Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be furious with the way social care is(n't) run in this country?

161 replies

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 14:08

I know I know I should have gotten angry about this before it affected me but... Mother has had severe stroke and is marooned in a community hospital in the back of beyond because there are no carers. None. Not in the community, not in nursing homes. The hospital is embarrassed. I'm quietly seething that a woman who has paid taxes all her life (forgive the cliche) has been left like this. There are no physios in the hospital so she is getting no rehab. I don't blame the hospital or any of the care agencies or companies. But I am raging with impotence.
Father is being cared for full time at home by a good private agency (we are paying) but even they cannot supply anyone.
The lady in the neighbouring bed to mother is way better than she is but has been waiting since early July for a care package to go home to.
What kind of place are we living in?
I do blame Brexit in part but don't want this to be a debate abut Brexit.
What can we do? It's AWFUL and inhumane

OP posts:
Peterbear · 19/08/2021 07:52

*deconditioned not reconditioned

Bananarice · 19/08/2021 07:40

I know two care workers who left their job when covid vaccine was made mandatory.

Peterbear · 19/08/2021 07:39

Care is such an undervalued and poorly paid job. The system is screwed - it’s all about making money (capitalism) and doesn’t give a crap about workers - mostly women (sexism). Stop voting Tory and maybe the system will change- councils need proper waged , in-house careers again. Before ‘care in the community’ and everything was privatised/outsourced things were better. Paying a carer £9 an hour is a fucking disgrace. They’d be better working in Mac Donald’s. Bojo and co don’t give a shit though they’ll have some posh live in carer when they get old. Meanwhile people stay in hospital (costing £2k per day to the NHS ) and get reconditioned and lose confidence.
Hope your mum gets out soon OP. We all need to write to our MPs and be fucking 😡

Greeneyedminx · 19/08/2021 07:13

The main problem is the underfunding by Social Services, tendering all care packages out to the cheapest company.
Many people may not be aware that each council who tenders out for care in the community, do not include their own in-house carers in these tenders.
Also, in rural areas carers would get paid the going rate for the level of care required, so in some cases the travelling time was factored into the prices paid by Social Services. If care was needed for someone who lived 20 minutes or more away from town centres, then they used to be paid for that time as well as part of the contract. Now that doesn’t happen, so carers and companies won’t take on care packages in rural areas as they are not viable.
Reputable companies pay travel time and mileage, but most cannot afford to do this anymore, due to the very low contract prices.

Vivana · 18/08/2021 23:49

I'm a support worker and do like my role but sadly social care is underpaid and understaffed and staff are leaving. In my old role 2 managers left 6 carers and 2 care coordinators in 4 weeks.

MNmonster · 18/08/2021 23:29

It's because caring of any kind in the UK is considered to be so worthless that it is not worth paying people a reasonable wage.
Childcare, is the same.
YEs, pre brexit migrant workers were willing to do it. Why aren't allof those people who said foreigns workers were stealing their jobs jumping to become carers.

JoborPlay · 18/08/2021 23:21

@DroopyClematis

As my mum can make a sandwich and can take herself to the loo , she doesn't qualify for care. She cannot shower or bathe herself but can stand, with a frame , in front of the sink and try to flannel herself. She can't wash her feet. She qualifies for financial assistance but not any care. She has to fund her own care which costs around £25 an hour and eats into her basic state pension as it costs more than her allowance.

The system is broken.

That's not right, I'd ask for a reassessment. She needs to be unable to do 2 of the care act eligibility criteria to qualify for support. And she doesn't need to be completely unable to do them- there's 3 aspects;
  • can't do it
  • takes longer than your average Joe
  • causes significant pain

She needs to be unable to, or have significant difficulty with 2 or more of;

  • managing nutrition
  • personal hygiene
  • toileting
  • dressing
  • using the home safely
  • cleaning (maintaining a habitable environment)
  • maintaining relationships
  • accessing education or work
  • using local facilities
  • carrying out caring responsibilities

I imagine if your mum needs a perching stool to wash, that she can't dress herself without pain or without taking a while. I'd also bet she can't get out and about to the shops or do the hoovering.

Ask for a reassessment and make sure you know the criteria before hand.

www.scie.org.uk/care-act-2014/assessment-and-eligibility/eligibility/definition-outcomes#outcomes

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 18/08/2021 23:02

It is very hard work physically and emotionally and it is unsafe in terms or environment or abusive clients or and as well as abusive families. The post war generation are not as grateful or kind as the pre war generation and their are a lot of unreasonable people who place unreasonable demands on carers.

Itsmeagainandagain · 18/08/2021 22:14

As a former social care assistant
Let me ask you this while ypu fester with rage is nmw worth being punched, kicked, bitten, hair pulled with absolute zero support from managers? Is being peed or shat on worth nmw? What about spat on and at risk of hep b or some other bbv?
What about patronising family members who make the jobs of carers 10 times harder?
You have no clue why there is a shortage, the bad outweighs the worthwhile and thats why there is a shortage of staff they are sick of 12 hour shifts where they are sore and never told a postive. 9 quid an hour to watch your life suck away from you to look aftet other peoples family, sacraficing time with their own families.

Paquerette · 18/08/2021 22:05

@Valorgreen

On top of the ridiculous amounts of income tax higher earners pay? Isn’t having almost half your salary taken away in tax enough?

Most people pay basic tax rates, many pay no tax at all as their incomes don’t meet the threshold.

Why punish middle and higher earners by expecting them to pay yet more tax on their hard earned incomes?

Everything about this post, but especially the last paragraph, shows exactly why we desperately need tough wealth redistribution policies to be put in place ASAP.

How well do you think that the NHS would run without most of the consultants and doctors? Bring in wealth redistribution policies and even more would leave for better paying countries abroad.
christinarossetti19 · 18/08/2021 21:34

The social care system has been becoming increasingly broken over the last few decades.

Most dom care used by be provided directly by local authorities, so staff had contracts, annual leave, salaried positions, paid training etc etc.

It's now nearly all or possibly even all now provided by care agencies who can only win tenders by undercutting other providers.

Hence the piss poor pay, not being paid for travel time, having to pay for own training and travel, zero hours contracts etc etc.

Recruitment and retention has been a nightmare for years and is only becoming increasingly so.

It's horrendous and no, money won't insulate you from its effects if there aren't enough carers.

DroopyClematis · 18/08/2021 21:28

As my mum can make a sandwich and can take herself to the loo , she doesn't qualify for care.
She cannot shower or bathe herself but can stand, with a frame , in front of the sink and try to flannel herself.
She can't wash her feet.
She qualifies for financial assistance but not any care.
She has to fund her own care which costs around £25 an hour and eats into her basic state pension as it costs more than her allowance.

The system is broken.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 18/08/2021 21:26

Also, the migrants just in my area do the better paid factory jobs and have not been involved in the care sector so Brexit hasn’t affected my area but the sheer number of older people buying homes in isolated rural areas when they are healthy but 5-10 years down the line are finding that they can’t get carers to come to them as the property is so rural it just doesn’t pay to take their care on.

Mscarna · 18/08/2021 21:24

I used to work in care. It's been heading that way for well over a decade. Years ago you could train into nursing on the job. You got paid time and a half for working bank holidays or night shifts and permanent jobs. All that was taken away. Who wants a dead end job where greedy owners cash in on you working Xmas day for minimum wage? It's back breaking work, literally. It can cause lifelong issues for people. And it was entirely predictable that there would be huge staff shortages following Brexit.

bungabungaboo · 18/08/2021 21:07

Unfortunately people do not get that there is a problem until it affects them, why would you?

It needs to be discussed in parliament and action taken

Care agencies do not get paid enough to pay carers enough

Care is not seen as a valuable career

As a society we need to care for those most vulnerable but we do not and people don't get it until they are affected

I understand why you would not want to care for your Mum, or indeed why she may not want you too, especially personal care

No simple answers and I sympathise

Have you tried advertising privately and paying more?

Or a live in carer maybe?

Apologies if you have mentioned this in your post

entropynow · 18/08/2021 21:05

@Starlightstarbright1

Yabu once you blame brexit. Social care has been highly underfunded sincevway before brexit.
Serious lack of care staff is down to Brexit. You may not like it, but tough. Them's the facts. Funding was tight but you could usually find personnel, most of whom were from Eastern Europe. Again, you probably don't like that fact, but there it is.
DismantledKing · 18/08/2021 21:05

@StrangeToSee

Everything about this post, but especially the last paragraph, shows exactly why we desperately need tough wealth redistribution policies to be put in place ASAP

Wealth redistribution policies? Then where is the motivation to study for years for a high earning profession, continue studying and paying to sit exams whilst working, clawing your way up the pay scales only to have more and more of your income taken in tax?

Because you can still earn a fucking fortune and far more than most people can dream of, but you have to contribute more to the pot.
DismantledKing · 18/08/2021 21:03

@StrangeToSee

We need a specific tax everyone over 40 pays towards their later life care. Everyone.

On top of the ridiculous amounts of income tax higher earners pay? Isn’t having almost half your salary taken away in tax enough?

Most people pay basic tax rates, many pay no tax at all as their incomes don’t meet the threshold.

Why punish middle and higher earners by expecting them to pay yet more tax on their hard earned incomes?

‘Ridiculous amounts of income tax’? Lol, piss off.
shallIswim · 18/08/2021 20:59

@ILoveAllRainbowsx

If you want prepare to be a carer why should anyone else

I'm not sure where you expect all these people to come from who want to be carers

I also don't know no who you expect to pay for it

Your mother might have paid taxes all her life but I'm sure we can do the calculations she's taken out a lot more than she put in

People need to start saving up to pay for their own Care not relying on everyone else

We also need to change the law said that people who don't want to be cared for can end their life

I don't want to go into into a care home if I can't look after myself but at the moment I don't have any choice

It's a good point. I earn my money and pay my taxes in other ways. I guess I now understand that I'd happily pay a little more in order that those who do the work we don't want to do (and I know that mum does not want me to be doing her personal care any more than I want to be doing it) are paid decently and more are encouraged to join their ranks.
OP posts:
ILoveAllRainbowsx · 18/08/2021 20:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 18/08/2021 20:50

Fairyliz clean and fed is such a low bar - its not considered acceptable any more.

Adult social care has vastly better pay and consitions in some EU countries. Anyone with proper qualifications should consider learning German if they want to double their pay and improve their working conditions...

It's still not perfect here, especially for carers visiting elderly care users in their own homes and the users of that type of care, because they are so rushed (as they are in the UK) with too short time slots, but no carer I've come across uses their own car - they're provided - nor pays for their own training (unless self employed of course).

A fully qualified full time carer can expect 36k € gross basic plus various allowances (there's a tariff plan so everyone knows what they should be paid, its transparent like nurses and teachers pay, and the geriatric and adult social care qualifications are comparable to nursing qualifications, same duration, hefty exams for state registration) in Germany.

We pay a shed load more in tax and other compulsory deductions though. Separate from income tax is 15.5% state health insurance plus separate state care insurance plus compulsory state unemployment insurance, then obviously compulsory state pension insurance. The equivalent of NI is multiple times more.

CovidCorvid · 18/08/2021 20:50

Said on the news tonight 1000 carer vacancies in North Yorkshire alone!

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 20:49

I would pay more tax. I do not want to see others go through this.
5 years ago my MiL was in a similar
Position and the problem wasn't anywhere near as acute.

OP posts:
bungabungaboo · 18/08/2021 20:48

I understand how you feel, I worked in social care

The social care system has been underfunded for decades

Wealth will make no difference because there are not enough carers

People do not realise until it affects them and their family

No one cares until then

People do not want to pay more tax and so it continues

Care needs to be valued

Well funded

We need root and branch reform agreed by ALL political parties

Care is expensive and should be valued like nurses were during the pandemic

Sad
shallIswim · 18/08/2021 20:39

@StrangeToSee

Everything about this post, but especially the last paragraph, shows exactly why we desperately need tough wealth redistribution policies to be put in place ASAP

Wealth redistribution policies? Then where is the motivation to study for years for a high earning profession, continue studying and paying to sit exams whilst working, clawing your way up the pay scales only to have more and more of your income taken in tax?

These are things my parents did. Worked hard; employed hundreds of people; saved. And all the money in the world cannot secure my mother care outside hospital that is fit for purpose. My dad already has full time care at home and we're hanging on to that gem of a carer for dear life. Please don't think wealth will insulate you.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread