Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is bloody daft of the hotel?

586 replies

JurassicPark101 · 18/08/2021 17:25

I’ve booked a hotel for Friday night until Monday morning. Unfortunately due to childcare issues I found out today that I won’t be able to get there until Saturday morning now. It’s all been prepaid for and as it’s less than 7 days before the booking it’s completely non-refundable and can’t be rearranged.

I’m not too fussed about it being non-refundable, totally understand they probably wouldn’t be able to fill the room again at short notice. Anyway, I phone the hotel to let them know that I do still want the booking but that I won’t be arriving until about 9.30ish on the Saturday rather than the Friday afternoon as originally planned. Receptionist on phone says ‘that’s fine, thanks for letting us know. Just so you know you’re welcome to use the facilities but your room won’t be available until check in at 3pm.” I reiterate that I’ve already paid for the room (and breakfast and dinner which I won’t be having either) from Friday so it should be available when I get there at 9.30. Again “sorry, no but we can’t allow early check in under any circumstances at the moment. We’re totally fully booked and the cleaners just can’t get the rooms ready before this.”

I ask to speak to someone else as I assume she’s possibly new or young or thick as mince. She passes me over to another woman but I hear her say “can you speak to this lady, she won’t understand why she can’t check in at 9.30am”. I explain the situation again. New lady replies with “I empathise with your situation but as we are fully booked we simply can’t allow you to check in nearly 6 hours early”. I tell her that it’s not 6 hours early, it’s 18 hours late. Im booked from the Friday night. I’m paying for the Friday night but I can’t get there until Saturday morning. I’ve paid £145 for a room, dinner and breakfast and none of it will be used. If I was arriving on time, I would be able to return to my room at 9.30am if I chose to do so. She tell me that I'm not arriving on time though so the room won’t be ready until 3pm Confused.

I ask if there’s a manager that I can email, or a head office as this is just bonkers. She gives me an email address. I write a very calm, concise email explaining that I’ll be getting there at 9.30 the day after I’m due to arrive. I’ve just had an email back (from the reception again) telling me that my room will be ready at 3pm and they hope I enjoy my stay.

How do I resolve this? They’re all mad. Aren’t they? I’m not going crazy in thinking I should be allowed in the room when I get there am I? It should be ready for 3pm on Friday so will still be ready at 9.30 on Saturday, surely?

OP posts:
JurassicPark101 · 21/08/2021 10:21

I’m currently sat by the pool drinking tea and reading books doomscrolling MN. Life is good and will continue to be good for at least another 48 hours.

OP posts:
Oblomov21 · 21/08/2021 10:19

Computer says no. Some peoples lack of common sense is shocking isn't it?

happinessischocolate · 21/08/2021 09:36

@JurassicPark101* I’m in!*

Have a fab time, and when you check out make sure you thank them for being so bloody helpful 🤣

DollyLostHerBrolly · 21/08/2021 09:23

@JurassicPark101 yes! Enjoy your stay Wine

MrsLargeEmbodied · 21/08/2021 09:22

what a palava, lucky you had a friend to check in for you

bonfireheart · 21/08/2021 09:20

@SusieBob that's a bit extreme. People are just asking for an explanation.

Person books a service and pays for it
Person has booked for service for hour x to hour y
Person will not arrive at hour x but intends to use the service up until hour y
Why is this not OK?
How does Hotel lose money by Person arriving later for a service that they have paid for?

JurassicPark101 · 21/08/2021 09:19

I’m in!

susiebob no one is debating that hotels do this - I said in my Op the reason I called in the first place was because I knew they’d likely resell the room if I didn’t turn up. But in the particular scenario, not some general how hotels operate kind of way which I don’t think anyone disagrees with, it doesn’t benefit the hotel to do this. Because they’ve done this they’ve now had to pay for a meal for my friend which they wouldn’t have done if they’d just done as I’d asked in the first place.

OP posts:
SusieBob · 21/08/2021 09:16

Looks like the pile-on to anyone who dares to try to explain how things work is continuing then.

Yes, hotels are mean evil bastards who steal people's money and fill the swimming pools with cash each evening to go swimming in it. Better?

bonfireheart · 21/08/2021 09:15

I don't understand either. Whenever we book a room, we turn up, check in, throw our suitcases in the room, go out, eat out, and don't come back till very late. Room is paid for, our choice to spend very little time in there. As OP, has paid for the room shouldn't make a difference if she spends one hour or six hours in it. Unless the owner is going to charge her and then book it out to someone else and charge them too - hence two payments for one room.

