Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think, if you run over a cat, you don't just dump it on the pavement and fuck off

218 replies

inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 18:28

God, it was awful.

DD (13) and I were just behind a car that ran over a cat, the poor little thing had a serious head injury (completely unsurvivable) and was convulsing in the middle of the road.

The driver and her passenger got out of their car, picked up the cat and unceremoniously dumped it on the pavement. I pulled up behind, got out to see to the cat (it very quickly passed away, fortunately) and asked if they were going to take it to the vet - the bloke said "I've got asthma" and they buggered off!

Fortunately another woman who was behind me also stopped and she offered to take the poor wee thing to the vet to see if it was microchipped as DD was extremely upset by this stage (she adores cats and it was a nasty thing to witness). So her and I wrapped it's body in DDs (knackered) sleeping bag which I happened to have in the boot and she took it.

I'm now sitting in the car whilst DD has her trampolining lesson and am a little bit traumatised to be honest! And a bit bloody angry. I hold no grievance towards them about hitting a cat - shit happens, and it's one of the things you learn to accept is a possibility if you have an outdoor cat (which we do). But to leave a dying cat on the pavement after you've hit it is, I think, despicable.

OP posts:
BoaCunstrictor · 18/08/2021 21:48

Interesting points sausageroll.

lochmaree · 18/08/2021 21:44

@DoubleTweenQueen luckily not, just scraped and shaken with a broken bike. a very nice man who saw what happened stopped and took him and his bike home (I was asleep with 4m old Blush) Yeah accidents happen unfortunately but the attitude of the driver makes a huge difference! this guy didn't even wait to see if he was OK, DH was a bit stunned I think so was just lying there. same Sad I absolutely love cycling too but the risks do make me wonder if it's worth it.

DoubleTweenQueen · 18/08/2021 21:31

@lochmaree OMG - I hope he wasn't badly hurt?
My DH was knocked off his bike on a country road, but at least the driver offered to take him to a&e - he was fine and I went to pick up him and the bike - but he really appreciated the decent attitude of the driver.

I know other cyclists who've not been so fortunate :(

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/08/2021 21:31

What's with all of the suggestions to 'just take it to a vet'? Apart from the fact that a vet will have the equipment to read a microchip, if there is one, what else are they meant to do?

In the UK, we have a public system in place whereby all humans can be treated free at an NHS hospital/facility by people who are paid by the government. We don't have a system like that for animals: vets only earn their money by being paid by the owners of the animals they treat. A vet is a doctor for an animal, not a social services equivalent. You wouldn't take an abandoned car to a random garage and dump it at their door; why would you dump a dead cat on a random vet?

As I said before, any pet owner who cares in the slightest about a pet that isn't under constant supervision/indoors will already have put a tag with a contact number on its collar as they first thing they did when getting it. I imagine that any vet being presented with a tag-less pet will already have a good idea that, even if the pet does have a microchip, it's not going to be straightforward to find a reasonable/responsible owner and that helping will end up costing them a lot of their time that they won't ever be remunerated for.

lochmaree · 18/08/2021 21:29

I would feel absolutely traumatised if I'd seen that OP, people are awful Sad hope you and your dd feel better again soon, its a horrible thing to have seen. ❤

inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 21:29

@lochmaree

A van driver caused my husband to fall off his bike (passed so close my DH was unable to avoid a pothole) and then he stopped, got out of his van, looked at DH lying in the road and said "I'm late for work" then drove off. Confused
Jesus wept - I despair.
OP posts:
inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 21:28

[quote DoubleTweenQueen]@inigomontoyahwillcox Did the driver slam his brakes on or could he not have avoided hitting the cat?
For me, it's not so much what happened afterwards - the poor thing was fatally the njured and no-one could have done anything to save it by the sound of it, but in my experience if you slow even a scared cat will make a decent call at getting out of the way.
What sort of road? Speed limit?[/quote]
It actually happened at traffic lights - so didn't realise what had happened until I saw the cat in the road, I just thought the car was stopping (so no slamming of breaks)

OP posts:
lochmaree · 18/08/2021 21:26

A van driver caused my husband to fall off his bike (passed so close my DH was unable to avoid a pothole) and then he stopped, got out of his van, looked at DH lying in the road and said "I'm late for work" then drove off. Confused

DoubleTweenQueen · 18/08/2021 21:25

@inigomontoyahwillcox Did the driver slam his brakes on or could he not have avoided hitting the cat?
For me, it's not so much what happened afterwards - the poor thing was fatally the njured and no-one could have done anything to save it by the sound of it, but in my experience if you slow even a scared cat will make a decent call at getting out of the way.
What sort of road? Speed limit?

