Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is bloody daft of the hotel?

586 replies

JurassicPark101 · 18/08/2021 17:25

I’ve booked a hotel for Friday night until Monday morning. Unfortunately due to childcare issues I found out today that I won’t be able to get there until Saturday morning now. It’s all been prepaid for and as it’s less than 7 days before the booking it’s completely non-refundable and can’t be rearranged.

I’m not too fussed about it being non-refundable, totally understand they probably wouldn’t be able to fill the room again at short notice. Anyway, I phone the hotel to let them know that I do still want the booking but that I won’t be arriving until about 9.30ish on the Saturday rather than the Friday afternoon as originally planned. Receptionist on phone says ‘that’s fine, thanks for letting us know. Just so you know you’re welcome to use the facilities but your room won’t be available until check in at 3pm.” I reiterate that I’ve already paid for the room (and breakfast and dinner which I won’t be having either) from Friday so it should be available when I get there at 9.30. Again “sorry, no but we can’t allow early check in under any circumstances at the moment. We’re totally fully booked and the cleaners just can’t get the rooms ready before this.”

I ask to speak to someone else as I assume she’s possibly new or young or thick as mince. She passes me over to another woman but I hear her say “can you speak to this lady, she won’t understand why she can’t check in at 9.30am”. I explain the situation again. New lady replies with “I empathise with your situation but as we are fully booked we simply can’t allow you to check in nearly 6 hours early”. I tell her that it’s not 6 hours early, it’s 18 hours late. Im booked from the Friday night. I’m paying for the Friday night but I can’t get there until Saturday morning. I’ve paid £145 for a room, dinner and breakfast and none of it will be used. If I was arriving on time, I would be able to return to my room at 9.30am if I chose to do so. She tell me that I'm not arriving on time though so the room won’t be ready until 3pm Confused.

I ask if there’s a manager that I can email, or a head office as this is just bonkers. She gives me an email address. I write a very calm, concise email explaining that I’ll be getting there at 9.30 the day after I’m due to arrive. I’ve just had an email back (from the reception again) telling me that my room will be ready at 3pm and they hope I enjoy my stay.

How do I resolve this? They’re all mad. Aren’t they? I’m not going crazy in thinking I should be allowed in the room when I get there am I? It should be ready for 3pm on Friday so will still be ready at 9.30 on Saturday, surely?

OP posts:
disco123 · 21/08/2021 00:06

@LouHotel

I raised the fact you booked through booking.com isn't about the price its about the aspect that you then amended directly via the hotel which (granted i bet you regretted that call in the end) isn't correct, part of paying out commission to third parties is they then 'manage' that booking until arrival for amendments, cancellations ect... they actually had the right to say if you didn't arrive Friday night they would cancel the entire booking allowing them to create cancellation revenue and resell a room but that's hard-core.

Whether the word cancelled was used or not, saying your not arriving on the booked day of your terms and conditions is cancelling as its altering the booking - their occupancy which they are likely targeted on is then affected.

Depending on how nice you were on the phone i probably would have pre checked you in on the Friday but if a hotel wasn't making budget that weekend how they responded isn't dim.

I've probably had enough entitled guest (which I'm not saying you are) to last a lifetime this summer but people on this thread questioning the intelligence of hospitality staff in this current climate has really pissed me off.

If you refund the price of the room for the night then fair enough. If you're going to take the money for a service and deny the customer access to it then they are going to feel justifiably aggrieved.

I think it's extremely poor customer service and very shortsighted. In this case the hotel has lost out a repeat customer and if anyone ever told me that a hotel chain conducted themselves in the way you have described, I would never stay with them again. Hotels survive on reviews and reputation.

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 21/08/2021 00:03

@LouHotel

Well I haven't, as I've arrived at ridiculous times such at 4, 5 and 6 am. I have let them know on each occasion and not once have I had anything but full understanding. I've even been told there wasn't any need to call as it happens literally all the time.

But I don't stay in places like premier inn. Maybe that makes a difference🙄

TheRebelle · 20/08/2021 23:57

@LouHotel

Honestly I'll try to cover some aspects here but clearly I've derailed into full hotel revenue management so I'll bow out.

Money lost is the cancellation revenue from the moment the guest was not arriving on Friday, you can disagree with it but an empty room is a revenue opportunity - you do not own a hotel room you rent it based on booking terms which will have an arrival date and departure date - you change the arrival date you've changed the terms.

@HyggeTygge occupancy as in room occupancy so 9 out of 10 rooms sold is 90% occupancy. This affects STR data which i expect is not relevant for a boutique hotel.

