Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think, if you run over a cat, you don't just dump it on the pavement and fuck off

218 replies

inigomontoyahwillcox · 18/08/2021 18:28

God, it was awful.

DD (13) and I were just behind a car that ran over a cat, the poor little thing had a serious head injury (completely unsurvivable) and was convulsing in the middle of the road.

The driver and her passenger got out of their car, picked up the cat and unceremoniously dumped it on the pavement. I pulled up behind, got out to see to the cat (it very quickly passed away, fortunately) and asked if they were going to take it to the vet - the bloke said "I've got asthma" and they buggered off!

Fortunately another woman who was behind me also stopped and she offered to take the poor wee thing to the vet to see if it was microchipped as DD was extremely upset by this stage (she adores cats and it was a nasty thing to witness). So her and I wrapped it's body in DDs (knackered) sleeping bag which I happened to have in the boot and she took it.

I'm now sitting in the car whilst DD has her trampolining lesson and am a little bit traumatised to be honest! And a bit bloody angry. I hold no grievance towards them about hitting a cat - shit happens, and it's one of the things you learn to accept is a possibility if you have an outdoor cat (which we do). But to leave a dying cat on the pavement after you've hit it is, I think, despicable.

OP posts:
IWantT0BreakFree · 19/08/2021 11:08

Rubbish. It's birds that kill other birds. Most cats are far too well fed and lazy to ever catch anything, and if they do, it's ill and was going to die anyway.

Well that's just bullshit as you well know. And even if it weren't, do you think it's OK for sick animals to be torn to pieces by your pet? On a thread about how very evil it is to leave an animal to suffer? That's exactly the kind of hypocrisy I'm talking about.

I think most of us at some point will have observed cats stalking and killing birds. We see it regularly as we live in a neighbourhood with lots of cats (lucky us). I would imagine most of us also know cat owners who tell us all about the half dead birds, rodents etc that their cat brings into the house. In my case, I also have a delightful colleague who posts regular updates on the group chat about the latest victims of his cats, often complete with photo evidence. So nice try, but we all know it's rubbish that cats don't kill wildlife.

Sensible cats don't take on squirrels, either.

Didn't actually mention squirrels. We don't see them in our residential area. But definitely we regularly have hedgehogs and birds killed by cats, and neighbours with ponds often lose their fish to the local cats.

StoneofDestiny · 19/08/2021 10:42

Would you still 'not have time' if it was a child that ran out?!

Geez - a child is way more important than a cat. There is a 999 service to help humans - do cat owners pay into a NHS service for pets? I’d stop if I saw a young unaccompanied child trying to cross a busy road. I’d not stop if I saw an unaccompanied cat! Seriously - ridiculous comparison.
If you love your cat keep it safe

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/08/2021 10:42

Rubbish. It's birds that kill other birds. Most cats are far too well fed and lazy to ever catch anything, and if they do, it's ill and was going to die anyway.

We observed a cat do just that in our garden yesterday - grabbing a young bird from very low down in the tree and dragging it away in its jaws. One cat out of millions, one garden out of millions, one minute out of millions: I'm sure we weren't unique in having the 'privilege' to witness that.

They don't do it because they need/want to eat the bird - I wouldn't actually have a problem with it if they did want it for food. They just do it for fun.

And if we're going down the 'survival of the fittest' route, saying that the bird was already sickly, weak and about to die anyway, how does that square with criticising those who don't stop or call a vet out for a seriously injured cat that's about to die anyway, and that's if it isn't already dead?

Twinkie01 · 19/08/2021 10:29

It's sad for the cat and the owner but there is no way I could bring myself to touch a dead animal.

TSSDNCOP · 19/08/2021 10:22

@WolfFleeceSpotter

Same happened to me although I was a random driver and stopped for a neighbours cat.

I own cats, I love cats but I wouldn't pick up a dead cat and put it in my car.

I would take an injured cat to the nearest vet.

igelkott2021 · 19/08/2021 10:19

@IWantT0BreakFree

Exactly *@TractorAndHeadphones*. And all the hypocrisy from cat owners claiming they'd stop for hedgehogs, rabbits, rats etc. They don't seem to care for all the birds, rabbits, hedgehogs, fish etc that their beloved pet subjects to a drawn out death while it's out roaming around everyone else's gardens. If they actually gave a shit about animal suffering they'd either not own a cat, or they'd keep it contained at home where it can't kill other animals for fun or get run over itself.
Rubbish. It's birds that kill other birds. Most cats are far too well fed and lazy to ever catch anything, and if they do, it's ill and was going to die anyway.

