyone else to move dead animals around.
I would stop and take a cat to a vet because I’d care about an animal I had hurt.

However I do agree with this comment to some extent. The number of pet cats in my mistake is insane…I’m sure there weren’t as many pet cats about on the estates I grew up on. People choose to have cats as pets and many choose to do so knowing that they will roam around busy roads, poo in other peoples gardens etc. Having a cat is a choice that people make.

I’d love to see as many conversations about responsible pet ownership on SM as posts about dead cars being found.

StrangeToSee · 18/08/2021 20:52

Sorry but I wouldn’t stop for a cat that ran in front of me. Unless it’s a very quiet road you risk someone going into the back of you and causing a pile up. There’s no way I’d take a dying cat to the vets, for a start it could be a stray and riddled with diseases, secondly what if you have nothing to wrap it in? Cats often lash out when you try to move them. Blood and fur on the car seats? What if the person is on their way to work/hospital/school and doesn’t want to be late. Or doesn’t want kids to see.

If it was a deserted country lane and it’s injuries clearly incompatible with life, I think many people would move it to the side and put it out of its misery? Few are going to try and find a vet or go knocking door to door looking for the owner, unless they’re not in a rush.

LidlMiddleLover · 18/08/2021 20:50

Driver was clearly totally unfeeling and a horrible person Hopefully karma catches up with him soon

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/08/2021 20:48

*cats - fat fingers put an errant apostrophe in there for some reason.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/08/2021 20:47

I agree with Ilse and Drink. If an animal is free to roam, it is also free to come a cropper. Your toddler would love to be allowed to run free alone outside, but you'd never countenance it, because you know what dangers could befall them. I also don't get why you'd expect somebody to 'show remorse' for an animal running straight into your wheels.

I would stop if I could (I have done for a cat before), but how would people necessarily know it was a cat they hit and not a badger, squirrel, fox, piece of rubbish jettisoned from a car or whatever? The one I hit was at night on a dual carriageway. I actually parked up quite dangerously to be able to see to it, but it was already dead, I had no way of knowing whose it was (no houses anywhere near at all), it was before the days of mobiles, so all I could do was move it to the side of the road and continue on my way. I was sad for the owner, but that's the price you pay for having a free-roaming pet.

Somebody's cat took a bird out of one of our trees a couple of hours ago and, going on the horrible screeching sound, I doubt the bird would have survived. No idea whose cat it is and its owners clearly couldn't care less about this and any other birds it regularly kills for fun.

This is a bit like the cat's pooing in gardens threads we often have on here - you either keep your pet enclosed and supervised at all times or you let it roam freely, abdicate your responsibilities for the unpleasant effects its behaviour has on others and, sadly, also accept that it might end up injured or killed through misadventure.

Thefaceofboe · 18/08/2021 20:46

couldn't personally give a fuck if you miss an appointment or have "allergies", if you hit an animal and leave it to die you are a dickhead.

Yep! I couldn’t sleep at night knowing I’d hit someone’s beloved pet and left it suffering at the side of the road. Disgraceful

inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 20:45

@5zeds

I’m confused. In your OP you say the cat died and then he left. He didn’t leave a dying animal in pain, he left a dead animal where it might be found by someone who knew it. If it wasn’t chipped would he have been expected to drive it back to where it was hit?
No I didn't?
OP posts:
FlyingRabbitsAtNoon · 18/08/2021 20:44

A cat isn’t just another animal in the same way as a squirrel or hedgehog is (though I’d still suggest there is an obligation to move them). It’s likely someone’s pet and they deserve to know. So yes, I think it does warrant notifying someone.

If you hit a dog you legally have to report it to the police. At least phoning a local vet to notify and see if they can do anything to help or recommend anyone isn’t a huge ask if you don’t actually have the time to take it anywhere.

5zeds · 18/08/2021 20:42

I’m confused. In your OP you say the cat died and then he left. He didn’t leave a dying animal in pain, he left a dead animal where it might be found by someone who knew it. If it wasn’t chipped would he have been expected to drive it back to where it was hit?

HawksAreRed · 18/08/2021 20:34

I would feel awful if I hit a cat! But I can also think of lots of reasons why I might not stop, in addition to being in a rush:

  • I would really struggle to pick up a bleeding/ squashed cat out of the road. I wouldn't want to touch it.
  • There might not be a safe place to stop.
  • I'd have to stop other traffic to try and get the cat.
  • I wouldn't know what to do with it.
  • I wouldn't knock on a strangers doors because I'd be scared of being screamed at by the cat owner.

Also does it only apply to cats? DH hit a pigeon on the duel carriageway a few weeks ago, should we have stopped?

BoaCunstrictor · 18/08/2021 20:34

Yy tractor. One person's decision to keep a roaming pet imposes zero moral obligation on anyone else to move dead animals around.

crazycatgal · 18/08/2021 20:29

Some people have a disturbing lack of empathy.

A few years ago my DP hit a rabbit. He got out of the car to see if it was suffering but it had died on impact.

inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 20:22

But you said the injuries were unsurvivable - so it would have been dead by the time anyone got to the vet, wouldn’t it?

Yes, more than likely, although dead or alive, it should still have been taken to someone who could have either eased its suffering whilst it passed and/or scanned for a microchip (it didn't have a collar on).

OP posts:
Sirzy · 18/08/2021 20:22

@Weeble09

Some people are just vile dicks. I've been late for work, including shifts as a carer, when stopping to help injured animals (pets and wildlife). If there's only me to help, then work just has to take second place. I'm not going to leave an animal suffering if I'm even remotely able to help.

I'm also one of the people who volunteer to collect dead RTA cats and take them to be scanned, it's horrible to do especially when nobody has even had the compassion to move an animal to the side of the road. Even if you're allergic, or don't like animals, at least stop to move one out of the way of traffic.

As much as I am all for helping animals where you can I would be a bit annoyed if a family member of mine didn’t get the carer in they where due because they had stopped to help a cat!
TractorAndHeadphones · 18/08/2021 20:19

I thought the discussion was about stopping for the dead cat AND finding the owner/takinf it to vet?
Stopping is what the people in the OP did.

Ednadidit · 18/08/2021 20:16

Someone once hit a cat who belonged to one of my neighbours and dumped it on my driveway. I was very confused when said neighbour banged down my door demanding to know why I’d killed her cat 😬 I don’t wish bad things on other people generally, but I hope the culprit experienced some karma for that. Poor cat :(

SusieBob · 18/08/2021 20:14

@donenowplease

I couldn't personally give a fuck if you miss an appointment or have "allergies", if you hit an animal and leave it to die you are a dickhead.

So you think someone's a 'dickhead' for putting their cancer screening or job interview or flight or any appointment with our already overstretched and backlogged nhs, above a dead animal. Do you have any idea how long the wait is for very important nhs appointments, can be months or even years. And your lack of sympathy for people with allergies is far worse than peoples lack of sympathy for a dead cat. I hope you never have yourself or a loved on go into anaphylaxis or break out in hives and struggle to breathe from exposure Hmm

Of course it's sad when anything dies and I'm not surprised a young child is upset. But frankly life is busy, people have a million other things going on and human lives and the things needed to live it (jobs, medical appointments, punctuality etc) are in most cases a higher priority than a dead cat not being left on the pavement. It's not nice but it's life and practicality. If someone came on here moaning that they'd been disciplined at work for being late or had missed a medical appointment and couldn't get another for months, and their reason was they stopped for a dead cat they would be told to prioritise better.

I literally takes about a minute to move an animal out of the road. Say, I dunno, about the time that you might get held up by a set of traffic lights that are at red rather than green.

I'd gently suggest that in the scenerios you describe cutting your time so fine is a bit stupid.

TractorAndHeadphones · 18/08/2021 20:14

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

I dont know. It's a nice thing to do. But the whole cats are free to roam / they are wild and have the right to shit in the garden / cat owners comparing them to foxes and badgers who shit everywhere in the wild...and then expect someone to treat your animal, who you have let out in the road, with much more compassion than a wild animal. Again although it's the right thing to do a lot of people will be too busy (eg if you were going to get pay docked or a warning if on the way to work) or just too squeamish
Sl as pp have posted - don’t have outdoor cats if you live in a busy area! Of course cats can also be hit in rural places but when I see cats on the motorway or at a busy crossing- the owner has no right to be shocked that an accident happened. Cats tend to run out suddenly and not all of them have road sense.

I’m from a country full of stray cats and feral dogs roaming the streets. Everyone manages to keep their pets indoors with no trouble at all

FourTeaFallOut · 18/08/2021 20:10

Even if you're allergic, or don't like animals, at least stop to move one out of the way of traffic.

Well, I can't pick it up without risking an asthma attack. I could kick it to the side but I imagine that would have me popped straight into the MN psychopath box.

nocoolnamesleft · 18/08/2021 20:09

There are very rare occasions where you quite literally cannot stop.

I am a paediatrician, called in from home for emergencies. One night, I was called in urgently at about midnight. Approaching the turn on to the main road, a speeding car took the corner wide and was approaching me head on. I mounted the empty pavement, to try to get out of the way, and they swerved and went up a bank on the side of the road. I honestly thought they were going to overturn. And I was praying that they would not overturn as I would have no choice but to stop and render help. But my not attending would increase the odds of the death of the baby whose resuscitation I was heading for. Thank god the car did not overturn, and I could drive on. But I was shaking like a leaf afterwards, not from the near miss, but from having been a hairs breadth from the decision on who to leave to die. In that situation, I would absolutely have driven away from a cat. And dealt with hating myself afterwards.

It's pretty unlikely this driver was in such a position as that, but there truly would be very rare occasions where stopping for an animal would not be possible.