Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is bloody daft of the hotel?

586 replies

JurassicPark101 · 18/08/2021 17:25

I’ve booked a hotel for Friday night until Monday morning. Unfortunately due to childcare issues I found out today that I won’t be able to get there until Saturday morning now. It’s all been prepaid for and as it’s less than 7 days before the booking it’s completely non-refundable and can’t be rearranged.

I’m not too fussed about it being non-refundable, totally understand they probably wouldn’t be able to fill the room again at short notice. Anyway, I phone the hotel to let them know that I do still want the booking but that I won’t be arriving until about 9.30ish on the Saturday rather than the Friday afternoon as originally planned. Receptionist on phone says ‘that’s fine, thanks for letting us know. Just so you know you’re welcome to use the facilities but your room won’t be available until check in at 3pm.” I reiterate that I’ve already paid for the room (and breakfast and dinner which I won’t be having either) from Friday so it should be available when I get there at 9.30. Again “sorry, no but we can’t allow early check in under any circumstances at the moment. We’re totally fully booked and the cleaners just can’t get the rooms ready before this.”

I ask to speak to someone else as I assume she’s possibly new or young or thick as mince. She passes me over to another woman but I hear her say “can you speak to this lady, she won’t understand why she can’t check in at 9.30am”. I explain the situation again. New lady replies with “I empathise with your situation but as we are fully booked we simply can’t allow you to check in nearly 6 hours early”. I tell her that it’s not 6 hours early, it’s 18 hours late. Im booked from the Friday night. I’m paying for the Friday night but I can’t get there until Saturday morning. I’ve paid £145 for a room, dinner and breakfast and none of it will be used. If I was arriving on time, I would be able to return to my room at 9.30am if I chose to do so. She tell me that I'm not arriving on time though so the room won’t be ready until 3pm Confused.

I ask if there’s a manager that I can email, or a head office as this is just bonkers. She gives me an email address. I write a very calm, concise email explaining that I’ll be getting there at 9.30 the day after I’m due to arrive. I’ve just had an email back (from the reception again) telling me that my room will be ready at 3pm and they hope I enjoy my stay.

How do I resolve this? They’re all mad. Aren’t they? I’m not going crazy in thinking I should be allowed in the room when I get there am I? It should be ready for 3pm on Friday so will still be ready at 9.30 on Saturday, surely?

OP posts:
Lemondrcps · 20/08/2021 11:12

I would call them back & tell them to expect you as usual on Friday night & then just turn up Saturday morning

Barmychick · 20/08/2021 11:03

This is nuts!

punnetofgrapes · 20/08/2021 10:33

The hotel staff are crazy - standard practise to guarantee early check-in by booking room for night before . I don't understand what they aren't getting

diddl · 20/08/2021 10:12

"but in that event they really are not entitled to prevent the person who paid for the room first having access to it when they want to"

But of course they are when that person then doesn't want the room!

From their POV the stay then starts on the Saturday night.

HelloDulling · 20/08/2021 10:10

OP, have a look at the Gurnard’s Head. Lovely rooms, great food, really welcoming. They have a sister place in Mousehole that I haven’t been to, as well as one in Wales that I have.

SusieBob · 20/08/2021 10:06

@Terhou

TBH I'm not even sure why people are so outraged by the idea of a business simply trying to make money. The number of people who don't show up for rooms is higher than most people would assume, and so almost all of the time hotels can resell rooms with no issues whatsoever. Anyone bumped will get compensated for it and so this perceived PR disaster just doesn't happen.

I can understand hotels reselling empty rooms, but in that event they really are not entitled to prevent the person who paid for the room first having access to it when they want to. They have a contract with that person and would be in clear breach of that contract. In OP's case, if they had any sense they would either decide to forgo re-selling - especially given that OP has prepaid - or give OP back the cost of one night's stay plus some sort of gesture towards compensation for the inconvenience.

This is the thing, they are not breaking the contract. Hotel rooms are sold on a nightly basis and usually the exact room is not assigned until checkin. Most hotels will stipulate check-in times and many will have a time stated after which your room is not guaranteed.

In most cases if you turn up late and there is an empty room then sure, you will of course get access to it, but if there is literally no empty rooms then, well, that's really the fault of the person who didn't turn up on time and didn't adhere to their side of the contract.

(And, for the avoidence of doubt for the inevitable "But this doesn't apply to the OP blah blah" posters - I am talking in general terms here about the practice as a whole).

Terhou · 20/08/2021 09:47

TBH I'm not even sure why people are so outraged by the idea of a business simply trying to make money. The number of people who don't show up for rooms is higher than most people would assume, and so almost all of the time hotels can resell rooms with no issues whatsoever. Anyone bumped will get compensated for it and so this perceived PR disaster just doesn't happen.

I can understand hotels reselling empty rooms, but in that event they really are not entitled to prevent the person who paid for the room first having access to it when they want to. They have a contract with that person and would be in clear breach of that contract. In OP's case, if they had any sense they would either decide to forgo re-selling - especially given that OP has prepaid - or give OP back the cost of one night's stay plus some sort of gesture towards compensation for the inconvenience.

PreTeensMum · 20/08/2021 09:40

@JurassicPark101 - sorry I posted before I managed to find out that you have a friend who will book for you. Glad you sorted it but yes fully agree with you how ridiculous & unreasonable the hotel is being - Like you, I don’t understand their reasoning. Enjoy your weekend

PreTeensMum · 20/08/2021 09:30

@JurassicPark101- where in West Cornwall is the hotel you booked? I’m currently in Looe (East Cornwall). If you haven’t managed to resolve this and you still want to stay the rest of your weekend away at that hotel, I might be able to help 😊

SusieBob · 20/08/2021 09:26

@Totallydefeated

This is going in circles.

SusieBob It certainly is, because you keep repeating yourself, failing to follow what other posters are saying and failing to grasp that OP isn’t a no-show.

It's not fraud, it's not "breech of contract" and it's common practice. If you have a prepaid hotel room and you don't turn up until the following day, the hotel owes you the grand sum of fuck all.

If you reread, this time more carefully, you will see that I have said ‘ it would be fraud in similar circumstances’, not that it actually is fraud. More by luck in how the terms of the Fraud Act 2006 is drafted than in terms of morality, however.

OP is not failing to show, she is merely arriving late.

You and all the other posters getting outraged about it doesn't change that.

As I have said twice already, it may well be common practice and the shysters may well get away with it, but it doesn’t make it right and it doesn’t make it good practice in terms of customer service and reputation.

Almost every other poster has said similar and other workers in the industry have said their hotel wouldn’t engage in such wide-boy tactics.

We’re allowed to be annoyed and outraged about things even if legally there’s no redress. The law is often an ass. You seem to be confused about things being common practice and being acceptable. They’re not one and the same.

You seem incapable of reading and retaining what anybody else writes.

The irony of you claiming I'm not reading things and yet completely failing to do so yourself.

I've already said I understand why the OP would be annoyed, I started out just explaining WHY the hotel might restrict a morning check-in and then have been answering questions on the more general practice since then.

I've also covered the difference between a no-show and people being late, what difference giving advance notice might make and how that sometimes people benefit from a bumping policy because if you turn up late without a booking at a hotel it can be the difference between getting a room and not getting a room.

TBH I'm not even sure why people are so outraged by the idea of a business simply trying to make money. The number of people who don't show up for rooms is higher than most people would assume, and so almost all of the time hotels can resell rooms with no issues whatsoever. Anyone bumped will get compensated for it and so this perceived PR disaster just doesn't happen.

SusieBob · 20/08/2021 09:10

@sunglassesonthetable

Once again, this mainly applies to hotels in cities and ones which tend to have shorter stays and less predictable booking patterns.

Once again this is in a small, independent hotel in West Cornwall, in the middle of nowhere, nearest alternative accommodation a pub about 20 mins away. ( though just getting a taxi at short notice would be an achievement ) OP is a returning customer of many visits. Cornwall is booked to the gunnels.

No shit, which is why I added caveatsto the post explaining I'm not applying this directly to the OP's situation which has already been discussed.
diddl · 20/08/2021 09:07

"Surely it's 'hers' from when she paid and the hotel took money for it - from 3pm today."

Well the hotel don't seem to think so!

I'm sure bookings are often cancelled & not refunded & no one expects that the room will be left empty.

Op had effectively cancelled the Friday night booking, so usual check in applied for the Saturday.

I'm not saying it's good practise on the part of the hotel though.

ButYouGottaHaveASkillJeff · 20/08/2021 08:59

@diddl

I do get the both sides of it.

That the room isn't "yours" until you book in & if you don't then it's still theirs to rent out if they can.

It's the inflexibility of not say giving a last minute booking an early checkout/Op an early check in.

