Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be furious with the way social care is(n't) run in this country?

161 replies

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 14:08

I know I know I should have gotten angry about this before it affected me but... Mother has had severe stroke and is marooned in a community hospital in the back of beyond because there are no carers. None. Not in the community, not in nursing homes. The hospital is embarrassed. I'm quietly seething that a woman who has paid taxes all her life (forgive the cliche) has been left like this. There are no physios in the hospital so she is getting no rehab. I don't blame the hospital or any of the care agencies or companies. But I am raging with impotence.
Father is being cared for full time at home by a good private agency (we are paying) but even they cannot supply anyone.
The lady in the neighbouring bed to mother is way better than she is but has been waiting since early July for a care package to go home to.
What kind of place are we living in?
I do blame Brexit in part but don't want this to be a debate abut Brexit.
What can we do? It's AWFUL and inhumane

OP posts:
StrangeToSee · 18/08/2021 20:36

Everything about this post, but especially the last paragraph, shows exactly why we desperately need tough wealth redistribution policies to be put in place ASAP

Wealth redistribution policies? Then where is the motivation to study for years for a high earning profession, continue studying and paying to sit exams whilst working, clawing your way up the pay scales only to have more and more of your income taken in tax?

EmmaGrundyForPM · 18/08/2021 19:42

I work in ASC for an LA with a very rural area. Some care calls are 15 minutes driving time apart. It's a nightmare for Providers, especially as we (the LA) just can't afford to pay any higher. We have cut services to the bone already. And some of the cuts are to non-statutory preventative services which often save money in the longterm by supporting people to remain independent.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 18/08/2021 19:26

The government could stop a lot of waste like throwing money at Stonewall but no funding an organisation that wants to take away women’s spaces is more important than giving councils money to care for people.

Valorgreen · 18/08/2021 19:18

On top of the ridiculous amounts of income tax higher earners pay? Isn’t having almost half your salary taken away in tax enough?

Most people pay basic tax rates, many pay no tax at all as their incomes don’t meet the threshold.

Why punish middle and higher earners by expecting them to pay yet more tax on their hard earned incomes?

Everything about this post, but especially the last paragraph, shows exactly why we desperately need tough wealth redistribution policies to be put in place ASAP.

Sparklestar1 · 18/08/2021 18:00

@Cooper88

The problem you face here with potentially having carers come in to care for your dm (i work as a dom carer and also do the rotas for my company so know.this very well) is that your dm is a double up. So you the company need to have 2x carers 4x a day. So say a company has 8x runs am and pm they need to find 2 runs 4x a day that has a space at the same time to then have the carers meet and do the visit. Then if the visit runs over, which double ups are very likely to do they then have the knock on effect for the rest of the day/night. This makes it a hell.of a.lot harder to do for a company on top of the staffing issues that all care companies seem to be facing as well.
Completely hit the nail on the head! It's so frustrating. We want to help more but our hands are tied - social services don't pay us enough to be increase staff wages even more then we have so we run at not much profit at all to ensure our carers get an above sector rate of pay. We ensure they have proper breaks and travel fines between clients. We map everything out to ensure they aren't travelling more then a few streets away and are in the same area all shift - a lot of care agencies do none of this but we are still struggling. 2 applicants in a month! Also I think there are still people who don't want the vax so won't look at working in care either!
Muchtoomuchtodo · 18/08/2021 17:56

@shallswim yes, it’s an awful situation but having money gives you options.
If you can offer better working conditions than local care agencies then employing a small team of people to care for both of your parents directly might be the only way of getting your mum out of hospital.
I work in the community for the NHS and even those with existing care packages often get calls at short notice to say that the agency have no one available to provide certain calls. Many patients get discharged to places that are not of their or their families choosing simply because the hospital beds are needed and this is the only option.
The expectation to have care provided for free in a place and at times of your choosing is a dim and distant memory unfortunately.
Have you contacted the hospital’s discharge liaison team or your mum’s social worker for updates? They must be tearing their hair out at such long delays to discharge.

Sparklestar1 · 18/08/2021 17:53

Hi, I'm a manager in homecare - the problem at the moment is recruitment and retention. We have tried absolutely everything we possibly can, pay well above the usual minimum wage including paying 18-24 year olds the same as everybody else! People either don't want to work in care or don't want to work! On top of that carers are going off at the drop of a hat - now if they have been pinged they can still work providing a negative PCR test but some test results have taken 5-6 days to come back. It's a shambles. The work home carers have done during this pandemic has been forgotten - they too have been front lines just like NHS and care homes. We are currently struggling with the clients we already have due to staffing never mind being able to take more, it's heartbreaking and we are really at a loss as to what to try next

SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 17:51

I don’t think individual families should pay more income tax. Businesses yes. But imagine you work hard, get a promotion and suddenly 40% of your income is taken in tax, leaving you worse off than before

Why would we imagine that, when that is not how tax works!! IF you get that promotion, 40% of your income in that bracket goes to tax, not 40% of your entire income. Huge difference. And it's only fair and right that it does so.

