Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is bloody daft of the hotel?

586 replies

JurassicPark101 · 18/08/2021 17:25

I’ve booked a hotel for Friday night until Monday morning. Unfortunately due to childcare issues I found out today that I won’t be able to get there until Saturday morning now. It’s all been prepaid for and as it’s less than 7 days before the booking it’s completely non-refundable and can’t be rearranged.

I’m not too fussed about it being non-refundable, totally understand they probably wouldn’t be able to fill the room again at short notice. Anyway, I phone the hotel to let them know that I do still want the booking but that I won’t be arriving until about 9.30ish on the Saturday rather than the Friday afternoon as originally planned. Receptionist on phone says ‘that’s fine, thanks for letting us know. Just so you know you’re welcome to use the facilities but your room won’t be available until check in at 3pm.” I reiterate that I’ve already paid for the room (and breakfast and dinner which I won’t be having either) from Friday so it should be available when I get there at 9.30. Again “sorry, no but we can’t allow early check in under any circumstances at the moment. We’re totally fully booked and the cleaners just can’t get the rooms ready before this.”

I ask to speak to someone else as I assume she’s possibly new or young or thick as mince. She passes me over to another woman but I hear her say “can you speak to this lady, she won’t understand why she can’t check in at 9.30am”. I explain the situation again. New lady replies with “I empathise with your situation but as we are fully booked we simply can’t allow you to check in nearly 6 hours early”. I tell her that it’s not 6 hours early, it’s 18 hours late. Im booked from the Friday night. I’m paying for the Friday night but I can’t get there until Saturday morning. I’ve paid £145 for a room, dinner and breakfast and none of it will be used. If I was arriving on time, I would be able to return to my room at 9.30am if I chose to do so. She tell me that I'm not arriving on time though so the room won’t be ready until 3pm Confused.

I ask if there’s a manager that I can email, or a head office as this is just bonkers. She gives me an email address. I write a very calm, concise email explaining that I’ll be getting there at 9.30 the day after I’m due to arrive. I’ve just had an email back (from the reception again) telling me that my room will be ready at 3pm and they hope I enjoy my stay.

How do I resolve this? They’re all mad. Aren’t they? I’m not going crazy in thinking I should be allowed in the room when I get there am I? It should be ready for 3pm on Friday so will still be ready at 9.30 on Saturday, surely?

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 19/08/2021 14:45

we do not guarantee your room will be held for you if you check in later than 10pm.

This bit is surely made up. I have never seen this in the T&C of any hotel I have ever stayed in.

DespairingHomeowner · 19/08/2021 14:37

@SeasonFinale

Message and say. That's fine I expect my room that I am paying for to be ready for me at 3pm on Friday. Thank you.

Then turn up and say here I am late for my room.

^ this. the cheeky effing bastards
JesusIsAnyNameFree · 19/08/2021 14:20

@bruffin

. It’s all prepaid so not concerned about her needing my debit That doesnt matter, i prepaid hotel last weekend, they still took my credit card
Yeah, they will do this in case you cause any damage, OP. Could your friend give them her CC at all? I doubt you will be trashing the place. Might make mini bar/room service awkward though.
DysmalRadius · 19/08/2021 14:12

Because, obviously, it varies between hotels, but if a person with a legitimate booking does get bumped what usually happens is they get put into a taxi and sent to the hotel round the corner with a drinks voucher. Hotels have reciprocal arrangements with others in the area to send bumped guests.

I'm not talking about someone who gets bumped - I'm talking about someone who wants to have access to a hotel room at, say, 10am on the day they arrive into town.

AryaStarkWolf · 19/08/2021 14:00

@Janaih

Omg that's the kind of thing that set Michael Douglas off in falling down. Really hope you can get it sorted.
bahahahahahaha that's exactly what it's like
bruffin · 19/08/2021 13:57

. It’s all prepaid so not concerned about her needing my debit
That doesnt matter, i prepaid hotel last weekend, they still took my credit card

nanbread · 19/08/2021 13:40

Because the deal includes dinner I wonder if they want to resell in order to make loads of markup on wine and drinks with the evening meal

TatianaBis · 19/08/2021 13:40

but a large number of hotels will seek to maximize revenue in this way and, as a business owner yourself, I'm sure you can understand that

Deterring customers from returning is not maximising revenue. As a business owner I understand that.

