Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be furious with the way social care is(n't) run in this country?

161 replies

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 14:08

I know I know I should have gotten angry about this before it affected me but... Mother has had severe stroke and is marooned in a community hospital in the back of beyond because there are no carers. None. Not in the community, not in nursing homes. The hospital is embarrassed. I'm quietly seething that a woman who has paid taxes all her life (forgive the cliche) has been left like this. There are no physios in the hospital so she is getting no rehab. I don't blame the hospital or any of the care agencies or companies. But I am raging with impotence.
Father is being cared for full time at home by a good private agency (we are paying) but even they cannot supply anyone.
The lady in the neighbouring bed to mother is way better than she is but has been waiting since early July for a care package to go home to.
What kind of place are we living in?
I do blame Brexit in part but don't want this to be a debate abut Brexit.
What can we do? It's AWFUL and inhumane

OP posts:
shallIswim · 19/08/2021 16:31

@NellDodds well no, you can't be having a pop at me because I have said clearly that as far as i'm concerned high tax is fine if it results in an improvement. I also don't give a monkeys that my inheritance is being spent at an alarming pace on first Dad's full time care, and now Mum's. I quite agree that the value of assets should count. But if all that is case, I'd blimmin like the system to work.

OP posts:
DiscoLightsOnAFridayNight · 19/08/2021 15:34

What interests me is that over half of the adult social care budget is spent on people aged 65+ (they make up 18% of the population) with 65% of this spending going to people with physical needs yet as an age demographic, they are most likely to vote Conservative.

So to those saying higher earners need to pay more tax, the age demographic who needs & benefits from social care the most are also the ones voting for lower taxes & wealth retention.

DiscoLightsOnAFridayNight · 19/08/2021 14:47

Because you can still earn a fucking fortune and far more than most people can dream of, but you have to contribute more to the pot.

  1. The top 5% already pay 31% of all direct tax revenue so they do contribute more to the pot. I imagine as a demographic, they also take the least out as well.
  1. Increasing taxes for higher earners is always the answer to everything on these threads, today it’s social care however it’s also meant to fix:
  • the NHS
  • Welfare
  • Childcare
  • Housing
  • Education
  • Pensions
  • Police / public order & safety
  • Defence (see Afghanistan threads)
  • Environment
  • Transport
  • Overseas aid (see Afghanistan threads)

& so on.

Also don’t forget that tax money goes towards other things that we don’t really consider like:

  • National debt interest
  • Government administration
  • Business / Industry
  • Culture

So the question is, how much more tax are higher earners meant to pay to cover ALL of these things to a standard that people are happy with?

NellDodds · 19/08/2021 12:59

@SoreusBacchus

What kind of place are we living in?

A place where we pay very low tax, keep trying to pay less, and yet expect to get an awful lot for those pitiful taxes, is where.

Exactly. OP (like many people) says her mum has paid tax all her life. Well, yes, that's the normal way. Problem is most of us don't pay nearly enough tax - or legally avoid it by diverting tax into pensions.

And many people are incensed that their (or their parents') home should be used to pay for care in old age. "They worked all their lives to pay for their house" they protest. No, they worked to put a roof over their heads and had the good fortune to benefit from house price inflation. Now use it to pay for care. I plan to.

Not having a pop at you, OP, btw. Must be awful to see your mum in this situation 💐

DismantledKing · 19/08/2021 12:48

@Planetsandstars

I think we are saying the same thing *@Carycy* - I just have to smile wryly at the nice lefty people who voted to remain all outraged that the Eastern Europeans have left so there’s no available labour to treat like dirt!
We didn’t like having them here to ‘treat them like diet’. We liked having them here because they added things to Britain, made it less inward-looking. They left because they were made to feel unwelcome by brexity twats. This country has lost a lot by ending free movement.
Carycy · 19/08/2021 12:44

I don’t think think immigrants only do the job. Like I said I did it for a while. I just think the thinking that they can solve the problem keeps the wages low and the conditions poor. It also doesn’t help that it is seen as female work as well, which also keeps the wages low. It is physically demanding work and most traditionally male physical work attracts a reasonable premium because it it “tough man’s work.”

EmeraldShamrock · 19/08/2021 12:23

It smacks of hypocrisy. There is a reason UK nationals don’t want to do it. It doesn’t pay the bills. Therein lies the problem.

Many national wc people do this job and do it without decent working conditions.
It is naive to believe only immigrants do the job. Probably why no-one cares to fix it.

The pressure put on community carers by "managers" who sit in the office and make thier timetables is immense. 15 minute slots to wash, dress, serve meals, help with medications then 5 minutes to get to the next. Of course that is barring that on arrival extra care is needed or ambulance support. Some days the carers who come to clients homes are the only social interaction these people have and often ask them to stay for 5 minutes longer which carers are not allowed to do.
Yes to all of this. One friend transferred from community to NHS hospital care, she was heartbroken knowing she hadn't 2 extra minutes to chat with the clients, some hadn't spoken to anyone all day.
Private companies creaming the profits.
She was spending an extra hour every day.

VickyEadieofThigh · 19/08/2021 11:59

I think a major part of the problem lies in the fact that care agencies take a significant amount of the fees paid for care, whilst paying pathetic rates to their staff. My dad, who has dementia and physical disabilities but still lives at home, was paying most of his Attendance Allowance for one carer visit per day.

Then, one of the agency carers broke away and set up on her own, recruiting a small team of women already trained and experienced to work with her. Dad now gets 4 visits a day (which he needs) for the amount he was paying the agency plus 50% again. These are proper, half hour visits, during which they get him the relevant meal, ensure he is clean (get him in the shower, etc), put his washing on and later hang it out, keep the kitchen clean, do him a weekly shop - and the lead carer sorts out his meds with the pharmacy, harasses the GP surgery when necessary, got the council to fit him a new shower when the old one broke - and lots more.

The ideal is to try to get care privately organised - that's what I think.

Carycy · 19/08/2021 11:46

Ha yes. Agree Planets. It smacks of hypocrisy. There is a reason UK nationals don’t want to do it. It doesn’t pay the bills. Therein lies the problem.
Also find myself getting mildly annoyed at people who have only ever done “naice” office jobs whinging. Everyone should get their hands dirty at least once in their life.
Maybe we should all have a year after school A-levels, where we have an option of community helping jobs to choose from inc care work, kind of like subscription. That might solve the problem long term. No one would ever go for it. Too much like hard work.

Planetsandstars · 19/08/2021 11:35

I think we are saying the same thing @Carycy - I just have to smile wryly at the nice lefty people who voted to remain all outraged that the Eastern Europeans have left so there’s no available labour to treat like dirt!

Carycy · 19/08/2021 11:30

That’s the point though planets.
People for Eastern Europe are being paid a reasonable amount in relation to the rate of pay in their own country so they will do it. They know that it’s temporary and they can build up a pot for home some day possibly where the money can go further.
How can UK based health professionals compete with that. There is no incentive to put the pay up while cheap foreign Labour is freely available.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 19/08/2021 11:23

@Sparklestar1

Hi, I'm a manager in homecare - the problem at the moment is recruitment and retention. We have tried absolutely everything we possibly can, pay well above the usual minimum wage including paying 18-24 year olds the same as everybody else! People either don't want to work in care or don't want to work! On top of that carers are going off at the drop of a hat - now if they have been pinged they can still work providing a negative PCR test but some test results have taken 5-6 days to come back. It's a shambles. The work home carers have done during this pandemic has been forgotten - they too have been front lines just like NHS and care homes. We are currently struggling with the clients we already have due to staffing never mind being able to take more, it's heartbreaking and we are really at a loss as to what to try next
Are you joking? " We have tried absolutely everything we possibly can" "People either don't want to work in care or don't want to work!"

My mother has work in both care homes and homecare/community care for over 15 years. The pressure put on community carers by "managers" who sit in the office and make thier timetables is immense. 15 minute slots to wash, dress, serve meals, help with medications then 5 minutes to get to the next. Of course that is barring that on arrival extra care is needed or ambulance support. Some days the carers who come to clients homes are the only social interaction these people have and often ask them to stay for 5 minutes longer which carers are not allowed to do.
It's all well and good saying minimum 20 mins per call on paper but the realities are carers are not given that much time. Especially when they are expected to be on a double up call where two carers are need for lifting etc in which case if one is late that's two carers running behind. Also homecare companies rarely pay over time as the carers are blamed for running late.

The rates of pay are shocking "well above the usual minimum wage" is what? £11- £12 per hour. A pittance in comparison for what carers have to put with from head office/clients/client's families.

The privatization of care services is the problem. It's all about making money with no care or thought given to the staff or clients. See as many clients as possible in one shift seems to be the attitude.

shallIswim · 19/08/2021 11:08

@m0therofdragons we pay similar for Dad's live in carer, and want to do the same for mum, but there's no one available. The money may run out but frankly we'll milk it til it does. Me and my sister have said stuff the inheritance! Which I realise is a lucky position to be in.

And yes - shocking lack of Physios, and literally no OTs. The Matron at the community hospital is embarrassed and angry in turn.

OP posts:
Planetsandstars · 19/08/2021 11:04

Who would be a carer though

People with no other options, or other options that are so shit that working 6am - 10pm for less than minimum wage is appealing.

People from Eastern Europe, a lot of the time. But they don’t matter because they are ummm … not British?

Kendodd · 19/08/2021 11:01

The best suggestion I heard for funding social care was basically a death tax. Everyone over retirement age who died paid 1 or 2% tax on their estate regardless of whether they needed care or not. Apparently this raised all the money needed to completely upgrade the system. The shouts of "it's not fair" from the elderly were deafening though so it never went anywhere.

Carycy · 19/08/2021 11:01

Who would be a carer though? Minimum wage for back breaking work. Why do that when you can go work in a restaurant or something and get minimum wage plus tips. We shouldn’t be relying on foreign labour in order to get away with paying people less. We should pay people appropriately for the relevant cost of living in the country they live in.
I say this as someone that did do care work before going on to an nhs profession. Still underpaid for my level of education and qualifications.
But the answer in this country rather than pay people appropriately is to ship people in from poorer countries. Until we stop doing that then we will continue to have a problem. I see it happening in the nhs now. Can’t get the staff because working conditions are horrendous. Staff leaving. The ones that stay aren’t rewarded financially. Someone overpaid in an office somewhen goes off on a recruit trip to India instead.

m0therofdragons · 19/08/2021 10:53

We paid £2100 per week for a carer at home but the money ran out so we now have to sell the home and my granny is in a care home.

I can’t understand why there are no physio or OTs in a community hospital - that’s a massive failing as rehab is exactly what community hospitals are for! I work in nhs hospital management and there’s such a big focus on patient flow with many initiatives to get patients home with the care they need - your county is failing you here!

Planetsandstars · 19/08/2021 10:51

Can’t believe the people claiming Brexit is the problem.

Do you realise you’re effectively saying ‘well, we’ve run out of polish and Lithuanian and Romanian people to treat like shit, so what did you expect?’ Grin

Votes remain by the way but seriously Hmm

ilovesooty · 19/08/2021 10:46

Meanwhile, Johnson, who promised ages ago to sort out social care, has failed to address it, and has "Got Brexit done" which has made the crisis much worse.

SoreusBacchus · 19/08/2021 10:33

@Bananarice

I know two care workers who left their job when covid vaccine was made mandatory.
There are stupid people in every profession
Walkingalone21 · 19/08/2021 10:09

Care work is only going to experience more shortages come November. This is the dead line for care staff to be double vaccinated or loose their jobs.
In an industry that is built on human rights, empowerment, honesty and choice I find this absolutely disgusting behaviour. Staff are being bullied and threatened.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 19/08/2021 08:22

The “tax more and they’ll leave” is generally complete bollocks - higher earners typically have more to lose when leaving. Round here it’s the NMW cleaners, baristas and carers who have gone back to Europe because once their job goes, or they’re not welcome, or there’s a bunch of paperwork in the way of them staying, why would you bother? Professional Europeans have just filled in the paperwork (or had it done by the employer) and stayed put because a) it’s harder to find a similar job at higher levels and b) they generally are supporting houses and families.

LA budgets have been screwed for decades. We need a serious council tax rise to pay for both education and social care, and politicians who have a bold vision to reform social care funding. If I could insure against care costs, I’d do it by any means possible.

shallIswim · 19/08/2021 08:02

@Itsmeagainandagain are you talking to me? I think I'm articulating that I'm learning how grim it is in social care.
I've referenced poor wages etc and haven't once dissed people actually doing the job. Quite the opposite. I'm wringing my hands for everyone here. But mainly my mum.

And I can't pay for a transfer into my area. She's already in my county. And my county (at the far end of England - there's nothing g beyond us - has an acute shortage. She is stuck, abs she's not alone.

I wish I could do the job. I wish my mum would be happy for me to do the job. She's not abs I'm not.

Properly funded social care abs a value put on those who do the job is the only way out of this mess

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock · 19/08/2021 08:01

I know two care workers who left their job when covid vaccine was made mandatory. I know someone who done that too, she'd every shot required travelling around Asia and regularly snorts cocaine.

PlanDeRaccordement · 19/08/2021 07:57

Your country is bankrupt, what do you expect? Especially in rural communities with high number of pensioners.

You can always pay for hospital transfer to bring her to your local area if there is better provision.

Swipe left for the next trending thread