@TheRebelle jobsworth? I'm cool with that, I had to make 10% redundancies 11 months ago when gm's in my county were losing 75% - mainly because I have a very good revenue team whilst maintaining customer scores.

@JesusIsAnyNameFree with some certainty you have probably stayed in one like it.

Cancellation revenue really isn't a scam and yeah if they were confused by a friday/Saturday 9am arrival thats an entirely different miscommunication.

Absolute gobeldegook - why should we as customers care about any of this? The OP has paid for a room from 3pm Friday to 10am Sunday, whether she arrives at 3:01 on Friday or 9:30am on Saturday doesn’t matter, the room should be ready and available for her.
HyggeTygge · 20/08/2021 23:57

occupancy as in room occupancy so 9 out of 10 rooms sold is 90% occupancy.

Well... obviously... I think most of us understand that! Grin
So as the room was sold, it was an occupancy, wasn't it?

You didn't answer my earlier Q about the money you expect to make from an occupied room?

DysmalRadius · 20/08/2021 23:55

I can't believe how many 'hotel managers' are trying to pretend that it's simply not possible to check into a hotel outwith their standard check-in times.

It's weird - we all know that it can be done! In fact, every time I've ever needed to check in earlier than usual and there hasn't been an option to pay for that specifically, I've been given the option of booking from the night before to guarantee the room in the morning as a solution to the problem.

LouHotel · 20/08/2021 23:53

Honestly I'll try to cover some aspects here but clearly I've derailed into full hotel revenue management so I'll bow out.

Money lost is the cancellation revenue from the moment the guest was not arriving on Friday, you can disagree with it but an empty room is a revenue opportunity - you do not own a hotel room you rent it based on booking terms which will have an arrival date and departure date - you change the arrival date you've changed the terms.

@HyggeTygge occupancy as in room occupancy so 9 out of 10 rooms sold is 90% occupancy. This affects STR data which i expect is not relevant for a boutique hotel.

@TheRebelle jobsworth? I'm cool with that, I had to make 10% redundancies 11 months ago when gm's in my county were losing 75% - mainly because I have a very good revenue team whilst maintaining customer scores.

@JesusIsAnyNameFree with some certainty you have probably stayed in one like it.

Cancellation revenue really isn't a scam and yeah if they were confused by a friday/Saturday 9am arrival thats an entirely different miscommunication.

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 20/08/2021 23:33

@LouHotel

Like others have said, how on earth do you lose money if the OP checks in about 10 h after the cutoff?

Lucky to never have stayed in your hotel or any like it. Imagine arriving in another country 15 hours since you left your house to be told that even though you paid for last night, you will need to fuck off for the next 9 hours or whatever.
Especially if you're there for a meeting with clients and you feel all icky from your travels🤢

JurassicPark101 · 20/08/2021 23:27

louhotel the confirmation from booking.com allows you to cancel the entire booking for the full price via the app or contact the hotel directly via the chat option on the app or by calling the phone number of the hotel, also listed on the app. I did both.

I was perfectly polite to the people I spoke to on the phone. And yes, I continue to think the people that I spoke to, not people who work in hospitality as a whole, we’re thick as mince. I really don’t think they were trying to resell the room, they just though I wanted an early check in and wasn’t taking no for an answer.

OP posts:
Iaccidentlykillplants · 20/08/2021 23:22

LouHotel "Depending on how nice you were on the phone i probably would have pre checked you in on the Friday "

But the Op wasn't offered that, the staff seemed to be under the impression she wanted to check in early on Friday not a late check on Saturday.

Gwenhwyfar · 20/08/2021 23:21

"I raised the fact you booked through booking.com isn't about the price its about the aspect that you then amended directly via the hotel which (granted i bet you regretted that call in the end) isn't correct, part of paying out commission to third parties is they then 'manage' that booking until arrival for amendments, cancellations ect... "

Not really because from the moment you make the booking, you deal directly with the hotel. If I'm checking in late, I inform the hotel, not booking.com.

Skiptheheartsandflowers · 20/08/2021 23:18

everyone acting like you got one up on the man when hospitality is one of the most overworked/underpaid industries in the world and UK market is currently saturated with UK tourist whilst hotels are struggling everywhere to get staff - congratulations you've managed to outsmart a probably something receptionist on minimum wage.

Now it's OP's fault that staff in hospitality are underpaid? Don't think so. Look at those at the top of the industry for that. I bet the CEOs are on good money. Why aren't they making sure their staff get a decent wage? Would it eat into profits? So much easier though to blame one woman booking a weekend break than those actually in charge (who really are 'the man').

