Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need to start building upwards instead of expanding outwards.

106 replies

SeoultoSeoul · 18/08/2021 10:16

I'm not talking about a return to hideous 60s housing blocks, but surely it would be more space effective to build some decent mid rise apartment blocks rather than continuing to destroy habitat and farmland by building new estates everywhere.

I'm lucky enough to live in a family sized house at the moment (there are 5 of us in it) but DH and I will downsize to a flat once the DC move on.

OP posts:
MiloAndEddie · 18/08/2021 11:05

@Lelliebellieboo as part of the planning application there is routinely section 106 obligations set out which means the developer typically pays contributions towards doctors/schools etc. It’s designed to mitigate (at least partially) the impact of the development on local resources. How and when the council decides to spend it, is down to them.

I’m not entirely sure I understand your last paragraph either? That developers maintain everything for 20 years? Because that’s definitely not true

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 18/08/2021 11:04

1 and 2 child households massively outnumber 3+ child households - almost 7 million vs 1.2 million in 2020 if I’ve read the stats correctly

countrytown · 18/08/2021 11:01

The problem isn't flats but the usual execution of them in the UK.

yep

Lelliebellieboo · 18/08/2021 10:58

I think more needs to be done to sort out property developers so that they actually provide what they should be providing.

In our village, we have been attacked by property developers because of its location. There's a plan going in place at the moment for an additional 500 homes. This is the third development in 5 years. If it gets approval, the population of the village will have increased by 70% which is insane. One of the biggest problems in my view is that the developers include plans for playgrounds/parks/doctors etc but then don't actually deliver.

The recent estate which was completed in 2020 made a big deal about how there would be a playground in the middle of the estate, but they've never done anything with it. It featured heavily in their initial marketing material. Even when we looked at a house a year ago they still talked about it, and in their office there were huge rendered drawings of it. However, a few months later when they were asked about it they simply shrugged and said "nothing to do with us, we've left the space - if you want it, you build it." Same with the space for the schools/doctors etc. The developers play heavily on the fact that they are including these necessities in their plans but don't actually deliver on it, and they never ever get called out on it.

Our local council will basically accept any planning application because they don't care. Because it's adjacent to a big town, they don't care that there are no schools/parks/doctors/dentists, etc because, in their view, residents can travel the 10 mins down the road into the neighboring local authority for those services.

Also, I think I read somewhere that the developers maintain priority for maintenance for 20 years - so in our council's eyes, they get all the money for council tax for 20 years without having to do anything at all. It's shocking!

MinesAMassiveSalad · 18/08/2021 10:58

There are a few very nice flats in our town with patio gardens downstairs and big balconies for upper ones. All facing onto a landscaped courtyard with the parking. It's very lovely.

The problem isn't flats but the usual execution of them in the UK.

Biancadelrioisback · 18/08/2021 10:54

Until I bought my current house, I lived in 'apartment blocks'. On one I was on 3rd floor and absolutely hated my upstairs neighbours. They didn't do anything massively wrong, but they were very heavy footed and worked opposite schedules to me. I cried so many times from being disturbed by thumping around.
We also had balconies and they would wash theirs every week and ours would end up covered in all their dirty water.

Second one I lived in was great but no lift (we were only on first floor) which was a nightmare with a newborn as I was forever carrying the pram up and down the stairs (hadn't considered this when I bought the pram tbf so that's on me!).

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 18/08/2021 10:54

We live in a flat and also have a garden that the DC never use.

countrytown · 18/08/2021 10:54

The UK ageing population is actually a real issue which no government wants to address.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/apr/20/britain-falling-birthrate-covid-pandemic-conservatives-removed-support-for-parents

BikeRunSki · 18/08/2021 10:52

No thought is given to leaving a gap in the fence to give them access, in fact I'm on quite a few gardening groups and even on there wildlife is referred to as "vermin".

What people do to their own gardens is obviously difficult to police, but planning requirements generally do require gaps under fences etc for wildlife passage.

Re gardens: people may not want gardens to tend in the traditional sense, but I think they want somewhere private to sit and play outdoors.

countrytown · 18/08/2021 10:51

I was talking statistically obviously so why would I need to put the word average in? Why would you assume your anecdotal experience is extrapolated for the population?

Biancadelrioisback · 18/08/2021 10:50

@SeoultoSeoul

Boood I completely agree.

Countrytown Do people really want "gardens" though? I see a lot of gardens being turfed over with plastic grass and patios. Gardens fenced off so that they are out of bounds for shrews, mice (food for owls) and hedgehogs.
No thought is given to leaving a gap in the fence to give them access, in fact I'm on quite a few gardening groups and even on there wildlife is referred to as "vermin".
If we aren't careful we won't stop building outwards until the whole of the UK is suburbia with no wild areas left.
If we built upwards we could leave swathes of the countryside for wildlife, food production and leisure.

Many people want outside space. For some it's a large patio with furniture and fire pits, for others its a neat, manicured lawn, for others it's a wild garden with wildlife and wildflowers, for others it's a basic green area for kids and pets to play, somewhere to stick the paddling pool on the 5 hot days we get each year.

Outside space requirements vary massively from family to family, but if lockdown 1 taught us anything, it's the value of your own outside space.

GoodMorrowFairMaiden · 18/08/2021 10:50

Many people want gardens and having access to gardens contributes to good mental wellbeing.

Do you know the percentage of the uk that is built on? It’s about 6%. A big chunk is devoted to agriculture but we also have a lot of natural landscape.

Chemenger · 18/08/2021 10:50

I lived in a 38 story apartment block in the US and I loved it. It had great communal spaces; a terrace on the top floor with barbecues and seating, a large lounge with big tables and a kitchen you could use for entertaining, a gym and work spaces. It even had a dog washing facility. There was a concierge service. I would move somewhere like that here in a heartbeat. I’m sure the service charge would be huge, however. We’re about to move from a house with a large garden to a flat in the centre of a city and I can’t wait, I’m over gardening.

Lockheart · 18/08/2021 10:49

[quote countrytown]@Lockheart omg just because you know some who have 3 doesn't mean every family does! 🤣🤣

The UK fertility rate is 1.6 & falling, have a think about it. [/quote]
Sure, but that doesn't mean "people in the UK don't have more than 2 DCs".

It means "the average person in the UK has less than 2 DCs".

MiloAndEddie · 18/08/2021 10:48

I love these kind of threads!

‘Build flats! That’s what we need!’

Don’t live in one themselves though Hmm

BikeRunSki · 18/08/2021 10:48

People in the UK don't have more than 2 dc though

This is not my experience at all.a quick straw poll in I reckon 3 dc families account for around 40% of my DC’s acquaintances, 2 dc families account for 40%, and larger/smaller for the rest. There is a local family of 11, although I recognise that’s an outlier! (I’m one of 4, I have 2 dc. Not out of principle, but because 2 was quite enough practically and mentally!).

countrytown · 18/08/2021 10:48

but the idea people in the UK have 2 or fewer children is silly.

Wowsers 🤔

FourTeaFallOut · 18/08/2021 10:45

I think that is going to be a hard sell after the last few years.

But, essentially, I agree that we should be thinking about how much space we are occupying relative to our needs. If I watch another grand designs with a couple swanning around a mansion sized house crowing about their green credentials and eco friendly design the telly will be in mortal peril.

countrytown · 18/08/2021 10:44

@SeoultoSeoul yes I think people do want gardens. Having a garden isn't just about wildlife though, I think many just want private outdoor space.

Why don't you live in a flat?

countrytown · 18/08/2021 10:43

@Lockheart omg just because you know some who have 3 doesn't mean every family does! 🤣🤣

The UK fertility rate is 1.6 & falling, have a think about it.

SeoultoSeoul · 18/08/2021 10:42

Boood I completely agree.

Countrytown Do people really want "gardens" though? I see a lot of gardens being turfed over with plastic grass and patios. Gardens fenced off so that they are out of bounds for shrews, mice (food for owls) and hedgehogs.
No thought is given to leaving a gap in the fence to give them access, in fact I'm on quite a few gardening groups and even on there wildlife is referred to as "vermin".
If we aren't careful we won't stop building outwards until the whole of the UK is suburbia with no wild areas left.
If we built upwards we could leave swathes of the countryside for wildlife, food production and leisure.

OP posts:
TonyThreePies · 18/08/2021 10:41

Lots of development where I am just outside of London and it's all going up!

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 18/08/2021 10:40

All the retirement accommodation being built around here is mid-rise apartments, so there is definitely a bit of that kind of building going on but aimed at a specific demographic

Lockheart · 18/08/2021 10:40

@countrytown

But in terms of reducing the demand on resources, natural and otherwise, it could be argued that people should but have more than 1 or 2 children

People in the UK don't have more than 2 dc though.

That's daft. I know several people with 3. Lots of people in the UK have more than 2. I agree it's bad for the environment but the idea people in the UK have 2 or fewer children is silly.
Lockheart · 18/08/2021 10:39

Apartments are not popular at the moment. Between covid lockdowns with no outdoor space, the cladding scandal and Grenfell, and other incidents like the recent collapse of that block in Florida, people are understandably wary. Additionally, flats tend to be leasehold, not freehold, meaning they come with additional ground rent and service charge costs on top of already high house prices and mortgage costs, and the longer you hold the flat the shorter the lease gets, which makes them more and more unattractive when you want to sell.

I don't disagree with your general point, but the answer is not to keep building up everywhere. We need to maximise the efficiency of our current housing stock, a surprising amount of which is left empty as investment, and in some areas is taken up with holiday cottages. We need to utilise brownfield sites first, and consider how/if recently empty commercial buildings in town centres can be converted.

There is a LOT of real estate out there, it just needs to be used.