I mean if there's only about 20 rooms you wouldn't think it was that difficult!

Surely it's 'hers' from when she paid and the hotel took money for it - from 3pm today.

diddl · 20/08/2021 08:49

I do get the both sides of it.

That the room isn't "yours" until you book in & if you don't then it's still theirs to rent out if they can.

It's the inflexibility of not say giving a last minute booking an early checkout/Op an early check in.

I mean if there's only about 20 rooms you wouldn't think it was that difficult!

BruceAndNosh · 20/08/2021 08:46

Ask your friend to "use" the bedroom too on Friday. Just mess up the towels and the bed to make the room look occupied

JurassicPark101 · 20/08/2021 08:42

theboywiththearabstrap no, further west and in the countryside. That place looks lovely though, have you been? I need to find somewhere else to stay for my next escape (which probably won’t be for another year but it’s good to have something to look forward to). I’m not sure I can face staying at my usual place again after this.

OP posts:
cervixuser · 20/08/2021 08:34

@mafted

We've just returned from a hotel and DH and DD had to show ID on check in.
and I've just returned from a hotel in England and not shown any ID - just told them my name and they found my booking. There are no hard and fast rules
Theboywiththearabstrap · 20/08/2021 08:33

It’s not the Penventon is it?

JurassicPark101 · 20/08/2021 08:32

pinkshimmersparkle payment has definitely been taken so no worry for friend about that. It wouldn’t be too much of an issue if it hadn’t though, she only lives over the road from me and we’re pretty close so I’m sure she’d be happy for me to just cashapp her quickly if I needed to for any reason.

OP posts:
JurassicPark101 · 20/08/2021 08:30

diddl that’s why I phoned in the first place. I didn’t want them to think I was a no show. Oh well, hopefully my mate will be able to check in this afternoon.

OP posts:
PinkShimmerSparkle · 20/08/2021 08:29

@JurassicPark101 booking.com are a third party they do not take any payment, it is the hotel that take payment, whether that be in advance or on arrival/departure. Please check that a payment has been taken because your friend might get a shock when checking in for you.
Also booking.com do not oversell rooms, it is the hotels that oversell them, the hotels manage the number of rooms that they have available by logging into their account and physically adding how many are rooms available. Overselling easily happen when the hotel is on many different 3rd party sites, also selling directly and they aren’t quick enough to update them with the actual available rooms. This is why we always put on less rooms that are actually available to avoid this situation.
I don’t understand why they refused to let you check in the following morning as you have paid for the room that is just bad customer service, enjoy your break OP.

JurassicPark101 · 20/08/2021 08:29

DdraigGoch I’m assuming it’s like everywhere round here at the moment in that they’re desperately trying to find staff now that a lot of the Eastern European students aren’t coming over for the summer. I think pretty much every restaurant and hotel in my town (tourist town in S Devon) is advertising for staff at the moment. Businesses are just hiring whoever is willing to turn up at the moment and it seems the hotel I’m staying at have employed receptionists who don’t know the difference between Friday and Saturday or susiebob

OP posts:
diddl · 20/08/2021 07:55

@QueenBee52

I wouldn't have told them you weren't arriving ... it makes no difference to them.. its your room.. you paid for it 😳
But then after a certain time wouldn't Op just be a "no show" & the room considered available for someone else for the night?
LittleMG · 20/08/2021 07:51

Just reading this has enraged me!

DdraigGoch · 20/08/2021 03:53

@JurassicPark101

itsgettingwierd I know, it’s pretty irritating. It’s my go to hotel whenever I have a bit of spare cash and my ex condescends to see his own kids - it’s a lovely spot with lush walks, less than 2 hrs away, not posh enough for me to feel self conscious eating dinner on my own, nice pool and just somewhere I know.

I’ve already thought it was slightly odd that it’s cheaper to book through booking.com. Most hotels you can see the booking m.com price but if you actually phone the hotel direct and quote that price they’ll offer it slightly cheaper or give you a room upgrade for the same price as booking direct means they don’t get charged booking.com fees, works out better for both of us. When I called last time about that they didn’t understand that either and got a bit shitty with me so I just booked through booking.com . Then with this ridiculousness too I think I’ll find somewhere else to stay next time I need a break. If anyone knows anywhere that sounds similar in Cornwall or Dartmoor way please let me know.

Has there been a change of management, or are they struggling for good reception staff and having to scrape the barrel?