AlternativePerspective · 18/08/2021 21:21

Can you just take a dead cat to any vet? yes. And if the cat is chipped then the vet will ring the owner to ask for payment for its disposal.

AlternativePerspective · 18/08/2021 21:18

There’s no need to put “allergies” in speech marks as if you don’t think they actually exist. As someone who has significant experience of taxi drivers claiming “allergies” as a reason why they have the right to refuse mine and various other people’s guide dogs, I think that the allergy excuse is often very overstated.

And just for reference, if a taxi driver has genuine allergies they can get an exemption certificate which exempts them from carrying a guide dog. They have to carry it and be able to produce it, failure to do so means they’re breaking the law.

Of the approx 50000 taxi drivers in London, there are just 7 who have exemption certificates.

So no. On the whole I don’t buy allergies.

That being said, I do understand why someone might not want to handle a dead animal to take it to the vet.

5zeds · 18/08/2021 21:17

@inigomontoyahwillcox

I pulled up behind, got out to see to the cat (it very quickly passed away, fortunately) and asked if they were going to take it to the vet - the bloke said "I've got asthma" and they buggered off! apologies I assumed you told the story in chronological order.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/08/2021 21:16

what you supposed to do if you find a dog and can’t find the owner then?

I would expect the very least for all responsible dog (and cat) owners to do would be to put a tag on their collar with a phone number to contact in case of emergency or accident. Microchips are all well and good, but not much use to a passer-by or driver at the side of the road. It's very sad, but I personally would assume that a cat or dog without a phone number on its collar would be either a stray or one whose owner sadly wasn't that bothered about it.

If the animal is already dead and its owner didn't care enough for it to make it easy to contact them if need be (without needing to be/take it to a vet), I don't morally see what you could or should have to do other than move its body out of the way of the traffic.

IWantT0BreakFree · 18/08/2021 21:16

I would stop if it was safe to do so and I wasn't running late for something very important. I'd try and get hold of a vet to let them know where the cat was, but I wouldn't move a cat which was covered in blood etc. I almost always have kids in the car with me and wouldn't have any way to adequately clean myself up. Not really sure what I'd do if it was alive still. I wouldn't be transporting it anywhere in my car, partly as I would have nowhere to put it (seats all taken, boot full of pushchairs etc) and nothing to wrap it in even if I was willing to handle it. I wouldn't be waiting by the side of the road indefinitely so I guess I'd have to hope that someone else was around who was willing to take over until the vet was able to come out.

I think lots of cat owners are among the most entitled people. Your pet is your responsibility. The fact you've let it run out in the road now means that someone has to live with the fact they've killed it, through no fault of their own. And you also expect them to drop everything to deal with the fallout? Otherwise "karma will get them" Hmm Is it not enough that we have to deal with them shitting all over the gardens our kids play in? I feel sorry for the cats who end up run over, but have no time for the guilt trips from the owners of these "beloved pets" who allow it to happen.

Feelingoktoday · 18/08/2021 21:08

I hit a cat. It run out so fast it didn’t have a chance. We were on a 50 mph single carriageway that came straight off a dual carriageway. There was no way I could stop or pull over - I would have caused an accident. I drove to the roundabout and went back to see if I could help. By then a group of pedestrians were dealing with it. I didn’t stop I’m afraid as enough people were helping. Looking back I’m not sure I could have done anything else. It was a very busy fast road at rush hour.

Rewis · 18/08/2021 21:08

Can you just take a dead cat to any vet?

HunterHearstHelmsley · 18/08/2021 21:08

I'm a huge cat lover. If I ever hit a cat, I'd probably be sobbing at roadside.

If you hit a cat (or any animal), the very least you can do is move it out of the road. If it's alive, take it to the vets. If it's died, time and situation allowing then I'd knock on doors. It's not always that easy though. If you can't, then ring the emergency RSPCA number that is there for this reason.