Terhou · 21/08/2021 09:12

If you have informed them you are not staying Friday night so have cancelled the first night, they have every right to re sell the room for that evening and indeed say you can't check in to 3pm on Saturday because you are altering your booking that the terms and conditions are based on.

But OP isn't altering her booking. She still wants the room to be available on Friday night so that she can check in early on Saturday.

The first night of that booking is no longer room revenue its cancellation revenue - its not poor customer service or bonkers practise, cancelling Friday will have cost them revenue in other departments which will have been forecasted.

Will it, given that dinner is prepaid? How is it possible to make an accurate forecast? If it were me, I never order drinks from overpriced hotel bars or room service, nor do I pay for wifi. If anything the hotel would be saving money by virtue of not having to pay for electricity, hot water, laundry, cleaning, in-room teas and coffees etc. To say nothing of the fact that I usually ask for extra milk for the room as they never leave enough.

In OP's case, the hotel also has to take into account the fact that they've got a returning customer who is now thoroughly pissed off, won't book there again and will let other people know. Sounds like thoroughly bad business to me.

HyggeTygge · 21/08/2021 09:05

@whatausername

I rather feel like people are piling on LouHotel when she is explaining how it works. As a GM she is highly unlikely to be setting the rules herself. Depending on the company culture she might have some leeway but that leeway can come at a price (e.g. the redundancies she mentioned earlier). It comes down to corporations wanting to forecast everything and set targets for every scrap of barely measaurable data from revenue to the number of hairs on an employee's head. Somehow the bigger a business gets the more common sense it loses.
She's not explaining how it works though. She said they'd lose an occupancy, then said an occupancy is a paid-for room, which is what this room is. She also hasn't explained the losses she said they would incur by someone not being physically present in the paid-for room having paid for a meal. I was genuinely interested, hence my questions about costs, which she has ignored. She doesn't seem like she actually understands the situation well enough to explain it beyond saying 'hotels need to hit targets'. Possibly just hasn't explained what she means very well, but it's hard to tell.
BarbaraofSeville · 21/08/2021 09:01

@BruceAndNosh

My sister runs a small guest house so I know how much booking. Com charges. But when I wanted to book a hotel a few weeks ago, I checked the price on bokking.com then rang the hotel hoping they would price match it but they couldn't. The price direct with the hotel was substantially higher.
That's utterly ridiculous but it must be that there's something in their contract with booking.com that means they aren't allowed to undercut booking.com?

Otherwise, if a hotel room is £120 pn on Booking.com and they take 25%, the hotel only gets £90 for the room. So you'd think that they'd be quite happy to take a direct booking for say £100/110 pn as there's a financial incentive for the customer to book direct and they get more money.

Terhou · 21/08/2021 08:52

@diddl

"but in that event they really are not entitled to prevent the person who paid for the room first having access to it when they want to"

But of course they are when that person then doesn't want the room!

From their POV the stay then starts on the Saturday night.

But OP did want the room, just a few hours later than the original booking. And the hotel accepted payment for it.
Terhou · 21/08/2021 08:51

This is the thing, they are not breaking the contract. Hotel rooms are sold on a nightly basis and usually the exact room is not assigned until checkin. Most hotels will stipulate check-in times and many will have a time stated after which your room is not guaranteed.

In most cases if you turn up late and there is an empty room then sure, you will of course get access to it, but if there is literally no empty rooms then, well, that's really the fault of the person who didn't turn up on time and didn't adhere to their side of the contract.

@SusieBob, you seem to have missed the fact that OP has already paid for this room. Therefore she has already performed her side of the contract. Telling her she can't have access to the room - whichever room it is - at a time that she has paid for is, beyond a shadow of a doubt, breaching the contract.

Bells3032 · 21/08/2021 07:53

@LouHotel as someone whose family have been in the hotel industry for many many years this is rubbish. She did not cancel the room, she had paid for the room including for a dinner she didn't intend to eat so less overheads for the hotel - not even including the electricity and water she wouldn't use. The hotel didn't seem to be reselling the room either.