Sensible cats don't take on squirrels, either.

igelkott2021 · 19/08/2021 10:18

@DrManhattan

Asthma is a bullshit excuse- doesn't stop him ringing someone who can come and help.
Who? Why do MNers assume that everyone has a massive support network who can drop everything at a moment's notice. They may not be local, either.
owlbethere · 19/08/2021 09:47

I agree.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/08/2021 09:44

Also, those (slightly bizarre) people equating a cat being killed on the road with a child being killed on the road - this just underlines the fact that cats are considered semi-domesticated, free-roaming creatures and that nobody is really responsible if they meet with disaster - which should actually even make you glad (in the circumstances).

If you did have a young child who was allowed to wander miles from home and then was tragically killed by a car, in an accident which no driver could reasonably have foreseen or prevented, you could rant on all you like about the selfish, disgusting, reckless, sub-human driver who killed a child and/or didn't take responsibility for the child's welfare at the time of the accident - but it wouldn't primarily be the driver whom the police and social services would want to 'speak with' (and maybe prosecute) about how the situation was allowed to arise in the first place.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/08/2021 09:36

Bold fail there

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/08/2021 09:36

My uncle witnessed a cat get run over in his road. He was in his house, not driving. Sadly the cat had died instantly, but he called the number on the collar to let them know he had taken it to the vets.
The cat owners then proceeded to call him and threaten him over several weeks, in the days when you couldn’t block a number, accusing him of being the driver and “murdering” their cat. They were obviously very upset and angry, but they were taking it out in him. He was pretty upset by the whole thing and said he would never call the owners of this ever happened again but would still take an animal to the vets,

This would be my fear too. People will obviously be upset and may be looking for somebody to blame and offload their upset on to, plus a lot of people are just plain stupid. As an entirely uninvolved third party, you kindly step in to give somebody a sad but important message, then they make you out to be the villain.

Imagine if it wasn't even just a phone number, but if they knew you/recognised you/found out where you lived and began a campaign of hatred against the 'cat killer'. I'm not saying the majority of pet owners would react like this at all, but when you get hard-working paediatricians attacked by idiotic, nasty vigilantes who can't read further than the first four letters.... these people are out there.

Hemingwaycat · 19/08/2021 09:10

I can understand why he wouldn’t want to pick the cat up as an asthmatic, it can cause an attack. He should have thought to call someone though and stayed there until someone collected it.

IWantT0BreakFree · 19/08/2021 09:04

Exactly @TractorAndHeadphones. And all the hypocrisy from cat owners claiming they'd stop for hedgehogs, rabbits, rats etc. They don't seem to care for all the birds, rabbits, hedgehogs, fish etc that their beloved pet subjects to a drawn out death while it's out roaming around everyone else's gardens. If they actually gave a shit about animal suffering they'd either not own a cat, or they'd keep it contained at home where it can't kill other animals for fun or get run over itself.

TractorAndHeadphones · 19/08/2021 08:22

@IWantT0BreakFree

Nobody is saying that by letting a cat roam - which most cats will do, given they are usually semi-domesticated by nature - they are transfering responsibility. Just that maybe if you were to hit an animal you treat it with a bit of respect. Apparently that's too much to ask some people though.

Various people on this thread have indicated that someone who hits a cat is responsible for all the things I listed. Saying it's about "a bit of respect" is minimising what you are actually expecting people to do. I don't want to handle an animal that is covered in blood and likely to scratch or bite me if it's still alive. I don't want to be late for/miss an appointment or whatever I'm doing that is important to me. I don't want to wait around with a dying animal that I can't actually help. You can "oh FFS" all you like, but actually where is your respect (assuming you're a cat owner) for the people you are burdening with your decision to own a pet that shits all over their gardens, kills all the wildlife they try to encourage and runs out in front of them on the road?

Add to that plenty of people arguing about ‘stopping and moving’ cat. Erm, that’s what the people in the OP did - and she’s still not happy about THAT? She wants it all taken to the vet blah just as poster above has said . You own a pet that you can’t control - you shouldn’t be shocked and surprised if it goes missing .

I agree with the not just leaving in the road (if possible) and calling a vet (if there’s a chance it could be saved) . Do what you can for the animal’s welfare but that’s it. The owner’s feelings are not part of animal welfare. And so don’t need to be considered. It’s their fault for not containing their pet.

gobackanddoitproperly · 19/08/2021 04:49

I killed a cat outright once and no way was I going to pick up it’s smashed up and bloodied body and put it in my car! If you don’t want your cat killed, keep it off the roads.