StrangeToSee · 18/08/2021 17:48

Oh god we should pay MUCH more tax, our tax rates are the lowest in Europe. Of course we can afford it if we choose to

I don’t think individual families should pay more income tax. Businesses yes. But imagine you work hard, get a promotion and suddenly 40% of your income is taken in tax, leaving you worse off than before! Or 45% over a certain amount. And it’s based on individual income not family income, so you could have a husband and wife better off for both earning just under the tax threshold than one main earner being a higher rate tax payer, trying to support the family on that one heavily taxed income!

It makes me really cross when people suggest ‘tax the higher earners more’ like it’s a magic solution. Most higher rate tax payers I know don’t splash out on luxury items, they save and invest wisely.

The NHS is barely fit for purpose so although we pay into it, few of us rely on it or use it. Waiting lists are so long even to see a GP (let alone a consultant) people who can afford to usually go private.

Social care isn’t much better. Under staffed, workers underpaid, private care agencies and homes making a profit.

I did care work as a student; never again. I found it physically and emotionally exhausting, not worth the pay. Dealing with bodily fluids, scrubbing out commode buckets, mopping floors all night, back breaking work.

If the hospital OT has recommended certain adaptations or equipment they can take weeks to arrive and be fitted. If social services recommends a package of care it takes weeks to secure funding (means assessed) and to get that package in place takes even longer. One way to speed it up would be for a relative to take over sourcing private carers, but then they’d have to monitor them and manage the budget.

Sadly the whole social care system is desperately understaffed, hard to recruit to and hard to retain staff. So yes discharges get delayed, but I wouldn’t blame social services when they’re on their knees.

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 17:41

@JoborPlay yup. That's what I'm trying cack-handedly to explain! It matters not if you have the money... the carers aren't available in any setting or format. And frankly having the money shouldn't fast track you: everyone should be entitled to dignified care in their old age

OP posts:
shallIswim · 18/08/2021 17:40

as @Cooper88 explains so well it's a double handed job so effectively 8 carers a day.
many of our local nursing homes are shutting up shop to new admissions anyway because of another covid wave so we're in a perfect storm: Brexit, low pay attracting few carers, and covid. And probably much else besides.

OP posts:
JoborPlay · 18/08/2021 17:40

@Ritasueandbobtoo9

You could look at Direct Payments and employing someone directly and also into single handed care equipment to make care with one carer safe.
The OPs mum is self funding. She still can't find care. It's the same in my local authority, there are no carers. It doesn't matter who is paying, there's no one to do the job.
JoborPlay · 18/08/2021 17:39

@StrangeToSee

We need a specific tax everyone over 40 pays towards their later life care. Everyone.

On top of the ridiculous amounts of income tax higher earners pay? Isn’t having almost half your salary taken away in tax enough?

Most people pay basic tax rates, many pay no tax at all as their incomes don’t meet the threshold.

Why punish middle and higher earners by expecting them to pay yet more tax on their hard earned incomes?

Because we need to fund social care more appropriately!

And it isn't half my income, it's half above a certain threshold. So yes, if I get a pay rise, half of that is tax but so what? I can afford it and it benefits the greater good.

Social care is dreadfully under resourced. Last year one local authority had a £6.4million over spend- that's the social bill costing £6.4 million more than they received via taxation AND those who paid something towards the care provided. We need to pay more tax. We need to pay carers better. We need to be more welcoming to the large swathe of foreign nationals prepared to do the care jobs.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 18/08/2021 17:37

The things / work that carers do is really quite skilled and carers are often really dedicated and caring people so pay should reflect the skills that are needed.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 18/08/2021 17:36

You could look at Direct Payments and employing someone directly and also into single handed care equipment to make care with one carer safe.

SimonJT · 18/08/2021 17:32

Care work is difficult, poorly paid and usually long hours.

A friend is in a care facility for people with aquired brain injuries, when vacancies come up it reveals that carers are on the NMW. These carers work 12 hour shifts, they’re providing vital medical and personal care. They’d be better paid on a till in a supermarket, which is criminal when you consider the skills and qualifcations required.

EmeraldShamrock · 18/08/2021 17:23

It is awful seeing a loved one without adequate care.
Brexit encouraged lots of care staff to move on, the training is intense and the working conditions aren't great.
Once it is recognised as a valued position.
I laughed once on MN a pp said "Well it isn't our DC who work in those roles" on a thread about Brexit.
I see a lot of people from my area working class people taking on the job with pride.
Unfortunately folk look down at carers and when you earn similar in a store it becomes more attractive.

Winter2020 · 18/08/2021 17:23

I think there is a lot of scope for employers to improve their terms and conditions to encourage people to come into care. There seems to be an attitude in care that you have to be available 24/7 but willing to accept low or zero hour contracts. It is no surprise then that many don't stick around as they can secure more family friendly/less anti social hours work with guaranteed hours. Also it is preferred that you are willing to work as many hours as the employer asks for (despite a low hours contract).

I don't know why there is such reluctance for fixed hours part time working for example. Retail or hospitality which are also often a 24/7 services seem more willing to give people fixed days, have weekend staff/employ students.

Despite a huge shortage of staff and plenty of staff that would prefer not to work weekends or evenings I don't have much confidence that a person approaching an employer for saturday/sunday work or evening work (to manage childcare around a partner with a 9-5 job) would be snapped up. I think in many cases they would be told they need people that are available all the time.

If employers are struggling to recruit as well as pay they should look at what else they can do to improve terms and conditions such as offering fixed hours part time contracts.

Cooper88 · 18/08/2021 17:22

The problem you face here with potentially having carers come in to care for your dm (i work as a dom carer and also do the rotas for my company so know.this very well) is that your dm is a double up. So you the company need to have 2x carers 4x a day. So say a company has 8x runs am and pm they need to find 2 runs 4x a day that has a space at the same time to then have the carers meet and do the visit. Then if the visit runs over, which double ups are very likely to do they then have the knock on effect for the rest of the day/night. This makes it a hell.of a.lot harder to do for a company on top of the staffing issues that all care companies seem to be facing as well.

Dontwatchfootball · 18/08/2021 17:18

In the short term - not much I think. It is tragic. Until you are in that situation (I was with mum last year) it is hard to credit how bad it is.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 18/08/2021 17:18

When care was moved into the community no one really complained. People were cared for by nurses in the NHS and carers in the community. When councils contracted out their care services no one really complained. Pay, conditions were ground down by councils wanting more for less. No support, no time, unsafe working conditions (Uncontrolled dogs eating peoples farces off the bed / drunk and unreasonable family members / abusive clients / remote rural areas up forest tracks / no lighting to name a few memories from my experience)
No one wants their child to become a carer, much better to encourage our children to go to university for three years to end up in Starbucks. So many older people needing care. Rural areas particularly bad because the young leave for jobs and Escape to the Country encourages older people to move to remote properties without any support. Honestly, It’s not Brexit, it’s 30 years of neglect of social care by successive governments. We are beyond breaking point and have been for years.

Dontwatchfootball · 18/08/2021 17:16

What can we do? Stop voting Tory. Expect care companies who make huge profits pay living wages and treat their staff like valued humans rather than hamsters on a treadmill. Keep demanding our MPs tell us why they think this is ok and what they plan to do about it.

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 17:15

@Muchtoomuchtodo

If you can find carers, could you get direct payments and employ them yourselves? You could do it for both parents. By offering better rates of pay, no travelling between jobs, no uniform needed etc it might be an attractive option for the right people.
This sounds like an easy solution but it isn't. Using a company means once you do have carers and are locked in they must find replacements so those carers can take breaks. Otherwise yiu spend you life trying to plug gaps. I know this because we tried!
OP posts:
Muchtoomuchtodo · 18/08/2021 17:08

If you can find carers, could you get direct payments and employ them yourselves? You could do it for both parents. By offering better rates of pay, no travelling between jobs, no uniform needed etc it might be an attractive option for the right people.

Sunnyfreezesushi · 18/08/2021 17:07

When my grandmother needed proper help we just employed someone full time to look after her, like you would a nanny for a child. We did the same when my father was dying. Paid a proper wage and said person also did housework etc and was a great help. To be honest this is what people who can afford it do in my home country too (Switzerland). Homes there are amazing but so expensive if you are well off (proportion of assets/earnings although it differs per region/canton) so that it is cheaper to hire someone yourself or share with another local
family. I don’t understand why people here think the state should pay for everything when you are relatively well off/have plenty of assets.
If you offer a decent wage and advertise you might find someone great (if you can afford it).

Swipe left for the next trending thread