TatianaBis · 19/08/2021 13:37

@Susibob you’re not differentiating between a guest who has cancelled a room so it’s available for rebook and one who is simply arriving late. In the latter case it’s sharp practice to not allow them access to the room they’ve paid for. Pissing off guest so they write a bad review and never come back is a bad business model

JurassicPark101 · 19/08/2021 13:24

Booking.com know nothing about my change in plans, I just contacted the hotel directly. They’d be getting the full amount from booking.com regardless. On my confirmation on the booking.com app it says I can change the dates but it will cost me the full amount (nearly £500) to do so, hence why I contacted the hotel rather than them.

Anyway, I’ve gone back and told them I’ll be checking in on Friday as planned. They explained again that I wouldn’t be allowed into the room until 3pm on Friday, as if I was the one being incredibly stupid 🤦‍♀️. It will be my friend checking in. It’s all prepaid so not concerned about her needing my debit card. If they want one she can just tell them to make sure she pays as she goes rather than charging anything to the room. Hopefully that won’t be too complicated for them to understand.

OP posts:
NautaOcts · 19/08/2021 12:32

Aw man this would really annoy me
Either the room is yours to use from friday and therefore from Saturday morning
Or it’s not available and you get refunded
🤦‍♀️

SusieBob · 19/08/2021 12:28

[quote DysmalRadius]@SusieBob

So how can someone get access to a hotel room in the morning then? Presumably hotels know that people aren't always able to check in between 3pm and midnight, so how does a traveller get a hotel room they can check in to in the morning?[/quote]
Because, obviously, it varies between hotels, but if a person with a legitimate booking does get bumped what usually happens is they get put into a taxi and sent to the hotel round the corner with a drinks voucher. Hotels have reciprocal arrangements with others in the area to send bumped guests.

SusieBob · 19/08/2021 12:27

@Totallydefeated

A business does it. A company trying to make money, with responsibilities to pay it's staff, it's overheads and make profit. Why wouldn't it?

You keep repeating this but ignoring the posts that point out the need for businesses like hotels to be mindful of customer satisfaction and reputation.

Of course hotels are businesses and are in it for the money, nobody disputes this. But a good business owner will not just be drooling over the idea of squeezing out every last penny they can from a customer in the short term, they also need to look to the medium and long term and sometimes sacrificing fleecing someone in the here and now makes way better business sense, as it promotes customer loyalty, a good reputation etc, which is worth far more in the long term if you want a sustainable briskness with long term growth. I know this as a business owner myself. You can’t be tunnel-visioned about relentlessly pursuing profit and not giving a shit about customer satisfaction and justify it to yourself as ‘being a business’ if you want to build a reputable and profitable brand.

What has happened here is that OP has paid for a service and they are denying her the benefit of part of that service because of an arbitrary rule that suits only the hotel, not the customer. They have essentially taken money for a service and then refused to provide it. Without their exploitative T&Cs that could potentially fall within the definition of fraud in other circumstances. OP and anyone in a similar situation will certainly feel ripped off. And well they might, it’s greedy, exploitative and unfair, regardless of whether it’s common practice or the hotel is a business and therefore is set up with the purpose of making money.

If the hotel cared about getting 5 star instead of 1 star reviews, if it cared about the experience and satisfaction of its customers, it wouldn’t deprive the OP of the service it’s taken her money for on some silly gotcha.

Perhaps if the hotel is in a popular area of Cornwall they think they can afford not to care about that as there will be business regardless. But it doesn’t make it right. I’d be leaving them a stinking review, personally.

What service is being denied? Hotel rooms are sold by night. If someone phones up and says "I'm not going to be in my room tonight" then they are not being denied any service. If the person has the room booked for the following night then they will of course get access to the room, but if they impose a check-in time of 3pm no contracts are being broken. You weren't in the room overnight so why should you be able to access it at 10am? Some hotels don't even have the staff to handle check-ins at that time as they will be dealing with breakfast/checkouts etc.

