Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be furious with the way social care is(n't) run in this country?

161 replies

shallIswim · 18/08/2021 14:08

I know I know I should have gotten angry about this before it affected me but... Mother has had severe stroke and is marooned in a community hospital in the back of beyond because there are no carers. None. Not in the community, not in nursing homes. The hospital is embarrassed. I'm quietly seething that a woman who has paid taxes all her life (forgive the cliche) has been left like this. There are no physios in the hospital so she is getting no rehab. I don't blame the hospital or any of the care agencies or companies. But I am raging with impotence.
Father is being cared for full time at home by a good private agency (we are paying) but even they cannot supply anyone.
The lady in the neighbouring bed to mother is way better than she is but has been waiting since early July for a care package to go home to.
What kind of place are we living in?
I do blame Brexit in part but don't want this to be a debate abut Brexit.
What can we do? It's AWFUL and inhumane

OP posts:
shallIswim · 20/08/2021 13:03

@BananaMilkshakeWithCream

Depends what level of care she needs. I’m an OT in a rehab unit and we’ve got at least 6 patients in a similar situation who are stuck here for the foreseeable. The ones who need the highest level of care at home, so 4 times a day and maybe a night visit or 2 will be here ages unless they pay privately 🤷‍♀️ Yes she’s paid her taxes but so have millions of other people.
Sorry if i've given the impression that I think she's special (tho she is to me, obv). I had hoped I'd gone out of the way to infer that this is crap whichever way you cut it. I've mentioned a lady in a neighbouring bed who has much less severe needs than mum but who has been waiting since mid July for a care package. Yes Mum will need double handed care at least 4 times a day, which is why we're going private and live-in - but even then there's no one available til the end of August. This is universal. There are no OT's in Mum's community hospital by the way. They are 'borrowed' infrequently from elsewhere - thereby obv depriving their main location of the service. It's a blimmin mess which you obv see day to day but which I am only just understanding and therefore venting my anger.
OP posts:
BananaMilkshakeWithCream · 20/08/2021 12:57

Depends what level of care she needs. I’m an OT in a rehab unit and we’ve got at least 6 patients in a similar situation who are stuck here for the foreseeable. The ones who need the highest level of care at home, so 4 times a day and maybe a night visit or 2 will be here ages unless they pay privately 🤷‍♀️ Yes she’s paid her taxes but so have millions of other people.

Mybestgirl · 20/08/2021 10:32

@JoborPlay

Mybestgirl and the situation has got worse in those 6 years and then fallen off a cliff this last few months.

All I can say OP is that in some ways, it's good your mum is in hospital because we have care agencies pulling out of care packages in the community leaving people with no support simply because they cannot staff the calls. It's an absolutely dreadful state of affairs.

I have two friends, both of whom have mothers with dementia. They live in different council areas 4 miles apart. One council is great, the one my other friend and me live in is dire! In this area there just seems to be little to no help available. Not much change here in 6 years….
Upamountain43 · 20/08/2021 09:59

It is really difficult - my son in law had a completely unexpected leg amputation a few weeks ago and was returned home within 4 days with no care package.

He was told to micro live in 1 room until OT could assess and get any adaptions - the waiting list is 9 months. He was given a wheelchair and a commode.

Luckily i know the system and called falls prevention who came after two weeks and they got an OT out much quicker.

My son in law is 42 and has two children one of whom has significant SEN and previously worked - after 9 months of lying in a bed all the time i doubt he would have ever have worked again.

My Mum was kept in hospital after a minor fall waiting for a care package and caught hospital acquired pneumonia and we lost her.

People are literally dying prematurely and losing all their independence - all because successive governments for the last 50 years have failed to plan for the aging population - this has not come out or nowhere it has been coming for 50+ years. I'm not too sure of the impact of Brexit as i worked predominantly in homes for people with Learning Disabilities/brain injuries/mental health and the vast majority of staff i see are from Africa.

SimonJT · 20/08/2021 09:57

@Kendodd

Brexit had a massive and totally predictable impact on care and hospitality. Anyone denying this is a fucking idiot.

Likewise farming, haulage and Northern Ireland.

The fishing industry is still suffering predictable problems as well
Kendodd · 20/08/2021 09:53

Brexit had a massive and totally predictable impact on care and hospitality. Anyone denying this is a fucking idiot.

Likewise farming, haulage and Northern Ireland.

HereticFanjo · 20/08/2021 09:47

Brexit had a massive and totally predictable impact on care and hospitality. Anyone denying this is a fucking idiot.

vivainsomnia · 20/08/2021 09:35

It was bad before Brexit, it's now in its worse crisis. Carers are expected to take on more and more responsibilities, dealing with utterly frustrating bureaucracy, insulting pay, long inflexible hours. It's frightening.

JoborPlay · 20/08/2021 08:26

Mybestgirl and the situation has got worse in those 6 years and then fallen off a cliff this last few months.

All I can say OP is that in some ways, it's good your mum is in hospital because we have care agencies pulling out of care packages in the community leaving people with no support simply because they cannot staff the calls. It's an absolutely dreadful state of affairs.

Mybestgirl · 20/08/2021 08:00

@SoreusBacchus

Oh and Brexit and the hostile environment is a massive issue when it comes to carers....the vast majority of paid carers in the UK are non UK nationals on minimum wage.
My Bil had dementia, he died 6 years ago. We couldn’t get him a care package for love nor money, there just weren’t any carers to be found, the whole family were on our knees…Brexit hadn’t been thought of then.
shallIswim · 20/08/2021 07:52

@Kendodd great idea for a hypothecated tax.

OP posts:
countrygirl99 · 20/08/2021 07:14

I'm in a similar position to the OP, dad in hospital waiting for discharge. They can pay after the initial reablement care but the carers just aren't there.
If anyone thinks agencies are creaming it in, they aren't. Insurance, NI and admin costs are huge and take up as big a chunk of the fee as wages. Those carers in the gield have to earn enough to pay the people who man the phones, sort the rotas and pay the bills etc. Then there are the costs of running the office. ILs agency charge them £22.50 and I would reckon the business owners probably see less than than £1 of that after costs. It's a low margin business. Same with care hones, that's why so many are going bust.
It's no good shouting that carers need to be better paid unless we are prepared to pay more ourselves, either directly or via taxes. There is no slack in the system for that money to be found at the moment.

Kendodd · 20/08/2021 06:40

And as for "worked all their life and paid tax" so what, that's what everyone does. The fact is the elderly generation didn't pay enough tax to cover their cost (not their fault, just the maths at the time) I don't think it's fair to make younger generations cover this shortfall while the older generation sit on huge housing wealth.
I'm older myself before anyone accuses me of just being jealous.

Kendodd · 20/08/2021 06:34

And as annoyed as I am at the present govt, I don't want to make this party political because there are no ideas on either side of the political divide.

I posted an idea up thread. I thought it was the best solution. I think it came from the LibDems. It was shouted down with howls of "it's not fair!'

Everybody who dies , past retirement age, pays a 1 or 2% death tax on their estate. This applies whether they needed care or not and raises more than enough to completely upgrade the system without further burdening the young.

Nightlystroll · 20/08/2021 00:30

@SlipSlop
I would say two points to your post.

  1. If your parent has long-term chronic conditions and needs permanent medication and nurse visits for injections, and stays in hospital etc, that would all be paid for by the NHS. No one suggests they should pay towards their costs of medication, or treatment of medical conditions, etc. If however they are fit and well and don't need any of that but they have dementia and they need assistance, then they get no money out of the NHS. They must fund everything themselves. That seems iniquitous.
  1. My mother has dementia and my dad left her with a good income but not much savings. We pay for everything for her and we do loads for her ourselves. But there is absolutely no help from SS or any of the charities where we can look for advice and availability of services. Even though we're willing to pay, our council provides nothing anymore. There's just no support or advice anywhere. And don't even get me started on Age UK, Alzheimer society etc. They are just useless. But to be fair, why should it fall on charities? The problem is only going to get worse and there seems to be no planning for it at all.

And as annoyed as I am at the present govt, I don't want to make this party political because there are no ideas on either side of the political divide.

SlipSlop · 19/08/2021 21:54

I was furious when Labour derided a perfectly reasonable plan by Theresa May when to deal with social care as the 'dementia tax'.

If someone wants or needs someone else to care for an elderly parent, why shouldn't the parent's assets above a certain reasonable level be used to pay for their care. If you want your parent's assets intact, then you have to earn it by looking after them yourself as citizens in very many other countries do.

MaudTheInvincible · 19/08/2021 20:17

There was a news story yesterday about North Yorkshire having 1000 vacancies for carers. My sister in law used to be a carer. It seems like a poorly paid, stressful job with very little effort made to attract or retain staff.

Nightlystroll · 19/08/2021 20:07

I have been saying fir years, long before Brexit was even a twinkle in Farages eye, that we have to have joined up medical and social care. Why don't we have half-way homes for people who no longer need to be in hospital but aren't ready to go home? Because it would mean massive investment and there's no money. The electorate always say they're happy to pay more tax to be spent on NHS services but then moan if they have to pay more tax.
When my friend retired, she did voluntary work at a speech therapy centre for stroke patients. A qualified therapist wrote care packages, and the volunteers did the exercises with the patients. She loved it and the patients got help they needed. The NHS trust then said that the therapist didn't have time to write the care plans so the whole place closed down. How does any of that make sense?
Unless a govt, of any colour, actually has the guts to tackle this, I don't see how care will survive in this country. And yes, we have more care than most. But we're the sixth biggest economy in the world, surely we can expect more than, hey, we're better than Ethiopia!

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 19/08/2021 20:06

Coaltit
We appreciated your contribution to our workforce but you are right.

I worked summers at a low skill employment. At the outset the workforce was local British,on permanent contracts, normal hours etc, lots of men & women with kids. When more eastern European countries joined the EU, steadily the local workforce was replaced by most polish & Romanian workers. The locals were pushed out by changing the hours from 8am-4pm, to a double shift 6am to 2pm, 2PM-10pm, only offering zero hours at rock bottom pay to new staff as old retired. The incoming EU staff accepted it because they were mostly in their 20s, living in extremely cheap HMOs with low rent. I made friends with 2 of them, they were bed shifting with another couple who worked nights, flipping the mattress over, they brought food & cigarettes in suitcases to save as much cash as possible. They were IT graduates and told me after 3 years working here they would have saved enough to buy a small house outright back home. The local labour force simply couldnt compete, what was offered wasnt enough to live here as a family long term but was great on a short term basis if you had a cheaper country to return to.

shallIswim · 19/08/2021 20:01

Every care company I've spoken to to try to source help have said the same thing: acute shortage due to Brexit

OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 19/08/2021 19:58

This is the demographic time bomb we have known was coming for years. We have too many old people to provide enough care for, while leaving enough people available in the labour force for other things. We also can't afford to have it provided.

This is why in so many countries, care of the elderly is managed within families a lot, it is too costly for it to be provided as a paid service.

When people are prepared to pay more for it, more people will be willing to work doing it. Carework is paid a pittance, the time & cost of travel to visit people at home makes it extremely hard to offer it at decent rates)

christinarossetti19 · 19/08/2021 19:52

Yes, I do think this systemic shift over the last 15 year or so, fuelled largely by cuts to local authorities is the root of the situation that we had now.

Dom care used to be an interesting, fulfilling if not well paid job. Carers build up relationships with their clients and had time for a chat. (Mainly) women took of these jobs when their children were small and stayed because they were decently treated and grew very fond of their clients. They were able to do so because they lived in social housing with low rents or had low mortgages when the property market was saner.

It's very sad to see what has happened to dom care over these years. Both the clients and carers tbh.

JoborPlay · 19/08/2021 19:36

@christinarossetti19

The social care system has been becoming increasingly broken over the last few decades.

Most dom care used by be provided directly by local authorities, so staff had contracts, annual leave, salaried positions, paid training etc etc.

It's now nearly all or possibly even all now provided by care agencies who can only win tenders by undercutting other providers.

Hence the piss poor pay, not being paid for travel time, having to pay for own training and travel, zero hours contracts etc etc.

Recruitment and retention has been a nightmare for years and is only becoming increasingly so.

It's horrendous and no, money won't insulate you from its effects if there aren't enough carers.

So true.

It's not every authority - where my sister works they have carers employed by the LA, it's salaried £19k per year plus holiday s and the better working conditions that comes with being in a local authority, decent sick pay, fair rotas etc. She's worked for agencies before and care homes and says the LA is the best employer by far.

JoborPlay · 19/08/2021 19:31

@Planetsandstars

Can’t believe the people claiming Brexit is the problem.

Do you realise you’re effectively saying ‘well, we’ve run out of polish and Lithuanian and Romanian people to treat like shit, so what did you expect?’ Grin

Votes remain by the way but seriously Hmm

But it's true! We have lost people prepared to do the job. Which yes, means people prepared to be treated like shit.

And it's not just wages. Not everyone is suited to care work. It's a skilled job but unlike other skilled jobs it's massively under valued.

To fix it we need a huge rise in tax to fund better training, qualifications and registration of care and care workers and better pay and conditions. But it take a very long time to turn around.

CoalTit · 19/08/2021 17:23

We didn’t like having them here to ‘treat them like diet [sic]’. We liked having them here because they added things to Britain, made it less inward-looking. They left because they were made to feel unwelcome by brexity twats. This country has lost a lot by ending free movement.

We foreigners were used to keep wages low, though. I worked as a carer on and off from 2004 to 2019. I felt really bad for the British carers by the end; they earned poverty wages, their agency co-ordinators were really vile to them and they hadn't the option of leaving the UK as I did.

Swipe left for the next trending thread