When we flew to Australia we arrived at 7am and decided to book a room from the night before as didn't want to wait til 3pm to have a rest so told them we weren't arriving til 9am. This was fine with the chain Hotel (intercontinental). I don't know why it's so complex for a little hotel that's unlikely to resell the room now

BruceAndNosh · 21/08/2021 07:49

My sister runs a small guest house so I know how much booking. Com charges.
But when I wanted to book a hotel a few weeks ago, I checked the price on bokking.com then rang the hotel hoping they would price match it but they couldn't. The price direct with the hotel was substantially higher.

Summerbreeze4 · 21/08/2021 07:46

@JurassicPark101 I hope you have a nice break, what I find astounding in all of this apart from the hotel staff ring utterly ridiculous is that your ex presumable had agreed to have them Friday night and after you have paid for your Friday night dinner and hotel he just changes his mind and you seem to be so accepting of this and everyone else on this thread. Is he such a twat that if you told him you had made arrangements for Friday (a night out for a friends birthday say, visiting an old friend) he would still refuse to have them Friday. I can see why you wouldn’t necessarily want to say you’ve booked a hotel, he might think your loaded and start cutt8ng maintenance or asking you for some!

bruffin · 21/08/2021 07:15

I assume the hotel think op will spend money on a drink with her meal

itsgettingwierd · 21/08/2021 07:06

@LouHotel

Really hoping I'm not the first manager of a hotel to respond to this but here goes....

If you have informed them you are not staying Friday night so have cancelled the first night, they have every right to re sell the room for that evening and indeed say you can't check in to 3pm on Saturday because you are altering your booking that the terms and conditions are based on.

The first night of that booking is no longer room revenue its cancellation revenue - its not poor customer service or bonkers practise, cancelling Friday will have cost them revenue in other departments which will have been forecasted.

And actually seeing as you choose to book through third party and in doing so cost them 26 per cent of the cost of the reservation (lower if its a chain) they actually didn't have to take your call at all and could have told you to go through booking.com customer services which quite frankly would have been hell on earth.

But hey ho I'm glad your friend is enjoying herself nothing wrong with that, but everyone acting like you got one up on the man when hospitality is one of the most overworked/underpaid industries in the world and UK market is currently saturated with UK tourist whilst hotels are struggling everywhere to get staff - congratulations you've managed to outsmart a probably something receptionist on minimum wage. Just don't be a twat and ask housekeeping to change the bedding from your friend staying, it won't be down as a departure.

How does someone booking and paying for a room they don't use until the following morning cost overheads?

Genuinely interested and confused!

I didn't realise 3rd party sites charged so much - I'll certainly be rethinking how I book in future.

bonfireheart · 21/08/2021 02:03

OP, ring booking.com direct. I had issue with a hotel I was staying at, hotel staff were useless but booking.com were so great at getting it resolved for me.

Holiday124 · 21/08/2021 01:34

What a stupid arrangement

whatausername · 21/08/2021 00:48

I rather feel like people are piling on LouHotel when she is explaining how it works. As a GM she is highly unlikely to be setting the rules herself. Depending on the company culture she might have some leeway but that leeway can come at a price (e.g. the redundancies she mentioned earlier). It comes down to corporations wanting to forecast everything and set targets for every scrap of barely measaurable data from revenue to the number of hairs on an employee's head. Somehow the bigger a business gets the more common sense it loses.

sunglassesonthetable · 21/08/2021 00:41

when hospitality is the most underpaid/overworked industries in the world ...not sure what this has got to do with anything. As a pre paying repeat customer OP is supporting the hospitality industry. You want to keep people like her.

cabingirl · 21/08/2021 00:31

@LouHotel so if the OP had driven 2 hours to the hotel on the Friday afternoon, checked in, then left the hotel and driven 2 hours home to stay overnight in her own house, and then driven back to the hotel on Saturday morning...what is the difference than being able to check-in in person on the Saturday morning.

She PAID for the Friday night, wasn't asking for a refund so was paying for the room to be available from Friday at 3pm. All the hotel had to do was make the room available FROM Friday at 3pm for her - nothing changes for them whether she slept in the room on Friday night or not.

whatausername · 21/08/2021 00:08

I think the real question here is, given that OP's friend didn't know the layout of the place and that OP wouldn't need to walk past reception to go to her room, did she wear a disguise?! Since this was an unplanned operation and said friend was already camping, I imagine any disguise would have been an obnoxiously large hat or a bush chosen from the local flora? (Are bushes considered flora? Perhaps not.)