LunaMay · 19/08/2021 04:00

Meh, maybe people need to be responsible for their cats. Buy/build a cat run if you can't have an inside cat. Not every one has the time to stop what they're doing to follow up for irresponsible pet owners.

donenowplease · 19/08/2021 03:24

@CalamityJaneDoe

The reason you have to report a dog is nothing to do with because someone 'loves them'. It's a historic (and actually outdated law) which qualifies them as 'working animals' (like horses). If you're going down that route you're more likely to find that it'll go the way of you don't need to report cats so no need to with dogs either (as in the modern day they are far less often actually working animals). Add to this that it's very rare that dogs are out on their own so it would be an anomaly and indicate the dog isn't where it's meant to be in the first place, whether cat owners will be the first to tell you their precious 'fur babies' need and have the right to roam.

It really doesn't matter that someone loves them, stopping on an A road or in the dark to see if you've hit a cat (because half the time it's just a bump and you don't know if it's cat, rabbit or rubbish in road) is wildly impractical and far more dangerous than people left wondering about their 'wild' and 'roaming' pets.

CalamityJaneDoe · 19/08/2021 03:11

If you can’t leave a dog then you shouldn’t be allowed to leave a cat. All these people going on about how they might be on their way to work... if you hit a dog, you have to report it to the police- why should it be any different for cats? Someone loves them just the same.

CharlotteRose90 · 19/08/2021 02:53

It’s not a legal law to stop. I think you only have to report it if it’s a dog. Sadly if I hit a cat I wouldn’t stop and pick it up. I’m highly allergic and it would put me in hospital touching a cat.

donenowplease · 19/08/2021 02:31

Would you still 'not have time' if it was a child that ran out?!

Of course not because it's a completely false equivalence Hmm

A child's life is inherently more important than a cats. We all know it. Animal lovers might hate to admit it but we all know it. If you were in a burning building and could only save a child or a cat you know you'd save the child (and if you don't you're the psychopath). Animal people who try and imply cats are equal to children are as crazy as pro lifers who equate embryo's to babies.

We all know it's different, stop kidding yourself and trying to guilt trip other people.

WolfFleeceSpotter · 19/08/2021 02:21

My uncle witnessed a cat get run over in his road. He was in his house, not driving. Sadly the cat had died instantly, but he called the number on the collar to let them know he had taken it to the vets.
The cat owners then proceeded to call him and threaten him over several weeks, in the days when you couldn’t block a number, accusing him of being the driver and “murdering” their cat. They were obviously very upset and angry, but they were taking it out in him. He was pretty upset by the whole thing and said he would never call the owners of this ever happened again but would still take an animal to the vets,

viques · 19/08/2021 01:52

@SW1amp

If you haven’t got any friends or family to help then yes, a local vets will usually pop down if they can spare the staff.

I’ve found 2 lost dogs over the last couple of years, neither wearing tags

I took both to the nearest vets. One turned me away at the door and told me to contact the council, the other took the dog in to check for a microchip but then refused to keep it and asked me to take it to Battersea dogs home.

I find the idea that a vet would send a member of staff out to a stretch of road to look for a dead body… unlikely

Not all vets are like that. I caught a budgie in my garden ( actually I caught it twice because the little bastard flew out of my open kitchen window when I brought it inside, fortunately only flew back into the same tree and fell for my “ this bamboo is a lovely perch like the one in your cage” trick a second time) I digress, the local vets were lovely , took it in and knew of someone with budgies who would take it off their hands.
DysmalRadius · 19/08/2021 00:52

@SW1amp

If you haven’t got any friends or family to help then yes, a local vets will usually pop down if they can spare the staff.

I’ve found 2 lost dogs over the last couple of years, neither wearing tags

I took both to the nearest vets. One turned me away at the door and told me to contact the council, the other took the dog in to check for a microchip but then refused to keep it and asked me to take it to Battersea dogs home.

I find the idea that a vet would send a member of staff out to a stretch of road to look for a dead body… unlikely

I've had a similar experience although they were really shitty with me as well when I said I couldn't take it home because I didn't want a strange dog loose in my car with me and my children!! I'd be surprised if they came out for a dying cat.

If you don't live in an area, then you aren't necessarily going to know anyone close by to help you in that situation. It's not exactly a black and white situation.

NowEvenBetter · 19/08/2021 00:47

It’s a shame that cat owners don’t bother to create a safe, contained outdoor space for their animal that they let loose outside. So much pain and upset could easily be avoided. ‘But how am I meant to contain my cat in my garden?!?!’ Google?

LolaButt · 18/08/2021 23:48

I would never touch or pick up a live cat, so there’s zero chance of me touching a dead or dying one.

I would call for help though and pray that someone nearby would intervene.

If that makes me a shit person who is going to be done over by karma then no problem. My life has been shit enough already so I’m resilient enough to deal with cat karma when it finds me 🙄.