Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need to start building upwards instead of expanding outwards.

106 replies

SeoultoSeoul · 18/08/2021 10:16

I'm not talking about a return to hideous 60s housing blocks, but surely it would be more space effective to build some decent mid rise apartment blocks rather than continuing to destroy habitat and farmland by building new estates everywhere.

I'm lucky enough to live in a family sized house at the moment (there are 5 of us in it) but DH and I will downsize to a flat once the DC move on.

OP posts:
WTFisNext · 18/08/2021 12:33

@Boood

You are completely right, but apartment owners in the UK have been screwed over so badly in the last couple of years that you’d be forgiven for thinking it was a deliberate government policy. Left holding the bill for unsafe building work that could be blamed on either corner-cutting construction firms or confused and inconsistent regulations, but definitely not on the poor bastard who did exactly as they were encouraged to do and bought a home. And then ordered not to go out for months at a time, often without the benefit of any private outdoor space. There are also significant issues with the way leasehold properties are owned, that can leave leaseholders at the mercy of greedy and uninterested freeholders. We do need to encourage more people to live in flats, but the way to do that is to build apartments that people want to live in- with decent-sized rooms and balconies, and enough bedrooms for families. And to reform property ownership laws so that leaseholders have more control and are protected from unscrupulous freeholders.
I agree completely. Tiny amounts of indoor space/storage, eye wateringly expensive service charges, financial chokehold that is the leasehold, minimal decent outdoor space (a concrete car park is not a communal outdoor space!) all needs to be addressed if we're to start building "up" earnestly so that they become viable spaces for families to live.

We can't keep expanding 'out', but we can't expand 'up' without serious changes.

Chemenger · 18/08/2021 12:33

@MadeOfStarStuff

YABU

it’s impossible to take anyone seriously saying that more people should live in flats when they themselves live in a nice family home with garden.

I live in a lovely detached family house. I am moving to a flat. I think building up rather than out is a good idea, am I allowed to say so?
newnortherner111 · 18/08/2021 12:32

We need to stop building out of town retail parks first. Use brownfield sites for housing.

SeoultoSeoul · 18/08/2021 12:32

godmum56

We are planning to move to one. I also have a DD who is looking for a flat at the moment as it's more convenient for her and her partner to be in a city, close to work and using public transport. Its also very difficult to afford the sort of 4 bed detached houses that are springing up all around our town.

OP posts:
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 18/08/2021 12:32

I would ban non U.K. tax payers buying homes- that before you ban British tax payers owning a second home

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 18/08/2021 12:29

Small blocks of flats with a communal garden and share of freehold.
Decent noise isolation - not to the highest standard but at least you don’t hear next door’s toilet flushing.
Some storage space - instead of trying to fit as many bedrooms as possible. Again, nothing extravagant, but I have seen bathrooms with no storage at all which is just ridiculous, an under sink unit is the minimum. Somewhere to store a vacuum and ironing board. This type of things.

This would be appealing even to young families.

Moonbelly · 18/08/2021 12:29

also the government to sort out the cladding issues and abolish leasehold

Moonbelly · 18/08/2021 12:28

Truly radical?
Ban second home onwership. reclaim abandoned buildings and homes. Encourage all employers who can to offer work from home so people can buy anywhere and be employed. all house bought for students to be reclaimed as family homes and the students who definitely don't garden to live in flats.
Of course you'd need a dictator to pull it off so not very plausible!

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 18/08/2021 12:24

Yabu, families need houses- flats are restrictive, over priced, tied into a leasehold - awful!
We need affordable houses!!!
New build flats, open plan- all a con to get less space and for the council to get even more council tax!

Proudboomer · 18/08/2021 12:22

Lots of flats going up around me but a lot will cost more than a small house on a new estate a couple of miles away.
I live on the south coast where lots of the large sea front properties have either been converted to flats or a row of them has been pulled down for larger new developments. Because of there position ie sea view and close to town they just aren’t affordable for first time buyers and even if they could scrap together enough deposit the service charges are eye watering expensive which is just not doable if you also have an eye watering mortgage to pay.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/08/2021 12:18

Theres a stigma or judgement attached to living in flats. When we sold our ground floor garden flat and were specifically looking for a first floor (with attic room) flat, for me dh and our 2dc, everybody we spoke to questioned why on earth we woildnt look for a house.

PersonaNonGarter · 18/08/2021 12:12

YABU

And selfish. Build up is always said by people with gardens.

Only 8% of the UK is built on. If we made that 10% we could house everybody.

People want a garden and to be able to park. These things don’t have to be big gardens or grand garages just a bit of space. And that’s fine.

MadeOfStarStuff · 18/08/2021 12:08

YABU

it’s impossible to take anyone seriously saying that more people should live in flats when they themselves live in a nice family home with garden.

godmum56 · 18/08/2021 12:02

@MiloAndEddie

I love these kind of threads!

‘Build flats! That’s what we need!’

Don’t live in one themselves though Hmm

ha! this. ^^
Thelnebriati · 18/08/2021 11:51

I agree that investors shouldn't be allowed to leave homes sitting empty any more. Locally, someone used EU money to build a large office block in a residential area, its never been used.

Well built flats could be a decent size, have a balcony, the building could have indoor sports facilities and a roof garden. They don't have to be pokey boxes.

bigbluebus · 18/08/2021 11:44

How about we just bring in rules to deal with all the empty property already sitting around doing nothing - and that includes everything from investment properties owned by offshore companies/overseas investors and those becoming derelict due to neglect. There are houses in our village that haven't been lived in for all the 29 years I've lived here - including a new build that was never finished and is now derelict!

DynamoKev · 18/08/2021 11:42

[quote MiloAndEddie]@Lelliebellieboo as part of the planning application there is routinely section 106 obligations set out which means the developer typically pays contributions towards doctors/schools etc. It’s designed to mitigate (at least partially) the impact of the development on local resources. How and when the council decides to spend it, is down to them.

I’m not entirely sure I understand your last paragraph either? That developers maintain everything for 20 years? Because that’s definitely not true[/quote]
...and there is an entire industry dedicated to helping developers dodge the various S106 provisions - even consultancies devoted to it. Like Lelliebellieboo my town is besieged by new estates - 3000+ new houses with zero infrastructure. The Council won't bother to rect until the next crisis of traffic, education provision etc. The "planning" isn't planning at all, it's a way to employ a few people to rubber stamp anything developers want to do.

Paq · 18/08/2021 11:34

When I'm older I'd love to live in a nice flat. Less maintenance, cheaper, more secure. However I'm put off by

  • poor soundproofing
  • dodgy leasehold arrangements, management rip off charges, crap service from the management company
  • worry about shared maintenance bills, e.g. cladding, roof
  • lack of outdoor space. I'd be happy with communal space if everyone respected it

Basically there's just been so many horror stories about living in flats. I'll be like loads of older people and try to find a nice little bungalow.

Biancadelrioisback · 18/08/2021 11:20

Also, nice flats are expensive. I was paying about the same in my 2 bed 'apartment' with single designated parking space as I am for my 3 bed house with front and back garden, garage and off street parking.

countrytown · 18/08/2021 11:13

statistically

countrytown · 18/08/2021 11:13

@SleepingStandingUp but statically that's not the norm.

Lelliebellieboo · 18/08/2021 11:10

[quote MiloAndEddie]@Lelliebellieboo as part of the planning application there is routinely section 106 obligations set out which means the developer typically pays contributions towards doctors/schools etc. It’s designed to mitigate (at least partially) the impact of the development on local resources. How and when the council decides to spend it, is down to them.

I’m not entirely sure I understand your last paragraph either? That developers maintain everything for 20 years? Because that’s definitely not true[/quote]
hmmm I must have misread something then.

Although I do remember years ago asking our council to do something years ago and them refusing, saying that it was the developer who had to do it. But as I say, our local council is absolutely shoddy! haha!

SleepingStandingUp · 18/08/2021 11:07

@countrytown

But in terms of reducing the demand on resources, natural and otherwise, it could be argued that people should but have more than 1 or 2 children

People in the UK don't have more than 2 dc though.

I have 3 🤪
isthisareverse · 18/08/2021 11:05

Honestly, unless you have young children, I find it easier to live in a (nice) flat than a house. So much less maintenance and less faff.

I do have a house, because with young children, a garden makes a world of difference, and it's not cost effective to move when they are getting older.

If things were built properly and rules about noise were stricter, I bet many people would actually enjoy their flat, with a terrace and a bit of communal space.

Sittingonabench · 18/08/2021 11:05

I definitely agree with you in theory. And with regards to gardens - I think it is more outside space that people want which could be provided in the form of large balcony spaces and usable rooftop spaces. It would be challenging for young families to adapt to this though for places for children to run and play. Access also needs to be considered - so many flats have lifts which have been broken for years! Also sound insulation here is terrible in some older buildings which puts people off but the use of concrete for each floor comes with problems such as carbon footprint and impact on foundations.
Europe appears much better at this than we are here and I think a lot has to do with how people were raised and what they’re used to. I like flats but ended up in a house and I do think it feels more like a home than a place to put my head so I’m not sure how to overcome people’s personal preferences.