If this particular hotel hasn't twigged that OP is a repeat customer, and responded in a way designed to hang onto her, they're not very good at what they do. For the sake of reselling one night, they've lost future custom.

TheRebelle · 20/08/2021 23:15

@LouHotel

I raised the fact you booked through booking.com isn't about the price its about the aspect that you then amended directly via the hotel which (granted i bet you regretted that call in the end) isn't correct, part of paying out commission to third parties is they then 'manage' that booking until arrival for amendments, cancellations ect... they actually had the right to say if you didn't arrive Friday night they would cancel the entire booking allowing them to create cancellation revenue and resell a room but that's hard-core.

Whether the word cancelled was used or not, saying your not arriving on the booked day of your terms and conditions is cancelling as its altering the booking - their occupancy which they are likely targeted on is then affected.

Depending on how nice you were on the phone i probably would have pre checked you in on the Friday but if a hotel wasn't making budget that weekend how they responded isn't dim.

I've probably had enough entitled guest (which I'm not saying you are) to last a lifetime this summer but people on this thread questioning the intelligence of hospitality staff in this current climate has really pissed me off.

But how is any of this the customers problem? You sound like a complete jobsworth.
VaccineSticker · 20/08/2021 23:12

@LouHotel you sound computer says no lady.
If someone has prepaid for the whole stay, but doesn’t turn up on time, why would you resell the room? They room is blocked under their name for the time they fully paid.
The T&C can write anything they want but ultimately if someone rented something for x amount of days, it is booked for them, under their name, and shouldn’t be sold again as it’s already sold. Sounds like cheating and scanning.

HyggeTygge · 20/08/2021 23:12

So if I book a room and invite 12 people to occupy it, I'm helping the hotel by increasing the 'occupancy which they are likely targeted on [?]'?

they actually had the right to say if you didn't arrive Friday night they would cancel the entire booking allowing them to create cancellation revenue and resell a room but that's hard-core.
OP does it state this in the small print somewhere when you paid for the booking?

LouHotel · 20/08/2021 22:55

I raised the fact you booked through booking.com isn't about the price its about the aspect that you then amended directly via the hotel which (granted i bet you regretted that call in the end) isn't correct, part of paying out commission to third parties is they then 'manage' that booking until arrival for amendments, cancellations ect... they actually had the right to say if you didn't arrive Friday night they would cancel the entire booking allowing them to create cancellation revenue and resell a room but that's hard-core.

Whether the word cancelled was used or not, saying your not arriving on the booked day of your terms and conditions is cancelling as its altering the booking - their occupancy which they are likely targeted on is then affected.

Depending on how nice you were on the phone i probably would have pre checked you in on the Friday but if a hotel wasn't making budget that weekend how they responded isn't dim.

I've probably had enough entitled guest (which I'm not saying you are) to last a lifetime this summer but people on this thread questioning the intelligence of hospitality staff in this current climate has really pissed me off.

HyggeTygge · 20/08/2021 22:41

@LouHotel

Really hoping I'm not the first manager of a hotel to respond to this but here goes....

If you have informed them you are not staying Friday night so have cancelled the first night, they have every right to re sell the room for that evening and indeed say you can't check in to 3pm on Saturday because you are altering your booking that the terms and conditions are based on.

The first night of that booking is no longer room revenue its cancellation revenue - its not poor customer service or bonkers practise, cancelling Friday will have cost them revenue in other departments which will have been forecasted.

And actually seeing as you choose to book through third party and in doing so cost them 26 per cent of the cost of the reservation (lower if its a chain) they actually didn't have to take your call at all and could have told you to go through booking.com customer services which quite frankly would have been hell on earth.

But hey ho I'm glad your friend is enjoying herself nothing wrong with that, but everyone acting like you got one up on the man when hospitality is one of the most overworked/underpaid industries in the world and UK market is currently saturated with UK tourist whilst hotels are struggling everywhere to get staff - congratulations you've managed to outsmart a probably something receptionist on minimum wage. Just don't be a twat and ask housekeeping to change the bedding from your friend staying, it won't be down as a departure.

I'm interested. If I have paid for a room but am not physically present overnight - so don't use electricity, hot water, tea bags, toiletries, need bedding changed - what would you be projecting I spend money on normally that would counteract this and turn this into a loss for the hotel? (Meal was paid for already too)
HalzTangz · 20/08/2021 22:30

@JurassicPark101

halztangz but it’s also completely ripping off a customer who still wants the room they booked. My Friday booking was 3pm until 11am Saturday. I wanted it from 9.30am Saturday. I hadn’t cancelled the room in anyway, I was just letting them know my arrival time.
I agree. I don't think hotels should do it but I get why they do
multivac · 20/08/2021 22:25

@LouHotel

Really hoping I'm not the first manager of a hotel to respond to this but here goes....

If you have informed them you are not staying Friday night so have cancelled the first night, they have every right to re sell the room for that evening and indeed say you can't check in to 3pm on Saturday because you are altering your booking that the terms and conditions are based on.

The first night of that booking is no longer room revenue its cancellation revenue - its not poor customer service or bonkers practise, cancelling Friday will have cost them revenue in other departments which will have been forecasted.

And actually seeing as you choose to book through third party and in doing so cost them 26 per cent of the cost of the reservation (lower if its a chain) they actually didn't have to take your call at all and could have told you to go through booking.com customer services which quite frankly would have been hell on earth.

But hey ho I'm glad your friend is enjoying herself nothing wrong with that, but everyone acting like you got one up on the man when hospitality is one of the most overworked/underpaid industries in the world and UK market is currently saturated with UK tourist whilst hotels are struggling everywhere to get staff - congratulations you've managed to outsmart a probably something receptionist on minimum wage. Just don't be a twat and ask housekeeping to change the bedding from your friend staying, it won't be down as a departure.

No, this is incorrect. She didn't 'cancel' - merely pointed out she wouldn't be physically present for the paid for room and paid for meal. The only impact on the business from her absence would have been less laundry, and a better bottom line on food (plus a potential negative impact on upsells like alcohol). I get it's a tough industry; but double selling accommodation sucks.
JurassicPark101 · 20/08/2021 22:22

louhotel I’ve already explained why I booked through booking.com - it’s cheaper, even when I phoned up to ask “it’s X amount via booking.com, what is the price if I book directly with you?” they still gave me a price of more than £25 per night extra if I wanted to book direct and would t let me pick the room like I could on booking.com

OP posts:
JurassicPark101 · 20/08/2021 22:20

halztangz but it’s also completely ripping off a customer who still wants the room they booked. My Friday booking was 3pm until 11am Saturday. I wanted it from 9.30am Saturday. I hadn’t cancelled the room in anyway, I was just letting them know my arrival time.

OP posts:
HalzTangz · 20/08/2021 22:15

@JurassicPark101

susiebob if a guest phones up telling you what time they will be arriving the next day and explicitly saying that they’ll be expecting to be able to access their room at that time you’re saying the hotel would still resell it? That’s ridiculous!
The hotel will resell it, it's an opportunity the get double the amount for the same room
AtillatheHun · 20/08/2021 22:14

OP already said that the third party booking was cheaper than direct with the hotel. Why should she pay extra to keep their profits higher? It’s not her responsibility to prop up the hotel if they aren’t capable of nimble pricing on their own site. She’s a repeat customer of many years who is being treated like an idiot.
QED absolutely right to pee in the front desk / set fire to the kettle or vice versa.

Kiduknot · 20/08/2021 22:11

🥱
Really louhotel

ImInStealthMode · 20/08/2021 22:07

@LouHotel Not a hotel manager but experienced reception / reservations / tour operator property manager here.

Granted my work has largely been in leisure rather than corporate hotels but I've never encountered a hotel that would take an advance notice 'booked & paid from Friday but now arriving early Saturday' as a cancellation of Friday night. As for revenue in other departments, OP could have checked in Friday and had an event to go to elsewhere so not spent an extra penny in-house anyway, or stayed for her pre-paid dinner but been tee-total and stuck to tap water. You can't forecast every penny of anticipated revenue.

The one hotel I worked in that might have done this was a city/train station hotel with a good amount of early morning departures. They'd have sold Friday night safe in the knowledge they'd have had a 7am depart turned round for OP arriving at 9.30.

As for OP choosing to book through a 3rd party, I always enquire directly with hotels I don't already work with for my own bookings, and am often quoted significantly more than the OTA rates. I'd happily book direct and save them the commission but not at 20/30% more for the same room.

I think the lesson we can take from this thread is that there is no industry standard for this situation. Different hotels, different markets, each does their own thing for better or for worse.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 20/08/2021 22:05

The first night of that booking is no longer room revenue its cancellation revenue - its not poor customer service or bonkers practise, cancelling Friday will have cost them revenue in other departments which will have been forecasted.

How when everything, including the meal, is paid for up front? Why should the hotel profit twice for the same room?

Are you saying that if someone was arriving on a late flight you wouldn't let them check in the following morning even though they had paid for the previous night?