SW1amp · 18/08/2021 21:07

[quote Whatinthelord]@SW1amp really…what you supposed to do if you find a dog and can’t find the owner then?

I posted on SM once when a dog was roaming our street. The owner came and got it but was very angry that I hadn’t got hold of the dog, even after I explained that the reason I didn’t get hold of the dog was because I was scared of dogs. As if it was my responsibility to keep HIS dog safe.[/quote]
When the vet refused to take it in, I took it back to the park I found it and asked a dog Walker to help, because I didn’t know the area, and thankfully they did
No idea what I would have done if I hadn’t stumbled across the walker though

The second time, I had baby DS with me and Battersea dogs home was 20-30 mins away so I said I couldn’t take the dog and just left
They weren’t happy but equally couldn’t chase me down the road with someone else’s dog..!

But the vets were not remotely interested in getting a live animal back to its owners

I cannot believe they will dedicate much time to getting a dead one back, let alone give it (expensive) treatment without knowing if someone will be picking up the bill

NailsNeedDoing · 18/08/2021 21:07

Do people who think that this driver was in the wrong also think that people should stop and find a vet if they hit a badger, or a fox or a pheasant or any other wild animal?

I wouldn’t have a clue how to handle an injured cat, I’m wary of them at the best of times and I’d be worried a cat in pain was going to bite or scratch. Although I’d feel terrible about being involved in an animals suffering, I’d feel no obligation to do a favour for the owner who has chosen to have a pet and allow it to cause road accidents. Knowing that there’s a high chance of your pet being run over is just something that cat owners need to accept when they choose to let their cats run wild in residential areas and they can’t expect other people to take responsibility for it.

Umbongoumbongo999 · 18/08/2021 21:07

I saw similar last week. I had youngest dd in the car (cat lover, very upset) . I took her home and went back with my dh and an old towel. The cat was dead on the pavement. Dozens of people must have driven/walked past. We took it to the vet, to check for chip, knocked on all the neighbours close to the scene and eventually located the owner.

What prevented me stopping when I first saw the injured cat was a. Having nothing to wrap it in (it was really bleeding a lot) and b. Not being prepared for my dd ( who has mh issues) to hold said bleeding cat/watch it die in pain in our car. I couldn't change the outcome for the cat (obviously not going to survive its injuries) and on balance the need to protect my dd was paramount. I think my subsequent actions were the next best thing, but can understand how people may walk on by. Not everyone is prepared to deal with a veterinary emergency.

IlseLey · 18/08/2021 21:06

If a pet is a member of your family, then treat it as one. Seriously, why are people allowing domesticated (wild) pets to roam freely - just because you can - then blaming the poor folk who encounter them? Get a goldfish or caged fury pet.

Whatinthelord · 18/08/2021 21:05

@DdraigGoch I mean I think some people just sell kittens by word of mouth/social media. I don’t think a lot of checks are happening in those circumstances. No idea why they kept getting cats it was awful.

HawksAreRed · 18/08/2021 21:05

I just think it depends on the situation.

If I was driving during the day, in my local area and close to home then I would say I'd definitely stop. I'd feel confident in my surroundings and have resources to help me. (I have the number for and know where the vet is, I could call people to help me or go home for a box/ blanket.)

If I was driving alone at night, miles from home with sleeping kids in the back for example, I wouldn't necessarily feel able.
Great for all the people who would pull their car over on a busy (or deserted) road. Pick up a dead cat and go wondering around knocking on strangers' doors in the middle of the night etc, but I know I couldn't do it.

I'd still feel awful though.

DdraigGoch · 18/08/2021 21:02

@Whatinthelord

I’m by no means in the biggest cat lover…in fact I really quite dislike cats as a pet. However if I knocked one over I’d feel terrible. I’d hope I’d be able to take it to a vet so the owner would at least know.

I’ve got to be honest as well though that I think SOME owners also need to be more sensible. I’ve got a friend who lives near several very busy roads. She’s had and lost about 4 cats to car accidents. Why she keeps getting more cats is beyond me.

Surely no one reputable will allow a cat to be homed near a busy road.
Porcupineintherough · 18/08/2021 21:02

The idea that people send their "beloved" pets out to take their chances with the traffic is frankly bizarre. Most people who love their pets keep them safe.