If they have booked pre-pay, non-refundable room they are not going to get a refund either, that's the risk you take.

Of course not every hotel does it, and it differs between city-centre hotels with shorter bookings compared to holiday lets/resort hotels where bookings are longer and far more predictable, but a large number of hotels will seek to maximize revenue in this way and, as a business owner yourself, I'm sure you can understand that. 99% of the time the hotels do this with no problems whatsoever and that money is worth far more than a couple of arsey tripadvisor reviews. The hotels aren't stupid, they know the balance of reward vs risk is easily in favour of reselling..

Totallydefeated · 19/08/2021 11:54

That’s ok if the guest doesn’t want the room in during the time they’ve already paid for. If they do, then it’s not ok and it’s not ok for the hotel to bar the guest from the room in order to try to make more money.

Exactly, she wants to use the room during the time period she paid for it. So what’s the problem?

Totallydefeated · 19/08/2021 11:53

A business does it. A company trying to make money, with responsibilities to pay it's staff, it's overheads and make profit. Why wouldn't it?

You keep repeating this but ignoring the posts that point out the need for businesses like hotels to be mindful of customer satisfaction and reputation.

Of course hotels are businesses and are in it for the money, nobody disputes this. But a good business owner will not just be drooling over the idea of squeezing out every last penny they can from a customer in the short term, they also need to look to the medium and long term and sometimes sacrificing fleecing someone in the here and now makes way better business sense, as it promotes customer loyalty, a good reputation etc, which is worth far more in the long term if you want a sustainable briskness with long term growth. I know this as a business owner myself. You can’t be tunnel-visioned about relentlessly pursuing profit and not giving a shit about customer satisfaction and justify it to yourself as ‘being a business’ if you want to build a reputable and profitable brand.

What has happened here is that OP has paid for a service and they are denying her the benefit of part of that service because of an arbitrary rule that suits only the hotel, not the customer. They have essentially taken money for a service and then refused to provide it. Without their exploitative T&Cs that could potentially fall within the definition of fraud in other circumstances. OP and anyone in a similar situation will certainly feel ripped off. And well they might, it’s greedy, exploitative and unfair, regardless of whether it’s common practice or the hotel is a business and therefore is set up with the purpose of making money.

If the hotel cared about getting 5 star instead of 1 star reviews, if it cared about the experience and satisfaction of its customers, it wouldn’t deprive the OP of the service it’s taken her money for on some silly gotcha.

Perhaps if the hotel is in a popular area of Cornwall they think they can afford not to care about that as there will be business regardless. But it doesn’t make it right. I’d be leaving them a stinking review, personally.

TatianaBis · 19/08/2021 11:26

A business does it. A company trying to make money, with responsibilities to pay it's staff, it's overheads and make profit. Why wouldn't it?

If a hotel knows that a room is sitting empty, especially in busy cities or in popular holiday spots where they are running at high occupancy of course they are going to try to resell it. It happens all the time and most of the time the people staying in the hotels are completely none the wiser.

That’s ok if the guest doesn’t want the room in during the time they’ve already paid for. If they do, then it’s not ok and it’s not ok for the hotel to bar the guest from the room in order to try to make more money.

I run holiday lets and sometimes people arrive late or the day after they’ve booked for. That’s fine. I don’t sell their dates from under them.
You can’t be sure their plans won’t change and they turn up early.

DysmalRadius · 19/08/2021 11:25

@SusieBob

So how can someone get access to a hotel room in the morning then? Presumably hotels know that people aren't always able to check in between 3pm and midnight, so how does a traveller get a hotel room they can check in to in the morning?

SusieBob · 19/08/2021 10:51

@Totallydefeated

You say "duh?" but plenty of people on this thread clearly don't get how things work and clearly don't bother - like most people, to be fair - to read the conditions that they book hotel rooms under.

Well, yes, because what sane, reasonable person would think a hotel that valued its reputation and customer experiences would draft its T&Cs to give it maximum opportunity to rip off its customers and despoil its own reputation?

It may be legal because they’ve got people booking to sign up to unreasonable T&Cs, but it’s not right. You can’t expect the layman to know or even suspect a hotel would gleefully trouser a charge for a nights stay and then refuse their paying customer use of a portion of it (that they paid for!!). What kind of arsehole does this kind of thing?

A business does it. A company trying to make money, with responsibilities to pay it's staff, it's overheads and make profit. Why wouldn't it?

If a hotel knows that a room is sitting empty, especially in busy cities or in popular holiday spots where they are running at high occupancy of course they are going to try to resell it. It happens all the time and most of the time the people staying in the hotels are completely none the wiser.

Phobiaphobic · 19/08/2021 10:39

They are absolutely insane. I would go completely nuclear on them!

sunglassesonthetable · 19/08/2021 08:48

Well I hope you get that room OP. It's crazy that that you can't be accommodated without all this rigmarole, just because your plans have altered slightly. It's not like you want anything you haven't paid for.

It does sound like a Rhod Gilbert sketch !

Terhou · 19/08/2021 08:13

@JurassicPark101

kidneybeans I tried explaining several times. It was almost like they were reading off a prompt sheet rather than listening to what I was actually saying though. I’d explain why I should be able to access the room, again and get “I empathise with your situation Mrs JurassicPark but unfortunately as we are fully booked and the cleaners can’t get the room ready earlier I am unable to fulfil your request”.Angry
Did you ask why the cleaners weren't getting the room ready on Friday?
ThisOldSaddo · 19/08/2021 07:55

Urgh, such "computer says no" thinking. Good luck OP. I do the same as you and fuck off for a few days at a time every now and then.

Congressdingo · 19/08/2021 07:35

The fact is, if you don't check into a room on a friday in a great
number of hotels you will not be able to book in until the normal checkin day on the saturday. It may sound daft but that is how it works
Enough posters on this thread and I have done exactly the same as op and got into our room at some point in our booked stay, whether 3am, 6am or 9.30am. It's never been a problem for me. I have paid for my room and if I wish to simply never step foot in it for my booked time then I can do just that.
Hotels must know that flights are delayed, cars break down, couples break up (happened to me once and we argued over who would use the hotel booking for quite some time) life happens. And paying customers will be late for a multitude of reasons, but once the room is paid for its that customers right to come and go as and when.

BarbaraofSeville · 19/08/2021 07:20

@trappedsincesundaymorn

If someone is going to check in for you make sure that you have read the T&C's. I have been to some hotels that ask to see the card the booking was made on and/or proof of ID.
The T&Cs will include some unhelpful 'may be asked for ID/may ask to see card the room was booked in' wording.

I've stayed in hotels a lot that have been booked by our work's corporate travel provider, so obviously I don't have access to the payment card and I could be any body, and sometimes we do send different people to the person booked anyway, if we've swapped jobs, or someone was ill or whatever. They've never asked for ID, as far as I recall.

I've also arrived at a hotel for the first time at 8 am before after a night shift and was granted immediate access to the room I would have probably fallen asleep on the reception floor if they hadn't but again the room was booked the day before by my employer so I don't know what arrangements were made about late check in, but there were airline crew using the hotel so they would have been used to arrivals at all times of day and night.

I think hotels are required to ask for ID if someone walks in and pays cash, but other than that, it's probably very rare.

KidneyBeans · 19/08/2021 07:07

@JurassicPark101

kidneybeans I tried explaining several times. It was almost like they were reading off a prompt sheet rather than listening to what I was actually saying though. I’d explain why I should be able to access the room, again and get “I empathise with your situation Mrs JurassicPark but unfortunately as we are fully booked and the cleaners can’t get the room ready earlier I am unable to fulfil your request”.Angry
I feel like this conversation is a bit like talking to the hotel Grin

Stop explaining and instead keep asking questions.
Why do the cleaners need access to the room?

It doesn't sound like they ever answered that question (or that you have specifically asked it)

Swipe left for the next trending thread