Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be furious with the way social care is(n't) run in this country?

161 replies

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 14:08

I know I know I should have gotten angry about this before it affected me but... Mother has had severe stroke and is marooned in a community hospital in the back of beyond because there are no carers. None. Not in the community, not in nursing homes. The hospital is embarrassed. I'm quietly seething that a woman who has paid taxes all her life (forgive the cliche) has been left like this. There are no physios in the hospital so she is getting no rehab. I don't blame the hospital or any of the care agencies or companies. But I am raging with impotence.
Father is being cared for full time at home by a good private agency (we are paying) but even they cannot supply anyone.
The lady in the neighbouring bed to mother is way better than she is but has been waiting since early July for a care package to go home to.
What kind of place are we living in?
I do blame Brexit in part but don't want this to be a debate abut Brexit.
What can we do? It's AWFUL and inhumane

OP posts:
countrytown · 18/08/2021 17:07

The problem is you can't just target income tax as that doesn't actually target wealth. Also income taxes have been increased by stealth in the last budget.

Dh is a teacher. He earns £79k, takes home £4,300 every month.

His pension payments should be much higher?

Unsure33 · 18/08/2021 17:00

I think it varies between areas. My mother has been in a similar position but the did get home with a care package of 4 visits per day fairly quickly. And those visits are continuing and paid for by social services

They have also said they will get double handed care if necessary.

So perhaps we were just lucky .

yellowspot · 18/08/2021 16:57

As an adult social worker I can assure you that we are just as unhappy as clients/ families are at the lack of care available. We do not employ the carers nor run the companies and can only offer what we can find. The problem is just how poorly carers are paid and treated. It has meant a serious lack of uptake in jobs within the care market which is understandable. It's a hard job to do for peanuts.

raspberrymuffin · 18/08/2021 16:49

No one pays 50% of their salary in income tax for heaven's sake. You pay 40% on income over 50k which is very much not the same thing. Very low earners may not pay income tax but as a proportion of their income they pay a phenomenal amount of VAT and council tax. So it's not as though they're getting a freebie by having care provided in their old age. Would it make you feel any better if we evened things out so the care workers get a fair share of the care company's profits and then everyone gets paid the same and pays the same amount of tax? No?

Either care work is paid enough that people are willing to do it for a long term career or we all accept that we're going to have to give up work in our 40s and 50s to care for our elderly parents and for our kids to do the same for us. Personally I'd rather pay a bit more tax.

Thecurtainsofdestiny · 18/08/2021 16:44

A relative works in social care. It seems that even when there is money, there are insufficient carers at the moment. But the carers there are seem to be poorly treated and poorly paid so it's not an attractive job option.

SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 16:42

On top of the ridiculous amounts of income tax higher earners pay? Isn’t having almost half your salary taken away in tax enough?

That's not how tax works, and higher earners don't pay ridiculous amounts of tax.

LaurieFairyCake · 18/08/2021 16:40

Oh god we should pay MUCH more tax, our tax rates are the lowest in Europe.

Of course we can afford it if we choose to.

If people weren't feeling so bloody entitled to spending 10k on holidays when they earn 100k maybe the environment would do better too.

Dh is a teacher. He earns £79k, takes home £4,300 every month. We're not bothered about holidays abroad for the obvious environmental reasons - yeah we could afford to pay £500 extra every month in tax.

We don't want or care about a bigger property, our flat is fine.

Honestly where we live (London) we're the poorest people we know.

Of course the middle and higher earners can afford more tax.

And carers should be paid LONDON LIVING WAGE here - £18 an hour (I think)

The whole way we run shit is a disgrace

Merryoldgoat · 18/08/2021 16:35

We need to close the ridiculous tax loopholes and make businesses pay proper tax and proper wages.

All these big companies posting massive profits but paying minuscule wages where people have to claim in-work benefits to survive are effectively being subsidised by the state.

Thar would be a good start.

StrangeToSee · 18/08/2021 16:27

We need a specific tax everyone over 40 pays towards their later life care. Everyone.

On top of the ridiculous amounts of income tax higher earners pay? Isn’t having almost half your salary taken away in tax enough?

Most people pay basic tax rates, many pay no tax at all as their incomes don’t meet the threshold.

Why punish middle and higher earners by expecting them to pay yet more tax on their hard earned incomes?

PragmaticWench · 18/08/2021 16:27

It won't help you now OP but maybe write to your MP?

BoaCunstrictor · 18/08/2021 15:37

It was bad enough before, but yes, Brexit has made it worse. Because there were shortages even before we cut off one of the ways in which people entered the sector. And this won't be popular, but the vaccination requirements won't help either. It may or may not be relevant in this specific instance, but we know it's driving some care sector workers away and deterring other people from entering the sector.

The whole system is a mess.

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 15:32

@emmylousings

I hate the way we idolise the NHS, but don't seem to give a toss about 'social care', what is the actual difference between social care and health care, when you think about it?! None. We need a specific tax everyone over 40 pays towards their later life care. Everyone. Germany and Japan do this. It's not complicated. We need to let politicians know that we want, because they are pathetically afraid of the radical idea, that is using taxation to address social problems.
Yes! That's what I'm after - some anger that will generate solutions. Honestly where are live there are NO carers private or state funded who can care for my mum. She needs a a minimum two four times a day. Or residential. And to think those carers whi are working are being paid a pittance just adds insult to injury. We are lucky. We have the promise of line in care which we'll find from Sept. Meanwhile mum remains in a hospital where she doesn't need to be and where staff want her (in the nicest way) gone
OP posts:
fantasmasgoria1 · 18/08/2021 15:29

Care assistants often don't get treated very well by their employers and the wages are so poor so why on earth would a person want to work as one. You get odd people say oh it's such a rewarding job and I love but not that many. I worked in elderly care when I was in my 20s and it was not good. That's one of the reasons why social care is in a poor state, people just don't want the job.

CovidCorvid · 18/08/2021 15:29

There was something on the news about this this morning and how it’s expected to get worse. And yes brexit seemed to be the reason.

So while nandos running out of chicken is a tad inconvenient this is really serious and has the potential to become devastating. What happens to people in care homes when staff leave and vacancies can’t be filled? What happens when the hospitals are full because people can’t be discharged.

I’m not sure what can be done. It’s too late to stop brexit, so a lot of the workforce has left and won’t be coming back. Where do you find people? Seems British people don’t want to do it…or not in sufficient numbers. Is it a wage issue, do wages need increasing….but then fees will increase. And if you increase wages too much pissed off nurses will Jack in nursing and go and work in care homes instead. 🤷‍♀️

I’m currently staying in a tourist area and numerous pubs/hotels are closing because they can’t staff the businesses. Every open shop/cafe has signs up saying they have multiple vacancies. I holiday here every year and never seen anything like it. There are hour long queues to get into cafes for lunch. 20 min queue to get into greggs for a take away sausage roll! Normally there’s a lot of Eastern European staff.

So no I don’t think yabu for mentioning brexit. It’s had a massive impact. I hope your mum gets sorted.

emmylousings · 18/08/2021 15:24

I hate the way we idolise the NHS, but don't seem to give a toss about 'social care', what is the actual difference between social care and health care, when you think about it?! None. We need a specific tax everyone over 40 pays towards their later life care. Everyone. Germany and Japan do this. It's not complicated. We need to let politicians know that we want, because they are pathetically afraid of the radical idea, that is using taxation to address social problems.

Monkeybusinesss · 18/08/2021 15:21

Have you looked into NHS continuing health care fund. It’s a life saver and you can be fast tracked if your mum is not well.
One of the key points deciders is mobility, we were given it without even asking. So I’m surprised she hasn’t given that she’s not well enough to go home

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 15:21

And that's shocking. And clearly part of the problem. The profession isn't funded. It's not right. As I said I have no beef with any of the carers I've met. You're blimmin brilliant. In any other profession a shortage would be met with sing wage levels. Clearly tho carers are an exception and that's wrong for everyone

OP posts:
bebanjo · 18/08/2021 15:15

I’m a carer, we get £9 an hour. We don’t get paid for training, which is mandatory. We get one uniform ( it’s just the top) any more you have to buy them at £15 each. We are always over worked and understaffed.
We are not allowed any time off in December. We don’t get paid travel time. We get phone calls when not at work asking us to pick up extra work.
I’m retaining to do something else, iv only been there a year and I won’t to be out before I make it to 2 years.
That’s why there are no carers.

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 14:44

@countrytown

physio, an OT, or much in the way of SAL you can't find any of these privately?
Not til she comes out of hospital. A private physio won't be insured to work in hospital. And she needs double handed care (hoist etc) when she comes out. And there are no carers and nor are there nursing homes spaces. One prominent local nursing home even told me they had space but not the staff. I've got private physio all lined up - but no where to go It's just just my family either - the lady next door to mums bed is in a far better physical Condition and like mum the hospital says she's ready for discharge but there's no care package. Plus of course covid - no one can visit
OP posts:
SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 14:38

Oh and Brexit and the hostile environment is a massive issue when it comes to carers....the vast majority of paid carers in the UK are non UK nationals on minimum wage.

SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 14:37

What kind of place are we living in?

A place where we pay very low tax, keep trying to pay less, and yet expect to get an awful lot for those pitiful taxes, is where.

countrytown · 18/08/2021 14:36

physio, an OT, or much in the way of SAL
you can't find any of these privately?

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 14:35

@Maryann1975

6 years ago, FIL was terminally ill and we were told he had between days and A couple of weeks left. He was desperate to come home and not die in hospital. We ended up having to discharge him with no care package so He could Have that request granted. It was almost a blessing that the end was quick as it took a real toll on the whole family who had no experience of nursing/end of life care and very quickly had to learn. As a family, we could have afforded to pay for care, But there were simply no carers free to come in and care for him. I dread to think how bad it is now if it was like that 6 years ago.
And that was a wonderful thing for you to all do for your FiL. I have the utmost respect. But as you say it took a toll. And I suspect if he'd had a package in place it would have been better for him too - calmer. A good carer is a wonderful thing.
OP posts:
countrytown · 18/08/2021 14:34

Well we don't fund it enough so the system is shit plus I wouldn't want to work as a carer.

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 14:33

No I don't work on social care, which is why I suppose my eyes are on my just now being opened.
And there are no catered whether private or state funded. Private care homes can and do take patients who are 'bed blocking' like my mum (awful phrase), and social services can find or part fund. We're not eligible because mum and dad's assets are too great.
Makes no difference either way (and nor should it - everyone should have access to social care). - there are no spaces and in some cases no staff so spaces have been curtailed. I've rung everything cafe home in the county so know!
There are no people. That's the problem
And sure mum is being cared for (tho not as the hospita would like - even the matron is embarrassed because the can't supply physio, an OT, or much in the way of SALT), but there's the problem - she's unwittingly bunging up a hospital place.
It's a mess

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread